Birmingham pub bombings: Victim's brother in police HQ protest

Brian Hambleton (l) and colleague Mike Watts Brian Hambleton (left) is demanding answers from the West Midlands force

Related Stories

The brother of a woman killed in the Birmingham pub bombings has staged a protest outside West Midlands Police headquarters.

Brian Hambleton, 58, said it was his frustration over the force finding documents relating to the Hillsborough investigation that led to his action.

His sister Maxine, 18, was one of 21 people killed when bombs exploded in the Tavern in the Town and The Mulberry Bush on 21 November 1974.

Police are "assessing" options.

He said he had been watching the news on Tuesday evening when he saw reports about the police finding a room full of evidence relating to the Hillsborough inquiry. West Midlands Police investigated South Yorkshire officers' conduct after the 1989 deaths.

'The truth'

He said although he did not want to jump on the back of other people's sorrow, he felt frustrated that he and other families were still waiting for answers about what happened in November 1974.

"All I want is the truth," he said. "It's been long enough now."

He added he had not spoken to police himself as "I don't believe anything they say".

Mr Hambleton dropped his sister off in the city on the night of the bombings and said he often wondered whether if she had made her way by public transport instead that night, she might still be alive.

Birmingham Six

Last month, his sister Julie Hambleton met Northern Ireland's First Minister, Peter Robinson, in a bid to secure a public inquiry to find out who caused the blasts.

Paddy Hill, Gerry Hunter, Johnny Walker, Hugh Callaghan, Richard McIlkenny and Billy Power, known as the Birmingham Six, were jailed for life for the bombings in August 1975.

The Court of Appeal ruled in 1991 their convictions were unsafe because they were based on unreliable forensic evidence and "confessions" obtained using violence.

No-one else has ever been charged over the murders.

Earlier this week West Midlands Police said "two items of material" relating to Hillsborough had been uncovered, including witness statements,

The paperwork is now at the Independent Police Complaints Commission, although the force claimed it had no reason to believe the documents had not been given to previous inquiries.

In September, an independent report into Hillsborough said that at the time of the initial investigation West Midlands Police knew South Yorkshire officers had altered statements but accepted the actions of their fellow officers.

'Forensic expert'

A West Midlands Police spokesman said the force's counter terrorism unit was not reviewing previous inquiries relating to the bombings.

"However, we are assessing what future opportunities we might have to resolve the case," he said.

He added police have had several meetings with the Hambleton family to explain what work is being undertaken.

He said police have given a commitment to consult a forensic expert as to what new developments may be applicable to exhibits, and to ensure that all documents and exhibits relating to the case are preserved and catalogued to current day standards.

"This will make them more easily accessible in the future should new lines of enquiry be identified," he said.

"A dedicated team of detectives has been assigned to the task. However, owing to the vast number of historical files that exist - we have identified several thousand so far - the work is likely to take some time to complete."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country



21 °C 16 °C

BBC Local Live

    In the news 14:59: Alice Rosenthal Journalist, BBC WM

    Coming up in the news at 15:00 on BBC WM:

    • More than half-a-million people from across North-west Birmingham and Sandwell will have a new hospital within five years
    • A West Midlands MP has denounced plans for people with treatable mental health problems to have treatment or lose their benefits as "dangerous and insensitive"
    • It`s been announced that the Birmingham Brummies Speedway team has been closed down
    Appeal over robbery 14:52: Sutton Coldifeld Observer

    Police are calling on the public to help them track down a woman who robbed an 84-year-old as he left a Perry Barr supermarket.

    Public example of government 'waste' 14:42: Express and Star

    Controversial arts centre The Public has taken centre stage in a national campaign against £120 billion of 'wasted' taxpayers money.

    Protect footballers after head injuries 14:29:

    Decisions on whether a footballer can return to the pitch after a head injury should be taken by an independent doctor and not the player or coach.

    Alberto Pereira is knocked out at the World Cup

    Antonio Belli, reader in neurotrauma at the University of Birmingham, says players don't understand how dangerous concussion can be.

    Brummies to close 14:12: Dan Pallett Sports presenter, BBC Midlands Today

    So the Birmingham Brummies have gone. The city loses its speedway side weeks after the Knights basketball club closes.

    Raising money 14:07: Birmingham Updates

    Saving Moor Pool Garden Suburb raised £3,800 in 20p pieces. A massive well done to everyone involved!

    'Caught on camera' 13:59:

    West Midlands Police tweets: We have 43 CCTV images and a video currently showing on our 'Caught on Camera' page. Recognise anyone? Call 101. .

    'Bostin walk' 13:46:

    How are you celebrating Black Country Day?

    Black Country canals

    BBC WM reporter Steve Hermon, who is off work today, says he's taking a "BOSTIN walk down the cut" [canal].

    Email or tweet us your photos.

    Queues on A456 in Halesowen 13:31:

    BBC Travel News reports there's queuing traffic on the A456 Manor Way in Halesowen at the B4043 Manor Lane junction in the roadworks area.

    There's congestion to the M5 J3 island junction and to Hayley Green Island.

    Man and wife die in crash 13:22:

    Police say a man in his late 70s and a woman believed to be his wife died in a crash involving three cars on the M42 earlier.

    Emergency services were called to the northbound carriageway between junctions 3 and 3a at about 01:00.

    The driver of a second car suffered a chest injury and was freed by the fire service while the person in the third car was uninjured and did not need to go to hospital.

    Coming up on BBC One 13:14: Tim Aviss Producer, BBC Midlands Today

    Coming up on BBC One at 13:30: Our reporter Sarah Falkland (pictured) will be live in Brierley Hill celebrating everything Black Country.

    Sarah Falkland at the Black Country Show

    Plus, we'll have more from our health correspondent about the new Midlands Metropolitan Hospital.

    'Right thing' for inquiry 13:04:

    Baroness Butler-Sloss says she is stepping aside as the head of an inquiry into allegations of historical child abuse.

    West Bromwich East Labour MP Tom Watson says "it is the right thing and probably best for the inquiry".

    In the news 12:59: Alice Rosenthal Journalist, BBC WM

    I'm reading the news on BBC WM this afternoon.

    In the news at 13:00 Sandwell Council's leader will explain why a new hospital in the West Midlands is good news.

    Cricket 12:54:

    Listen to full commentary of day two Durham v Warwickshire on BBC Sport with Clive Eakin.

    'Headphone hair' 12:42: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    Oh dear. I've been caught with "headphone hair" in the office. I'm often sitting listening to interviews and clips as part of what I do on BBC Local Live and slammed them on my head and created this hair masterpiece.

    Headphone hair

    Jay Vydelingum, who I sit opposite, took this photo and thinks I look like someone from Star Wars...

    A38 tunnels advice 12:32:

    Birmingham City Council tweets: Join the @brumtunnels team today in Victoria Square for info & advice on A38 tunnels closures #brumtunnels

    Cows on the loose 12:23: Express and Star

    Journalist Peter Madeley was in hot pursuit of a herd of cows this morning in Wolverhampton.

    Cows on the run in Windmill Crescent, Wolverhampton

    Sixteen cows got lose and he spent a few hours with police as they waited for a farmer with a large bag of food to persuade them to mooooo-ve on. Read more online.

    Fight against gun crime 12:14:

    San Francisco is scaling up its use of an intelligent gunshot sensor system, but when the same scheme was trialled in Birmingham it was abandoned after two years.

    ShotSpotter Flex Mobile Console

    However, the technology of the sensors has improved, so is it time to retry the system? BBC Technology takes a look at how it's improved and the benefits it brings.

    Black Country Day on BBC WM 12:04: Danny Kelly Presenter, BBC WM

    Today I'll be hitting the Black Country trail between 14:00-16:00.

    I'll be hopping on the BBC WM Black Country bus to carry out a whistle stop tour of the region to visit some of the places and people that make the area one of the best.

    From the top of Dudley Castle to Brierley Hill, to Craddocks Brewery and the Red House Glass Cone - I'll sample the very best of the Black Country with plenty of special guests and music. Listen live

    News headlines 11:55: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    Coming up in the news at 12:00 on BBC WM:

    Black Country Day 11:42: Express and Star

    Break out the faggots and paes - today is official Black Country Day with thousands of people celebrating in the sunshine as specially-designed flags fly high over local landmarks.

    Fort Dunlop sold 11:29:

    The former rubber plant Fort Dunlop in Birmingham has sold, developers Urban Splash announces.

    M42 reopens 11:25:

    BBC Travel News says the M42 northbound has reopened following a crash involving three vehicles.

    Congestion is still heavy and queuing to junction 2.

    Smethwick hospital plans 11:15: Kath Stanczyszyn Political reporter, BBC WM

    More than half-a-million people from across North-West Birmingham and Sandwell will have a new hospital by 2018-19.

    The Chancellor has announced that £353m will be spent on the Midland Metropolitan Hospital which will house all acute services for Sandwell and West Birmingham Hospitals NHS Trust.

    It will be built on Grove Lane in Smethwick, with building work getting under way in 2016.

    Large parts of Sandwell Hospital in West Bromwich and City Hospital will close although certain departments will stay.

    'Flying with pride' 11:04:

    West Bromwich Albion FC tweets: ‏We are flying the flag with pride at The Hawthorns to mark #BlackCountryDay @officialBCday #wba

    Black Country flag flying at West Brom
    In the news 10:56: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    A new multi-million pound hospital has just been announced for Smethwick.

    BBC WM's political reporter Kathryn Stanczyszyn will explain more in the news at 11:00.

    Plus, the latest from Chester Le Street, as the second day of the county championship match between Warwickshire and Durham gets under way.

    New youth coaches 10:52:

    Wolves tweets: Wolves have appointed Scott Sellars and Rob Edwards as the new u21 and u18 coaches respectively. Story and pictures to follow.

    HS2 debate heads to Lords 10:50: Birmingham Post

    The Lords' Economic Affairs Committee has invited written submissions for its inquiry at a time when the HS2 Hybrid Bill has reached the committee stage in the House of Commons

    M42 deaths 10:41:

    Two people have died in a crash on the M42 near Redditch.

    West Midlands Ambulance Service said a man and a woman who were travelling in the same car were pronounced dead at the scene after suffering serious injuries.

    The M42 remains closed northbound between junction 3 and 3a.

    James Hawkes, from the Highways Agency, says there will be a rolling road block in place shortly and warned of delays of up to two hours on surrounding routes.

    Your Black Country photos 10:34: via Facebook

    How are you marking Black Country Day? BBC Midlands Today has shared a selection of photos, from comedian Lenny Henry donning the black, white and red coloured flag to a stunning sunrise.

    Black Country Day photos

    Email or tweet us your photos and we'll feature our favourites on BBC Local Live.

    Your views 10:24:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

    New hospital announcement 10:15:

    A new £353m acute hospital is to be built in Smethwick, the Chancellor of the Exchequer announces.

    George Osborne says it will be funded by both the public and private sector as he visits Rowley Regis Hospital today.

    Black Country anthem 10:06:

    To celebrate Black Country Day, local band, Empty Can, wrote and recorded the official anthem - I Vow To Thee Black Country.

    Empty Can, perform, I Vow To Thee Black Country.

    The lead singer has almost lost his voice after performing it "a lot" of times over the last week.

    In the news 09:57: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    Germany are celebrating after winning the World Cup, with a 1-0 victory over Argentina.

    In the news at 10:00 on BBC WM, we'll hear from a German teacher at Aston University who says it's an important win for his country.

    Two killed in M42 crash 09:48: Birmingham Mail

    A man and a woman were killed in a horrific three-car pile-up which caused traffic chaos on the M42 near Birmingham.

    Bus-lane cameras reactivated 09:37: Midlands Today

    Controversial bus-lane cameras in Birmingham have been reactivated.

    Birmingham bus lane

    Thousands of drivers were issued with fines in the past year and the city council received £1.7m in revenue.

    But an independent adjudicator ruled warning signs were inadequate at three locations and fines which had been issued should not be enforced. The council says clearer signs are now in place.

    On air 09:28: Adrian Goldberg Presenter, BBC WM

    Should people off work with depression be forced to get help if they want to claim the dole?

    The government is floating the idea of making it compulsory for anyone with a psychiatric condition to seek help or risk being booted off benefits? If you've ever suffered depression would you have welcome help like that? Listen live to BBC WM.

    World Cup final 09:18: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    Did you watch the World Cup final last night? Germany beat Argentina with a goal in extra time.

    Man dancing in Rio near graffiti

    Like many, I've walked away with nothing from the office sweepstake though the pain was taken away with this amazing montage, put together by BBC Sport.

    It shows the highs and lows of the competition, with the drama of people dancing in Rio.

    Malala's appeal 09:09:

    The Birmingham schoolgirl and campaigner Malala Yousafzai has travelled to Nigeria to meet the families of more than 200 kidnapped schoolgirls.

    Pakistani activist Malala Yousafzai holds a picture of kidnapped schoolgirl Sarah Samwell with her mother Rebecca, during a visit to Abuja, Nigeria, 13 July 2014

    They were abducted by the militant Islamist group Boko Haram in April.

    Malala, now lives Birmingham, after being shot in the head by the Taliban for campaigning for girls' education in Pakistan.

    News headlines 09:00: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    The headlines at 09:00 on BBC WM:

    • There's a call for parents in the afro-caribbean community to be banned from smacking their children
    • Israel has kept up air strikes and artillery fire on the Gaza Strip as its offensive against Hamas enters a seventh day
    • The Birmingham schoolgirl and campaigner Malala Yousafzai has travelled to Nigeria to meet the families of more than 200 kidnapped schoolgirls
    Severe motorway delays 08:58:

    There are severe delays on the M42 after it was closed northbound between Junction 3 and 3a. Drivers are told delays may last for about two hours.

    There's also heavy congestion on the M6 after a six vehicle accident northbound at Corley services. Read the latest on BBC Travel News.

    'Protest for justice' 08:48: Midlands Today

    Friends and family of a man who died after he'd been detained by police will protest today against the findings of an investigation into his death.

    Kingsley Burrell

    Kingsley Burrell, 29, from Birmingham, was held under the Mental Health Act three years ago.

    Four police officers were arrested in connection with his death but the Crown Prosecution Service found insufficient evidence to bring prosecutions.

    Pollen count 08:39:

    Healthy Brum tweets: Today's #healthybrum pollen count is again moderate. #hayfever advice

    Black Country Day 08:30: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    It's Black Country Day today.

    Black Country Day flag

    A series of events are being held to mark the first ever day. How will you be marking the day? Email or tweet us your standing proud photos and comments.

    Firefighters' strike 08:23:

    West Midlands firefighters have begun an eight day strike.

    West Bromwich firefighters on a picket line while on strike

    The fire service is asking people to take extra care during the action which is planned for fixed two-hour periods every day.

    The industrial action is part of a national dispute over changes to firefighters' pensions.

    Trains delayed 08:13:

    Passengers travelling through Stafford and Rugby on the train are warned to expect delays of about 15 minutes due to over running engineering works.

    Virgin Train says the delays are expected to last until about 10:00.

    Warm sunshine 08:02:

    A fine start to the day and a good deal of warm sunshine around this morning.

    Through the afternoon, it will tend to cloud over, especially in western areas, with perhaps a little patchy rain by evening. A high of 22C (72F).

    Good morning 08:00: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    It's a beautiful start to the morning here in Birmingham.

    I'll be bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather updates for Birmingham and the Black Country today. If you want to get in touch then email



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.