Wrongly jailed mum Lorraine Allen loses compensation bid

Lorraine Allen Lorraine Allen had argued the current criteria meant she effectively had to prove her innocence to get compensation

Related Stories

A mother who was wrongly imprisoned for killing her four-month-old son has lost a legal battle for compensation.

Lorraine Allen, formerly Harris, was jailed in 2000 for the manslaughter of her son, Patrick, in December 1998.

The European Court of Human Rights ruled the refusal was "not inconsistent with her innocence".

The conviction of Ms Allen, originally from Derbyshire but now living in Scarborough, was quashed in 2005 following fresh medical evidence.

The decision cannot be appealed against.

Barry George

The BBC's home affairs correspondent Danny Shaw says the ruling has major implications for other miscarriage of justice victims who have been denied damages for the time they have spent behind bars.

One of the highest profile of these is Barry George, who was convicted in 2001 of shooting TV presenter Jill Dando.

He was acquitted at a retrial in 2008 after doubt was cast on the reliability of gunshot residue evidence.

Currently, compensation is paid if the conviction is reversed on the grounds a new, or newly discovered, fact shows beyond reasonable doubt there had been a miscarriage of justice.

'Very disappointed'

Ms Allen claimed this was contrary to her right to be presumed innocent and placed a burden on her to prove her innocence.

But the European Court of Human Rights found UK judges properly considered whether any miscarriage of justice had taken place, and concluded this had not been established beyond reasonable doubt.

Start Quote

It has been a long battle for Lorraine and she has been very stalwart in trying to get the justice she thinks she deserves”

End Quote Mike Pemberton Solicitor

However, this decision, the court ruled, did not represent a comment on her guilt or innocence.

It said: "The language used by the UK courts in their decisions to decide on compensation had not undermined Ms Allen's acquittal or treated her in a manner inconsistent with her innocence."

Ms Allen was originally convicted after a jury was told her son had died from "shaken-baby syndrome", also known as Non Accidental Head Injury (NAHI).

After serving 16 months of a three-year sentence, the conviction was quashed at the Court of Appeal after fresh evidence from medical experts suggested the baby's injuries could have been caused in other ways.

She challenged the original compensation decision by Judicial Review, but this was refused by the High Court in 2007 and the subsequent appeal was dismissed in 2008.

Her fight then went to the European Court in Strasbourg, which heard her case in November but only now published its judgment.

Mike Pemberton, Mrs Allen's solicitor, said: "We are very disappointed with the outcome of today's case - it has been a long battle for Lorraine and she has been very stalwart in trying to get the justice she thinks she deserves.

"I would now call on the government to seriously consider bringing back the previous scheme to allow a discretionary and moral approach to compensation.

"It is abhorrent that the right to compensation following a miscarriage of justice relies entirely on the strength of evidence... in complex cases concerning differing expert views, it is highly likely that the high threshold required to obtain compensation will never be met."

UK Justice Minister Damian Green said: "I am pleased that the European Court of Human Rights has agreed with the judgment of our domestic courts and agrees that compensation is not applicable in this particular case."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Derby

Weather

Derby

8 °C 2 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    09:46: Mac: 'We played well' BBC Sport

    Steve McClaren said he thought his side played well at Brighton last night, despite losing 2-0.

    Steve McClaren

    He said: "We created so many openings and opportunities but at the present moment things just aren't working out for us."

     
  2.  
    09:29: Christmas lights switch BBC Radio Derby

    Derby could be getting a different kind of Christmas lights to help save the city council save thousands of pounds.

    The authority is considering replacing the existing lights with pictures projected onto buildings such as Derby Cathedral.

     
  3.  
    09:16: Father-to-be killed by barrier BBC Radio Derby

    The pregnant girlfriend of a man who was killed after a parking barrier swung into his car says she has received incredible support from family and friends.

    Rachael Cook and Will Page

    Will Page, 22, from Ilkeston, was crushed to death when the barrier went through the windscreen of his vehicle at an industrial site on Saturday.

    His partner Rachael Cook has been speaking to us about her loss.

     
  4.  
    08:57: News on the hour Sally Swinfen Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    The pregnant girlfriend of a man killed by a parking barrier, says she's grateful he had the chance to tell his family he was going to be a father.

    You can hear more on this story in my 09:00 bulletin.

     
  5.  
    08:44: A38 litter complaints Martyn Williams Reporter, BBC Radio Derby

    I've been out to take a look at the litter next to the A38 near Little Eaton island, following several calls from listeners.

    A38 litter

    One caller, Linda, said it seemed to have got much worse over the past two years and she believed lorry drivers were to blame.

     
  6.  
    08:31: Burton crash BBC Travel

    An accident has led to delays at the junction on Derby Road and Hawkins Lane in Burton.

     
  7.  
    08:20: Rams beaten again BBC Sport

    Derby County have dropped to second in the Championship after losing 2-0 at Brighton last night.

    Disappointed Derby County players

    The Rams dominated large parts of the game but succumbed to late goals from Dale Stephens and Kazenga Lua Lua.

     
  8.  
    08:05: Sunshine and showers Sara Blizzard BBC Weather

    After a chilly start it will be a bright and breezy day with sunny periods and just a few light showers.

    Sara Blizzard

    The wind will be strong at times during the morning but will ease later this afternoon with highs of 8C (46F).

     
  9.  
    08:00: Good morning Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    Hi everyone. I'll be bring you all of today's news, sport, travel and weather for Derbyshire and East Staffordshire.

    I enjoy featuring your comments and photos, so email derby.locallive@bbc.co.uk or tweet us @bbcderby at any time.

     

Features

  • Elderly manSuicide decline

    The number of old people killing themselves has fallen. Why?


  • Petrol pumpPumping up

    Why are petrol prices rising again?


  • Image of George from Tube CrushTube crush

    How London's male commuters set Chinese hearts racing


  • TricycleTreasure trove

    The lost property shop stuffed with diamonds, bikes... and a leg


Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.