Wrongly jailed mum Lorraine Allen loses compensation bid

Lorraine Allen Lorraine Allen had argued the current criteria meant she effectively had to prove her innocence to get compensation

Related Stories

A mother who was wrongly imprisoned for killing her four-month-old son has lost a legal battle for compensation.

Lorraine Allen, formerly Harris, was jailed in 2000 for the manslaughter of her son, Patrick, in December 1998.

The European Court of Human Rights ruled the refusal was "not inconsistent with her innocence".

The conviction of Ms Allen, originally from Derbyshire but now living in Scarborough, was quashed in 2005 following fresh medical evidence.

The decision cannot be appealed against.

Barry George

The BBC's home affairs correspondent Danny Shaw says the ruling has major implications for other miscarriage of justice victims who have been denied damages for the time they have spent behind bars.

One of the highest profile of these is Barry George, who was convicted in 2001 of shooting TV presenter Jill Dando.

He was acquitted at a retrial in 2008 after doubt was cast on the reliability of gunshot residue evidence.

Currently, compensation is paid if the conviction is reversed on the grounds a new, or newly discovered, fact shows beyond reasonable doubt there had been a miscarriage of justice.

'Very disappointed'

Ms Allen claimed this was contrary to her right to be presumed innocent and placed a burden on her to prove her innocence.

But the European Court of Human Rights found UK judges properly considered whether any miscarriage of justice had taken place, and concluded this had not been established beyond reasonable doubt.

Start Quote

It has been a long battle for Lorraine and she has been very stalwart in trying to get the justice she thinks she deserves”

End Quote Mike Pemberton Solicitor

However, this decision, the court ruled, did not represent a comment on her guilt or innocence.

It said: "The language used by the UK courts in their decisions to decide on compensation had not undermined Ms Allen's acquittal or treated her in a manner inconsistent with her innocence."

Ms Allen was originally convicted after a jury was told her son had died from "shaken-baby syndrome", also known as Non Accidental Head Injury (NAHI).

After serving 16 months of a three-year sentence, the conviction was quashed at the Court of Appeal after fresh evidence from medical experts suggested the baby's injuries could have been caused in other ways.

She challenged the original compensation decision by Judicial Review, but this was refused by the High Court in 2007 and the subsequent appeal was dismissed in 2008.

Her fight then went to the European Court in Strasbourg, which heard her case in November but only now published its judgment.

Mike Pemberton, Mrs Allen's solicitor, said: "We are very disappointed with the outcome of today's case - it has been a long battle for Lorraine and she has been very stalwart in trying to get the justice she thinks she deserves.

"I would now call on the government to seriously consider bringing back the previous scheme to allow a discretionary and moral approach to compensation.

"It is abhorrent that the right to compensation following a miscarriage of justice relies entirely on the strength of evidence... in complex cases concerning differing expert views, it is highly likely that the high threshold required to obtain compensation will never be met."

UK Justice Minister Damian Green said: "I am pleased that the European Court of Human Rights has agreed with the judgment of our domestic courts and agrees that compensation is not applicable in this particular case."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Derby

Weather

Derby

19 °C 15 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    'Love and laughter' 11:08:

    There will be lots of tears but also "love and laughter" at the funeral of medical student Neil Dalton later, reports BBC News Online.

    Neil Dalton

    The service for the 22-year-old, who was stabbed to death in Borneo alongside fellow Newcastle University student Aidan Brunger, will be held in Belper.

     
  2.  
    News on the hour 10:55: Sally Swinfen Journalist, BBC Radio Derby

    Charges for garden waste collections could be reintroduced in Amber Valley, a little more than a year after they were scrapped.

    Hear this story and more on BBC Radio Derby at 11:00.

     
  3.  
    Girl mauled by dog 10:50: Burton Mail

    A nine-year-old girl was mauled by a dog as she played in Anglesey Community Park with her family.

     
  4.  
    WW1 story broadcast 10:36:

    A television interview with a World War One veteran from Derby is being shown for the first time.

    Edward Glendinning

    The testimony of Edward Glendinning, a former Sherwood Forester, was recorded in the 1960s for the BBC's landmark Great War series, remembering the 50th anniversary of the conflict's outbreak, but was thought too harrowing to broadcast.

    Mr Glendinning speaking about some of his experiences is now available to watch online.

     
  5.  
    Medical science bid rejected 10:21: BBC Radio Derby

    The family of a Derby woman who wanted her body donated to medical science have had their application rejected by the University of Nottingham.

    Angela Tideswell, who died of cancer on Sunday, asked for her body to be used to further research into the disease.

     
  6.  
    Today's cover photo 10:09: Dave Wade BBC Local Live

    Michiko Smith sent us this great picture of the heather and hillside in Hathersage, which has been chosen as today's cover photo on BBC Radio Derby's Facebook page.

    Hathersage

    You can tweet your Derbyshire photos, email or upload them to Facebook.

     
  7.  
    TOP HEADLINES
     
  8.  
    News on the hour 09:56: BBC Radio Derby

    In the news at 10:00, a man who spied on a woman about to try on a bikini in a Derby shop has been jailed for eight weeks.

    Hear this story and more on BBC Radio Derby.

     
  9.  
    Jobs fair 09:52: Buxton Advertiser

    A huge jobs fair will take place on September 5 with the help of bus operator Trent Barton.

     
  10.  
    30-second forecast 09:34: Charlie Slater Weather Presenter, BBC East Midlands Today
  11.  
    Derby 1-0 Charlton 09:20: Owen Bradley BBC Radio Derby Sport

    Derby County are through to the third round of the League Cup.

    Derby County's Zak Whitbread (centre left) and Charlton Athletic's Michael Morrison (centre right) battle for the ball

    Spanish forward Ivan Calero scored on his debut as the Rams beat Charlton 1-0 last night.

     
  12.  
    Funeral for student stabbed in Borneo 09:11:

    The funeral of Neil Dalton, from Derbyshire, who was stabbed to death in Borneo, takes place today.

    Neil Dalton

    Mr Dalton, 22, from Ambergate, was killed alongside fellow Newcastle University medical student Aidan Brunger earlier this month.

    His funeral will be held at St Peter's Church in Belper this afternoon.

     
  13.  
    News on the hour 08:57: Sally Swinfen Journalist, BBC Radio Derby

    The family of a Derby woman who wanted her body donated to medical science have had their application rejected by The University of Nottingham.

    Hear this story and others in the news at 09:00 on BBC Radio Derby.

     
  14.  
    Utilities firms fined 08:41: Derby Telegraph

    Utilities firms, including Western Power and Severn Trent, have been fined after delaying Derby's drivers with roadworks for which they did not have a permit.

     
  15.  
    Community hospital 'unsuitable for children' 08:30:

    A hospital's minor injury unit will close overnight after audits showed it was underused and unsuitable to treat children, reports BBC News Online.

    Ilkeston Community Hospital
     
  16.  
    Looking good on the roads 08:20: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    It's not looking too bad on the roads this morning, with no major incidents reported by BBC Travel as yet.

     
  17.  
    Sunny spells 08:10: Charlie Slater Weather Presenter, BBC East Midlands Today

    It will be dry, settled and bright today with a good number of sunny spells throughout.

    But it'll remain breezy, which will take the edge off the temperatures,. However, 20C (68F) is likely nonetheless.

     
  18.  
    Good morning 08:00:

    We'll be bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather updates for Derbyshire today.

    If you'd like to comment on any of the stories we're featuring, please get in touch via email or tweet @BBCDerby.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.