Hundreds of breast cancer patients 'failed'

Report author Sir Ian Kennedy: "Opportunities were missed on a number of occasions"

Related Stories

Bosses at an NHS trust failed hundreds of breast cancer patients, an independent report has found.

The report by lawyer Sir Ian Kennedy found concerns about surgeon Ian Paterson dated back to 2003 but were not dealt with for four years.

He carried out "cleavage sparing" mastectomies while at the Heart of England NHS Foundation Trust and the review found some women were exposed to a risk of cancer returning.

The trust said it was "very sorry".

Solihull Hospital previously found the surgeon breached guidelines over a procedure that involved leaving behind breast tissue to provide an improved cleavage.

Sir Ian's report made a number of recommendations relating to better transparency, improved recording of information, the role of regulators, encouraging staff to raise concerns and increased scrutiny.

'Secrecy and containment'

It found senior managers at the trust did not respond effectively until 2007 and said their response was neither sufficiently robust nor rigorous.

Following Mr Paterson's suspension by the General Medical Council [GMC] last year, it referred the case to officers at West Midlands Police.

A spokeswoman for the force confirmed its investigations are continuing.

Sir Ian's report said the case had lessons for the whole NHS.

"It is a story of clinicians at their wits' end trying for years to get the trust to address what was going on.

"It is a story of clinicians going along with what they knew to be poor performance.

Ian Paterson Mr Paterson was appointed by the trust as a surgeon in 1998.

"It is a story of weak and indecisive leadership from senior managers. It is a story of secrecy and containment."

Mr Paterson was appointed by the trust as a surgeon in 1998.

Sir Ian said the breast surgeon, who has since been placed under an interim suspension order, was allowed to carry on operating on women for several years despite a series of concerns raised about him by other medical staff.

He added: "I was shocked by how long it took for effective action to be taken. Why was there not in place a system that could properly address the needs of women?"

Sir Ian said senior managers resorted to "a sort of auto pilot" and "excluded everyone but a small number in the know".

However, the report went on to say that it was "mistaken and naive" to believe that any one person was truly responsible.

Start Quote

If they [the board] are going to sleep on the job and don't hold their chief executive to account then they have failed”

End Quote Sir Ian Kennedy

The report said the trust had "a huge task on its hands to win back some measure of confidence".

It added: "[Staff] have lost confidence in the management of the trust, they...feel betrayed that no one listened to them, that things were allowed to go unchallenged for so long, that they cannot trust those charged with leading the trust."

The review found the trust board was excluded from access to much of the information by senior managers and made no formal effort to assert itself and become involved.

Sir Ian said: "The board is responsible for everything that happens in the trust and if they are going to sleep on the job and don't hold their chief executive to account then they have failed."

Up to 400 women are believed to be suing the trust for failing to take action over the claims.

'Completely unacceptable'
Lord Hunt Trust chairman Lord Philip Hunt apologised

NHS England said it "fully supports the recommendations that Sir Ian details in his report".

Trust chairman Lord Philip Hunt said: "I wish to give a full unreserved apology to all patients and their relatives. This was completely unacceptable and I am very sorry indeed."

He said a taskforce would be set up in January to oversee the implementation of Sir Ian's recommendations.

Lynne Rolinson, 53, from Solihull, underwent a mastectomy and breast reconstruction surgery performed by Mr Paterson in January 2007.

She said: "I feel it's quite a tragedy. Had the trust listened to people who raised concerns in 2003 and 2004 I would not be standing here.

"It's very difficult to deal with on a day-to-day basis, because I don't really know if I'm clear or I'm not."

Kashmir Uppal from Thompsons Solicitors, which is handling almost 400 of the compensation cases, said she welcomed the conclusions of the report.

She said she was "concerned about the failings of the trust and the failings of senior management" to act against Mr Paterson.

"The fact that clinicians tried to raise their concerns and weren't listened to... it's just not acceptable."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country

Weather

Birmingham

8 °C 4 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    13:40: Coming up on TV Amy Cole Reporter, Midlands Today

    A leaked report into the NHS in Staffordshire identifies a health care system in crisis facing a £270m deficit by 2018.

    Our health correspondent Michele Paduano will have more details on Midlands Today now on BBC One.

     
  2.  
    13:34: Teenager arrested for 'murder bid'

    A teenager has been arrested on suspicion of attempted murder after a man was stabbed in the head on his doorstep in Dudley earlier this week, police have revealed.

    The 17-year-old boy was arrested at an address in Netherton and is in police custody.

    The 65-year-old householder was attacked just before 6.15pm in Owen Street, Kates Hill, on Tuesday, suffering serious stab wounds to his head, shoulder, chest and back.

     
  3.  
    13:25: New TV station Ben Godfrey BBC Midlands Today

    A new digital TV channel for the West Midlands will start broadcasting tomorrow.

    BIG CENTRE TV

    Big Centre TV comes almost three years after the government invited towns and cities in the UK to bid for local TV licences.

    The channel took over the licence from City TV which went bust before it even went on air. Watch my report on Midlands Today at 13:40.

     
  4.  
    13:09: 200 jobs to go in Walsall cuts Caroline Gall BBC News

    About 200 jobs will be lost at Walsall Council after £29m of spending cuts were approved.

    Some children's centres will close and council tax will go up by 1.99%.

    Walsall council offices

    But a decision to close five libraries was reversed by councillors at their 2015-16 budget meeting as the authority looks to slash £86m over the next fours years.

     
  5.  
    12:59: News on the hour Chris Blakemore News editor, BBC WM

    Walsall's much loved concrete hippo is to be restored.

    "Hoppy" has been smiling at shoppers from The Bridge in the town centre since 1972, but lately he's been looking a bit worse for wear.

    More on this story in our 13:00 headlines.

     
  6.  
    12:45: 'Murder in the making' foiled Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    After police foiled a gun attack, Detective Chief Inspector Simon Wallis said: "Thankfully, no weapon was discharged and the prompt response of our highly-trained officers prevented Jamie Webster from carrying out his attack, which was potentially a murder in the making.

    A loaded revolver was found on Sarbjit Bhamra's seat

    Webster and Sarbjit Bhamra were handed a 15-year sentence for each offence: conspiracy to possess a firearm with intent to endanger life and conspiracy to possess ammunition with intent to endanger life - to run concurrently. Arron Burris-Hale was handed 13 years for each crime, also to run concurrently.

     
  7.  
    12:32: Albion striker back in contention Steve Wilson BBC Match of the Day commentator

    West Bromwich Albion forward Victor Anichebe is back in full training after a groin injury and may be involved against Southampton.

    Victor Anichebe celebrates his equaliser against Chelsea at The Hawthorns

    More team news here.

     
  8.  
    12:16: How MPs boosted their earnings Express and Star

    From property to surveys and appearing on TV and radio, MPs in the West Midlands added to their £67,000 a year pay in different ways.

    Just two MPs across 19 constituencies covered by the Express & Star declared income from a second job, however, as Parliament voted against a ban on the practice.

     
  9.  
    11:56: News on the hour Rob Mayor Journalist, BBC WM

    We will have more on the breaking news about a man arrested for attempted murder after a woman was found after a fall from the third floor of a block of flats in Caldmore.

    Listen live to the news at 12:00 here.

     
  10.  
    11:52: Attempted murder arrest BREAKING NEWS

    A 52-year-old man has been arrested on suspicion of attempted murder after a woman in her 20s was found with "serious injuries" after an apparent fall from a third floor window in Walsall.

    Walsall Police tweeted they were called to the block of flats in Little London, Caldmore, this morning and the area has been cordoned off as an investigation has been launched.

     
  11.  
    11:42: Blues need to get tough BBC WM Sport

    Birmingham City boss Gary Rowett says his side needs to focus on becoming harder to beat, as their defence was key in their earlier form.

    Gary Rowett

    Blues lost just twice in 13 games after Rowett's appointment in late October, but Tuesday's defeat at Ipswich has left them now without a win in nine matches.

    He says there are no fresh injury concerns heading into tomorrow's match at home to Brentford.

     
  12.  
    11:28: Local TV to launch Andrew Dawkins BBC News

    Birmingham's new local TV channel launches tomorrow, three months after it was awarded the licence.

    Logo

    Big Centre TV will appear at 18:00 GMT on Freeview channel 8 after previous licence holder City TV went into administration before getting on air.

    Channel director Chris Perry said: "People think of local TV and they think possibly cheap they think possibly poor. I want to change those perceptions absolutely completely. I want us to be a very professional station."

     
  13.  
    11:11: Have your say Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  14.  
    10:58: News on the hour Rob Mayor Journalist, BBC WM

    A 41-year-old man has been arrested after a six-hour stand-off with police negotiators in Birmingham.

    More on this story in our 11:00 bulletin.

     
  15.  
    10:35: Arrest after stand-off via Facebook

    A man has been arrested after a stand-off following threats to emergency services as they dealt with a flood at a block of flats on Milton Street, Newtown, this morning.

    Several roads were closed while specialist negotiators from West Midlands Police were locked in talks with an occupant of the flats making "substantial threats" according to officers, since 02:17 today. At around 08:15 officers entered the premises and detained a 41-year-old man, posted police in Birmingham.

     
  16.  
    10:15: Gun plot trio jailed Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    Three men have been jailed for a combined 43 years for arming themselves with a revolver for a revenge attack after a dispute in Ladywood Community Centre, according to police.

    Jamie Webster, Arron Burris-Hale and Sarbjit Bhamra were sentenced at Birmingham Crown Court yesterday after being found guilty of plotting to possess a firearm and ammunition with intent to endanger life.

    From left to right: Jamie Webster, Arron Burris-Hale and Sarbjit Bhamra

    Officers caught Webster and Bhamra on 30 June 2014 within four minutes of being called to Guild Close in Ladywood after receiving reports of two men with handguns chasing a black car, a Mercedes, up the road.

     
  17.  
    09:59: News on the hour Rob Mayor Journalist, BBC WM

    The parents of an 11-year-old Birmingham boy with autism say they have been discriminated against, after they were stranded on holiday when their airline refused to let him board the flight home.

    Arshad Sherbaz and his partner Selina Begum from Ward End were told by Thomas Cook their son Mustafah needed a "fit to fly" certificate, despite warning them about his son's disability before their holiday.

    We will hear more on this story in our 10:00 news.

     
  18.  
    09:49: One-night stand blackmailer jailed Express and Star

    A man who blackmailed a married woman into giving him more than £1,000 after they had a one-night stand has been jailed for three years, fainting in the dock as he was sentenced.

     
  19.  
    09:32: Card cloning scam appeal

    Detectives investigating a fuel-card cloning scam have released CCTV footage showing two men they believe may have filled up with £30,000 of stolen petrol and diesel from forecourts across Birmingham, primarily in Washwood Heath and Erdington.

    The two suspects

    Officers have already arrested and charged a cashier suspected of duplicating the cards - and they've now issued images of two men caught on CCTV using them to buy fuel.

     
  20.  
    09:09: Standstill on the M6 Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    The normally busy M6 saw drivers walking around cars parked in traffic this morning after a crash involving an overturned lorry brought the northbound carriageway to a standstill.

    Driver walking on the carriageway

    Motorist Tom Patrick tweeted a picture of the road, with people standing waiting by their cars. He said during his delay "the only thing to have improved is the weather, I've not moved an inch since 7:09".

    Stay up to date with the latest details of the disruption here.

     
  21.  
    08:59: News on the hour Rob Mayor Journalist, BBC WM

    The MP for South Staffordshire says plans to develop a travellers site in Great Wyrley into a residential site for 14 families are a disgrace.

    We will hear more from Gavin Williamson in our 09:00 bulletin.

     
  22.  
    08:39: Police criticised over delay Birmingham Mail

    Police have still not decided if any action will be taken over claims by a former senior IRA officer that the terrorists were responsible for the murder of 21 people in the Birmingham pub bombings.

     
  23.  
    08:25: Sherwood targets Villa wins BBC Sport

    Aston Villa boss Tim Sherwood has targeted six wins from the remaining 12 league games to avoid relegation.

    Tim Sherwood

    "The reality has to kick in that we are in a dogfight and need points as soon as possible," said Sherwood.

    Villa have won just five games out of 26 in the league, with only Leicester below them in the table.

     
  24.  
    08:14: M6 traffic warning BBC Travel BBC Travel

    One lane is closed and there is slow traffic on the M6 northbound between J9 for Wednesbury and J10 for Wolverhampton, because of emergency repairs, drivers are warned.

    More details here.

     
  25.  
    08:03: Cold but sunny Charlie Slater Weather Presenter, BBC Midlands Today

    Generally fine with plenty of sunshine, and any remaining showers soon fading away. However cloud will gradually thicken spread in from the west by dusk.

    weather

    Highs of 7C (45F).

     
  26.  
    08:00: Good morning Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    It's me in the BBC WM newsroom today bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather for Birmingham and the Black Country.

    We'd like you to send us your views about our updates and it would be good to see your pictures too, so get in touch over email, Facebook and Twitter.

     

Features

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.