Trojan Horse leaked report says pupils 'not protected from extremism'

Golden Hillock School Golden Hillock School is among 25 Birmingham schools under investigation

Related Stories

Pupils are not being protected from extremist views at a Birmingham school named in the Trojan Horse inquiry, according to leaked Ofsted reports.

Golden Hillock School in Sparkhill was described as inadequate by inspectors.

Another leaked report claims the governing body at Saltley School "paid private investigators to interrogate the emails of senior staff".

Ofsted began inspections after claims that hardline Muslims were trying to take over Birmingham schools.

Start Quote

The Ofsted reports make absolutely no suggestion, nor did they find any evidence, that Golden Hillock either promotes or tolerates extremism ”

End Quote Statement Golden Hillock School

The inquiry has sparked a government row in Cabinet between ministers about how extremism in schools is handled.

A statement from Golden Hillock said it wholeheartedly disputed the validity of the inspection, one of 21 being carried out in Birmingham.

These were to be published together by Ofsted - but details have already emerged.

Six Birmingham schools are expected to be put into special measures following the inspections ordered by the Department for Education.

They were sparked by an unverified, anonymous letter that set out a strategy for a group of hard-line Muslims to install sympathetic staff and governors in Birmingham schools.

'Vulnerable to radicalisation'

In the Golden Hillock report, Ofsted said: "Too little is done to keep students safe from the risks associated with extremist views."

Inspectors concluded leaders and governors were "not doing enough to mitigate against cultural isolation" and this "could leave students vulnerable to the risk of marginalisation from wider British society and the associated risks which could include radicalisation."

Parents in Birmingham must be wondering how everyone else seems to have these "Trojan Horse" inspection reports when they are still kept in the dark.

This latest leak shows Golden Hillock school, part of the Park View academy chain, to be inadequate and failing to "keep students safe from the risks associated with extremist views".

It doesn't say there is extremism, but that there is a lack of awareness about preventing it.

Another leaked report shows that Saltley School is inadequate in all categories.

It highlights poor governance, a "state of crisis" and some staff feeling "intimidated". But there are no findings of extremism.

These are damning reports - but parents of children at the schools are still not able to see them.

Head teachers' leaders have called on Ofsted to publish all 21 reports immediately, attacking the "fear and confusion" caused by the delay.

But the Trojan Horse claims are part of a widening political battle. Who is going to be blamed for the weaknesses in oversight? The Department for Education, local council or inspectors?

In this strange story, the chair of the academy trust running Golden Hillock is himself an Ofsted inspector.

And there will be questions about how schools, recently found to be good or outstanding, have now been found to have so many problems.

However, the report praised the behaviour of students and their eagerness to learn, despite quality of teaching and leadership being branded inadequate at the school, which is sponsored by the Park View Academy Trust.

Inspectors had rated it as requiring improvement in February 2013, before it became an academy last October.

'Kids are happy'

A statement from the school said it would be challenging the Ofsted findings.

"Ofsted judges that Golden Hillock is not doing enough to raise students' awareness of the 'risks of extremism'," it said.

"However, it is crucial to note that the Ofsted reports make absolutely no suggestion, nor did they find any evidence, that Golden Hillock either promotes or tolerates extremism or radicalisation.

"The trust accepts that there is room for improvement at its schools, but categorically does not accept that Golden Hillock School is inadequate."

One parent, who did not want to be named, said: "My kids are happy, the progress they are making is good. I don't know how Ofsted can say this a failing school.

"I think the government are scared that all the governors are Muslim and that they have a right to change things at the school, but if you look around it's all Asian communities so it's always going to be mainly an Asian school."

'Very worrying'

Park View Educational Trust, which oversees the school, said it was not happy with the inspectors' verdict.

"On behalf of the staff, students and parents who have worked so hard to improve their school, we are extremely disappointed to confirm that Ofsted has decided to place Golden Hillock in Special Measures," it said in a statement.

Golden Hillock School inspection

Areas rated inadequate:

  • Achievement of pupils
  • Quality of teaching
  • Behaviour and safety of pupils
  • Leadership and management

Shadow Education Secretary Tristram Hunt described the report as "very worrying" and said the culture of isolation and marginalisation was exactly what a senior head teacher had warned the Department for Education about in 2010.

Labour MP for Birmingham Hall Green, Roger Godsiff, said the report was "damning".

"It is right that these issues are investigated but this report offers up more questions than answers which have to be put to Ofsted," he said.

Saltley School in Bordesley Green was criticised by inspectors for inadequate governance - with governors accused of failing to recognise a "state of crisis".

They are criticised for interfering in the running of the school and spending unnecessarily on consultants and lawyers.

"Some staff feel intimidated by their colleagues and feel that they cannot talk freely," says the Ofsted report, which rated the school inadequate.

'Fear and speculation'

A Department for Education spokesperson said: "The allegations made in relation to some schools in Birmingham are very serious and we are investigating all evidence put to us in conjunction with Ofsted, Birmingham City Council and the police.

"It is absolutely vital these investigations are carried out impartially, without pre-judgment.

"Ofsted has inspected a number of schools in the light of recent allegations and will report to the Secretary of State shortly.

"Retired senior police officer Peter Clarke has been asked by the Secretary of State to make a full enquiry into Birmingham schools and will report back this summer.

"It would be inappropriate to comment further at this stage."

The school leaders' union NAHT called on Ofsted to publish the 21 school inspection reports without further delay.

"The vacuum created encourages fear and speculation that could hinder a proportionate response or appropriate action," said NAHT general secretary Russell Hobby.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country

Weather

Birmingham

17 °C 11 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Bears lose despite Trott's runs 11:48:

    Luke Fletcher hit the final ball of the match for four as Nottinghamshire beat Warwickshire by one wicket to secure a One-Day Cup quarter-final home tie.

    trott

    Earlier on, Warwickshire, who also qualify for the last eight, made 302-7 with Jonathan Trott scoring 108 and Tim Ambrose 98.

     
  2.  
    Police hunt Wolverhampton men 11:40:

    Detectives continue to search for two men they want to trace in connection with a robbery in which a woman was assaulted outside a Wolverhampton pub.

    Wolverhampton suspects

    Donavon Wilson, aged 19 and from Sedgley, and Omari Maitland, aged 20 and from Wolverhampton, are wanted for questioning after the 38-year-old woman was robbed of her car on Robert Wynd, Woodcross on 18 June.

     
  3.  
    High hopes for pub owners 11:34: Birmingham Post

    The owners of a newly restored historic pub in inner-city Birmingham say they want to turn it into a Michelin-star quality restaurant.

     
  4.  
    PCC Elections 11:28: Birmingham Updates

    tweets: 732,119 people in Birmingham are eligible to vote - Use it don't waste it! #WMPCC14

     
  5.  
    Woffinden calls for help to share burden 11:25:

    Speedway world champion Tai Woffinden wants UK teams to be allowed to sign two number one riders to ease the pressure during a hectic season.

    woffinden

    Wolverhampton star Woffinden took a break from the sport in July suffering from exhaustion and stress.

     
  6.  
    Birmingham MP Shabana Mahmood hauled in by Labour bosses 11:18: Birmingham Mail

    A Birmingham Labour MP who took part in a pro-Gaza demonstration which forced a city centre supermarket to close has been hauled in for talks with the party leadership.

     
  7.  
    Watch live: Planning Committee meeting 11:14:

    Birmingham City Council tweets: Webcast: We're streaming today's Planning Committee live here: http://bit.ly/1kRxOgp

    #brum #birmingham #localgov

     
  8.  
    Pupils 'affected by teacher leaving' 11:02: Alex Homer BBC News Online

    I'm down at Golden Hillock School, one of the schools affected by the alleged Trojan Horse plot, as pupils arrive to collect their GCSE results.

    I just spoke to Humzah Hussain, a 16-year-old, who walked away with the results he needed to go to Solihull Sixth Form next year.

    He said he felt under pressure preparing for his science exams because his teacher left the school before lessons had finished for the year - which Humzah believed was connected to the alleged plot and subsequent investigation.

    He said: ‎"We had to have two cover teachers and then a new science teacher. I was panicking because I really wanted to pass science."

     
  9.  
    news on the hour 10:56: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    There are claims 1,400 jobs could go at two West Midlands hospitals.

    I'll have more in the news at 11:00.

     
  10.  
    Your family's WW1 history 10:51:

    Who Do You Think You Are genealogist Laura Berry will be running free workshops to delve into your family's World War One history today at BBC Birmingham.

    Who do you think you are logo

    To book your free 40 minute session e-mail publicspaceteam@bbc.co.uk

     
  11.  
    Best and worst excuses for doing badly in GCSEs 10:39: Hannah Richardson BBC News education reporter

    Let's face it - no-one likes to mess up. So when it comes to disappointing GCSE results - it's useful to have someone or something else to blame.

    student
     
  12.  
    Thug 'high on cocaine' stamped on girlfriend 10:32: Express and Star

    A terrified woman was forced to barricade herself in a room at her own home after being viciously attacked by her boyfriend who was high on cocaine, a court heard.

     
  13.  
    Wolves fan pleased 10:26:

    Dan Johnson tweets: Would've been chuffed with 2 draws & a win from tough 1st 3 games so delighted @OfficialWolves currently sit on 6pts. Bring on the redbirds.

     
  14.  
    Traders' anger over Stirchley store delay 10:21:

    Traders in Birmingham say they are angry the opening of a new Tesco store, first proposed 16 years ago, has been delayed for three more years.

    stirchley

    Shops and homes in Stirchley received leaflets from the council telling them the development has been put back.

     
  15.  
    Have your say 10:15: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We write it from here in Birmingham. We'd like to get your views.

     
  16.  
    Polling stations for PCC election 10:09:

    WM Police has tweeted a number of links for locations of polling stations in the West Midlands for today's Police and Crime Commissioner by-election.

    See their Twitter feed for more details.

     
  17.  
    Channel swimming legend dies aged 93 10:03: Birmingham Mail

    A Black Country legend whose long list of achievements include swimming the Channel in record time has died.

    Bill Pickering, who passed away on Sunday aged 93, had a lesser known claim to fame. The former Bloxwich Swimming Baths boss taught funnyman Ken Dodd to swim.

     
  18.  
    News on the hour 09:57: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    Intelligence agencies are attempting to identify the suspected British killer of the American journalist, James Foley.

    The masked man - who was seen in a video released by Islamic State militants - is believed to be among a handful of Britons guarding the group's captives.

    Footage of the video was place on social media websites. Erdington MP Jack Dromey says viewing the film only fuels terrorist propaganda.

    Hear more in the 10:00 bulletin.

     
  19.  
    Watch: Wrong way driver collision 09:48:

    Yesterday we reported on how police staged a controlled collision to stop a car driving the wrong way down the M6 toll. Today West Midlands Police has released footage of the moment of impact.

    police video
     
  20.  
    Schools braced for GCSE results 09:43:

    Schools in England are braced for "volatile" GCSE results, following significant changes to the exam system.

    Hundreds of thousands of teenagers in England, Wales and Northern Ireland will be getting their grades today.

     
  21.  
    Police confirm identity of body 09:37: Express and Star

    A body found in a field was that of missing woman Amanda Hawkins, 44, of Walsall, police have confirmed.

     
  22.  
    Fulham 0-1 Wolves 09:30:

    Fulham suffered a third straight defeat since being relegated from the Premier League after Bakary Sako's goal earned Wolves victory at Craven Cottage.

    bakary sako

    Sako struck after the Cottagers failed to deal with a first-half corner - the former France Under-21 international firing into the bottom corner.

     
  23.  
    NHS Trust to cut jobs 09:24: Birmingham Post

    More than 1,400 jobs are set to be slashed from a key city NHS trust.

    Sandwell and West Birmingham Hospitals NHS Trust will make the swingeing cuts over the next six years.

     
  24.  
    Burglar jailed for having stun gun 09:19:

    A burglar who was found with a stun gun disguised as a mobile phone when he was arrested in Birmingham has been jailed.

    marvin forbes

    Police found the illegal firearm in the foot well of Marvin Forbes' VW Golf when they stopped him on Queens Road, Aston in March.

     
  25.  
    Top Headlines
     
  26.  
    EDL protestors in court 09:08:

    Six men appeared before Birmingham Magistrates Court yesterday accused of violent disorder at a protest by the English Defence League last year.

    The group were charged last month with crimes that allegedly took place when the EDL staged a demonstration in Centenary Square on 20 July 2013.

     
  27.  
    News on the hour 08:58: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    The BBC understands two Birmingham schools at the centre of the alleged Trojan Horse plot have seen a sharp dip in GCSE results.

    Hear more in the 09:00 bulletin.

     
  28.  
    Farah to race in Birmingham 08:48:

    Double Olympic champion Mo Farah has confirmed he will race over two miles at the Birmingham Diamond League.

    The Birmingham meet on 24 August will be the newly-crowned European 10,000m champion's first race in Britain since his London Marathon debut in April.

    Mo farah

    Farah, 31, has endured a troubled year, withdrawing from the Commonwealth Games in Glasgow because of fitness concerns.

    "I was gutted to withdraw," said Farah. "But I'm really pleased I'll be back on the track at Birmingham."

     
  29.  
    Drug arrests in Birmingham 08:36:

    Three men have been arrested as part of an ongoing operation to tackle drug dealers.

    Officers from Birmingham along with the Serious and Organised Crime Unit searched houses and businesses across Rowley Regis, Bordesley Green and Kitts Green as part of the long-standing operation to tackle the importation and supply of drugs.

     
  30.  
    Nine-year-old's letter to grave thieves 08:25: Birmingham Mail

    A nine-year-old girl left heartbroken after thieves stole keepsakes from her sister's grave has written to culprits in a desperate plea for them to return the items.

     
  31.  
    PCC by-election under way 08:17:

    Voting in the by-election for the West Midlands police and crime commissioner (PCC) has begun, to appoint a successor to Bob Jones, who died in July.

    pcc candidates WM 2014

    The candidates are David Jamieson (Labour); Les Jones (Conservative); Keith Rowe (Ukip); and Ayoub Khan (Liberal Democrat). Voting began at 07:00 and polling stations will remain open until 22:00.

     
  32.  
    Chilly but bright 08:10:

    A chilly but bright start, particularly in the south. It is going to turn cloudier through the day as some outbreaks of rain slowly spread their way southwards this afternoon. Temperatures still slightly below average for the time of year.

    weather
     
  33.  
    Wolverhampton travel issues 08:04:

    The A449 Penn Road in Goldthorn Hill, Wolverhampton, is closed inbound between the Pennhouse Avenue junction and the B4161 Rookery Lane junction, because of emergency repairs and telecoms work.

    Traffic heading into Wolverhampton from the south of the city will be diverted from the roundabout at Lloyd Hill along Warstones Rd. Expect delays.

    See BBC Travel News for more information.

     
  34.  
    Good morning 08:00: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    Morning all, I'll be bringing you news, sport, travel and weather from the region from now until 18:00.

    If you'd like to get in touch you can email locallive@bbc.co.uk

     

Features

  • Baby being handed overFraught world

    The legal confusion over UK surrogate births


  • Bad resultsBlame game

    The best excuses to use when exam results don't make the grade


  • Welsh flagDragon's den

    Why Wales will make its own mind up on independence


  • BKS IyengarFlexible guru

    The man who helped bring yoga to the West


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.