Would the West Midlands welcome a Greater Birmingham?

Birmingham aerial view Birmingham and its surrounding boroughs currently have their own local authorities

Related Stories

It has been touted as a way for the West Midlands to compete with London and vie for international investment. But will rebranding large parts of the region as "Greater Birmingham" make a difference?

Business leaders have argued the label will boost the area's international profile, while some politicians have gone a step further and called for a region-wide authority.

They say Birmingham should follow the lead of areas like West Yorkshire, which recently formed a single body, to co-ordinate economic recovery.

If adopted, it could mean areas like the Black Country and Solihull, which are currently viewed separately from Birmingham, fall under the same umbrella.

'Nightmare' authority

But could it work? What would you call a single West Midlands authority? Send us your thoughts at newsonline.westmidlands@bbc.co.uk

John Lewis boss Andy Street is head of the Greater Birmingham and Solihull Local Enterprise Partnership (GBSLEP), a collection of nine local councils and businesses aiming to raise the region's profile.

He has not called for a new authority but believes a collective regional identity would help the West Midlands to market itself to the rest of the world.

He said: "If you're a businessman selling in China you have no idea what the West Midlands is.

"Chinese businessmen know what Birmingham is, it's got an image, a reputation and I absolutely believe we should lead on that brand."

Greater Birmingham sign 'Greater Birmingham' could stretch as far as Coventry and Wolverhampton

Birmingham City Council leader Sir Albert Bore, who sits on the GBSLEP, believes a combined body is the way forward for local government.

He re-stated his calls for closer working between councils in his 2014 budget statement, and has said local government will struggle to deliver services in its current form.

But there is scepticism as to whether 'Greater Birmingham' would work.

Catherine Staite, director of University of Birmingham's institute of local government studies, warned the prospect of creating a single West Midlands authority would be a "nightmare".

She said the size of Birmingham's single "massive" council, surrounded by much smaller unitary bodies, made it problematic to join them all together in the same way Manchester did 40 years ago.

Mrs Staite said that unlike councils in Greater Manchester, which have spent four decades developing a "relationship of trust", there was more discord among Midlands authorities.

"There is a deep-seated mistrust of Birmingham on the part of smaller unitaries trying not to be swallowed up and swamped," she said.

"They want to keep a special distinctive air about them."

Greater Birmingham map Greater Birmingham could stretch out to include outlying areas like Coventry and Wolverhampton

As well as practical concerns over restructuring, proposals to create a single authority have not been greeted well by all residents in the surrounding areas.

Some people in the Black Country area said they would not want to be classed as part of Birmingham.

Claire Mansell, owner of a cake shop in Wednesbury, said the area - which consists of the Walsall, Sandwell and Dudley boroughs and includes parts of Wolverhampton - had a long history of distancing itself from Birmingham.

"I think it would get a lot of resistance, especially from older people who have lived here all their lives," she said.

"I wouldn't be happy to call myself a Brummie - people from Birmingham have a reputation for being arrogant around here.

"They should leave it alone, it's been the Black Country for too long to try and change it."

Peter Lyons Peter Lyons, from Knowle, said he felt rebranding would not boost his butcher's shop business
Bethan Read Wolverhampton shop worker Bethan Read said she wouldn't want her home city to lose its identity
Claire Mansell Cake shop owner Claire Mansell said she thinks the Black Country should be left alone

The village of Knowle, in the Solihull district, was part of Warwickshire for centuries before it was brought under the authority of the short-lived West Midlands County Council (WMCC), formed in 1974

Butcher Peter Lyons remembers villagers were not impressed with the boundary change then, and said the idea of a 'Greater Birmingham' would be similarly unpopular today.

"I think the general reaction here is that it should retain its identity as part of Solihull," he said.

"I like Birmingham and I'm proud of the Midlands but we have our own community here which we are very proud of."

'Wolverhampton girl'

Mrs Staite said instead of re-labelling or "unnecessarily" changing where people live, more local authorities should build on existing projects which have seen them work together.

The parts of the West Midlands

  • The West Midlands is a 348 sq mile (902 sq km) area divided into seven metropolitan boroughs
  • Figures from the 2011 census put the population of the region at about 2,738,000 - Greater Manchester was estimated at about 2,685,000
  • Birmingham, Coventry and Wolverhampton's boroughs each have city status
  • The boroughs of Sandwell, Dudley and Walsall are generally termed 'The Black Country' alongside parts of Wolverhampton, though there is dispute over the exact boundary
  • Solihull, to the south of Birmingham, has its own borough council which includes some former parts of Warwickshire
  • The Greater Birmingham and Solihull LEP includes parts of North Worcestershire and South Staffordshire, but not Wolverhampton or the Black Country boroughs, which have their own "consortium"

"There are already lots of examples where West Midlands councils are running shared services," she said.

"I think this vision of a Greater Birmingham would absorb a huge amount of energy that could be put into doing things more efficiently.

"Restructuring takes twice as long as you think it will and is a departure from the task at hand."

The GBSLEP and Centro, which co-ordinates public transport across the West Midlands, are examples of cross-boundary collaboration, although the Black Country has its own separate LEP.

Albert Bore has called for the two LEPs - which traditionally bid against each other - to work together for the benefit of the region's economy.

In Wolverhampton Bethan Read, an assistant shop manager, said she supported efforts to boost businesses but did not want her home city to lose its individual identity.

"I've always thought of myself as a Wolverhampton girl, where you're from is quite an important part of who you are.

"I think you need to have a mix of identities and areas as well, so I'd prefer to keep it separate."

For Catherine Staite, the answer lies in improving the way current councils go about their business rather than changing their identity.

"People associate themselves with those towns or cities and not some amorphous 'West Midlands'," she said.

"I think local councils can do something good without spending a lot of money or causing a lot of bother.

"That will be achieved more easily with innovative ways of doing things rather than going through the process of creating a new authority."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country

Weather

Birmingham

Min. Night 14 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Savage tips Villa and West Brom for drop 16:53: Birmingham Mail

    Former Birmingham City star Robbie Savage tipped Aston Villa and West Bromwich Albion for the drop - as he prepared to have his trademark blond locks cut off.

     
  2.  
    Local Commonwealth stars in action 16:46:

    Birmingham's Hannah England will be in action this evening in the 1500 metre final.

    The race is scheduled for 21:50.

     
  3.  
    Hereford to New St train delayed 16:35:

    London Midland Trains is advising passengers that the 15:40 Hereford to Birmingham New Street service (due 17:11) is running 19 minutes behind schedule having been delayed in Ledbury.

     
  4.  
    Arrests following break-in 16:32: Royal Sutton Coldfield Observer

    Two Erdington men are in police custody after a Sutton Coldfield restaurant was broken into this morning.

     
  5.  
    Call for end to flight path trials 16:16:

    Conservative MP Caroline Spelman has called for the transport secretary to stop flight path trials being carried out from Birmingham Airport.

    BHX

    The airport began a six-month trial for two potential new flight paths in May as part of a runway extension.

     
  6.  
    News from BBC WM 16:05: Alice Rosenthal Journalist, BBC WM

    A Dudley drug dealer, who assaulted a police officer then reached for a loaded gun while being arrested, has been jailed for 10 years.

    Stefan Rattray, 24, stretched for the weapon while a PC was trying to detain him during a search last November - he'd already kicked her head and body.

    Officers found drugs and dealing equipment along with a silencer and some bullets. He's been convicted for a number of crimes including having a gun and dealing heroin. Listen live

     
  7.  
    Gold for Wolverhampton gymnast 15:54:

    England won gold in the men's gymnastics team final as Scotland landed a historic silver medal.

    england gold winning team commonwealths 2014

    Kristian Thomas of Wolverhampton was part of the English team, lining up alongside Louis Smith, Sam Oldham, Max Whitlock and Nile Wilson.

    Over the two days of competition they scored 266.804.

     
  8.  
    Ex teacher denies sex offences 15:39:

    A former PE teacher has denied a string of sexual offences against pupils dating back to the 1950s.

    Marcus Marcussen, 91, pleaded not guilty to 28 counts of indecent assault and two of indecency with a child.

    A trial has been scheduled for 19 January.

     
  9.  
    Your views 15:19: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? Tell us what you think about the service we run from the BBC in Birmingham.

     
  10.  
    Commonwealth winners' gallery 15:06: Midlands Today

    We're extremely proud of our Midlanders winning medals in Glasgow. We'd love you to leave your messages for the athletes on our Facebook page.

    wm commonwealths 2014
     
  11.  
    News on the hour 14:56: Alice Rosenthal Journalist, BBC WM

    Border forces have stopped two stun guns being smuggled into Britain through Birmingham Airport. They were found in a baggage search on Friday after a flight landed from Istanbul.

    A 47-year-old British woman, who lives in Florida, has been charged with two counts of importing an offensive weapon and will appear in court in September. Listen live

     
  12.  
    Thomas trained 'so hard' 14:48:

    "The last few months we've just been training so so hard, so this is for the whole team," says Kristian Thomas, from Wolverhampton, who has just won gold with the England men's gymnastics team.

     
  13.  
    Dozens of jobs created in Harborne 14:38: Birmingham Post

    Dozens of jobs have been created at a new Birmingham café-bar which opens today.

     
  14.  
    Dealer absconds from open prison 14:27:

    A 35-year-old drug dealer has gone on the run from Sudbury open prison in Derbyshire.

    Asaf Mahmood

    Asaf Mahmood, who has links to Birmingham, was jailed for more than three years in 2013 but failed to return from temporary leave yesterday.

     
  15.  
    Team gold for local gymnast 14:10:

    Kristian Thomas, from Wolverhampton, has just won gold in the men's team gymnastics at the Commonwealth Games.

    Kristian Thomas

    Thomas joined team-mates Louis Smith, Max Whitlock and Nile Wilson posting a score of 266.804.

     
  16.  
    News on the hour 13:59: BBC WM

    The ICC, cricket's governing body, has said Birmingham-born England batsman Moeen Ali cannot continue to wear his "Save Gaza" and "Free Palestine" wristbands during the third test against India. Listen live.

     
  17.  
    Cricket: Warks v Sussex 13:54:

    Warwickshire are in action shortly when they take on Sussex in the One Day Cup. Play starts at 14:00. Listen live.

     
  18.  
    Your pictures: Birmingham Cathedral 13:39:

    Thanks to Daniel Sturley for sharing this picture of the weathervane on St Philip's Cathedral Birmingham.

    Weathervane St Philip's, Birmingham

    If you've taken any pictures you'd like to share you can email us.

     
  19.  
    Teenager seriously injured in crash 13:26: Express and Star

    A 15-year-old girl was today fighting for her life in hospital after being hit by a car in Wolverhampton.

     
  20.  
    Coming up on BBC One 13:16: Elizabeth Glinka Presenter, BBC Midlands Today

    We'll have the latest on our competitors at the Commonwealth Games after Staffordshire swimmer Adam Peaty took Silver in the Men's 50m Breaststroke.

    And we'll also be finding out whether Birmingham could become one of the first major cities to introduce a higher tax for diesel cars which put out higher levels of pollution.

    Join me at 13:30.

     
  21.  
    House prices surge in West Midlands 13:06: Birmingham Post

    The West Midlands was the only UK region reporting a significant rise in house prices last month, new data shows.

     
  22.  
    News on the hour 12:57: BBC WM

    A girl is in hospital with life-threatening injuries after being hit by a car on Wolverhampton ring road yesterday.

    We'll have more in our 13:00 bulletin.

     
  23.  
    Bell dedicates ton to grandfather 12:51:

    Warwickshire and England batsman Ian Bell dedicated his return to form to the memory of his grandfather William, who died earlier this month.

    ian bell southampton 214

    Bell scored his first Test century in almost a year to lead England to 569-7 declared on the second day of the third Test against India, who closed on 25-1.

     
  24.  
    Diesel cars could face charges 12:40:

    The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs has said that unless action is taken cities such as Birmingham could face dangerous levels of pollution from vehicle exhausts by 2030.

    exhaust

    Now cities around the UK are considering brining in low emission zones to force out older diesel vehicles that are responsible for higher levels of fumes.

     
  25.  
    Bike brake pierces girl's leg 12:30: Birmingham Mail

    Fire crews had to remove part of a bike's handlebars that had become embedded in the leg of a six-year-old girl in a freak accident at a Shard End park.

     
  26.  
    Slow traffic on A456 12:19:

    BBC Travel News says there's slow traffic on the A456 Manor Way eastbound in Halesowen between Grange Road Roundabout and the B4043 Manor Lane junction in the roadworks area.

     
  27.  
    Walsall properties to be cleared 12:06:

    Work started yesterday on the demolition of derelict properties in Walsall as part of a multi-million pound project.

    walsall demolitions

    The Albion Tannery, a three-storey building, together with an adjacent unit, number 7 Hatherton Street, will be flattened to help promote the site as a development opportunity, the council says.

     
  28.  
    News on the hour 11:57: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    The ICC, cricket's governing body, has said Birmingham-born England batsman Moeen Ali cannot continue to wear his "Save Gaza" and "Free Palestine" wristbands during the third test against India. Listen live

     
  29.  
    Former MEP dies 11:41:

    Former West Midlands Labour MEP Christine Oddy has died, aged 58.

    christine oddy

    Ms Oddy won the seat in 1989 and retained it in 1994. Five years later she stood as an Independent following a dispute with the Labour Party.

    She died on Saturday from cervical cancer, the Trade Union and Socialist Coalition says.

     
  30.  
    Grateful parents ink thanks to hospital 11:39: Birmingham Mail

    Grateful parents have inked their thanks to a Birmingham hospital - by having tattoos paying tribute to the care their children received.

     
  31.  
    Erdington meeting streamed 11:29:
  32.  
    Boys in Collymore racist abuse probe 11:18:

    Four teenage boys have been spoken to by police for making racist and threatening tweets to ex-footballer Stan Collymore.

    stan collymore

    Mr Collymore said he had been racially abused and sent death threats via Twitter between January and May.

     
  33.  
    ICC warns batsman 11:06:

    England batsman Moeen Ali has been warned not to wear wristbands showing support for Gaza during the third Test with India any more.

    moeen ali gaza wristbands

    The Birmingham born batsman, 27, wore bands saying "Free Palestine" and "Save Gaza" on the second day's play in Southampton.

     
  34.  
    News on the hour 10:59: Chris Blakemore News editor, BBC WM

    Solihull has been named as a hotspot for young adults still living with their parents despite having jobs.

    It's being claimed nearly two million young adults in England aged 20 to 34 are struggling to leave home because of rising rents and high house prices. Listen live

     
  35.  
    Your views 10:52: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place.

    Tell us what you think about the service for Birmingham and the Black Country.

     
  36.  
    Children blamed for blaze 10:38: Express and Star

    Fire crews called to tackle a blaze at remote farmland in Wall Heath near Kingswinford found two cans containing the hazardous substance propane in the debris.

     
  37.  
    Doctor Who comes to Birmingham 10:19:

    Doctor Who is preparing to take to the stage with live music and a cast of 100 actors and singers - and Daleks.

    Doctor Who live

    The show will tour the UK and will be visiting Birmingham in May next year. Tickets will go on sale on 1 August.

     
  38.  
    Girl injured in ring road crash 10:08:

    A 15-year-old girl was seriously injured in a crash on Wolverhampton's ring road last night.

    The teenager was crossing the Ring Road at the Waterloo Road junction, at about 16:30, when she was struck by a Volkswagen Golf.

    Police are appealing for witnesses.

     
  39.  
    News on the hour 09:56: Chris Blakemore News editor, BBC WM

    The MP for Meriden, Caroline Spelman, has asked the transport secretary to stop flight path trials being carried out by Birmingham Airport.

    The airport's been testing two new flight paths since May as part of the new runway extension.

    She says there are real problems for local people. Listen live

     
  40.  
    Airport response on flight path 09:48:

    Birmingham Airport says in a statement that the new flight path, to the south of the airport, is required as a result of the runway extension which is now open.

    It is aware of a petition circulating in the community and is recording and responding to all correspondence received.

     
  41.  
    Villa buyer could be imminent 09:39: Birmingham Mail

    A new owner of Aston Villa could emerge "within a month" following a close season of intense behind the scenes negotiations with potential buyers, it was claimed today.

     
  42.  
    Top Headlines
     
  43.  
    Government lobbied over flight path 09:22: BBC WM

    The government is being lobbied to force Birmingham Airport to stop flight trials over Balsall Common.

    People living there say the noise is making their lives a misery after the tests started in May and, in some instances, planes are flying too close to their houses.

    Caroline Spelman, the MP for Meriden, is asking the transport secretary to stop the trial.

     
  44.  
    Police hunt screwdriver attackers 09:06:

    Two capped men lashed out at a Birmingham shop-keeper with a screwdriver when he refused to serve them alcohol.

    screwdriver attackers

    The pair attacked a member of staff at Aston's Express Convenience Store in Birchfield Road just before 23:00 on 29 May.

    Anyone with information is asked to contact Det Con Phil Langstone on 101 or call Crimestoppers anonymously on 0800 555111.

     
  45.  
    News on the hour 08:55: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    A West Midlands MP is calling for an end to flight path trials carried out by Birmingham Airport.

    We'll be hearing from Caroline Spelman, MP for Meridan, in the 09:00 bulletin on BBC WM.

     
  46.  
    Bell puts England in strong position 08:44:

    Warwickshire batsman Ian Bell returned to form with a first hundred in almost a year as England dominated the second day of the third Test against India in Southampton.

    ian bell

    Bell made 167, sharing century stands with Gary Ballance and debutant Jos Buttler, who dazzled on the way to 85 from 83 balls.

     
  47.  
    City launches hunt for housing developer 08:33: Birmingham Post

    Plans for a major housing scheme in south Birmingham have taken another significant step forward after the city council cabinet agreed to open the tender process to build more than 300 homes.

     
  48.  
    Footage of officer flung from van 08:23:

    West Midlands Police has released this dramatic footage of the moment a Birmingham police officer was flung to the ground as he tried to stop a getaway van.

    police screen grab

    Detectives are appealing for help to solve the case.

     
  49.  
    Birmingham tunnel delays 08:12:

    The planned tunnel closures in Birmingham city centre are causing delays in both directions.

    See BBC Travel News for more information.

     
  50.  
    Cloudy later 08:03:

    After some morning sunshine, it will turn increasingly cloudy from the northwest. Though most places will remain dry, the odd spot of rain is possible.

    weather

    Late in the day, the cloud may tend to break allowing sunny spells to return.

     
  51.  
    Good morning 08:00: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    I'll be bringing you the latest news, sport, weather and travel throughout the day for Birmingham and the Black Country.

    You can get in touch by emailing locallive@bbc.co.uk.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.