West Midlands Police rapped over Lloyd Butler custody death

Lloyd Butler Lloyd Butler died after he was held in a cell at Stechford Police Station

Related Stories

Police made an "alarming number of mistakes" and behaved "unacceptably" before a man died in custody, a watchdog has found.

Lloyd Butler, from Birmingham, was held at Stechford police station in 2010 when he should have gone to hospital.

The Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) report was released after an inquest heard he may have lived had he gone to hospital earlier.

West Midlands Police apologised and said improvements have been made.

'Big gap'

Mr Butler's mother Janet said her son's treatment had been "appalling".

"The day I was told my son passed away at Stechford was the day my life had a big, big gap," she said.

"There's no such thing as closure. His two boys have no father.

"I'm told deaths in custody have gone down but they should never happen in the first place."

Officers were originally called by Mr Butler's family because he was drunk and they were concerned about his welfare.

The 39-year-old father from Sheldon was declared dead at hospital after officers started first aid in his cell. He died of cardiac arrest from an alcohol-related condition.

Mr Butler's mother Janet said her son's treatment was appalling Mr Butler's mother Janet said her son's treatment was appalling

The IPCC found officers on duty in the custody suite failed in an observation plan that required him to be regularly roused and his condition checked.

Some of the visits were missed entirely while others failed to rouse Mr Butler sufficiently.

IPCC criticisms of the police also included:

• PC Dean Woodcock surfed the internet and made personal calls rather than monitoring CCTV footage of Mr Butler's cell

• Sgt Mark Albutt made improper entries in the custody record alleging that officers were checking more often and more thoroughly than actually occurred

• PC Woodcock and civilian member of staff detention escort officer Darren Wall joked about Mr Butler's condition and made insulting remarks about him. They included when Mr Butler's trousers fell below his waist, instead of assisting him.

'Concerned and disappointed'

The inquest concluded Mr Butler was already "incapable" when he arrived in custody.

The narrative conclusion was: "Had Mr Butler been on a monitor in A&E the probability is, he was likely to have survived."

Police released CCTV after an inquest criticised them for the death in custody

Birmingham senior coroner Louise Hunt said she "remained concerned about contact in custody suites" and there needed to be a "change of culture to take account of vulnerable people".

She will now write to West Midlands Police and send a report to prevent future deaths.

The custody sergeant responsible for Mr Butler's care in a cell, Sgt Albutt, was found guilty of gross misconduct last January and given a final written warning.

Two other officers were also found guilty of misconduct and given advice.

'Tragic loss'

Acting Ch Con Gary Cann said he was "concerned and disappointed" by the actions of officers, who had failed to carry out an adequate risk assessment when arresting Mr Butler and placed him in custody instead of taking him to hospital.

"We do not underestimate the impact the death of Lloyd Butler has had on his family and friends and the force extends its sincere condolences," he said.

He added: "Improvements have been made since this case which will help ensure safeguards are in place to prevent deaths in custody."

IPCC Associate Commissioner Guido Liguori said: "My thoughts are with Lloyd Butler's family and friends for their tragic loss. The indifferent treatment of Mr Butler by officers and staff of West Midlands Police showed a disregard for both the stated procedures of detention and also for human decency."

The watchdog said it referred the case to the Crown Prosecution Service but it was decided the officers' actions "did not meet the threshold for prosecution".

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country



Min. Night 9 °C

BBC Local Live

    Last chance to see Staffs hoard 16:20: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    Birmingham Museums says this weekend is your last chance to see the Staffordshire Hoard until a new gallery opens in mid-October.

    Bus driver fears he could lose home 16:11: Birmingham Mail

    A bus driver who lost his job after becoming virtually totally blind fears he is just a month away from having his Birmingham house repossessed.

    News on the hour 16:01: Alice Rosenthal Journalist, BBC WM

    In the 16:00 news bulletin: The West Midlands has a new police and crime commissioner. Labour's David Jamieson polled just over 50% of the total votes.

    Second voting stage not needed 15:48: Kath Stanczyszyn Political reporter, BBC WM

    The second stage of counting for the police and crime commissioner was not needed as Labour's David Jamieson had more than half the votes.

    David Jamieson
    Your pictures 15:37: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    Thanks to Henry for sharing this picture of the train outside the Library of Birmingham.

    Flower train

    If you've taken any pictures you'd like to share you can email them to us at locallive@bbc.co.uk.

    New council houses 15:24: Express and Star

    People will get the chance to apply for one of Wolverhampton's first new council homes in 30 years from next week.

    One in 10 voted in commissioner poll 15:09:

    The overall turnout for the West Midlands Police and Crime Commission election has been adjusted to 10.41%.

    In total, 205,456 people voted.

    News on the hour 14:56: Alice Rosenthal Journalist, BBC WM

    The by-election for a new police and crime commissioner for the West Midlands has attracted little interest among voters.

    In the news on BBC WM at 15:00 we hear from the leader of Sandwell Council, Darren Cooper.

    Volunteers needed for parkrun 14:48: via Facebook

    Cannon Hill parkrun needs volunteers for tomorrow's event. See its Facebook page for more details.

    'Tough act to follow' 14:34:

    New West Midlands Police and Crime Commissioner David Jamieson says "he stands there in humility because he has a very tough act to follow", after the death of Bob Jones in July.

    Bears in final 14:22:

    Birmingham Bears will compete in the Natwest T20 Blast Finals Day tomorrow at Edgbaston.

    T20 cricketers

    The Bears, who opted not to use Warwickshire as their name for this season's competition, have not reached the final since 2003.

    On that occasion they were beaten by Surrey, who will again be their opponents in the first semi-final. Lancashire and Hampshire will contest the other semi.

    Man 'first in world to pirate copy film' 14:10: Express and Star

    An internet pirate who cost Universal Pictures an estimated £2.3million by being the first person in the world to pirate a copy of their blockbuster film Fast & Furious 6 has been jailed.

    Be a curator 14:00:

    Birmingham Museums tweets: 1st chance to play Curation Game @BM_AG today. Be a curator and help us with plans to re-display 17thC art galleries! Gallery 25, 2-4pm.

    News on the hour 13:55: Alice Rosenthal Journalist, BBC WM

    About one in 10 people turned out to vote yesterday in the election for a new police and crime commissioner.

    I'll have more at 14:00.

    Film distributor 'lost millions' 13:48:

    More on the man jailed for filming Fast and Furious 6 in a cinema. A judge in Wolverhampton ruled that Philip Danks, 25, uploaded the movie, which was downloaded 700,000 times.

    The Federation Against Copyright Theft (Fact) claimed this meant "millions of pounds" lost for the film's distributor, Universal Pictures.

    Labour candidate is new PCC 13:34:

    Labour's David Jamieson has been elected as the new West Midlands police and crime commissioner, as it emerged the turnout was just 10.41%.

    PCC Vote count WM 2014

    The turnout was lower than the 12% in the area in the original PCC contest in 2012, won by Bob Jones, who died in July. Votes were counted at the ICC in Birmingham.

    Manufacturer secures new funding 13:26: Birmingham Post

    A Black Country manufacturing group has secured a new £1.2 million funding deal with HSBC to support its growth plans and contract wins with global car manufacturers.

    GCSE results breakdown 13:14:

    A report with regional GCSE statistics has been published.

    News on the hour 12:57: Alice Rosenthal Journalist, BBC WM

    The West Midlands has a new police and crime commissioner.

    I'll have more in the 13:00 news bulletin.

    Man who filmed in cinema jailed 12:47:

    A man has been jailed for 33 months after recording Fast And Furious 6 from the back of a cinema in Walsall.

    Fast and Furious 6

    A judge in Wolverhampton ruled that Philip Danks, 25, uploaded the movie, which was downloaded 700,000 times.


    David Jamieson, the Labour candidate in the West Midlands PCC by-election, has been confirmed as the winner.

    Sunday service for Monday buses 12:19:

    National Express West Midlands will operate a Sunday service on its bus routes on bank holiday Monday.

    Strain of demise on Carson Yeung 12:09: Birmingham Mail

    See a dramatic snatched photograph from inside a Hong Kong prison van which graphically shows the demise of former Blues owner Carson Yeung.

    News on the hour 11:55: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    In the 12:00 news bulletin: Figures confirmed in the past hour show about one in 10 people turned out to vote for a new West Midlands police and crime commissioner.

    On your marks 11:41: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    Anyone else training for this year's Great Birmingham Run? It's eight weeks on Sunday. If you haven't entered yet there are still places available.

    Great Birmingham Run

    Organisers are expecting 20,000 entrants this year. The race starts by the Library of Birmingham and takes in numerous city landmarks including the Cadbury Factory, Edgbaston and the Bullring.

    PCC vote turnout 11:30: Kath Stanczyszyn Political reporter, BBC WM

    The average turnout across the West Midlands for the PCC by-election has been confirmed at 10.32%.

    Selly Oak had the lowest voting percentage - just 6.67. West Midlands Police has released a breakdown of results.

    WW1 heritage day 11:18:

    B14 tweets: World War One heritage open event at Brandwood Cemetery Saturday 13th September, 11AM-2PM

    Man spared jail after bottle attack 11:08: Halesowen News

    A 21-year-old Halesowen man who hit a friend in the face with a bottle in a Stourbridge nightspot after he took offence at a "tasteless joke" has been spared jail.

    News on the hour 10:57: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    In the 11:00 news bulletin: Counting is now under way for the election of the West Midlands' new police and crime commissioner - but it looks like fewer people turned out to vote than in the first election two years ago.

    Illicit cigarette sales 10:44: Birmingham Mail

    Birmingham has been branded the worst city in the UK for illicit cigarette sales after 120 packs were sold to undercover investigators from 48 shops in just three days.

    Cost per head of PCC vote 10:33: Chris Blakemore News editor, BBC WM

    It's believed the cost of the PCC by-election was £3.7m. If the turnout is confirmed at about 10.5% then that would mean the cost of each vote will have been about £18.50.

    Anti-knife campaign launches 10:21:

    A campaign urging people to hand in knives is being launched in Birmingham.

    Joshua Ribera

    Birmingham knife attack victims include Joshua Ribera (pictured) who was stabbed through the heart in September.

    Feedback 10:11: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service, which we write from the BBC's Birmingham office.

    News on the hour 10:01: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    In the 10:00 news bulletin: Mothers whose sons have been stabbed to death will be marching through Birmingham later as a new anti-knife campaign is launched in the city.

    Hundreds of new jobs 09:50: Birmingham Post

    Hundreds of jobs are to be created by a manufacturing firm at a giant new plant in Birmingham.

    Low turnout for PCC by-election 09:40: Kath Stanczyszyn Political reporter, BBC WM

    The turnout for Birmingham in the PCC by-election was 10.26%. There are rumours that one Nechells polling station had received no votes at all by 5pm yesterday.

    Sandwell's rate was 9.8% and Walsall's 10.72%. The highest so far is Dudley with 11.4%. Coventry, Wolverhampton and Solihull are still to verify. Counting started at 09:30 this morning.

    Appeal after sex assault on train 09:35:

    A woman was "left traumatised" when she was sexually assaulted by a man as she slept on a train between London Euston and Milton Keynes, said police.

    The 25-year-old woke up as the train passed through Leighton Buzzard to find the man touching her.

    Anyone who was on the 18:49 Euston to Birmingham New Street service on 13 August and may have seen what happened is asked to call police.

    Warning for barbecue chefs 09:23:

    It might not feel like barbecue weather at the moment but, ahead of the bank holiday weekend, the Food Standards Agency is warning people of the dangers of not adhering to basic food safety procedures.


    In a survey, 94% of people admitting to at least one bad barbecue habit.

    Wolves chief backs investment 09:12: Express and Star

    Wolves owner and property boss Steve Morgan has welcomed £500,000 of investment into a youth zone project in the heart of Wolverhampton.

    News on the hour 08:55: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    The mother of a man who was stabbed to death is urging people in Birmingham to back a new anti-knife campaign being launched in the city today.

    Hear more at 09:00 on BBC WM.

    Beauty queens' endurance challenge 08:53: Birmingham Mail

    Trainers, tiaras and treadmills took centre stage at Birmingham's Queen Elizabeth Hospital as a bevy of beauty queens embarked on a gruelling charity endurance challenge today.

    CCTV clue to hotel assault 08:39:

    A CCTV image of a man who is suspected of assaulting a woman in a Birmingham hotel has been released by police.

    CCTV image

    The 35-year-old woman was assaulted on 16 March at a hotel in Brindleyplace.

    PCC by-election 08:30:

    Polls have closed in the by-election for the West Midlands police and crime commissioner, to appoint a successor to Bob Jones, who died in July.

    The result is expected at about 16:30 today.

    GCSE results down at 'Trojan' schools 08:18:

    GCSE exam success has dropped at two schools investigated in the Trojan Horse inquiry, the BBC understands.


    Senior sources said just 58% of pupils at Park View School achieved five or more A* to Cs including maths and English, compared with 75% last year.

    Sunny spells 08:07:

    A mostly dry and fine day is forecast, with frequent sunny spells. One or two isolated showers remain possible throughout, although these should be infrequent.

    Weather chart

    It will feel cool, especially when exposed to the north-westerly breeze.

    Good morning 08:00: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    Morning all. I'll be bringing you news, sport, travel and weather throughout the day.

    If you'd like to get in touch you can email locallive@bbc.co.uk.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.