Bombardier report: Credit rating 'settled rail deal'

Select committee chairwoman Louise Ellman said the Thameslink decision should be reviewed by the National Audit Office

Related Stories

A superior credit rating helped German firm Siemens beat trainmaker Bombardier to a £1.4bn government contract, a Transport Select Committee report says.

Derby-based Bombardier was told in June it had lost the deal to build 1,200 Thameslink carriages.

The government said the German firm's bid offered better value for taxpayers, but campaigners have called for a U-turn in favour of the British firm.

The committee's report called for a full National Audit Office review.

Canadian-owned Bombardier announced it was cutting 1,400 jobs after Siemens was named as the preferred bidder for the lucrative contract.

Critics said the government's procurement process had failed to take into account the wider social and economic impact of awarding the deal to the German firm.

'Significant contribution'

In September the Transport Select Committee, chaired by Labour MP Louise Ellman, heard evidence from company bosses and the then Transport Secretary Phillip Hammond.


Chris Doidge

BBC Radio Derby

The committee's recommendations come served with a heavy dose of déjà vu.

The National Audit Office says it will take its recommendations seriously, but it has already examined - and cleared - the way Thameslink has been handled up to now.

Regularly rehearsed criticisms made of the deal have been accepted by the committee.

Concerns over the importance of Siemens' credit rating are shared by the MPs.

But campaigners' hopes that the committee would call for a complete rethink of Thameslink have been rebuffed. For that reason alone, this report could be a disappointment to many in Derby.

Its report on the hearing states: "It is hard to escape the conclusion that Siemens' A+ credit rating made a significant contribution to its success in winning the Thameslink procurement."

Bombardier was reported to have a B++ credit rating.

The committee has now written to the National Audit Office to recommend it holds a full review into the deal.

Ms Ellman said: "We could not evaluate whether the decision to choose Siemens was arrived at correctly because all of the bids were and remain confidential.

"We believe that in the public interest an independent review must evaluate whether this massive contract was awarded correctly on the basis of the criteria in the original invitation to tender."

MPs also concluded the bundling together of train manufacture and financing in large procurement exercises would skew the market towards larger multinational firms, possibly at the expense of excellence in train design and domestic manufacturing.

'Veil of secrecy'

The report called for the government to release more information about its decision.

It said: "If the government proceeds to sign a contract with Siemens we recommend that it publish the reasons for favouring Siemens over Bombardier and the difference in the cost of the two bids."

In October, the National Audit Office told campaigners it had decided against a full review of the deal but had not ruled out examining the deal at a later date.

It said it would consider the committee's recommendations.

Unite union general secretary Len McCluskey said: "The select committee's report is a damning indictment of the government.

"The Thameslink contract has been shrouded in a veil of secrecy.

"It will be a national scandal if the transport secretary refuses to put the Thameslink contract on hold to allow a full inquiry."

A Department for Transport spokesman said: "We welcome the committee's report, which moves on from the process set up by the last government and endorses the coalition's decision to look again at how procurement can be improved.

"The committee recognises that the procurement process started by Labour was too narrowly drawn to take account of socio-economic factors, and could not have been reopened by the current government."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Derby



6 °C 2 °C


  • Mukesh SinghNo remorse

    Delhi bus rapist says victim shouldn't have fought back

  • Aimen DeanI spied

    The founder member of al-Qaeda who worked for MI6

  • Before and after shotsPerfect body

    Just how reliable are 'before and after' photos?

  • Lotus 97T driven by Elio de AngelisBeen and gone

    A champion F1 designer and other notable losses

  • A poster of Boris Nemtsov at a rally in St Petersburg, Russia, 1 MarchWho killed Nemtsov?

    Theories abound over murder that shocked Moscow

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.