Derby fire deaths: Mairead Philpott to appeal against jail term

Duwayne Philpott, 13, Jade Philpott, 10, and brothers John, nine, Jack, seven, Jesse, six, and Jayden, five Five of the children died on the morning of the fire and the eldest died three days later

Related Stories

A lawyer for Mairead Philpott, who killed her six children in a fire, said she would appeal against her jail term.

Philpott and her friend Paul Mosley will serve half of their 17-year sentences for manslaughter. Her husband Mick was given a life sentence.

Shaun Smith QC, Mairead's barrister, admitted she was "instrumental in the killing" but not to the extent the judge said.

The six children died after a fire at their Derby home started by the trio.

Jade Philpott, 10, and brothers John, nine, Jack, seven, Jesse, six, and Jayden, five, died on the morning of the blaze on 11 May 2012.

Duwayne, who was 13, died three days later in hospital.

Mairead Philpott Mairead Philpott was accused at her trial of putting her husband before her children

Mr Smith, who represented the mother in the trial at Nottingham Crown Court earlier this year, said her sentence was too long.

"She was instrumental in killing six children but we feel as though her role in the deaths was not as substantial as the trial judge has assessed," he said.

"We will have to wait and see what the Court of Appeal say."

In passing sentence on Mairead Philpott on 4 April, Mrs Justice Thirlwall told her: "These were your children. Your first responsibility, surely, was to them.

"The risks were obvious and overwhelming and anyone who has heard the harrowing wailing from you on the 999 call can hear your realisation that this had gone horribly wrong and your children were in mortal danger.

"But by then it was too late and you bear your responsibility for that.

"You put Michael Philpott above your children and as a result they have died."

'Very vulnerable'

Mr Smith was talking in an interview with BBC Radio Nottingham and he described his first meeting with Mairead Philpott when he was assigned to her defence.

"She was very scared, she was very vulnerable. She was clearly someone who had been in a horrendous relationship, as the court heard," he said.

"She was someone who was quite frankly in the wrong place at the wrong time.

"It was a very upsetting case for everybody involved. I think it took a little piece out of me."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Derby



Min. Night 11 °C

BBC Local Live


    Today's Local Live updates have now finished. The service will be back at 08:00 on Thursday.

    17:49: Mild evening Anna Church BBC Weather

    Cloudy overnight with some patchy light rain and drizzle. Mild with lows of 10C (50F).

    17:40: East Midlands Today Dominic Heale Presenter

    On BBC One at 18:30, we'll be talking to the Candy Crush entrepreneur who's spent over £1m of his own money buying a remarkable hi-tech machine for a Derby hospital.

    Surgical equipment

    We'll also have all of the goals from Derby's cup clash with Chelsea .

    17:27: Safe haven for party-goers

    People enjoying festive nights out in Derby city centre are being offered a safe place to seek medical attention and help.

    The triage service, being run by police, the ambulance service, health workers and street pastors, will be based at the Central United Reformed Church on Becketwell Lane on busy nights over the next fortnight.

    17:19: Rams accept red card

    Derby County say they will not appeal against the red card shown to Jake Buxton in last night's cup clash with Chelsea.

    The club said: "Having taken due consideration and all factors into account, the club have decided not to appeal the decision and will make no further comment."

    17:15: 'Ignore shopping centre rumours'

    Derbyshire Police has told people to ignore an "urban myth" being circulated which suggests shopping centres should be avoided this weekend.

    Derby's Intu shopping centre

    The force said the yarn, which usually involves a good Samaritan being warned by the person they've helped that something terrible is due to happen at a given place, was often shared at this time of year but had "no credibility".

    17:12: Power station plan moves forward Derby Telegraph

    Consent has been given for a 17-mile gas pipeline that is the latest step towards work starting on a billion-pound power station in Derbyshire.

    17:04: Your photos Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    Thank you to Andrew Burdett for this wonderful photo of Hucklow Edge, taken last week.

    Hucklow Edge

    Email or tweet us your best pictures of Derbyshire. I'll feature the cream of the crop on BBC Local Live.

    16:55: News on the hour Martyn Williams Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    In my 17:00 bulletin, an Oakwood footballer appears in court over an alleged assault at a bar in Derby.

    16:51: Homes could bring new jobs BBC Radio Derby

    Burton MP Andrew Griffiths has welcomed plans for a major housing development in Branston.

    Developer St Modwen has unveiled proposals for more than 600 new homes along with manufacturing and storage businesses, which it says will create up to 1,500 jobs.

    16:42: History maker

    The Church of England's first female bishop has been unveiled as the Glossop-born Reverend Libby Lane.

    Libby Lane

    She will become the eighth Bishop of Stockport at a ceremony at York Minster on 26 January.

    16:29: Friday switch-on for transmitter BBC Radio Derby

    Another digital radio transmitter for Derbyshire is to be switched on this Friday.

    The new transmitter, at Stanton Moor, will allow more people in north Derbyshire to listen to BBC Radio Derby on DAB Digital Radio.

    16:15: Hughes 'exceptional'

    The Independent's Kevin Garside praised Derby County's performance in last night's 3-1 defeat to Chelsea.

    Will Hughes tussles with Eden Hazard

    He wrote: "Derby fairly charged into the game, paying England's pre-eminent force nil respect.

    "Real Madrid loan star Omar Mascarell excelled at the base of the Derby midfield and, at the point of the diamond, Will Hughes (pictured) was exceptional."

    16:06: Feedback Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

    15:54: News on the hour Martyn Williams Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    In my 16:00 bulletin, a children's charity praises Derbyshire's John Port School for helping to raise awareness of "sexting".

    15:50: School places deadline approaches

    Amid the festive flurry, Derbyshire County Council is reminding parents the deadline for applying for their child's primary school place is 15 January.

    The authority said a quarter of parents had still yet to express a preference.

    15:39: Footballer in court

    BBC News Online has more on Nottingham Forest's Jamaal Lascelles appearing in court charged with assaulting a man at a nightclub in Derby.

    Jamaal Lascelles

    Mr Lascelles, 21, from Oakwood, will be back in court in March over the incident, which happened at Derby's Lola Lo in April.

    15:26: New face

    A former hairdresser has become Ashbourne's new police community support officer (PCSO).

    Gemma Darby

    Gemma Darby spent six years cutting hair in Alfreton but has now joined the town's crime-fighting team after deciding on a change of career.

    15:11: New road named after WW1

    A new street in Darley Dale has been named Poppy Fields Close to mark the centenary of the start of World War One.

    Deborah Shimwell and her son Kristian on Poppy Fields Close

    Deborah Shimwell and her son Kristian (pictured) are among the new residents at the 34-home development, which includes a plaque featuring a verse from the popular wartime poem In Flanders Fields.

    14:59: News on the hour Martyn Williams Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    In the news at 15:00

    The Burton MP Andrew Griffiths is attempting to deliver 40 thousand cards this christmas - one to every house in his constituency.

    14:41: Chimney fire put out Derby Telegraph

    Firefighters tackled a chimney fire in Derbyshire this morning.

    14:25: School praised for 'sexting' warning BBC Radio Derby

    Claire Lilley, the NSPCC's head of online safety, said staff at John Port School in Etwall deserved credit for bringing the issue of "sexting" to parents' attention.

    She said: "This is happening in every school around the country and I think the school is to be commended for taking such decisive action to work in partnership with parents and make them aware of the situation."

    14:12: No red card appeal Owen Bradley BBC Radio Derby Sport

    I really feel for Jake Buxton but can see why Derby County aren't appealing the red card he received against Chelsea last night.

    Jake Buxton receives a red card

    He'll now miss the next two games for the Rams, against Norwich and Birmingham City.

    13:56: News on the hour Martyn Williams Newsreader

    A new report has found government departments are unwilling to share information with local Staffordshire councils responsible for safeguarding young people from issues such as sexual exploitation.

    I'll bring you the full story in my 14:00 bulletin on BBC Radio Derby.

    13:46: Christmas bins

    Derbyshire Dales District Council tweets: Don't get caught out! Changes to our bin collections timetable over festive season happen from this Sat >

    13:32: Winter wildlife Andy Potter Presenter, BBC Radio Derby

    At 13:45, I'll be finding out how the arrival of winter is affecting wildlife around Carsington Water. Listen live.

    Carsington Water, taken by Andy Potter
    13:18: East Midlands Today Sarah Teale Presenter

    On BBC One at 13:30, we speak to the Candy Crush entrepreneur who's buying life saving equipment at the Royal Derby Hospital.

    Entrepreneur Mel Morris meets staff at the Royal Derby Hospital
    13:06: Panto cash Sally Pepper Presenter, BBC Radio Derby

    Thank you to everyone who donated to the Colin Bloomfield Melanoma Appeal at the BBC Radio Derby panto on Sunday - you raised an amazing £2,060.39.

    Sally Pepper

    You'll be able to hear the panto itself on BBC Radio Derby, at 18:00 on Christmas Day.

    12:54: News on the hour Martyn Williams Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    The NSPCC has praised a Derbyshire school for raising awareness of "sexting".

    I'll bring you the details in my 13:00 bulletin.

    12:50: Food fest to be shelved Derbyshire Times

    A long-running annual event celebrating Derbyshire's food and drink producers is to be axed.

    12:37: Footballer in court

    Nottingham Forest defender Jamaal Lascelles has appeared in court charged with a nightclub assault in Derby.

    Jamaal Lascelles

    The 21-year-old, from Oakwood, was granted conditional bail until his next court appearance over the 23 April incident.

    12:27: Your photos for Facebook Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    Our latest Facebook cover photo, showing a wintry Chatsworth House, was sent in by regular contributor Villager Jim.

    Facebook cover photo showing Chatsworth House

    Nominate one of your pictures as a future cover image by emailing it to

    12:18: Afternoon outlook Charlie Slater BBC Weather

    It will be dull, cloudy and mainly overcast for most of this afternoon, with highs of 11C (52F).

    12:07: MP cards 'not politically motivated' BBC Radio Derby

    Andrew Griffiths, Conservative MP for Burton, dismissed the idea that sending 40,000 Christmas cards to constituents was electioneering.

    He said: "There's no politics involved. I think people appreciate their MP taking the time and trouble to wish them a merry Christmas."

    11:56: News on the hour Sally Swinfen Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    The NSPCC says it's getting an increasing number of calls from children affected by sexting.

    It comes after John Port School sent letters home to parents informing them that police are investigating cases of pupils being coerced into sending explicit images of themselves to strangers.

    Find out more in my 12:00 bulletin.

    11:55: Chellaston assault

    A man suffered a broken cheekbone when he was punched in the face as he walked through Chellaston at the weekend.

    The victim said his attacker had been standing with two other men and a woman before the assault, on Derby Road at 01:00 on Saturday.

    11:40: Rams verdict

    Daily Mail sports writer Ian Ladyman called last night's Derby v Chelsea cup tie "gripping" and described the Rams as "a capable team".

    He wrote: "They looked sporadically dangerous with the ball and deserved to be in the contest until the death.

    "By some distance, their best player was the young Englishman Will Hughes."

    11:28: Bryson on Chelsea goal

    Craig Bryson's second-half strike was the high point for Derby County in last night's 3-1 League Cup defeat to Chelsea.

    Craig Bryson scores

    Afterwards he said: "It's obviously good to score against Chelsea but we're disappointed to lose the game."

    11:18: Mild Wednesday

    BBC Weather has shared this map showing mild conditions across the UK this afternoon.

    Weather map
    11:09: Robotic gift from Candy Crush tycoon

    BBC News Online has more on Derby entrepreneur Mel Morris buying a £1.2m robotic arm for the Royal Derby Hospital.

    Mel Morris

    The Derby County director, who made a fortune from his involvement with the firm that created Candy Crush Saga, said he hoped the equipment would attract more top surgeons to the hospital.

    10:56: News on the hour Sally Swinfen Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    My 11:00 bulletin will feature the latest on an investigation into a suspected "sexting" scam at John Port School in Derbyshire. Listen live.

    10:45: New homes jobs hope Burton Mail

    Jobseekers have been handed a Christmas boost after it was revealed that a major housing development on the outskirts of Burton will create 1,500 new jobs.

    10:36: Roberts takes the biscuit

    Former Derby County player Gareth Roberts was filmed tucking into a pack of biscuits during his Chester side's FA Cup game against Barnsley last night.

    Gareth Roberts

    However, the energy boost failed to stop Roberts and his team-mates losing 3-0 to Barnsley.

    Email: 10:26: MP cards 'a waste of money'

    Susie Cliff wrote in after receiving one of 40,000 Christmas cards sent by Burton MP Andrew Griffiths.

    She said: "What a waste of money. Do what most people do - give the money you would have spent on Christmas cards to charity!

    "My Christmas card from Andrew Griffiths went straight into the recycle bin!"

    10:14: MP sends 40,000 cards BBC Radio Derby

    Burton MP Andrew Griffiths is sending out 40,000 Christmas cards to constituents.

    Andrew Griffiths

    He said the cards were being delivered by volunteers as "a bit of Christmas fun" and said the printing bill had been shared by himself and the local Conservative association.

    10:04: 'Sexting no worse at John Port'

    John Foxon, assistant head teacher at John Port School, sought to reassure parents after it was revealed pupils may have been targeted in a "sexting" scam.

    John Foxon

    He said: "This school has no more or less a problem than any other school. As a school community, we need to address it and give our young people the maximum protection and safeguarding measures."

    09:55: News on the hour Sally Swinfen Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    After John Port School wrote to parents about a "sexting" scam, the NSPCC has warned the practice is becoming more widespread.

    Find out more in my 10:00 bulletin.

    09:48: Grieving mother welcomes drugs move Matthew Barlow Reporter, BBC Radio Derby

    The mother of a woman who died after taking drugs during a night out in Buxton just before Christmas two years ago has welcomed a police crackdown on drugs ahead of this year's festive party season.

    Lisa Hallsworth with a photo of her daughter Charlotte

    Lisa Hallsworth's 20-year-old daughter Charlotte died after taking cocaine and ecstasy while out drinking in December 2012. She says Christmas will always be a tough time for the family now.

    09:39: CCTV switch-off fears Derby Telegraph

    Proposals to switch off council-run CCTV cameras in Derby city centre have been branded "potentially disastrous" by business owners.

    09:25: Have your say Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you news, sport, travel and weather updates in one place. We'd like to find out what you think of the service.

    09:16: Roma report finds weaknesses BBC Radio Derby

    An Ofsted report has highlighted issues with the way Roma pupils are supported through the education system in Derby.

    Roma students in the city are moved between two different schools - a language centre and a regular school - to help them integrate, but Ofsted said the method was proving disruptive for pupils.

    09:07: Entrepreneur's hospital gift Simon Hare Reporter, BBC East Midlands Today

    A Derby entrepreneur who made millions from the mobile game Candy Crush Saga has used some of his money to buy a piece of hi-tech hospital equipment.

    Mel Morris with new equipment

    Mel Morris has spent £1.2m on the da Vinci machine for the Royal Derby Hospital. It helps surgeons carry out intricate life-saving procedures using virtual reality-type controls.

    08:58: News on the hour Sally Swinfen Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    In my 09:00 bulletin, we'll hear from the NSPCC after John Port School wrote to parents about investigations into "sexting" scams.

    08:46: Rotherham role for children's chief The Guardian

    Read an interview with the outgoing head of children's services in Derbyshire, Ian Thomas.

    Mr Thomas is taking on the same role in Rotherham, where it was revealed earlier this year that more than 1.400 children had been sexually exploited between 1997 and 2013.

    08:35: 'Sexting' reports worry parents BBC Radio Derby

    Some parents of pupils at John Port School, in Etwall, say they are worried about reports some pupils were coerced into sending explicit photos of themselves to strangers.

    John Port School

    The school has sent letters to thousands of parents after several pupils were targeted in a suspected "sexting" scam.

    08:25: Rams beaten by classy Blues

    Derby County were knocked out of the League Cup by Chelsea last night.

    Chelsea celebrate their second goal

    Eden Hazard, Filipe Luis and Andre Schurrle netted for the Blues while Craig Bryson scored for the Rams shortly before Jake Buxton was sent off.

    08:16: Grey but mild Charlie Slater BBC Weather

    A much milder day with highs of 11C (52F), although we won't see a huge amount of sunshine.

    There may be occasional outbreaks of light and patchy rain too.

    08:06: Abnormal load causes disruption

    BBC Travel warns there are delays on the A50 between the Foston and Alton Towers junctions because of an abnormal load.

    08:00: Good morning Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    Hi everyone, I'm here to bring you all today's news, sport, travel and weather updates.

    I love to feature your contributions so be sure to email or tweet your comments and photos at any time.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.