Free school with 20 pupils branded 'a waste of money', by NUT

Anand Primary School teaches 20 children in Graiseley, Wolverhampton

Related Stories

A free school in Wolverhampton has been branded a "waste of money" after it emerged it has just 20 pupils.

Anand Primary School, which opened in September, received £220,000 in government funding for its first year.

Head teacher Kulbinder Pouni said pupil numbers were low because admissions opened before a school site was found.

But the National Union of Teachers (NUT) said that free schools with "very small numbers of children" were "a major waste of taxpayers' money".

'Inefficient and costly'

Anand Primary, in Great Brickkiln Street, Graiseley, has capacity for 420 pupils between the ages of four and 11 and claims "to provide greater choice for parents" looking for "outstanding education".

Run by the Sangat Education Trust, it is based on core Sikh values but is open to non-Sikh children,

It is part of a growing number of free schools which are set up by groups and are state-funded but operate outside local authority control.

They have independence from councils to decide their budgets, curriculum and the length of their school day and terms.

Free school growth

  • On Thursday, 10 more free schools were approved by Education Secretary Michael Gove, including two in Birmingham
  • These are The East Birmingham Network (EBN) free school in Sutton Coldfield and King Solomon International Business School in central Birmingham
  • They will join 174 free schools already operating
  • A further 115 are preparing to open

Christine Blower, general secretary of the NUT, said free schools are "an inefficient and hugely costly mechanism for delivering new school places".

She claimed it was unwise to use government funds for "very small numbers of children" in free schools before they were operating at full capacity.

Instead she called for local authorities to be given the powers and funding "to open new community schools in areas of greatest need".

'Fabulous' start

Anand's head teacher Kulbinder Pouni claimed the school year had started "fabulously" despite only having 20 children.

"To put the numbers in context, we didn't have a site when admissions opened and I wasn't in place so there was a level of uncertainty for parents," she stated.

She said a "good number" of parents with prospective pupils had arranged to visit the school since September.

Education Secretary Michael Gove, who conceived the free school model, said they were "driving up education standards" as he announced on Thursday that 10 new free schools would provide 5,000 extra places.

Anand Primary School, the first of its kind in the Black Country, was officially opened by the mayor of Wolverhampton, Councillor Milkinder Jaspal, earlier.

The Department for Education was unavailable for comment.

However, Conservative MP for Wolverhampton South West Paul Uppal said he hoped the school would become a "beacon" for education standards in the city.

"I think it will eventually increase its numbers. It's going to take a bit of time but we have to challenge the status quo," he said.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country



10 °C 1 °C

BBC Local Live

    10:00: News on the hour Michelle Dawes Journalist, BBC WM

    Every emergency vehicle across the West Midlands will be given keys to access a block of flats in Druids Heath after a woman lost her twin babies and spent nine days in a coma after paramedics struggled to gain access to help her.

    More on this in our 10:00 news.

    09:50: Saddlers fans celebrate Wembley tie Rob Gurney BBC WM Sport

    This was the jubilant scene at the Banks' Stadium at the final whistle last night, when it was confirmed the Saddlers had booked their place at Wembley.


    Already 2-0 up from the first leg of the Johnstone's Paint Trophy northern area final at Deepdale, Dean Smith's men needed only to avoid defeat.

    Walsall have never reached a Wembley final in their 127-year history.

    09:41: Balti Curry Seeks a Place in British Culinary Lore New York Times

    At a time when tensions over immigration, assimilation and religious and ethnic differences seem to be growing ever sharper, Adil's adaptation of Pakistani cooking to British tastes is a symbol of culinary cross-fertilization in one of Britain's most multicultural cities.

    Most customers at Balti restaurants in Birmingham are non-Asian — a tasty retort to the much-mocked reports that areas of Birmingham, and of a number of other European cities, had become "no-go zones" for anyone but strict Muslims.

    09:29: Construction company in administration Jennifer Harby BBC News Onlne

    A Birmingham construction company has gone into administration with the loss of 150 jobs.

    Parkstone's offices

    The Parkstone Group said it had been struggling financially, in part because of late bill payments by clients.

    About 74 staff at the firm's headquarters, near Coleshill (pictured), will be made redundant, along with a number of contractors.

    09:10: Local reaction to Saddlers' success Caroline Gall BBC News

    I'm off to Walsall to find out what fans - and non-fans - think of the football team's upcoming trip to Wembley.

    Their goalless draw with Preston last night booked their place at "the home of football" for the first time in their 127-year history.

    Walsall fans celebrate

    Walsall have never previously reached a Wembley final - since 1984 they've been within one step of reaching the national stadium four times - but now they've done it.

    08:57: News on the hour Michelle Dawes Journalist, BBC WM

    On the morning after Walsall Football Club made history - manager Dean Smith tells us the game which secured them their first trip to Wembley has made a hero out of every player.

    More on this in the 09:00 bulletin.

    08:37: Golden Hillock joins national academies chain Andrew Dawkins BBC News

    A school at the centre of the so-called "Trojan Horse" allegations of a takeover by Muslim hardliners is to join a different group of academies.

    Golden Hillock School

    Golden Hillock School will join the Ark network in September, following a resolution by current management at Park View Educational Trust.

    In December, Ofsted said the school was "making reasonable progress" - it was previously rated inadequate in all categories.

    08:25: Tipton road closure BBC Travel

    The A457 Sedgley Road East in Tipton is closed westbound between the A4033 Dudley Road West junction and the A461 Dudley Port junction, because of emergency repairs and a collapsed manhole.

    A diversion is in operation. More details are here.

    08:14: Walsall's Wembley tie makes history BBC Sport

    Walsall's goalless draw with Preston last night booked their place at Wembley for the first time in their 127-year history.

    Walsall celebrate reaching Wembley

    Already 2-0 up from the first leg of the Johnstone's Paint Trophy northern area final at Deepdale, Dean Smith's men needed only to avoid defeat.

    But, on a tense evening, the Saddlers had to hang on in a frantic finale.

    08:04: Sunny but cold today Charlie Slater Weather Presenter, BBC Midlands Today

    Showers this morning which are replaced by sunshine and much colder temperatures in the West Midlands this afternoon.


    Highs of 9C (48F). More about the outlook for the next few days is here.

    08:00: Good morning Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    I am back in the BBC WM newsroom bringing you today's news, sport, travel and weather.

    Get in touch with us during the day over email, Twitter or Facebook.



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.