Could Birmingham's green waste anger decide its election?

Recycling bin and ballot box composite picture Waste collection has become a key talking point in the lead-up to Birmingham's local elections

Related Stories

A row over bin collections has dominated the run-up to Birmingham's local election, with some claiming it could damage the city's Labour administration. But why do people get so angry about their bins? And could voters really vent their fury at the polling station?

In February Birmingham City Council stopped free garden waste collections and introduced a £35 charge for the service.

It is thought about a third of UK councils have introduced the measure - branded a "garden tax" by critics - in a bid to make savings in the face of central government cuts.

Birmingham has saved £2.1m by introducing charged collections, according to its 2014 budget document, as part of £85.7m of cuts made this year.

The move has been criticised in some quarters, with 40,000 of the city's 400,000 households signing up for paid collections, although the council said it was receiving 1,000 new subscribers each week.

'Matter of principle'

It comes against a backdrop of several high-profile crises in Birmingham - such as the highly critical Ofsted inspection of its beleaguered children's services department and allegations some of the city's schools have been infiltrated by Muslim hardliners.

But it is the issue of garden waste collections that has become one of the key topics ahead of Thursday's ballot.

Conservative and Liberal Democrat councillors in Birmingham have vowed to scrap the charges if elected, while the Labour administration has said it will not reverse its decision.

But why have people become so animated about the idea of paying for bin collections?

Garden waste in Prince of Wales lane Residents in Prince of Wales Lane, Yardley Wood, said bags had been left for two weeks
Garden waste abandoned in Druid's Heath Piles of uncollected garden waste have accumulated in a number of areas

Paul Dale, chief blogger at Birmingham political site The Chamberlain Files, believes one reason is a sense of annoyance among taxpayers at being asked to pay for a once-free service.

"It's a drop in the ocean but it's the kind of thing that people get really annoyed about," he said.

"They think 'this time last year the council came and collected our garden waste for free and now they want us to pay £35 to continue'.

"It's not a lot of money but it's a matter of principle: people are damned if they're going to pay extra on top of their council tax."

'Taking liberties'

Since the change, abandoned bin bags filled with hedge trimmings and grass cuttings have appeared across Birmingham - and huge peak-time queues have been reported at household refuse sites.

Rather than take them away, binmen have placed bright yellow stickers on the bags advising residents of the new charges and reminding them of possible prosecution for fly-tipping.


The green waste charge has been targeted as a genuine vote winner by the Conservatives and Liberal Democrats.

Both of those parties have pledged to abolish what they call the "garden tax".

Sir Albert Bore, leader of the current Labour-run authority, said the charge had already brought in £1m, with more than 30,000 people signing up.

He said the income would off-set service cuts, for which he blamed the Conservative/Liberal Democrat government in Westminster.

The local Conservatives said they could find the savings elsewhere - by cutting £3.8m spent on policy officers and reducing the spend on memberships of groups like the Local Government Association.

The Lib Dems, meanwhile said they had examined the budget and "didn't have trouble finding £20m to fund a package to restore street cleaning, garden waste collection and a host of other measures".

Shannen O'Reilly, who lives in Prince of Wales Lane, in Yardley Wood, said several piles of bags had been left in the road for about two weeks.

"I think it's stupid, you shouldn't have to pay to have your bins collected," she said.

"No-one wants to pay for it - if you're paying council tax already you expect them to take your rubbish away.

"They're taking liberties."

Kevin Golding-Williams, from pedestrian campaign group Living Streets, said the issue impacts a large number of people, and the fallout - with bin bags dumped on streets - is highly-visible.

He said: "It's one of those services which affects everyone regardless of area, regardless of whether you're in the most affluent areas or the poorest areas.

"It's going to start rotting and smelling which isn't particularly nice.

"If there are a number of bags there it becomes a real problem."

Some have also argued the issue of garden waste has proved so emotive because it brings politics to people's doorsteps and drives.

Mr Dale said the inconvenience of losing the collections would have been keenly felt among a number of residents.

"In Birmingham there are lots of people without cars so they can't take their own garden waste to the tip," he said. "So they have to pay the £35."

Yellow sticker attached to abandoned waste bags The council has warned people they may face prosecution if they are caught fly-tipping

Dr Steve McCabe, of Birmingham City University's business school, agreed those on low incomes or with limited access to transport may feel "trapped" into paying.

"For a lot of people finding £35 a year might not seem a lot," he said.

"But if you are retired and on a limited pension, finding £35 might not be so easy, but you may not feel you have a choice, especially if you don't have your own transport."

The big question is whether feelings over bags of garden waste will actually influence the outcome of the election.

Chair of the Local Authority Recycling Advisory Committee, Andrew Bird, said he thought voters would understand local councils faced a "difficult financial situation".

"With budget pressures local authorities are having to look at all their services and anything that's non-statutory will come under closer scrutiny.

"Unfortunately, garden waste falls into that category."

Mr Dale is not so sure.

"I don't know that people will actually connect it with the Labour party as a lot of people might not actually know who runs Birmingham City Council," he said.

"It may be more likely to contribute to people not voting as an expression of protest."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country



Min. Night 16 °C

BBC Local Live

    Good evening 18:01:

    BBC Local Live is back from 08:00 on Thursday with the latest news, sport, travel and weather updates for Birmingham and the Black Country.

    Midlands Today 17:58: Mary Rhodes Presenter, BBC Midlands Today

    On the programme tonight: Tributes to West Midlands first police and crime commissioner Bob Jones - over 800 turned out to celebrate his life at Wolverhampton Civic Hall.

    And, rebuilding the economy brick by brick - the impact of the recovery in construction and steam punk anyone? All will be explained at 18:30 on BBC One.

    Children playing 17:56: Alex Homer BBC News Online

    This is the back garden where the two children were playing with a football earlier today, according to their cousin Dennis.

    Missing children

    It is connected to a small alley you can access off Nigel Road. Anyone with any information about their whereabouts is asked to call police on 101.

    Park searched 17:51:

    West Midlands Police tweets: MISSING CHILDREN UPDATE - Officers are showing photos of the children to passers-by in Washwood Heath. Ward End park is also being searched.

    Cricket 17:45: Richard Wilford BBC WM Sport

    Looks like Warwickshire will face a couple of awkward sessions with bat tomorrow. Sussex 116/2, lead by 196, 15 overs left today.

    Coverage continues online via BBC Sport tomorrow from 11:00.

    Family gathered 17:38: Alex Homer BBC News Online

    Dennis Sava went on to say the family are Romanian and Saina speaks a bit of English while Adi is not as able to use the language.

    There are a number of family members and friends gathered at the home and outside at the moment.

    'Everybody looking' 17:27: Alex Homer BBC News Online

    I'm in Washwood Heath speaking to people about the two missing children. I've just spoken to the children's cousin Dennis Sava, a painter and decorator, aged 22. The father-of-one lives on Highfield Road nearby himself.

    He said: "Their father says they were playing in the back garden but when he went out to see them at about midday, they were no longer there.

    "Everybody is looking for them. We're just waiting for some word from them."

    Song for Bob 17:26: via Facebook

    Wolverhampton Today posts: Rest in Peace Bob Jones - a man who dedicated his life to serving the people of Wolverhampton and the West Midlands.

    A celebration of life for Bob Jones

    As Bob's coffin was carried out of the Civic, the audience sang his favourite song: Monty Python's Always Look on the Bright Side of Life.

    See coverage of this service on BBC Midlands Today at 18:30.

    Murder suspect sectioned 17:14:

    A 23-year-old man arrested on suspicion of the double murder of a Solihull couple has been detained under the Mental Health Act, police say.

    Scene at Hermitage Road, Solihull

    The bodies of Pin Chang, aged 58, and his wife Quoi Chang, aged 50, were found with stab wounds, after reports of an attack inside the property in Hermitage Road earlier this month.

    'Too many people' 17:08: via Facebook

    We've been asking for your experience of students after BBC WM's report on claims students are turning some areas of Birmingham into "shanty towns".

    Tom Oufc Phipson posts: "I don't think this problem is restricted to students.

    "Yes students are given a bad name but there's plenty of examples around where families have too many people under one roof. Its a problem for the council to sort (add more bins in these areas) and the problem wouldn't exist."

    Have your say on the issue on the BBC WM Facebook page.

    News headlines 17:00: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    The headlines at 17:00 on BBC WM:

    Rail disruption continues 16:52:

    The signalling problem at Barnt Green has now been resolved and all lines are now open again, the National Rail website reports.

    While services return to normal disruption is expected to continue until about 20:30.

    Saina and Adi missing 16:45:

    West Midlands Police tweets: More info on the missing children. They are Saina Sava (11-year-old girl) and Adi Sava (4-year-old boy).

    Photos of missing children 16:35:

    Police release a description of the children they want to find, after they went missing in Washwood Heath at midday.

    Missing children in Washwood Heath

    Saina Sava and her brother Adi were last seen on Wright Road.

    'Ludicrous and unfounded' 16:33:

    Former MEP Nikki Sinclaire says she "strongly refutes" the charge of money laundering and misconduct in public office.

    She says in a statement: "I am disappointed that the police have chosen to charge me with the above offences without questioning me on them, after a two and a half year investigation.

    "I strongly refute these charges and will be firmly defending myself. I am certain I shall be found innocent of these ludicrous and unfounded accusations."

    Missing children descriptions 16:19:

    Police release more details of the two children they are searching for.

    The 11-year-old girl is wearing light blue jeans with diamante studs. The four-year-old boy is wearing a yellow t-shirt, yellow/brown shorts and has short hair which is brushed forward.

    Anybody who thinks they have seen them is urged to call 999.

    Helicopter search 16:08:

    NPAS Birmingham tweets: We've been busy searching for 2 missing children in the Washwood Heath area of Birmingham - see @WMPolice for further details. #airsupport

    Top story 15:58: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    In the news at 16:00, our top story: The former West Midlands MEP Nikki Sinclaire has been charged with money laundering and misconduct in public office.

    We'll have the latest from our reporter Alice Rosenthal on this in the bulletin shortly.

    Search for missing children 15:51:

    Police are appealing for help to find an 11-year-old girl and boy aged four who have gone missing in Washwood Heath.

    The girl is described as 5ft tall with long dark hair in a bun. The four-year-old is thought to be in a black and red four-wheeled pushchair.

    Anyone with information or sees them is urged to dial 999. West Midlands Police says its helicopter is assisting in the search for the children.

    Missing children 15:40:

    Police are appealing for sightings of two children who've gone missing in Washwood Heath.

    An 11-year-old girl, a boy aged four, are said to have gone missing on Wright Road at about midday.

    Death probed 15:31: Express and Star

    CCTV footage from a police station is being studied by independent investigators after a mother-of-four died shortly after being arrested.

    Murder investigation 15:09:

    A body is discovered in a burnt out car in Birmingham, prompting a murder investigation.

    Det Insp Warren Hines says they are not looking for anyone else in connection with the death, following the arrest of a man yesterday evening.

    News headlines 14:57: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM
    School break in 14:45:

    Do you know this man?

    Photo of a man police want to speak to

    Police say they want to trace him after a break in at Moseley Secondary School on 5 July.

    Court appearance 14:27:

    Former MEP Nikki Sinclaire will appear at Birmingham Magistrates Court on 17 September, West Midlands Police said.

    Ms Sinclaire, 45, of Shirley, was arrested in February 2012 and has been on police bail.

    Three more people arrested over the matter will not face any further action.

    'False travel expense claims' 14:21:

    The CPS said it is alleged Ms Sinclaire used funds paid into her bank account by the European Parliament in respect of false travelling expenses claims.

    The offences are said to have taken place between October 2009 and July 2010.

    Nikki Sinclaire charged 14:14: BREAKING NEWS

    Former West Midlands UKIP MEP Nikki Sinclaire is charged with money laundering and misconduct in public office relating to travel expenses claimed while serving in the European Parliament, the Crown Prosecution Service says.

    Body found in field 14:07:

    A body found in a field in Burntwood is thought to be that of missing Walsall woman Amanda Hawkins.

    Ms Hawkins, 44, went missing from her assisted accommodation complex in Moxley on 30 May.

    Police say the body is believed to be that of Ms Hawkins but further tests will take place to confirm the identity and cause of death.

    News at 2pm 13:59: BBC WM

    Our top story is the murder investigation being launched after a body was found in a burnt out car in Erdington last night.

    'Down to earth' 13:54:

    Joe Mace, 50, from Wolverhampton, said he had known Bob Jones for 30 years.

    Joe Mace

    "A very good bloke has gone," he said.

    "He was articulate, friendly, simple. He wasn't stuck up even though he recently got elected to high office."

    West Midlands Police and Crime Commissioner Mr Jones died on 1 July.

    Black bows 13:38:

    Locomotive No.7 'Tom Rolt' at Tywyn Wharf has black bows tied on the front of it to mark the funeral of Bob Jones.

    Locomotive No.7 'Tom Rolt' at Tywyn Wharf

    Mr Jones was a member and supporter of Talyllyn Railway. His family ask those who wish to mark his death to make a donation to the charity.

    'Popular man' 13:27:

    Paul Flint, 42, from Wolverhampton, is at the celebration for former Police and Crime Commissioner Bob Jones who died on 1 July.

    Mr Flint said he had known him for 10 years.

    "He was a very nice person, very personable, very easy to talk to," he said.

    "I saw him on various (Camra) trips and he was a very likable, very popular man."

    Sewer collapse 13:18:

    Formans Road in Sparkhill, Birmingham, is closed in both directions at the A34 Stratford Road junction, because of a sewer collapse, BBC Travel News reports.

    'Benefits Street' warning 13:17:

    James Turner Street in Birmingham had the spotlight shone on it when it appeared on Channel Four programme Benefits Street.

    Sign on a street in Southampton telling Love Productions not to film there

    The production company behind the programme, Love Productions, is filming in Southampton for a new series looking at immigration.

    It looks as though people in Southampton aren't keen though - this is one sign which has been placed warning camera crews not to film. BBC reporter Joanna Palmer tweets this photo on Derby Road in the city.

    Coffin procession 13:07: Andrew Dawkins BBC News

    Bob Jones' coffin has been brought into Wolverhampton Civic Hall.

    Bob Jones' coffin
    In the news 13:00: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    We'll have the latest local, national and international news headlines in the bulletin.

    Plus, we'll have the latest from our sports reporter Richard Wilford as Warwickshire hope to build on a sizeable score on day three of their County Championship match with Sussex. Listen live.

    Guard of honour 12:50: Andrew Dawkins BBC News

    More than 800 people are expected at Wolverhampton Civic Hall this afternoon for a service to the police and crime commissioner Bob Jones.

    Friends of Bob Jones gathering outside Wolverhampton Civic Hall

    The coffin is due to arrive at 12:50 and I'm told there will be a police guard of honour. Friends, family and colleagues who knew Bob are wearing red.

    A private funeral will take place later this afternoon.

    Body information appeal 12:40:

    Police want anyone with any information about the body found in a burnt out car in Erdington to get in touch.

    If you can help call police on 101. Alternatively, contact Crimestoppers anonymously on 0800 555 111.

    'Unusual crime' 12:34:

    A man remains in custody following the discovery of a body in a burnt out car.

    The identity of the person is yet to be established and a post mortem is due to take place, police say.

    Det Insp Warren Hines said it is the early stages of what is likely to be "a very complex investigation into an exceptionally unusual crime."

    "An arrest has been made and we are not looking for anyone else in connection with this matter," he said.

    Murder arrest 12:23: BREAKING NEWS

    A man has been arrested on suspicion of murder after a body was discovered in a burnt out car in Erdington last night.

    West Midlands Police say they were called out to Feltham Road at around 20:30 by a member of the public reporting a parked car on fire.

    Heading to Wolverhampton 12:14: Andrew Dawkins BBC News

    I'm on my way to the service to celebrate the life of West Midlands Police and Crime Commissioner Bob Jones, that is happening in Wolverhampton later.

    Mr Jones, died "in his sleep" aged 59 earlier this month.

    Hundreds of people are expected to attend the service at the Civic Hall. They have been asked not to wear black but an item of red clothing by his family.

    News headlines 11:58: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    The headlines at 12:00 on BBC WM:

    • A former care worker from Birmingham has appeared before magistrates charged with seven counts of sexual assault and one of rape
    • Hundreds of thousands of school support staff and local government workers are going on strike in September
    • People in part of Birmingham claim students are turning the area into a shanty town - with too many people living in houses and litter everywhere
    Signalling problems 11:48:

    Due to signalling problems at Barnt Green, all trains between Birmingham and Worcester are not serving Bromsgrove, Network Midlands reports.

    Flood scheme plans 11:36:

    A new flood scheme for Perry Barr and Witton is being proposed by the Environment Agency.

    Members of the public are being invited to attend two drop-in sessions next week.

    The proposal includes a localised low level wall construction and wall replacement through Witton.

    Cricket commentary 11:25: Richard Wilford BBC WM Sport

    Another glorious morning at Horsham for day three of Sussex v Warwickshire.

    Sussex v Warwickshire - view from the press box

    Hear full commentary online now.

    Bus sex assault 11:16:

    Police have released a photo of a man they would like to speak to after a woman was verbally abused and then sexually assaulted.

    Man police want to speak to

    The woman, in her late teens, was approached by a man on the number 243 bus during the afternoon of 30 April. He got off the bus in Cradley Heath.

    In the news 10:59: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    Another strike by school support staff and local government workers has been announced.

    Members of Unison will walk out on Tuesday the 30th of September over their ongoing row over pay. Hear that story and others in the news at 11:00. Listen live.

    M6 lanes re-open 10:50:

    Highways Agency tweets: All lanes now open on #M6 sb btwn J3A and J3 due to an earlier accident. Thanks to @Highways_Agency Traffic Officers and @warkspolice.Delays

    'Terrific legacy' 10:39:

    The widow of Police and Crime Commissioner Bob Jones says the service today is to say "thank you" to her husband who spent so much of his life helping others.

    Sarah Jones says: "He was very good at listening. And then following it up and trying to do something about it.

    "All the letters I've had, at least half of them say say 'Bob did so and so for me'. It's helped us. It's a terrific legacy to have - that you've managed to help people."

    Inside a helicopter 10:28:

    Ever wondered what it looks like inside a police helicopter? NPAS Birmingham tweets this 360 photo of the cabin.

    Inside the West Midlands police helicopter
    Neighbour's arson charge 10:17: Birmingham Mail

    Neighbour charged with arson following fire at Coseley flats.

    M6 delays 10:11:

    Two lanes of the M6 Warwickshire are closed southbound between J3a M6 Toll and J3, A444 (Nuneaton), because of an accident, BBC Travel News reports.

    Travel time is 60 minutes. Congestion to J4, M42 (Coleshill).

    In the news 09:59: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    Students say that claims they're turning some parts of Birmingham into ghettos aren't true.

    In the news at 10:00, we'll hear from a student living in Selly Oak who lives in a house with seven other people. Listen live.

    Which sport? 09:58: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    The Commonwealth Games opening ceremony takes place in Glasgow later. To mark the occasion, and to have a giggle, BBC News has put together a short test to work out which sport best suits you. Answer the questionaire now.

    Commonwealth Games sports icons

    My closest matches are: Hockey - Rugby sevens and athletics (throwing).

    I did play hockey and throw shot put at school - though that was some time ago!

    Teachers' 'Trojan Horse' review call 09:44:

    The council-commissioned review into the so-called Trojan Horse allegations "ought to be reviewed itself", teachers say.

    Ian Kershaw's report

    Members of the National Association of Head Teachers said Peter Clarke's government-commissioned report into allegations of a hardline Muslim takeover of schools was more thorough.

    The two reports differed in their conclusions, although neither found evidence of extremism in the schools.

    Cricket: Sussex v Warwickshire 09:30: BBC Sport
    Council meeting 09:15:

    Birmingham City Council health and social care scrutiny panel meeting is live online from 10:00.

    The agenda includes an inquiry session on dementia.

    Summer fun ideas 09:07: via Facebook

    Wolverhampton Today posts: Looking for something to keep the kids occupied today (and throughout the summer hols)? Then check out the special activities taking place at Bert Williams Leisure Centre, Central Baths and Aldersley Leisure Village... more details here:

    Summer fun at Wolverhampton leisure centres
    News headlines 08:57: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    I'm reading the news bulletins on BBC WM this morning. The headlines at 09:00:

    • There's calls for restrictions to be brought in to limit the number of people who can live in one property - over claims students are turning parts of Birmingham into shanty towns
    • A fourth man has appeared in court charged with murdering a man in Sparkbrook at the start of the month
    • US intelligence officials say they have no evidence of "direct" Russian involvement in the Malaysian jet crash over eastern Ukraine
    Metro delays 08:53:

    The Metro tweets: Midland Metro running with minor delays due to a tram failure in Birmingham

    Bob Jones memorial 08:50:

    Friends, and colleagues will gather in Wolverhampton today at a memorial service for the West Midlands police commissioner Bob Jones, who died earlier this month in his sleep.

    Bob Jones

    Hundreds are expected to attend today's celebration of his life at the city's Civic Hall.

    Speedway: Wolves 44-46 Lakeside 08:40:

    Speedway, Wolves' hopes of making the play-offs in the Elite League took another turn for the worse with a 46-44 defeat at the hands of Lakeside at Monmore Green last night.

    Ricky Wells was Wolves' top scorer with 12 points.

    Team manager Peter Adams says Lakeside were lucky to win after two of his riders suffered bike problems.

    As it happened
    • News, sport and weather for Wed 23 July
    • Join us again from 08:00 on Thursday
    • Listen: BBC WM
    Baton guard 08:33: Halesowen News

    A former Wolverley CE Secondary School pupil is guarding the Queen's Baton on its relay around Scotland as part of this year's Commonwealth Games.

    The baton arrives in Glasgow today.

    Cannon Hill Park 08:30:

    BBC Local Live's Ed Barlow snapped this picture of "tropical Birmingham" while running through Cannon Hill Park this morning on his way to work.

    Cannon Hill Park

    Share your Birmingham and Black Country photos with us - email, tweet or upload them on Facebook.

    Slow traffic 08:20:

    BBC Travel News reports of delays of up to 40 minutes on the A456 eastbound in Halesowen between the B4183 Hagley Road junction and the B4043 Manor Lane junction.

    And in Birmingham there's slow traffic on the inbound A38(M) Aston Expressway and the A38 southbound and northbound around St Chads Queensway because of the tunnel closures.

    Sparkbrook murder charge 08:13:

    A fourth man has appeared in court, charged with murder after a man was stabbed in Sparkbrook earlier this month.

    West Midlands Police say Sardar Khattak, 34, from Bordesley Green, has been remanded in prison.

    So far four men have been charged with the murder of Ullah Khan, who died from a stab wound to the neck as violence broke out between two groups of men on 2 July.

    'Shanty town' claims 08:09: BBC WM

    People in a part of Birmingham claim students are turning the area into a shanty town - with too many people living in houses and litter everywhere.

    Residents in the Bournbrook district of Selly Oak say they're fed up with landlords turning properties into student accommodation.

    Hear more on this story on BBC WM.

    Mostly fine and dry 08:05:

    Patchy low cloud will soon clear, to leave another mostly dry and fine day and it will become very warm or locally hot.

    Isolated heavy and thundery showers may move westwards across some southern parts in the afternoon. A high of 28C (82F).

    Good morning 08:00: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    I'll be bringing you the very latest news, sport, travel and weather for Birmingham and the Black Country.

    If you'd like to get in touch, and let us know about something happening in your area, please email or tweet @BBCWM.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.