Builder John Jenkins 'exploited' widow, court told

John Jenkins John Jenkins depicted himself as a 'Good Samaritan', the court heard

A builder "manipulated and exploited" a vulnerable and lonely widow, charging more than £500,000 for work that should have cost £60,000, a court heard.

John Jenkins, 70, "lined his pockets" with Josephine Stubbings' savings, St Albans Crown Court was told.

Mr Jenkins, of Aylesbury, Bucks, spent tens of thousands of pounds of her money on foreign holidays and shopping trips, the jury heard.

He denies theft of £532,695 and fraud by false representation.

The jury heard Mrs Stubbings, 67, was befriended by the builder.

Prosecutor Michael Speak told the jury the widow was vulnerable, eccentric and likeable, but that she also had underlying mental health issues.

"She is trusting in ways she should not be and is easily persuaded to do things which none of you would do," he said.

Start Quote

Mr Jenkins realised this was a golden opportunity to make money dishonestly”

End Quote Michael Speak Prosecutor

Mr Jenkins had worked as a general builder, but by 2008 had either stopped working, had run out of work or was semi-retired.

Mrs Stubbings had seen his "defunct" advert in the Yellow Pages and contacted him to carry out a job at her modest home in Berkhamsted, Hertfordshire.

She lived a frugal existence, but, through investments made by herself and her late husband, had managed to "salt away" well over £500,000, the prosecutor said.

"Mr Jenkins realised this was a golden opportunity to make money dishonestly," he added.

'Buy a Jaguar'

He claims Mr Jenkins invented "preposterous" charges for his work.

"She trusted him and did not have a clear grasp of the situation. Sadly, she thought he was a friend - in reality, he was anything but," said Mr Speak.

Mr Jenkins "relentlessly" spent her money, he said, once taking her to a car dealership where he tried to persuade her to buy him a Jaguar.

He failed, but she did buy him a Peugeot.

The jury was told Mrs Stubbings' losses were revealed in November 2011 after she asked to borrow money for food from a neighbour.

Start Quote

Although he swindled me, I don't bear him any animosity”

End Quote Josephine Stubbs Alleged victim

When Mr Jenkins was first interviewed, he said Mrs Stubbings' house was in an appalling state of repair when he went there.

'He swindled me'

He said he had got Mrs Stubbings out of her shell and cheered her up. "He depicted himself as the Good Samaritan," said Mr Speak.

When police examined six bank accounts belonging to Mr Jenkins, they found she had paid him a total of £530,000.

A surveyor calculated the value of the work at no more than £60,000.

In pre-recorded video evidence, Mrs Stubbings said: "Although he swindled me, I don't bear him any animosity. He swindled me out of a lot of money. He has taken a lot of money."

She said she was given no invoices or receipts for the work, and thought she had paid him about £150,000.

Mr Jenkins denies theft and fraud by false representation between 1 April 2008 and 31 December 2011.

The case continues.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Beds, Herts & Bucks



Min. Night 5 °C


Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.