West Midlands Police rapped over Lloyd Butler custody death

Lloyd Butler Lloyd Butler died after he was held in a cell at Stechford Police Station

Related Stories

Police made an "alarming number of mistakes" and behaved "unacceptably" before a man died in custody, a watchdog has found.

Lloyd Butler, from Birmingham, was held at Stechford police station in 2010 when he should have gone to hospital.

The Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) report was released after an inquest heard he may have lived had he gone to hospital earlier.

West Midlands Police apologised and said improvements have been made.

'Big gap'

Mr Butler's mother Janet said her son's treatment had been "appalling".

"The day I was told my son passed away at Stechford was the day my life had a big, big gap," she said.

"There's no such thing as closure. His two boys have no father.

"I'm told deaths in custody have gone down but they should never happen in the first place."

Officers were originally called by Mr Butler's family because he was drunk and they were concerned about his welfare.

The 39-year-old father from Sheldon was declared dead at hospital after officers started first aid in his cell. He died of cardiac arrest from an alcohol-related condition.

Mr Butler's mother Janet said her son's treatment was appalling Mr Butler's mother Janet said her son's treatment was appalling

The IPCC found officers on duty in the custody suite failed in an observation plan that required him to be regularly roused and his condition checked.

Some of the visits were missed entirely while others failed to rouse Mr Butler sufficiently.

IPCC criticisms of the police also included:

• PC Dean Woodcock surfed the internet and made personal calls rather than monitoring CCTV footage of Mr Butler's cell

• Sgt Mark Albutt made improper entries in the custody record alleging that officers were checking more often and more thoroughly than actually occurred

• PC Woodcock and civilian member of staff detention escort officer Darren Wall joked about Mr Butler's condition and made insulting remarks about him. They included when Mr Butler's trousers fell below his waist, instead of assisting him.

'Concerned and disappointed'

The inquest concluded Mr Butler was already "incapable" when he arrived in custody.

The narrative conclusion was: "Had Mr Butler been on a monitor in A&E the probability is, he was likely to have survived."

Police released CCTV after an inquest criticised them for the death in custody

Birmingham senior coroner Louise Hunt said she "remained concerned about contact in custody suites" and there needed to be a "change of culture to take account of vulnerable people".

She will now write to West Midlands Police and send a report to prevent future deaths.

The custody sergeant responsible for Mr Butler's care in a cell, Sgt Albutt, was found guilty of gross misconduct last January and given a final written warning.

Two other officers were also found guilty of misconduct and given advice.

'Tragic loss'

Acting Ch Con Gary Cann said he was "concerned and disappointed" by the actions of officers, who had failed to carry out an adequate risk assessment when arresting Mr Butler and placed him in custody instead of taking him to hospital.

"We do not underestimate the impact the death of Lloyd Butler has had on his family and friends and the force extends its sincere condolences," he said.

He added: "Improvements have been made since this case which will help ensure safeguards are in place to prevent deaths in custody."

IPCC Associate Commissioner Guido Liguori said: "My thoughts are with Lloyd Butler's family and friends for their tragic loss. The indifferent treatment of Mr Butler by officers and staff of West Midlands Police showed a disregard for both the stated procedures of detention and also for human decency."

The watchdog said it referred the case to the Crown Prosecution Service but it was decided the officers' actions "did not meet the threshold for prosecution".

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country



23 °C 16 °C

BBC Local Live

    Trojan Horse: Police release statement 11:24:

    West Midlands Police has released a statement saying "contrary to media reports today, no crimes have been referred for police investigation directly linked to the alleged [Trojan Horse] 'plot' and no fresh inquiry has been launched by the force".

    PC commended over arrest 11:14: Stourbridge News

    Brave Dudley cop PC Jessica Preston has been commended for her courage after she put her life in danger to arrest Stefan Rattray.

    Things to do 11:05:

    The BBC has put together a list of Things To Do in the region. Activities include sports and nature trails.

    to do
    News on the hour 10:55: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    It's emerged a man's been checked for the deadly Ebola virus after landing at Birmingham Airport.

    Tests were carried out as a precaution, but doctors gave him the all clear. Listen live

    Sandwell welcomes Stimpson back 10:50: via Facebook

    Sandwell Council writes: "Our very own double gold medal winner Jodie Stimpson is back in Sandwell on Sunday to compete in the Jodie Stimpson Aquathlon at Sandwell Valley Country Park.

    "So please come along and cheer Jodie and all of the competitors on!

    "The 750m Swim starts at 9am from Swan Pool, followed by a 5k run. If you fancy taking part, please register here: http://www.stuweb.co.uk/events/2014/08/03/1669/."

    Your views 10:43: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    We've introduced BBC Local Live in Birmingham and the Black Country to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think about this local service.

    New breed of buses 10:31: Birmingham Post

    A new breed of buses are set for Birmingham's streets within two years under a £15m scheme.

    New wrestling correspondent 10:21: John Bray Assistant editor, BBC Midlands Today

    We've just had the Midlands Today morning meeting where we discuss what stories we're going to cover today.

    I've given Kath Stanczyszyn the task of getting to the bottom of what Oldbury's bronze medal winning wrestler Chinu's surname is, so she's off to Wolverhampton Wrestling Club where he trains.

    New Street work 10:08:

    Birmingham New Street Station says it's "another step closer" as work on the new Hill Street staircase nears completion.

    Bham New St steps July 2014
    News on the hour 09:59: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    The Police Federation in the West Midlands has told BBC WM government cuts are to blame for an increase in attacks on officers.

    It comes a day after a drug dealer was jailed for 10 years for attacking a female officer in Dudley. Listen live

    Disappointment for Hannah 09:47: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    Birmingham based athlete Hannah England finished a disappointing seventh in the 1,500m final last night.

    Compatriot Laura Weightman took the silver though to round off a day of success for Team England.

    Hannah's husband Luke Gunn will be competing in the 3,000m steeplechase later in the week.

    Bank robber dressed as builder 09:35: Express and Star
    Chopra ton helps Bears win 09:24:

    Varun Chopra hit his first century of the summer as Warwickshire made it two wins out of two in the One-Day Cup with victory over Sussex by 118 runs.

    varun chopra
    Good news for hayfever sufferers 09:15:

    Health Brum tweets: Today's #healthybrum pollen count is again low. #hayfever advice ow.ly/vgBq2

    Bronze for Wolves wrestler 09:07: John Bray Assistant editor, BBC Midlands Today

    Congratulations to Wolverhampton wrestler Chinu Xxx, who won bronze last night in the men's 125kg.

    We're hoping to hear from him later - and our priority will be to ask him about his unusual name. Apparently it comes from a bit of confusion with the Passport Office.

    Wolverhampton Wrestling Club call him Chinu Singh so we'll go with that for now.

    News on the hour 09:00: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    It's emerged a man's been checked for the deadly Ebola virus after landing at Birmingham Airport.

    Tests were carried out as a precaution, but doctors gave him the all clear.

    It comes just hours before Foreign Secretary Philip Hammond chairs a meeting of the Cobra emergency committee to discuss the outbreak of Ebola in West Africa.

    Aid agencies there say the disease has killed more than 670 people since February. Mr Hammond says the epidemic "is a threat". Listen live

    Driverless cars to be tested 08:48:

    Driverless cars are to be tested on roads in the West Midlands next year.

    Nissan car

    The vehicles are guided by a system of sensors and cameras and are said to be potentially safer and more efficient than normal cars.

    The government is to outline measures later to permit driverless cars to use public roads by next year.

    Top headlines
    Protest over council flag decision 08:36: Birmingham Mail

    Gaza supporters are to stage a silent protest in Victoria Square after Birmingham City Council refused to fly the Palestine flag.

    Trojan Horse: No criminal investigation 08:27: Kath Stanczyszyn Political reporter, BBC WM

    West Midlands Police says there will be no Trojan Horse criminal investigation following the recently published Clarke Report into the alleged takeover of certain Birmingham schools by hardline Muslims.

    Information is "still being assessed" though.

    Travel updates 08:17:

    Two lanes are closed and there's queuing traffic on the M42 northbound between J7a M6 and J8 M6 because of over-running roadworks. Travel time is about 25 minutes and there's congestion to J6, A45 (Birmingham Airport).

    There are also delays in and around Birmingham city centre because of the planned tunnel closures. See BBC Travel News for more.

    Brighter later 08:07:

    A mainly fine and dry day once again. Often fairly cloudy through the morning, but becoming brighter with some warm sunny spells into the afternoon and early evening.


    See BBC Weather for more information.

    Good morning 08:00: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    I'll be bringing you the latest news, sport, weather and travel throughout the day for Birmingham and the Black Country.

    You can get in touch by emailing locallive@bbc.co.uk.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.