Minister threatens Derby's Al-Madinah Muslim free school with closure

Al-Madinah headteacher Dr Stewart Wilson: "They are treated equally and fairly"

Related Stories

A Muslim free school in Derby will be closed unless "unacceptable" teaching standards improve and discrimination against female staff and pupils stops.

In a letter to the chair of the Al-Madinah Education Trust, Education Minister Lord Nash laid out 17 issues.

These included forcing female teachers to cover their hair and failing to carry out background checks on staff.

The interim principal said its pupils were treated equally. The school's trust said it was seeking legal advice.

Dr Stuart Wilson, the acting head teacher, said there were areas the school needed to address and it was co-operating with Ofsted.

When asked if staff and children are treated equally at the school, Dr Wilson replied: "Yes, they are treated equally and fairly."

The Al-Madinah School Education Trust said in a statement on the school's website that "the letter had come out of the blue" and while it intended to co-operate fully with the Department for Education, it would also be speaking to the school's solicitors.

Lord Nash's letter stated if urgent steps were not taken by 15 October, funding will be pulled.

The school was closed for a week on the first the day of an Ofsted inspection on 1 October citing "health and safety issues".

Free Schools

  • State funded
  • Funded on a per-pupil basis
  • Answerable to Department of Education
  • 174 in England
  • Can be set up by anyone, once a business plan and demand is demonstrated

Ofsted released its statement to "clarify media reports" about why the school had closed.

In it, HM Inspector Sir Michael Wilshaw said: "Inspectors discovered that staff records showing whether they were cleared to supervise children were either missing or incomplete.

"The school remained closed until yesterday [Monday] when inspectors made a return visit to satisfy themselves that the necessary safeguarding arrangements were in place and that there were sufficient numbers of adults with the necessary clearance for the school to function safely."

A full Ofsted report is expected soon, he added.

Discrimination problems

Addressing chair Shazia Parveen, Lord Nash wrote: "The trust has manifestly breached the conditions of its funding agreement by:

  • Failing to ensure the safety of children at the school
  • Delivering an unacceptably poor standard of education
  • Discriminating in its policies and procedures towards female staff
  • Failing to discharge its duties and responsibilities in respect of the governing body

"I will not tolerate breaches of the commitments you gave when entering into the funding agreement," he added.

He has urged the school's trust to take five "urgent steps" by 15 October, including providing written confirmation that "you have ceased any practices and procedures that have as their reason, cause or effect that women and girls are treated less favourably than men and boys".

The school has been given a deadline of 22 October for nine further action points and must provide a plan setting out a clear management structure by the start of November.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Derby



26 °C 15 °C

BBC Local Live

    Bus station disruption 13:21:

    Bays at Derby bus station are to be resurfaced next month.

    Derby bus station

    The three-week project will start on 4 August and will involve several stops being moved to the Morledge, Derwent Street and Corporation Street.

    Three cyclists injured in hit-and-run 13:11:

    A 24-year-old cyclist from South Derbyshire was one of three injured in a hit-and run in Kent, police have said.

    The cyclists were struck by a vehicle on the A2 in Ashford on Tuesday night. You can read more online.

    News on the hour 12:59: BBC Radio Derby

    Stories in the 13:00 bulletin include:

    • The MP for Burton says he has concerns about the leadership of Burton Hospitals Trust
    • BBC Radio Derby is now available on DAB digital radio
    • Burton Albion have confirmed they are in talks with goalkeeper Jon McLaughlin over a move to the club
    East Midlands Today 12:51: Sarah Teale Presenter

    On BBC One at 13:30, police confirm a Derby man has joined a terrorist group fighting in Syria.

    We'll also be looking around the Commonwealth Games village with some of our local athletes and we're live at an East Midlands zoo celebrating a special birth.

    Bars & Melody 12:41:

    Young musical duo Bars & Melody, who came third in this year's Britain's Got Talent competition, recorded an interview with Andy Potter this morning. These fans turned out to see them arrive.

    Bars & Melody fans

    You can hear the interview on BBC Radio Derby after 13:00.

    Bradley returns to Reds 12:30:

    Midfielder Dan Bradley has signed a new two-year contract with Alfreton Town.

    The 25-year-old former England C international is rejoining the Reds from Barnet following a misunderstanding over relocation arrangements.

    Village hall 'dream come true' 12:20: Derbyshire Times

    Residents in a Derbyshire village will see their "dream become a reality" as they are to get their own village hall thanks to a grant of £500,000.

    Which sport are you made for? 12:10: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    To mark the start of the Commonwealth Games, BBC News Online has created a quiz which tells you which sport you are most suited to.

    Commonwealth quiz results

    I got judo and athletics (jumping and middle-distance running).

    News on the hour 11:59: Sally Swinfen Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    In my 12:00 bulletin, we hear from Burton MP Andrew Griffiths on why he has concerns about leadership at the trust in charge of the town's Queen's Hospital. Listen live.

    Matthew handed opening honour 11:50:

    Duffield squash player Nick Matthew will lead out Team England at tonight's opening ceremony for the Commonwealth Games in Glasgow.

    Nick Matthew

    The three-time world champion was nominated for the honour by his fellow athletes.

    Hospital boss 'very confident' 11:40: BBC Radio Derby

    The chief executive of Burton Hospitals NHS Trust says she fully believes the trust will be out of special measures within the next six months.

    Helen Ashley said: "We're already talking to the Care Quality Commission about when they might come back and re-review the hospital [Queen's Hospital] because we're very confident that, within a few months, we'll have made all the changes we need to make."

    Your photos: Ladybower 11:30: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    Mick Ryan shared this splendid silhouette photo of Ladybower Reservoir.

    Ladybower Reservoir

    Email or tweet us your most impressive pics of Derbyshire and East Staffordshire. I'll feature the best on Local Live.

    Your views 11:20:

    Tell us what you think of BBC Local Live. We'd like your feedback about this service.

    Wednesday's warming up 11:10: Mel Coles BBC Weather

    The cloud has burnt back to reveal plenty of sunshine which will be with us for the rest of the day.

    At times it may turn a bit hazy but, even with a refreshing easterly breeze, it'll feel hot with highs of 25C (79F).

    Latest headlines 10:59: Sally Swinfen Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    My 11:00 bulletin includes these top stories:

    Bailey leaves Rams 10:51:

    Derby County midfielder James Bailey has joined Barnsley on a free transfer.

    James Bailey

    The 25-year-old made 65 appearances during a four-year spell with the Rams.

    On-air 10:43: Sally Pepper Presenter, BBC Radio Derby

    On Friday we'll be broadcasting live from Ladies Day at Uttoxeter Racecourse. Today I'll be talking to the only trainer in Derbyshire with two horses competing. Listen live.

    Transformer heading to town 10:31: Burton Mail

    An electric transformer the size of a bungalow is due to arrive in Burton tomorrow.

    'Buck stops with trust boss' 10:22: BBC Radio Derby

    Burton MP Andrew Griffiths indicated Helen Ashley's position as chief executive of Burton Hospitals NHS Trust was under pressure after it emerged the trust faces another six months in special measures.

    Burton Hospitals sign

    He said: "The buck absolutely stops with the chief executive. It's quite clear that if the hospital is not out of special measures within this six-month period, then Helen Ashley will have even bigger questions to answer."

    New Facebook pic 10:10: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    Our latest Facebook cover photo was taken by Andy Potter in Melbourne.

    Facebook cover photo

    If you'd like us to consider one of your pics as a future cover image, email it to

    Latest headlines 09:59: Sally Swinfen Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    The top stories in my 10:00 bulletin are:

    • Burton's MP says he has concerns about the leadership of the trust in charge of Burton's Queen's Hospital
    • The head of a Commons committee writes to David Cameron to find out why more than 250 government licences to export arms to Russia remain in place
    • BBC Radio Derby is made available on DAB Digital Radio for the first time
    Retuning advice 09:50: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    If you've been listening to BBC Radio Derby on DAB Digital Radio, let us know where you can hear us by emailing or tweeting a message or a photo.

    Digital radio

    If you need any help retuning, there's some really useful advice here.

    Rams beaten in Austria 09:40: Owen Bradley BBC Radio Derby Sport

    Derby County suffered their first defeat of pre-season, losing 2-0 to Russian side Zenit St Petersburg in Austria.

    New signing George Thorne was substituted in the first-half after picking up two knocks, but the Rams say there are no injury concerns over the 21-year-old midfielder.

    Bridge to reopen 09:31: BBC Radio Derby

    The new-look Jubilee Bridge will be unveiled in Matlock Bath later.

    Jubilee Bridge in Matlock Bath

    The district council has spent three months strengthening and painting the walkway (pictured as it looked before work began) to restore it to its original 1887 condition.

    Gay hate father goes to Syria 09:21: Derby Telegraph

    A would-be suicide bomber in Syria is a father from Derby who has twice been convicted for spreading hatred against gay people in the city.

    Reds to sign midfielder 09:11: Owen Bradley BBC Radio Derby Sport

    Midfielder Dan Bradley will be unveiled as an Alfreton Town player (again) later this morning.

    He's left Barnet after just two months.

    News on the hour 08:59: Sally Swinfen Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    The top stories in my 09:00 bulletin are:

    • The MP for Burton says he has concerns about the leadership of Burton Hospitals NHS Trust
    • The UK is still exporting millions of pounds worth of arms to Russia, MPs say
    • A refrigerated lorry containing victims of the MH17 crash arrives at Kharkiv airport
    We've gone digital 08:50: BBC Radio Derby

    The switch-on has taken place and BBC Radio Derby is now official broadcasting on DAB Digital Radio.

    Digital display

    This is the first phase of our DAB rollout, covering about 350,000 people in the Derby area from a transmitter in Quarndon, but more transmitters covering other parts of Derbyshire and East Staffordshire will be added over the next year.

    M1 problems 08:40:

    A four-car accident is blocking two lanes of the M1 northbound at J24, reports our travel news team.

    A broken down vehicle has also closed a lane on the M1 southbound between J29a and J29.

    Top headlines
    • Burton: Queen's Hospital 'must improve'
    • Jubilee: Matlock Bath bridge reopens
    • Listen: BBC Radio Derby
    Hospital 'must improve' 08:31: BBC Radio Derby

    The chief executive of the trust in charge of Burton's Queen's Hospital says she's confident required improvements will be made ahead of its next set of inspections.

    Yesterday the Care Quality Commission recommended the trust stay in special measures for a further six months as it needed to raise standards in a range of areas, including patient care, children's services and dementia provision.

    BBC Radio Derby going digital 08:20: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    BBC Radio Derby will officially start broadcasting on DAB Digital Radio shortly after 08:30.

    Big green button

    However, tune us in now and you'll be able to hear Sally Pepper at the launch event at the iPro Stadium.

    Warm sunshine 08:10: Mel Coles BBC Weather

    A grey start with mist in places. That will clear quickly and the cloud should lift and break to reveal plenty of warm sunshine. Light winds with highs of 26C (79F).

    Good morning 08:00: Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    I'm here with today's news, sport, travel and weather updates for Derbyshire and East Staffordshire.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.