Birmingham dentist Joyce Trail jailed for £1.4m fraud

Dr Joyce Trail Dr Joyce Trail was convicted at Birmingham Crown Court on 31 July

Related Stories

A Birmingham dentist who defrauded the NHS out of £1.4m has been jailed for seven years.

Dr Joyce Trail, 50, of Park Drive, Little Aston, Sutton Coldfield, was convicted in July after a five-week trial at Birmingham Crown Court.

The jury heard Trail had submitted claims for treating more than 100 patients who were dead, and made duplicate claims for others.

Jailing Trail, Judge Peter Carr said she had been motivated by pure greed.

At Coventry Crown Court, Trail was sentenced to six-and-a-half years for conspiracy to defraud and a further six months for perverting the course of justice, which she had admitted before the trial.

Her daughter Nyri Natilia Sterling, 33, of Ashwood Close, Oldbury, was also jailed for two years for conspiring to defraud the NHS.

The trial was told that Sterling had worked in the administration side of the Handsworth practice and assisted her mother in committing the fraud.

Trail is thought to have made about £1.4m between April 2006 and March 2009, by making claims for dental work that she had not performed.

Trail's collection of shoes The court heard Trail's shoe collection would "make Imelda Marcos proud"

The court heard she used the money to travel the world, sometimes staying in £1,000-a-night hotels and pay for a designer shoe collection that would "make Imelda Marcos proud".

Investigators also found expensive jewellery, designer clothing and foreign currency at Trail's home.

Judge Carr was told the sum could have been used to fund 73 newly-qualified nurses for a year, 221 hip replacements, or life-saving drugs for 51 leukaemia patients.

Trail was first investigated by the NHS in 2004, when she was found to have over-claimed and was ordered to pay back more than £320,000.

Judge Carr told her: "It is my view that, having been ordered to pay back such a large sum, and not wishing to forgo the lifestyle to which you by then had become accustomed, you deliberately set out to ensure that you did not.

"You knew, as a result of that investigation, exactly what was required to try and ensure that your fraud was not discovered."

Condemning the dentist's conduct as calculated, blatant and persistent dishonesty, the judge said he was satisfied that although she had recruited others into the fraud, she was its "organiser and leading light".

Analysis

Joyce Trail had a contract that was three or four times greater than other NHS dental practices of a similar size.

Although she officially claimed about 25% of the care was for visits to nursing homes - the reality was that nearly all her claims were bogus.

She claimed that virtually every patient real or dead needed a new set of dentures every three months. She could then charge the NHS the maximum amount each time.

Some of these homes were as far afield as Nottingham and Manchester.

After Joyce Trail was arrested for the £1.4m fraud in 2009, the NHS continued to pay her practice a further £1m until she was finally convicted in July 2012.

Birmingham and Solihull NHS Cluster said it had continued to pay Trail until the conviction, rather than risk facing "an enormous compensation claim".

It said: "Dr Trail exploited this and spent huge amounts on legal and regulatory support challenging the PCT unsuccessfully at the NHS Litigation Authority and Judicial Review.

"She and her advisers made every effort to thwart the PCT from effectively managing her contract whenever possible."

It added: "With the benefit of hindsight we are looking back to see whether more could have been done and earlier."

The trial followed an investigation by NHS Protect, which combats fraud within the health service.

Speaking after the hearing, the organisation said Trail had forged more than 28,000 documents to support her "bogus claims".

More than 150 claims, costing over £26,500, were for fitting dentures or taking impressions for people who were dead at the time she claimed to have started treatment.

NHS Protect added: "Even after Trail's assets had been frozen, she continued to act dishonestly.

"She used a bank account in another person's name and paid money from the dental practice into this bank account.

"She also rented a house out, and asked the tenant to pay in cash so there would be no paper trail of this additional income."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Birmingham & Black Country

Weather

Birmingham

20 °C 14 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    MP: 'Appalling' people do these things 11:05: Caroline Gall BBC News

    I've been in touch with Richard Burden, MP for Northfield, who said he has "real sadness with what's happened here today".

    Northfield Manor House

    He added: "It's important now that we retain the building and all the initial signs are that may be possible.

    "It's appalling that people should do this kind of things. There could have been people inside. It could have been much more serious."

     
  2.  
    News on the hour 11:00: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    The former home of the Cadbury family in Birmingham has been destroyed in an arson attack.

    Northfield Manor - an empty four storey property off Bristol Road South in Northfield - was gutted by a fire last night and much of it has now collapsed. Listen Live

     
  3.  
    Your views 10:53: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service which we write from the BBC at the Mailbox in Birmingham.

     
  4.  
    'Happy memories' of Northfield 10:41:

    Dawn Smith, a former student resident at Northfield Manor, got in touch to express her sadness about last night's fire.

    She wrote: "I have many happy memories from my time there, and the fact that it was a hall of residence with history and character, rather than just a featureless warren of rooms really added to the experience."

     
  5.  
    Hard call to make 10:34: Richie Anderson BBC WM reporter

    I was working on the Breakfast Show for BBC WM today and was asked to phone Justin Cadbury, great-great grandson of the found of Cadburys. His family used to own Northfield Manor which burned down last night.

    He hadn't heard the news so I had to explain. He was instantly shocked and devastated.

     
  6.  
    Video: Fire takes hold 10:23:

    Dramatic footage showing Northfield Manor House on fire last night can be seen here.

    Northfield Manor House

    The flames and smoke could be seen from the Lickey Hills, about three miles (5km) away.

     
  7.  
    'Slight' hope for Manor House 10:13: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    In the last few minutes one of the fire crew at Northfield Manor has told me the structural engineers have said there's a "slight" possibility they may be able to save some of the building.

    The other good news is they were able to contain the fire and stopped it spreading to neighbouring buildings.

     
  8.  
    Manor fire: Your reaction 10:05: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    You've been getting in touch about the fire which has destroyed Northfield Manor House, the former home of the Cadbury family in Birmingham.

    Judy Stambouly says it was such a shame if the building has to be demolished. "Such a beautiful building and a great part of Birmingham history."

    Jack The Biscuit writes on Twitter that the "beautiful building should never have been left empty".

     
  9.  
    News on the hour 09:57: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    Investigations are under way after it's emerged a huge fire which destroyed the historic Northfield Manor in Birmingham was caused by arson.

    One hundred firefighters tackled the blaze last night. Listen Live

     
  10.  
    Manor fire: Plans to redevelop 09:48: B31 Voices

    has collated all their posts about Northfield Manor, which was destroyed by fire last night. There had been plans for the site to be redeveloped.

    B31 screen grab
     
  11.  
    Cadburys donated house 09:31:

    Local historian Chris Upton has been telling BBC WM about the history of Northfield Manor, which the Cadbury family bought in the 19th Century.

    northfield manor

    "[The property] goes back to the 1700s, though of course it has been rebuilt a number of times. Most of the building that went up last night was Victorian."

     
  12.  
    Youths punched girl in face 09:22: Birmingham Mail

    Three young thugs spat at a teenage girl and punched her in the face in an unprovoked attack when she shunned their advances after they followed her off a bus in a busy part of Birmingham.

     
  13.  
    Watch: Northfield Manor fire 09:10: Midlands Today

    We've posted some video of last night's fire at Northfield Manor on our Facebook page.

    fire at northfield manor
     
  14.  
    Another fire 24 hours before 09:03: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    I've been told there was a smaller fire, which is also being treated as arson, at Northfield Manor 24 hours before the blaze that destroyed the building.

     
  15.  
    News on the hour 08:55: Jay Vydelingum Journalist, BBC WM

    The former home of the Cadbury family in Birmingham has been destroyed in an arson attack.

    Northfield Manor, an empty four storey property off Bristol Road South in Northfield, was gutted by a fire last night and much of it has now collapsed. Listen live

     
  16.  
    Making the building safe 08:42: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    Firefighters say contractors will be on site today and that the priority will be to make the building as structurally safe as possible.

     
  17.  
    Top headlines
     
  18.  
    Cadbury family 'shocked' 08:28:

    Justin Cadbury, the great-great grandson of the founder of Cadbury's, has told BBC WM he is "deeply shocked" at the news of the fire that has destroyed Northfield Manor.

    Although he never lived in the house - the family sold it the year he was born - he said: "It's memories that make the soul of a house and bring real sadness and I feel very sorry for them."

     
  19.  
    Northfield road closure 08:24:

    Manor House Drive in Northfield is closed at the A38 Bristol Road South junction because of the fire at Northfield Manor. Police are directing traffic.

    See BBC Travel News for more information.

     
  20.  
    Part of building completely gutted 08:17: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    Northfield Manor was built in 1890 by the Cadbury family. It's now owned by the University of Birmingham but we've learned that because of the extent of the fire damage it will have to be demolished.

    Northfield Manor

    Several firefighters are still working on the roof and the middle of the building has been completely gutted.

     
  21.  
    Home to be demolished 08:08: Steve Hermon Journalist, BBC WM

    I'm in Northfield at the site of the fire at the former Cadbury family home.

    We've just learned that because of the extent of the damage it will have to be demolished.

     
  22.  
    Northfield Manor House fire 08:03:

    The former home of the Cadbury family in Birmingham has been destroyed in an arson attack, the fire service says.

    Manor House Cadbury home fire July 30 2014 Birmingham

    At its height up to 100 firefighters were tackling the blaze at Northfield Manor House from about 20:00 on Wednesday.

     
  23.  
    Thunder possible 08:02:

    After a bright start, some showery rain, perhaps heavy and thundery, is possible.

    weather

    Becoming brighter from the northwest later, with sunny spells and isolated showers. Feeling pleasantly warm in sunnier intervals.

     
  24.  
    Good morning 08:00: Ed Barlow BBC Local Live

    I'll be bringing you the latest news, sport, weather and travel throughout the day for Birmingham and the Black Country.

    You can get in touch by emailing locallive@bbc.co.uk.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.