Could Birmingham's green waste anger decide its election?

Recycling bin and ballot box composite picture Waste collection has become a key talking point in the lead-up to Birmingham's local elections

Related Stories

A row over bin collections has dominated the run-up to Birmingham's local election, with some claiming it could damage the city's Labour administration. But why do people get so angry about their bins? And could voters really vent their fury at the polling station?

In February Birmingham City Council stopped free garden waste collections and introduced a £35 charge for the service.

It is thought about a third of UK councils have introduced the measure - branded a "garden tax" by critics - in a bid to make savings in the face of central government cuts.

Birmingham has saved £2.1m by introducing charged collections, according to its 2014 budget document, as part of £85.7m of cuts made this year.

The move has been criticised in some quarters, with 40,000 of the city's 400,000 households signing up for paid collections, although the council said it was receiving 1,000 new subscribers each week.

'Matter of principle'

It comes against a backdrop of several high-profile crises in Birmingham - such as the highly critical Ofsted inspection of its beleaguered children's services department and allegations some of the city's schools have been infiltrated by Muslim hardliners.

But it is the issue of garden waste collections that has become one of the key topics ahead of Thursday's ballot.

Conservative and Liberal Democrat councillors in Birmingham have vowed to scrap the charges if elected, while the Labour administration has said it will not reverse its decision.

But why have people become so animated about the idea of paying for bin collections?

Garden waste in Prince of Wales lane Residents in Prince of Wales Lane, Yardley Wood, said bags had been left for two weeks
Garden waste abandoned in Druid's Heath Piles of uncollected garden waste have accumulated in a number of areas

Paul Dale, chief blogger at Birmingham political site The Chamberlain Files, believes one reason is a sense of annoyance among taxpayers at being asked to pay for a once-free service.

"It's a drop in the ocean but it's the kind of thing that people get really annoyed about," he said.

"They think 'this time last year the council came and collected our garden waste for free and now they want us to pay £35 to continue'.

"It's not a lot of money but it's a matter of principle: people are damned if they're going to pay extra on top of their council tax."

'Taking liberties'

Since the change, abandoned bin bags filled with hedge trimmings and grass cuttings have appeared across Birmingham - and huge peak-time queues have been reported at household refuse sites.

Rather than take them away, binmen have placed bright yellow stickers on the bags advising residents of the new charges and reminding them of possible prosecution for fly-tipping.


The green waste charge has been targeted as a genuine vote winner by the Conservatives and Liberal Democrats.

Both of those parties have pledged to abolish what they call the "garden tax".

Sir Albert Bore, leader of the current Labour-run authority, said the charge had already brought in £1m, with more than 30,000 people signing up.

He said the income would off-set service cuts, for which he blamed the Conservative/Liberal Democrat government in Westminster.

The local Conservatives said they could find the savings elsewhere - by cutting £3.8m spent on policy officers and reducing the spend on memberships of groups like the Local Government Association.

The Lib Dems, meanwhile said they had examined the budget and "didn't have trouble finding £20m to fund a package to restore street cleaning, garden waste collection and a host of other measures".

Shannen O'Reilly, who lives in Prince of Wales Lane, in Yardley Wood, said several piles of bags had been left in the road for about two weeks.

"I think it's stupid, you shouldn't have to pay to have your bins collected," she said.

"No-one wants to pay for it - if you're paying council tax already you expect them to take your rubbish away.

"They're taking liberties."

Kevin Golding-Williams, from pedestrian campaign group Living Streets, said the issue impacts a large number of people, and the fallout - with bin bags dumped on streets - is highly-visible.

He said: "It's one of those services which affects everyone regardless of area, regardless of whether you're in the most affluent areas or the poorest areas.

"It's going to start rotting and smelling which isn't particularly nice.

"If there are a number of bags there it becomes a real problem."

Some have also argued the issue of garden waste has proved so emotive because it brings politics to people's doorsteps and drives.

Mr Dale said the inconvenience of losing the collections would have been keenly felt among a number of residents.

"In Birmingham there are lots of people without cars so they can't take their own garden waste to the tip," he said. "So they have to pay the £35."

Yellow sticker attached to abandoned waste bags The council has warned people they may face prosecution if they are caught fly-tipping

Dr Steve McCabe, of Birmingham City University's business school, agreed those on low incomes or with limited access to transport may feel "trapped" into paying.

"For a lot of people finding £35 a year might not seem a lot," he said.

"But if you are retired and on a limited pension, finding £35 might not be so easy, but you may not feel you have a choice, especially if you don't have your own transport."

The big question is whether feelings over bags of garden waste will actually influence the outcome of the election.

Chair of the Local Authority Recycling Advisory Committee, Andrew Bird, said he thought voters would understand local councils faced a "difficult financial situation".

"With budget pressures local authorities are having to look at all their services and anything that's non-statutory will come under closer scrutiny.

"Unfortunately, garden waste falls into that category."

Mr Dale is not so sure.

"I don't know that people will actually connect it with the Labour party as a lot of people might not actually know who runs Birmingham City Council," he said.

"It may be more likely to contribute to people not voting as an expression of protest."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country



Min. Night -1 °C

BBC Local Live

    16:28: Free theatre project hits decade deadline

    A decade-long project to allow children from some of Birmingham's most deprived areas to see free theatre for their first 10 years has come to a close.

    Alison Fuller and daughter Amaya

    Alison Fuller and daughter Amaya were among the first families to join the theatre project.

    A total of 240 children were signed up to Rep's Children and were able to see special annual performances by Birmingham Repertory Theatre.

    16:09: City Link failure 'won't cost taxpayer'

    Former City Link owner Jon Moulton dismissed criticism taxpayers would end up paying for the firm's redundancies after administrators said they would refer employees to the government's statutory redundancy payments scheme.

    City Link sign

    "I don't think the taxpayer is going to end up footing much of a bill on this," he said, adding the firm had paid "a fortune" in taxes such as PAYE.

    15:59: Car flips over

    Solihull Police has shared a photo of a car which flipped onto its roof amid icy conditions on Dovehouse Lane this morning.

    Flipped car

    They said nobody was hurt in the accident.

    15:21: Taxpayers still owed cash Express and Star

    A council in the Black Country has yet to refund more than £1 million in overpaid council tax, it has been revealed.

    15:02: Paradise Circus redevelopment Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    Buses in Birmingham city centre will be diverted from 5 January while work starts to demolish buildings as part of the Paradise Circus redevelopment.

    From 10 January there will be restrictions on all vehicles.

    14:44: MPs remembered

    Former Wolverhampton MP Lord Bilston, originally Dennis Turner, features in a BBC Politics round-up of ex-Parliamentarians who died in 2014.

    Dennis Turner

    The list also includes Tony Benn and Lord Barnett.

    14:33: Gritters sent out

    Gritters will be treating roads in Birmingham from 18:30, the city council says.

    Priority footways will be treated from 03:00 on Tuesday.

    14:16: City Link staff addressed Chris Blakemore News editor, BBC WM

    A total of 50 out of 56 workers at City Link's depot in Wednesbury have been told today they are out of a job.

    City Link vans

    The courier company went into administration on Christmas Eve and is expected to have made more than 2,000 redundancies by New Years Eve.

    13:57: 'Treecycling' push BBC WM

    Hamish Shilliday, community fundraising manager at Selly Oak's St Mary's Hospice, said the Treecycling scheme was a key fixture in their fundraising calendar.

    He said: "We collected nearly 500 trees last year and the average donation was well above the £10 we ask for."

    13:43: Mother killed in hit and run Stourbridge News

    A man has appeared in court concerning the hit and run crash which killed Dudley mother-of-five Paula Jolly before Christmas.

    13:30: Wolves 'back in the mix'

    Wolves defender Richard Stearman says concentrating on "the basics" in training helped the team pick up two Christmas wins which have put them back into play-off contention.

    Richard Stearman

    He told the club's official site: "We have picked up two tough wins in the space of three days and are back in the mix - we're delighted with that."

    13:16: Football rumours BBC Sport

    Today's BBC Sport football gossip round-up includes speculation Liverpool want to sign Saido Berahino from West Bromwich Albion and Aston Villa are interested in a Fulham midfielder.

    13:00: 'Treecycling' time BBC WM

    St Mary's Hospice in Selly Oak is heading out again to collect used Christmas trees for a small donation.

    Its annual Christmas Treecycling scheme has now been running for three years, raising thousands of pounds for the hospice.

    12:43: Cold alert to last days

    The Met Office says a cold weather alert for the Midlands will stay in place until 12:00 on Wednesday.

    The alert level is one below a national emergency and indicates social and healthcare services should target "high-risk" groups, such as the very young or old, or those with chronic diseases.

    12:27: No Irvine announcement BBC Sport

    West Bromwich Albion are not expected to make an announcement about the future of manager Alan Irvine today.

    Alan Irvine

    The 56-year-old's job is thought to be in the balance after a poor run of results left the Baggies a point off the relegation places.

    12:08: Crash in Solihull BBC Travel

    Dove House Lane in Solihull is closed near the B425 Lode Lane junction following an accident, advises BBC Travel.

    11:48: Unusual 12 months

    From a chocolate teapot to Angelina Jolie attempting a Midlands accent, BBC News has been looking back at some of the zaniest stories of the past year.

    Angelina Jolie
    11:33: Have your say Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you news, sport, travel and weather updates in one place. We'd like to find out what you think.

    11:20: Metro plan Express and Star

    A long-awaited new Midland Metro tram line from Wolverhampton to New Cross Hospital is being revived after 10 years on the shelf.

    Plans for the new line have been a dream since the Metro was first opened in 1999 but suffered various setbacks over funding.

    11:02: Bus attack pic appeal

    Police have made a photo appeal after a group of men smashed a bus window in Birmingham.

    CCTV still

    Officers believe the group were trying to get to the person in this photo when they used a large weapon, possibly an axe, to smash a window on the 11C service in Stechford in October.

    10:46: Blues happy with Rowett

    Birmingham City FC tweets: P10, W6, D2 highest St Andrew's score in 20 years, 23rd place to 14th . . great start under Gary Rowett to end year

    10:30: Festival bosses consider charge BBC WM

    Organisers of Birmingham's Chinese New Year Festival say they could be forced to charge for the event from 2016 as a result of city council funding cuts.

    Chinese New Year celebrations

    The event was one of several to lose money when the authority announced £117m savings earlier this month and festival bosses say they're looking at other ways of funding it.

    10:13: Team attitude impresses Lambert BBC Sport

    Aston Villa boss Paul Lambert says he was delighted with how his players responded after Fabian Delph was sent off during yesterday's home draw with Sunderland.

    Fabian Delph

    He said: "All credit to the lads, we could have won it and had chances at the end."

    09:36: Heavy congestion BBC Travel

    BBC Travel warns there's disruption in King's Heath on the A435 in both ways around Addison Road.

    09:24: City Link BBC Radio 4

    Jon Moulton of Better Capital, the investment firm that owns City Link, is defending his firm's ownership of the now closed City Link. "We chased every possible way to save this company," he's told Today.

    A Citylink worker and van

    Mr. Moulton says the company had simply failed, and that delaying the closure over Christmas had not been an option, as trading while insolvent was a criminal offence. Could the affair have been better handled? "Not particularly, no," he says.

    09:13: Thug 'terrorised residents' Birmingham Mail

    A thug has been locked up for four months for repeatedly terrorising residents in Yardley Wood.

    08:55: Irvine under pressure BBC Sport

    West Bromwich Albion boss Alan Irvine accepts his job is on the line after yesterday's 2-0 defeat at Stoke left his side a point above the relegation places.

    Alan Irvine

    In his post-match press conference, he said: "Obviously it is up to other people [about my future]. All I can do is keep working as we do and we will see what happens."

    08:35: Icy roads warning

    West Midlands Ambulance Service tweets: Back to work today? Don't start your week with a visit from us; it's icy out there. The gritters have been out, but ease off the accelerator

    08:19: City Link future BBC WM

    Administrators for West Midlands courier firm City Link say depots will reopen this morning, even though the company is expected to close on New Years Eve.

    City Link vans

    Staff found out on Christmas Eve that the company had gone into administration with about 2.700 jobs thought to be at risk, including 126 at depots in Aston and Wednesbury.

    08:07: Sunny but cold Charlie Slater BBC Weather

    A cold, frosty and even foggy start to the day with lots of sunshine but it will remain cold with ice for some. Highs of 3C (37F).

    08:00: Good morning Gavin Bevis BBC Local Live

    Hello everyone. I'll be bringing you today's news, sport, travel and weather updates for Birmingham and the Black Country.

    I love to feature your comments and photos, so email them to or tweet us at @bbcwm



  • Rik Mayall, Elena Baltacha, Lynda Bellingham, Colin PillingerLooking back

    Remember some of those who died in the past 12 months

  • Sam Smith, Taylor Swift, Ed Sheeran and Iggy AzaleaMusic in 2015

    Concerts, albums and events to anticipate

  • David Karp founder of TumblrTumble up

    Tumblr founder excited about social storytelling

  • Uber app and Taxi rankThe big 12

    What were the biggest ideas of 2014?

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.