Birmingham City Council 'may have overpaid contractor £19m'

Birmingham Council House MITIE repairs council-owned buildings

Related Stories

Birmingham City Council believes it has overpaid one of its major contractors by almost £19m, the BBC understands.

An internal document states accountants think outsourcing firm MITIE may have been charging as much as 25% more than allowed in its contract.

The company repairs council buildings, including schools in the south of the city.

MITIE said it does not accept the findings and all invoices have been agreed and authorised by the council.

This potential dispute relates to two contracts MITIE has held with the council - one covering repairs to council houses between 2006 and 2011, and a second ongoing contract over the maintenance of council-owned buildings, including schools, according to a leaked document seen by BBC political reporter Elizabeth Glinka.

'Loss of value'

The information came to light during an audit of some contracts started before the new Labour administration took control in last May's election.

It said that "significant issues have been identified" in relation to some of their maintenance agreements.

According to the document, accountants from Ernst and Young told the council in August last year they had found what they described as "contract leakage" in relation to the agreement with MITIE which they said had not been operating as defined leading to a "loss of value" for the council.

The council document said following more detailed investigations a "variation" - or difference between the agreed price list, called the the "schedule of rates" - and the actual amount charged by MITIE was found.

There had been a difference of 27% for the current contract and 23% for the previous one which covered between 2006 and 2011, the report said.

The document summarises that "a conclusion has been drawn from these detailed analyses that this approximate level of variation has existed from 2006 to present", which leads to the £19m figure.

The document also suggested that the authority believes it has a 12-year retrospective window in which to make a claim and the council believes it can offset overpayments in the past against future ones.

The response from the firm in the report states it does not accept the council's findings which it said are flawed, it has acted under instruction and final invoices have been approved by the council.

Start Quote

MITIE was awarded this work through a competitive tender process and we have a full and robust audit trail for all work delivered and costs charged through this contract, all of which was approved by the council. ”

End Quote MITIE

The authority must save £102m as part of it 2013-14 budget and it anticipates having a "funding gap" of £615m by 2017, £15m more than it expected in October.

In a statement, the council said it had already commissioned Ernst And Young to work with the council's procurement team to examine major contracts to test for what is called "contract leakage" whereby suppliers may be charging for work not strictly in accordance with the detailed terms of the contract.

'Not simple and obvious'

"In this exercise the review has identified that there may be differences in the method of charging for works compared with the terms of the contract.

"Where this has been identified, the council in the first instance engages with a contractor to explore these findings and seek resolution, either by clarifying matters or by seeking a financial settlement.

"Often these matters are highly technical and not simple and obvious."

A spokesman for MITIE said the firm strongly refutes the allegations saying it has a "robust audit trail" for all work delivered and costs charged.

Meetings have taken place between the parties to try to resolve the issues.

In a separate statement the firm said: "MITIE was awarded this work through a competitive tender process and we have a full and robust audit trail for all work delivered and costs charged through this contract, all of which was approved by the council.

"We have not seen any detailed information to support these false and damaging claims.

"If either BCC or Acivico (a council-owned subsidiary) felt they had a case to claim compensation, we would expect that they take this process through the appropriate channels rather than directly to the media."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country

Weather

Birmingham

20 °C 13 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Oops - wrong ground 11:18:

    West Brom goalkeeper Ben Foster tweets: Ha, some Walsall FC player turned up at our training ground this morning in a taxi, Sorry lad, wrong team!

     
  2.  
    Walsall 0 - 3 Crystal Palace 11:13:

    Dwight Gayle (left) scored a first-half hat-trick as Crystal Palace eased past Walsall and into the third round of the Capital One Cup.

    dwight gayle (left)
     
  3.  
    News at 11 10:59: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    The latest headlines from BBC WM

    • Pressure is growing on South Yorkshire's police and crime commissioner to quit following the child sex abuse scandal in Rotherham
    • Speed cameras across the West Midlands could be switched back on
    • There's been a big increase in the number of long-term migrants arriving in Britain
     
  4.  
    Watch: Inside Out trailer 10:51: Andy Akinwolere Presenter, BBC Inside Out West Midlands

    Inside Out returns on Monday night with more surprising stories from familiar places. Have a look at our new 30 second trailer - see how many places you recognise.

    Inside Out West Midlands
     
  5.  
    Boy struck by car 10:50: Express and Star

    A 10-year-old boy has been hit by a car in Pendeford. The accident happened in The Droveway, near the junction with Armstead Road, at 4.40pm yesterday.

     
  6.  
    Birmingham 0 - 3 Sunderland 10:41:

    Birmingham manager Lee Clark's reaction to the home defeat against Sunderland in the third round of the Capital One Cup.

     
  7.  
    Curfew for flat trasher 10:37: Dudley News

    A man who trashed the Dudley flat he shared with his girlfriend when their relationship hit the rocks has been given a three month curfew.

     
  8.  
    Aston Villa 0 - 1 Leyton Orient 10:29:

    Premier League Aston Villa suffered a shock exit from the Capital One Cup as Romain Vincelot's late header gave Leyton Orient a dramatic victory.

    roman vincelot
     
  9.  
    Library of Birmingham 10:17:

    More than 2.7m people have visited the Library of Birmingham in its first year, managers said.

    library of birmingham

    The £189m building, which houses one million books, was built to replace the previous Central Library, which is due to be demolished.

     
  10.  
    Murder accused 'drank 25 cans a day' 10:08: Birmingham Mail

    A man accused of stabbing his girlfriend to death at their Midland flat regularly drank more than 25 cans of lager a day, a court heard.

     
  11.  
    West Midlands snubbed by foodies 10:06: Adrian Goldberg Presenter, BBC WM

    The Good Food Guide top 50 restaurants in the country came out yesterday - and Birmingham's been snubbed!

    Even though we've got 4 Michelin starred restaurants, cities with no stars, like Manchester and Liverpool, were both on the list.

    So I want to big up the West Midlands' best restaurants this morning - if you could put one restaurant in to the Good Food Guide, which would it be and why?

    Call in on 03453 00 99 56 or text 81333 (start your message with WM).

     
  12.  
    News on the hour 09:59: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    Some 650,000 parents in the West Midlands have cut back on food in a bid to pay their rent or mortgage, according to housing charity Shelter. Hear more in the news at 10:00.

     
  13.  
    Watch: Police riot training 09:46:

    Watch this exclusive footage of riot training in action, offering an insight into the dangers faced by public order officers at West Midlands Police.

    riot police
     
  14.  
    City of Colours 09:44: Birmingham Post

    A sea of colour and artistry will descend on Digbeth next weekend for the first City of Colours festival.

     
  15.  
    Term bus pass 09:36:

    NX West Midlands tweets: Have you got your Term Plus pass sorted for back to school or college? You can sign up by direct debit til 7th Sept http://ow.ly/ALuUL

     
  16.  
    New striker 09:27:

    Walsall have responded to their slow start to the new League One season by making striker Mathieu Manset their seventh summer signing.

    mathieu manset
     
  17.  
    Top headlines
     
  18.  
    'Devoted Dad' 09:18: Birmingham Mail

    A biker killed in a horror road crash was a devoted dad who helped his baby son fight a rare form of cancer.

     
  19.  
    Park ready for winter 09:16: via Facebook

    Sandwell Valley Country park posts: In early June, we re-sowed one of our fields with a special mix, (barley, wheat, linseed and a few others) which are already starting to produce seeds.

    Field in Sandwell Valley Country Park which has been re-sewn

    Over the winter, when there is normally less food available, this field will be a really important source of food for many visiting and over wintering birds.

     
  20.  
    News on the hour 09:00: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    Police are investigating a burglary at the National Motorcycle Museum in Solihull. A range of trophies were taken from cabinets in the foyer sometime last night.

    I'll have more in the hourly news bulletin.

     
  21.  
    Watch: Revived donor liver 08:45:

    Doctors have successfully transplanted a "revived" donor liver into a patient.

    Satpal Mahal

    Surgeons at Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Birmingham, pumped warmed blood through the organ after it was transported 200 miles in an ice box.

    They said the liver - taken from a cardiac death victim - would previously have been deemed "unviable".

     
  22.  
    Chief executive's expenses 08:32:

    The £232,000-a-year chief executive of two health trusts claimed up to £30,000 in expenses for hotels and transport over the past year, it has emerged.

    The BBC has obtained records of 92 hotel stays by West Midlands and East of England ambulance services chief Anthony Marsh.

    anthony marsh wm ambulance chief exec

    The ambulance services said Mr Marsh's combined role actually saved £130,000 in public money.

     
  23.  
    Some sun 08:21:

    A fine morning with patchy cloud and some sunny spells. Showery outbreaks of rain will spread from the west this afternoon, the odd heavier burst possible, but should only last a couple of hours before clearing.

    weather
     
  24.  
    Solihull diversion 08:11:

    The A41 Solihull Bypass in Solihull entry slip road is closed southbound at the B4025 junction, because of resurfacing work. Diversion in operation - via Lode Lane and Hampton Lane to join the A41 Solihull Bypass. Expect delays.

    See BBC Travel for more local updates.

     
  25.  
    Good morning 08:00: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    Morning all, I'll be bringing you updates from Birmingham and the Black Country from now until 18:00.

    If you'd like to get in touch you can email or tweet us.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.