Trojan Horse probe headed by ex-Met chief Peter Clarke

Park View Academy, Saltley School, Regents Park Community Primary and Adderley Primary School (clockwise from top left) The leaked letter sent to local authorities last year made claims about several schools

Related Stories

The former national head of counter terrorism is to lead an inquiry into 25 Birmingham schools over allegations of a hard-line Islamist takeover plot.

But the appointment of Peter Clarke, an ex-deputy assistant commissioner of the Met, was described as "desperately unfortunate" by the chief constable of West Midlands Police, Chris Sims.

The Department for Education (DfE) has appointed Mr Clarke to review evidence.

Birmingham City Council said it had more than 200 reports over its inquiry.

Mr Sims added: "Peter Clarke has many qualities but people will inevitably draw unwarranted conclusions from his former role as National Co-ordinator for Counter Terrorism."

Peter Clarke's appointment has been questioned by police and some community leaders

Mr Clarke's background includes leading the investigation into the London 7 July bombings, in 2005.

'Firm action'

The city council's Labour leader, Sir Albert Bore, said: "He [Mr Clarke] will have to build relationship with the community, the community of Birmingham, the Muslim community of Birmingham.

"And coming with a background which is that of counter-terrorism doesn't make for a good starting point.

"I think many of the community in Birmingham would not want an investigation to be conducted along those lines because they do not believe that the activities in the schools are the starting point for terrorism in the city."

Khalid Mahmood, Labour MP for Birmingham Perry Barr, also questioned the appointment.

"It's the perception that it gives to people across the country - that this is an issue of terrorism, not about structures and how schools work," he said. "And that would be detrimental to the Muslim community, not just in Birmingham, but across the whole country."

The so-called "Operation Trojan Horse" letter, which came to light in March, purported to outline a template on how schools could be pushed into adopting more Islamic cultures.

Peter Clarke The DfE said Peter Clarke would work closely with the city council

Apparently written by someone in Birmingham to a contact in Bradford last year, the undated and unsigned document proposed a co-ordinated effort of installing governors and replacing staff - including head teachers - who were unsympathetic to Muslim doctrines.

It claimed the tactics had been successfully deployed at several schools in Birmingham.

Mr Clarke, who has been appointed education commissioner, is due to report back with his findings in the summer and his remit will cover local council-run primary and secondary schools as well as academies.

Explaining the appointment, Education Secretary Michael Gove said: "I have already asked Ofsted to inspect a number of schools of concern and these investigations are ongoing.

"But wider, more comprehensive action is needed.

"These allegations need either to be substantiated and firm action taken, or to be shown to be baseless.

"We cannot allow uncertainty for parents or pupils to persist."

A DfE spokeswoman said Peter Clarke's background made him "exactly the right appointment for this important job" and that he had worked for many years with diverse communities.

"He has long experience of leading sensitive investigations, and has earned a reputation for thoroughness, integrity and independence," she added.

'Dispassionate manner'

But Bob Jones, the elected West Midlands Police and Crime Commissioner, said: "My main concern is that the Secretary of State is attempting to divert attention away from the governance and diversity issues that might be embarrassing to his policies and approach to school governance."

The DfE said Mr Clarke would be responsible for analysing "evidence of extremist infiltration in both academies and council-run schools".

Analysis

The alleged Trojan Horse plot is about claims a small group of Muslims, with strongly held religious beliefs, had co-ordinated takeovers at schools in Birmingham in order to impose a more Islamic style of teaching.

The plot, if it exists, was not about a Muslim takeover of schools, but about one particular group trying to enforce its views upon others, in areas where the Muslim population is greater than 90%.

Until Tuesday, the various investigations were about education, governance and teaching methods.

The latest DfE statement on the issue uses words like "Islamist" and "extremist".

There is a danger such language could inflame sentiment within a population which already feels isolated and victimised.

The authorities in Birmingham have prided themselves on working successfully and closely with the Muslim community, and fear that if there is a heavy-handed intervention from London it might have a detrimental effect.

The department said Mr Clarke would be accountable to Mr Gove and would work closely with the city council, which has appointed former head teacher Ian Kershaw as its own chief advisor for the inquiry.

Norman Smith, the BBC's chief political correspondent, said government sources had denied Mr Clarke's appointment was evidence of a possible terrorist link.

He added sources said Mr Clarke had been appointed because he was a "top policeman who will get to the bottom of what has been going on".

The council's investigation, running in parallel to the DfE's inquiry, is due to initially report back in May.

Ofsted has been sent in to inspect 15 Birmingham schools in recent weeks, after the Trojan Horse allegations first broke.

The Society Of Local Authority Chief Executives said the involvement of so many bodies in multiple investigations "demonstrated the confusion caused by recent reforms and highlighted the need for clearer lines of responsibility".

With the spread of academies, free schools and others outside of the local authority's control, the society said the accountability system for schools in England was "broken and in need of urgent review".

Since the Trojan Horse letter surfaced, a number of school staff have come forward to make various allegations.

These include claims of boys and girls being segregated in classrooms and assemblies, sex education being banned and non-Muslim staff bullied.

Park View Education Trust, which was implicated in the original document, has rejected claims of a takeover.

Its chairman Tahir Alam said it was facing a "witch hunt" based on "all sorts of false allegations" and an internal investigation had found no evidence to substantiate the claims.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country

Weather

Birmingham

Min. Night 11 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    18:00: Good evening

    That's all for today from BBC Local Live in Birmingham and the Black Country.

    We'll be back again at 08:00 tomorrow with the latest news, sport, weather and travel updates.

     
  2.  
    17:52: Tonight's forecast Shefali Oza BBC Midlands Today Weather

    The mild temperatures are part of a transitional phase and after that we're back to cold clear conditions, although no snow in the next few days.

    Shefali Oza reads the forecast

    This cloud being generated from the west is going to create some wet conditions but it's bits and pieces of rain. Temperatures around 11C (52F).

     
  3.  
    17:41: Coming up Midlands Today Mary Rhodes Presenter, BBC Midlands Today

    "The darkest moment in my life" - that's how Shah Jehan from Wolverhampton described the moment he heard his young cousins had been killed in the Pakistan school massacre.

    Ten-year-old Saif and 9-year-old Noor were among the 141 children and adults killed by the Taliban yesterday. We'll be live at Birmingham Central Mosque, where special prayers are being held this evening.

    Join us for Midlands Today on BBC One at 18:30.

     
  4.  
    17:34: Crash near Birmingham Airport Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    One lane is closed and there is queuing traffic on the M42 northbound at J6, for the A45 by Birmingham Airport, because of a crash.

    Travel time is 25 minutes with congestion back to J4 by the A34 for Shirley, warns BBC Travel.

     
  5.  
    17:30: Ashes Tests for Edgbaston Mark Mitchener BBC Sport

    Edgbaston and Old Trafford have been allocated Ashes Tests for 2019 by the England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB).

    The other three venues - Headingley, Lord's and The Oval - had already been awarded the England v Australia games.

    Edgbaston

    The Oval, Edgbaston - which hosted the final of the 2013 event - and Cardiff are also set to be the three host venues for the ICC Champions Trophy in 2017.

     
  6.  
    17:23: Birmingham pedestrianisation

    The A38 underpass which currently goes underneath the old library which is due to be demolished as part of a radical rehaul of the city's roads.

    Paradise scheme artist's impression

    The Queensway section, which is currently one-way, will become a two-way route. The site of the former library will be redeveloped which it's hoped will improve access for pedestrians.

     
  7.  
    17:13: Brummie band to be showcased Louise Brierley BBC WM Reporter

    We've just got some amazing news about Brummie band Ekkah. They've secured the BBC Introducing weekly slot on the Radio 1 playlist in the week commencing 19 January.

    Ekkah

    It comes a month after they recorded a session at Maida Vale for Huw Stephens show on Radio 1, which you can watch again here.

     
  8.  
    16:57: News on the hour Rebecca Hume Journalist, BBC WM

    At 17:00 we hear the West Midlands police and crime commissioner's reaction to the announcement the region's force is to lose £23m funding next year.

    Tune in to our bulletin for more on this and other stories.

     
  9.  
    16:41: Profit on false claims probe Birmingham Mail

    A Birmingham law firm made £900,000 from a £31 million investigation into false claims that British soldiers murdered and tortured Iraqi civilians.

     
  10.  
    16:30: 'Costly' eco-heating blasted Ben Godfrey BBC Midlands Today

    An "eco-friendly" heating system designed to cut household bills in a Birmingham tower block has increased costs, according to tenants.

    Contractor Carillion said its communal Ecopod boiler aims to reduce energy consumption and fuel poverty.

    Ecopod control panel

    But residents in the city council-managed Derwent House, Harborne, said heating their flats was more now more expensive. Carillion says it had discussed "cost effective" usage with residents.

     
  11.  
    16:20: Vehicle destroyed in Dudley car blaze Dudley News

    A car fire which caused a cloud of black smoke over Dudley left one vehicle burned out.

    The incident happened at just before 8am on December 16 when flames engulfed a Volkswagen car in Grazebrook Road

     
  12.  
    16:08: Coming up Paul Franks Presenter, BBC WM

    Pete York from Birmingham's The Spencer Davis Group popped into the Havill & Travis gallery in Harborne to see some of the pictures of the '60s music scene.

    Pete York next to a picture of himself in The Spencer Davis Group

    Jim Simpson was there to capture this "then and now" photo. Hear my interview with Jim about his retrospective at 16:20 on BBC WM.

     
  13.  
    15:55: News on the hour Rebecca Hume Journalist, BBC WM

    Prayers will be said in Birmingham tonight for the 141 people killed by the Taliban in Pakistan yesterday.

    More on this and other stories in our 16:00 news.

     
  14.  
    15:37: Rock stars' humble beginnings Paul Franks Presenter, BBC WM

    A new photography exhibition has opened - featuring pictures of pop and rock stars performing in Birmingham before they were famous.

    Jim Simpson discovered Black Sabbath (pictured) and now organises the city's International Jazz Festival.

    Black Sabbath

    His collection of photos dating back 50 years is now on display at the Havill & Travis Gallery in Harborne. I'll be speaking to him after 16:00 on BBC WM.

     
  15.  
    15:22: Showdown with Preston Rob Gurney BBC WM Sport

    Walsall now know which side stands between them and a first ever trip to Wembley - it's Preston.

    Loan man Michael Cain and Anthony Forde celebrate Walsall's progression in the cup at Prenton Park

    Dean Smith's side will now face the winners of last night's other semi-final, between Notts County and Preston North End, in a two-legged regional final in January.

     
  16.  
    15:11: Unlicensed taxi crackdown Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    Two taxi drivers face prosecution after being snared plying for hire in a licensing crackdown on Broad Street, Birmingham, last weekend.

    One of them was a member of the public posing as a licensed driver and was rumbled by undercover police.

    Revellers are being encouraged to pre-book their taxis home after their Christmas and New Year celebrations by the city council.

     
  17.  
    14:56: News on the hour Rebecca Hume Journalist, BBC WM

    Our top local story: Parts of Birmingham city centre are to be pedestrianised in a £500m rehaul of the city's roads.

    Listen live at 15:00.

     
  18.  
    14:49: War hero dies Halesowen News

    A Black Country World War II hero who was horrifically injured in the Anzio landings, has died following a short illness.

     
  19.  
    14:39: FA Cup giant killer BBC WM

    Everyone loves a giant killing in the FA Cup - and tonight Worcester City could secure another famous victory.

    They've already knocked out the 1987 winners Coventry City in this season's competition and tonight they host Scunthorpe in a second round replay.

    Nathan Vaughan

    Worcester City goalkeeper Nathan Vaughan (pictured) also works at the Jaguar Land Rover plant in Solihull. His boss has given him today off ahead of the game and says his team can go on in the cup.

     
  20.  
    14:24: 'Bleak period' for manufacturers Tom Richardson BBC News Online

    Manufacturers in the Black Country are facing a "bleak period" for their sector, a report has found.

    The Black Country Chamber of Commerce, which published its Quarterly Economic Survey today, found optimism among local businesses had "significantly declined" over the past year.

     
  21.  
    14:10: Listen: 'He had a lot of life' Danny Kelly Presenter, BBC WM

    It was an emotional show today. A caller contacted me earlier to talk about how the Peshawar school massacre (pictured) is affecting families in the West Midlands.

    Sadj, from Handsworth in Birmingham, told how his 15-year-old cousin Mohammed was among those killed by Taliban militants.

    Relatives comfort injured student Mohammad Baqair in Peshawar, 16 December

    He said Mohammed, an only child, died instantly after being shot three times. "He was a young boy, he had a lot of life, a lot of friends," he said. Listen to Sadj's full call here.

     
  22.  
    13:58: News on the hour Rebecca Hume Journalist, BBC WM

    Prince William recently held a private meeting with Tariq Jahan who wants the circumstances surrounding the death of his son and two friends in the Birmingham riots in 2011 to be formally re-examined.

    A Palace spokesman has confirmed the meeting took place.

    More on this and other stories in our bulletin at 14:00.

     
  23.  
    13:49: Campaigners dealt blow in battle to save Sedgley pub from supermarket plans Express and Star

    Campaigners fighting to save a popular Sedgley pub from being turned into a supermarket have been dealt a blow after council planners backed the proposals.

     
  24.  
    13:39: Tongues wag on Ideye John Platt BBC WM Sport

    The performances of West Bromwich Albion's record-signing Brown Ideye was a hot topic callers on last night's football phone-in.

    Brown Ideye

    Former Baggies midfielder Ian Hamilton told Franksy he believes Ideye needs to be given a run in the team, if he's to have any chance of discovering his best form. Have your say from 18:00 tonight with Paul Franks

     
  25.  
    13:29: Watch: Mailbox roof completed Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    Work has been completed on the Mailbox's brand new roof, as its refurbishment moves a step closer to completion ahead of its opening in Spring 2015.

    A screenshot from the timelapese video

    You can see how the project has come together in this time-lapse video showing the work.

     
  26.  
    13:17: Shoeboxes full of donations

    The high commissioner for Sierra Leone has thanked Bishop Vesey's Grammar School, in Sutton Coldfield, for giving shoeboxes full of donations to children in the Ebola-hit country.

    The high commissioner receives the gifts

    Donations were collected by the school from as far away as Hull and Sheffield.

     
  27.  
    12:58: News on the hour BBC WM

    A Lichfield man says he's being forced to move to China to be with his pregnant wife because a visa for her to live with him here has been turned down.

    We'll bring you more on this in our 13:00 bulletin.

     
  28.  
    12:40: Coming up on TV Amy Cole Reporter, Midlands Today

    The father of a man killed during the Birmingham riots in 2011 says the Duke of Cambridge supported his calls for a public inquiry during a recent private meeting.

    We will hear from Tariq Jahan live in the studio.

    Council tenants living in tower blocks in Birmingham are meanwhile demanding an investigation after seeing their hot water and heating costs double since a new system was installed. Join us for Midlands Today on BBC One at 13:30.

     
  29.  
    12:29: Food firm 'beyond unreasonable' BBC Newsnight

    A major UK food manufacturer is setting "beyond unreasonable" terms in proposed contract agreements, one of its suppliers has told us.

    The firm, 2 Sisters - set up by West Midlands billionaire, "the chicken king" Ranjit Singh Boparan - has been seeking more than four months to pay its bills, a document seen by our programme shows.

    Chicken on supermarket shelf

    It would have also been entitled to a 3% discount for paying within 90 days. 2 Sisters, which produces Goodfella's pizza and Fox's biscuits, said its proposal was only the starting point for a negotiation with its suppliers.

     
  30.  
    12:20: Council must 'radically change' Tom Richardson BBC News Online

    Birmingham City Council needs to "radically change" if it is to compete with the likes of Manchester.

    That's according to the man who led a review of the city's governance published earlier this month.

    Sir Bob Kerslake

    Writing in the Guardian, Sir Bob Kerslake said there was a "council knows best" culture in Birmingham and said members should not look to blame others for the city's problems.

     
  31.  
    12:09: First details of local TV Birmingham Post

    Birmingham's long-awaited TV station will have 41 hours of local programmes a week - and 40 hours of repeats.

     
  32.  
    11:55: News on the hour Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    At 12:00 we hear from a Handsworth man who called BBC WM to tell us his 15-year-old cousin was killed in the massacre in Peshawar, Pakistan.

    Listen live here.

     
  33.  
    11:47: Warning on flu virus Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    Pregnant women in Wolverhampton are being urged to come forward by the city council for a free flu vaccination this winter.

    It comes after a report published last week showed that flu was the cause of death in one in 11 women who died in, or shortly after, pregnancy, between 2009 and 2012.

     
  34.  
    11:38: Radical rehaul for city Jennifer Scott BBC News Online

    Parts of Birmingham city centre are to be pedestrianised in a radical rehaul of the city's roads.

    The new road layout

    The Paradise project, due to start on 5 January, will see the A38 underpass removed and traffic redirected around Paradise Circus Queensway.

     
  35.  
    11:26: Pakistan school horror Danny Kelly Presenter, BBC WM

    I've been speaking to a Wolverhampton man who lost a close friend in the Peshawar school attack in Pakistan.

    Listen live for more reaction.

     
  36.  
    11:10: Donations for Ebola-hit country Jennifer Scott BBC Local Live

    I've been speaking Bishop Vesey's Grammar School in Sutton Coldfield, which has collected hundreds of donations of toys for children in Sierra Leone.

    Edward Turay, High Commissioner for Sierra Leone (pictured), visited the school to thank its 900 pupils for their efforts.

    Edward Turay, ambassador for the Sierra Leone High Commission, thanks pupils at Bishop Vesey's Grammar School

    Teacher Julie Wadeson says the school is looking for a firm to help transport the boxes down to London. Once there, they'll be shipped to the Ebola-hit country for Christmas. If anybody can help, they can contact the school on twitter .

     
  37.  
    10:59: News on the hour Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    At 11:00 we hear from one of five men, who claims to have been abused by a former teacher at Tettenhall College in Wolverhampton.

    He pursued a civil claim against the college which settled out of court. The institution stressed there were no allegations of negligence against the college in the civil action and they would cooperate with any further enquiry.

    More on this and other stories in our 11:00 bulletin.

     
  38.  
    10:46: Defining Birmingham

    Why has Birmingham been named as one of the world's top 10 cities by travel handbook company Rough Guide? Read more here.

    Bull Ring
     
  39.  
    10:35: Watch: Malala 'heartbroken' by massacre BBC News Asia

    Nobel Prize winner Malala Yousafzai who goes to school in Birmingham says she is ''heartbroken'' by the news of a Taliban massacre at a school in Peshawar, killing 141 people, 132 of them children.

    Malala Yousafzai
     
  40.  
    10:15: Unemployment falls Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    Unemployment fell by 14,000 across the West Midlands - to 187,000.

    The latest ONS figures for between August and October equate to 6.8% of the population.

     
  41.  
    09:56: News on the hour Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    A supplier to a Black Country food manufacturer has criticised the company for asking for four months to pay its bills.

    More on this in our 10:00 bulletin.

     
  42.  
    09:49: Call to overturn 'cruising' ban BBC WM

    2,000 people have signed a petition calling on a group of Black Country councils to overturn a ban on car cruising.

    A three-year injunction came in this month and will see anyone taking part, promoting or organising races on public roads arrested.

    Car meeting

    Shane Lloyd, who set up the petition, told us modified car owners were being victimised

     
  43.  
    09:36: MP warns of 'NHS emergency' with Birmingham hospitals in danger of running out of beds Birmingham Mail

    A Birmingham MP has warned the city could run out of hospital beds after a shock investigation showed wards are nearing full capacity.

    Former health minister Liam Byrne said health chiefs face an 'NHS emergency' after latest grim statistics revealed some hospitals are using 96 per cent of available beds.

     
  44.  
    09:22: Travel update

    London Midland tweets: CLEARED: Line problems owing to suspected cable theft at Stourbridge Jucntion have ended.

     
  45.  
    09:10: Inside Out returns Ed Barlow BBC Inside Out

    Filming for the new series of Inside Out West Midlands has already begun. We're back on 12 January.

    Filming for Inside Out

    If there are any stories from the West Midlands you think we should be covering do get in touch.

     
  46.  
    09:00: News on the hour Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    More than 120 people in the West Midlands had to go to hospital after being bitten by a dog in the last 10 months, according to figures released to us.

    More on this and other stories in our 09:00 bulletin.

     
  47.  
    08:49: Free parking in Walsall Tom Richardson BBC News Online

    Fourteen days of free parking starts in Walsall Town Centre this weekend, says the borough council.

    The offer applies to council-controlled car parks only - around 1,200 spaces - and runs from Saturday 20 December to Friday 2 January.

     
  48.  
    08:39: Programme details revealed for Birmingham's local TV station Birmingham Post

    Birmingham's long-awaited TV station will have 41 hours of local programmes a week - and 40 hours of repeats.

     
  49.  
    08:23: Grounds ban for Koran-ripping fan Duncan Leatherdale BBC News Online

    A football fan who ripped up pages of the Koran during a match in Birmingham has been banned from every football ground in England and Wales for three years.

    St Andrew's

    Julie Phillips, 51, tore pages at St Andrew's during Middlesbrough's 2-2 draw away at Birmingham City, last December.

     
  50.  
    08:11: M6 lane closures Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    Resurfacing work means there is a lane closed on the M6 exit slip road at J8 for the M5 southbound and there is queuing traffic.

    A broken down vehicle and recovery work on the northbound carriageway of the M6, between J10 for Wolverhampton and J10a for the M54 means there is another lane closure there.

    Keep up to speed with all the rush-hour traffic news here.

     
  51.  
    08:04: Today's forecast Charlie Slater Weather Presenter, BBC Midlands Today

    Highs of 13C (55F) today in the West Midlands which is exceptionally mild for the time of year! A couple of showers are also possible.

    Charlie Slater reads the forecast

    The outlook for the next few days is here.

     
  52.  
    08:00: Good morning Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    I'm back in the BBC WM newsroom bringing you today's news, sport, travel and weather.

    Get in touch with us during the day about our updates over email, Twitter or Facebook.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.