Birmingham bus lane drivers get nearly 60,000 fines

Priory Queensway The council said the signs on Priory Queensway were clear and legal

Related Stories

Nearly 60,000 fines were handed out to motorists for driving in bus lanes in Birmingham over just 11 weeks, the council has revealed.

Responding to a Freedom of Information request from the Birmingham Mail, the council said it had issued 58,582 fines to drivers since cameras were introduced in the Priory Queensway area, yielding up to £3.5m.

Motorists said signs were misleading.

Start Quote

It's totally put me off going into Birmingham and I'm putting off as many other people as I can”

End Quote Maurice Abney-Hastings Fined driver

But the council said only a "minority" of motorists had broken the rules.

'An absolute joke'

Driver Ben Cheney, from Sutton Coldfield, who is appealing against his fine, said: "I'm in favour of bus lanes but the Priory Queensway one is an absolute joke.

"There is not one sign that tells you you can't go down there and, once you've made that left turn, you can't escape the bus lanes.

"I believe it is a trap."

Another driver said he had received five fines during the two days his son was in Birmingham Children's Hospital - some offences taking place within minutes of each other.

Where are the cameras?

  • The Priory Queensway (southbound towards Old Square)
  • The Priory Queensway (southbound towards Masshouse Lane)
  • The Priory Queensway (northbound towards Colmore Circus)
  • St Martin's Queensway (towards Moor Street Queensway)
  • The Priory Queensway (northbound towards Old Square)
  • Bull Street (towards Corporation Street)
  • Moor Street Queensway (eastbound slip road)
  • Moor Street Queensway (towards The Priory Queensway)
  • Moor Street Queensway (south-west bound slip road)
  • St Martin's Queensway (towards New Street station)

"I have no problem with bus lanes," he said. "However, they have got to be correctly signposted."

Disabled driver Maurice Abney-Hastings, from Alcester, was fined £180 for three offences on the same day.

He said he had decided not to take the train into Birmingham because of difficulties with access at some stations.

He emailed the council to explain his circumstances but, despite paying his fine promptly, he was charged £60 for each offence, rather than the discounted £30. He said he had received no response or explanation from the council.

"It's totally put me off going into Birmingham and I'm putting off as many other people as I can," he said. "A council that is run with that kind of arrogance is unbelievable."

However, Councillor Tahir Ali said he did not believe the cameras were unfair.

Mr Ali, who was behind the introduction of the 10 cameras in September, said he planned to roll them out to bus lanes in Birmingham's suburbs.

"The vast majority of motorists do abide by the rules," he said.

"I've been told the signs meet national standards and they are legal.

"Motorists need to be diligent when they are driving and take notice of the restrictions in place."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country



12 °C 10 °C

BBC Local Live

    11:18: Fire treated as suspicious

    The fire service says a blaze overnight at a Birmingham school is being treated as arson.

    West Midlands Fire Service says a large amount of equipment has been destroyed following the blaze at North Birmingham Academy, in Erdington.

    The school closed on Friday for the Christmas holiday and will reopen on 5 January, according to its website.

    11:07: Judge considering sentence Giles Latcham Reporter, Midlands Today

    I'm at Birmingham Crown Court following the Levi-Blu Cassin case.

    His mother and father were cleared of the toddler's murder, but convicted of causing or allowing his death.

    Today they will be sentenced and the judge is now retiring to consider them.

    10:57: News on the hour BBC WM

    In the news at 11:00: The West Midlands is going to be one of 11 places where experts in genetics will treat people with cancers and rare inherited diseases.

    10:48: Street light cuts

    Street lights are being switched off or dimmed to save money in three-quarters of England's council areas, according to Labour Party research.

    A street light

    They've been dimmed at times in Birmingham for years and Dudley Council is planning to switch some off in 2016.

    It comes after councils warned of "huge financial challenges" after next year's government grants were announced.

    10:35: Have your say Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you news, sport, travel and weather updates in one place. We'd like to find out what you think.

    10:17: Rubbish boss to have assets seized Joanne Malin Presenter, Midlands Today

    The boss of a waste firm who was jailed for failing to clear a rubbish pile in the Black Country is to have his assets seized.

    Rubbish piling high in Brierley Hill

    Robert McNaughton, the director of Refuse Derived Fuel, was jailed for six months for repeatedly failing to clear a 42ft (13m) tall pile of rubbish in Brierley Hill.

    Now a High Court writ's been granted, allowing for his and the firms assets to be seized.

    09:58: News on the hour Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    In the news at 10:00 on BBC WM: A man has died in Staffordshire after being shot with a Taser by police.

    09:33: Rowett wants keeper to stay BBC Sport

    Birmingham manager Gary Rowett plans to keep hold of Darren Randolph in January, despite interest in the in-form goalkeeper.

    Darren Randolph

    Rowett says: "Every player in my team has ambition and I want them to be ambitious.

    He adds: "If a Premier League club comes in for Darren, then fantastic, but I want to keep him."

    09:13: 'Vicious attack on family man'

    Police are appealing for witnesses after a 40-year-old man was hit over the head with a brick in Stechford.

    Det Insp Neil Postins says: "This was a vicious attack on a local family man. It's an outrageous response to a verbal spat in the street. It's also a cowardly act to grab whatever he could lay his hands on and use it as a weapon.

    "The attacker may well have spoken about the incident to someone. If so, I'd ask them to do the right thing and get in touch."

    08:55: News on the hour Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    Our top story at 09:00 on BBC WM: We'll hear from the NSPCC's head of child protection awareness, as a Birmingham couple are due to be sentenced for causing or allowing the death of their son in 2013.

    08:48: Birmingham joins DNA scheme

    A new genetics project could help "unlock a series of secrets about devastating diseases", the NHS says.


    Eleven Genomics Medicine Centres, including one in Birmingham, are being set up in English hospitals to gather DNA information to help devise targeted treatments for a wide range of diseases.

    The scheme is focusing on cancer and rare genetic diseases.

    08:38: 'Severe' fire at school Caroline Gall BBC News

    Firefighters have been tackling a "severe" fire at a Birmingham school, believed to have been started deliberately.

    Fire at North Birmingham Academy, on College Road in Erdington

    Arsonists are thought to have set fire to two shipping containers outside the school, which led to lots of equipment being destroyed, West Midlands Fire Service said.

    Crews were sent to North Birmingham Academy, on College Road in Erdington, at 04:15 and say the fire was dealt with by about 06:00.

    08:29: Man struck in head with brick

    A man is in an induced coma after being hit over the head with a brick as he walked to the shops.

    Stud Lane, at the junction with Church Lane in Stetchford

    The 40-year-old father, from Birmingham, was attacked in Stud Lane, at the junction with Church Lane (pictured) in Stetchford, at about 12:00 on Saturday.

    Police say it is understood the victim had a row with another man before he was struck with the brick and left unconscious in the street.

    08:20: Couple due to be sentenced

    A couple are due to be sentenced later for causing or allowing the death of their son in 2013.

    Danielle Cassin, 27, and Mark Piper, 31

    Birmingham Crown Court was told Levi-Blu Cassin died from "catastrophic" internal injuries in February 2013.

    Danielle Cassin, 27, and Mark Piper, 31, of Chelmsley Wood, had both denied delivering a fatal blow to the 22-month-old and were cleared of murder.

    08:07: Today's forecast Charlie Slater Weather Presenter, BBC East Midlands Today

    It will be windy, dull and cloudy for most of the day with a few showers thrown into the mix for good measure.

    Charlie Slater

    Very mild with highs of 12C (54F).

    08:00: Good morning Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    It's feeling quite mild this morning in Birmingham city centre, if not a little windy.

    I'm in the BBC WM newsroom bringing you the very latest news, sport, travel and weather.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.