End of the road? Are major routes through cities outdated?

Queensway tunnels The A38 Queensway tunnels have been criticised for being noisy and unattractive

Related Stories

A report looking at Birmingham's transport network for the next 20 years has concluded the future of the Queensway tunnels should be examined. It is not the only place in the UK that relies on a route for cars through the city. So are such roads outdated?

When it emerged Birmingham's Queensway tunnels would be closed for six weeks over the summer, it is no surprise there were predictions of "chaos".

The main through route for the A38, the tunnels are used by thousands of drivers each day and have been an integral part of the city's transport network since they were built in the 1970s.

There was some surprise, therefore, when the anticipated gridlock did not materialise.

The reality was so different that a report into Birmingham's transport network for the next 20 years has called for a debate about how much they are needed, pointing out they create a "noisy unattractive barrier to intra-centre movement".

Motorists in Manchester, Leeds and Glasgow rely on similar urban routes - the A57M, A58M and M8. But do we really need them?

'Almost vandalism'

"Our view is that it is entirely inappropriate to have major roads crashing through the middle of cities," said David Tittle, from the Design Network, which advises on design in urban environments across the country.

He said while such roads were effective at getting drivers directly from one place to another they split areas down the centre, reducing the scope for development and regeneration.

"The more we can do away with them - the better," he said.

Peter Rayner, a fellow of the Chartered Institute of Logistics and Transport and former advisor to the government's transport select committee, said major urban roads through cities "fly in the face of the inevitable".

"In the future we will not have the oil to run cars so it is foolish to have large roads running through city centres," he said. "It's almost vandalism."

Mr Rayner said councils needed to think about moving away from a reliance on such routes and instead concentrate on the development of integrated public transport and tram networks.

Big Dig tunnel Studies have shown the Big Dig project has yielded financial benefits for Boston's economy

There have already been a number of schemes to abolish major urban routes in the US to create extra space.

In Boston, an underground highway was created to replace an elevated six-lane route which previously carried 200,000 cars per day through the heart of the city.

Although the Big Dig project, which also saw the creation of two new bridges over the Charles River, overran by billions of pounds, studies have shown it has already yielded benefits.

A study by the Massachusetts Turnpike Authority said getting rid of the road had encouraged $5.3bn worth of construction projects in the freeway's vicinity which had generated nearly 36,000 new jobs.

Meanwhile in Portland, Oregon, city bosses in 1974 closed the Harbor Drive freeway to make way for a 37-acre park.

The three-mile long highway ran alongside the Willamette River and carried 25,000 vehicles a day.

'Trusted friend'

But a report called the Seattle Urban Mobility Plan said the move had increased land values in Portland from a total of $466m to more than $1.6bn and reduced trips on nearby roads by just under 10%.

Council bosses have already been looking at the long-term future of the A58M in Leeds and the M8 in Glasgow.

Councillor Richard Lewis, responsible for highways at Leeds City Council, said he believed the city could cope without the A58m but said the council would need to do a lot of things to replace it.

"It's a trusted friend," he said. "There may come a time when we don't need it anymore but we would not want to part company with it in a hurry."

Mr Lewis said they were spending £20m to refurbish the east-west link at various sections and said: "I don't want to be spending large sums of money on something that is no longer fit for purpose."

Meanwhile Alistair Watson, executive member for transport at Glasgow City Council, said he would welcome exploration of alternatives to the M8 but said any change would require a "radical overview" of how Glasgow connected to other towns and cities.

The tunnels Birmingham Chamber of Commerce believes the city could survive without the Queensway tunnels

And back in Birmingham? Katie Teasdale, from Birmingham Chamber of Commerce, believes the city could survive without its tunnels.

"Yes of course, but there would need to be a genuine alternative in place," she said.

"At the moment they are very important. Yes we want a safer, cleaner, greener city but we also need to make sure people can get from A to B."

But Dr Pat Hanlon, a lecturer in transport economics at the University of Birmingham, could not see the benefit.

"It would create such an accumulation of traffic at the bottom end by Bristol Road... I shudder to think what would happen to all the traffic," he said.

"I would be really worried if they did that."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country

Weather

Birmingham

15 °C 7 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Man feared drowned 12:10: Express and Star

    Officers continued to search the lake at Walsall Arboretum this morning after a man was spotted in difficulty in the water.

     
  2.  
    Top story at midday 12:02: BBC WM

    The top story at 12:00:

     
  3.  
    Cricket: Warks v Sussex 11:55:

    Warwickshire have lost their match against Sussex by seven wickets. Captain Ed Joyce scored two centuries in the match, ending the second innings on 151 not out.

    Full scorecard.

     
  4.  
    Surgeon returns to work 11:52:

    A surgeon who allegedly branded his initials into a patient's liver has been allowed to return to work.

    Simon Bramhall surgeon

    Simon Bramhall, who works at the Queen Elizabeth Hospital in Birmingham, still faces a full disciplinary hearing.

     
  5.  
    Dudley Tories 'will survive' 11:42: Dudley News

    Dudley Conservatives will survive despite the news that five long-serving top Tories are to step down at the next election, party leader Councillor Patrick Harley has promised.

     
  6.  
    Trojan Horse: Appointment a 'disaster' 11:33:

    A school governor has said it is "a disaster for community cohesion" that the former national head of counter terrorism has been appointed to lead an inquiry into 25 Birmingham schools.

     
  7.  
    Loudest gigs ever 11:17: Adrian Goldberg Presenter, BBC WM

    A fan has claimed the volume at a UB40 gig made their ear bleed, but I'm sure they're not the loudest band around.

    So I want to know, what are the loudest gigs you've ever been to?

    sex pistols

    Give us a call on 03453 009956 or text 81333, starting your message with WM.

     
  8.  
    Insolvency risk falls for businesses 11:06: Birmingham Post

    The risk of redundancy among key business sectors in the West Midlands appears to have fallen, suggests new research.

     
  9.  
    News on the hour 10:55: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    The headlines from BBC WM include:

    • The latest unemployment figures for the West Midlands show the jobless total has gone up for the first time this year
    • Specialist police and fire teams are searching Walsall Arboretum for a man who it's feared has drowned in the lake
    • A major rescue operation is taking place off the South Korean coast, where about 300 passengers are missing after a car ferry capsized
     
  10.  
    UB40 gig 'made fan's ear bleed' 10:45:

    Music at a UB40 concert was so loud it was "altering heart rhythms" and caused a fan's ear to bleed, it has been claimed.

    UB40 2014
     
  11.  
    London Midland trains 10:33:

    London Midland tweets: CLEARED: Trains are now running normally between Redditch / Longbridge and Birmingham New Street #Northfield

     
  12.  
    Sunrise pictures 10:24: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    Thanks to Hampson Haulage for sharing this picture of sunrise over Knowle.

    sunrise knowle

    If you'd like to send us your pics you can email, tweet or contact us on Facebook.

     
  13.  
    Cricket: Warks v Sussex 10:14:

    Warwickshire are looking set to lose their match against Sussex despite an unbeaten 189 from Ian Bell yesterday. The visitors need just 57 more runs to win and have eight second innings wickets in hand.

    Listen live from 11:00.

     
  14.  
    Wolverhampton road reopens 10:03:

    West Midlands Police tweets: TRAFFIC: Goldthorn Hill in Wolverhampton has reopened following collision involving three cars earlier today. http://bit.ly/1gA1FCj

     
  15.  
    News on the hour 09:57: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    The headlines from BBC WM include:

     
  16.  
    Bus driver suicide 09:46: Express and Star

    A bus driver involved in a crash where a teenage cyclist was killed hanged himself after suffering depression following the accident, an inquest heard.

     
  17.  
    Pensioner attacked 09:36:

    The family of a man who was dragged from his car and attacked outside a Bilston pub on Friday night are appealing for help to trace his attackers.

    Michael Green

    Michael Green (pictured), 84, had just left the Trumpet Pub in High Street at about 23:30 when the thugs struck, West Midlands Police says

     
  18.  
    Missed bulletin 09:26: Midlands Today

    Apologies. Due to a technical glitch we were unable to bring you our last bulletin at 09:00. Normal service will resume at 13:30.

     
  19.  
    LATEST UPDATES
     
  20.  
    Search for man seen in lake 09:16: David Lumb BBC News, West Midlands

    Searches have been taking place for a man seen getting into difficulty in a lake.

    Lake search

    Emergency services were called to Walsall Arboretum after a passer-by spotted the man at about 19:30 last night.

     
  21.  
    Footballer defrauded by life coach 09:07:

    A lifestyle coach who defrauded Premier League footballer Peter Odemwingie (pictured) and six other clients out of more than £80,000 has pledged to pay them back.

    Peter Odemwingie

    Stoke City and former West Bromwich Albion striker Odemwingie was defrauded out of £22,000, the court heard. Claire Duke was given a two-year year suspended prison sentence.

     
  22.  
    News on the hour 08:56: Kevin Pashby Journalist, BBC WM

    The headlines from BBC WM include:

     
  23.  
    Student gambled £20k 08:46: Birmingham Mail

    A former Birmingham University student has told how he considered suicide after blowing £20,000 on Fixed Odds Betting Terminals in high street bookies.

     
  24.  
    Boy arrested over stabbing 08:36:

    A 15-year-old boy has been arrested in connection with a stabbing in Birmingham that left a man in a critical condition.

    "A young man is fighting for his life in hospital, so if anyone saw anything [on Monday night] and has not yet spoken to us, I would urge them to come forward as soon as possible," said Det Insp Paul Joyce.

     
  25.  
    Travel update 08:26:

    The latest from BBC Travel News.

    • There's one lane closed on the M42 northbound between J4, A34 (Shirley) and J5, A41 (Solihull), because of a broken down vehicle
    • The A4039 Goldthorn Hill in Fighting Cocks, Wolverhampton, is closed in both directions between the Ward Road junction and the Ednam Road junction, because of a serious accident
     
  26.  
    Man feared drowned 08:15: Richie Anderson BBC WM reporter

    A man is feared to have drowned after being spotted in difficulty in a lake at Walsall Arboretum last night.

    It's not yet known whether he'd fallen in or was swimming. A full-scale search by specialist police and fire teams is now under way.

     
  27.  
    Chilly start, but be patient 08:06: Rebecca Wood BBC Weather

    It will be a chilly but crisp and clear start to the day. Another fine day then follows, with near unbroken sunshine. It will feel warm in the light breeze and strong April sunshine.

    Weather chart
     
  28.  
    Good morning 08:00: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    I'll be bringing you news, sport, travel and weather updates throughout the day.

    If you'd like to get in touch you can email, tweet or contact us on Facebook.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.