UKIP: Can Yorkshire be a political springboard?

UKIP celebrates in Rotherham UKIP took 10 seats in Rotherham in what has always been a traditional Labour stronghold

UKIPs success in Labour's Yorkshire backyard shows the party has now permanently changed the face of politics as we know it.

Who says so?

Well, Nigel Farage says so.

He says it often and in an increasingly louder voice.

But a more reflective look at the results shows that his prediction is far from a done deal with the electorate.

Earthquake or tremor?

Take the local council elections.

Just before the polls Labour had a majority in six of the big district authorities across South and West Yorkshire.

So how much of that power has Labour lost thanks to the UKIP earthquake?

In fact Labour now has majorities in seven of those councils- and runs the other two as the biggest party.

Professor Colin Mellors of the University of York is the down-to-earth political number cruncher who has been keeping a close watch on developments in Yorkshire for even longer than me.

He says UKIP success in now having eight councillors in Rotherham and a handful more across Sheffield, Doncaster, Wakefield and Bradford is the result of very careful strategic planning by the party.

"It is interesting that if you look at the councils, the wards where UKIP do well is of a particular type - white, urban, working class," he told me. "This is equally true of West and South Yorkshire

"The moral is simple and one that was learned by the Lib Dems; targeting is far better than blanket coverage, especially if their vote declines."

UKIP Yorkshire MPs

Within two weeks of the local and Euro polls UKIP's surge was tested at a by-election in the Tory stronghold of Newark. In the event the Tory majority was halved but they retained the seat. Labour lost some of the share of the vote it had in 2010 to come in third.

Colin Mellors' number crunching following the elections in Yorkshire predicts UKIP could take three Yorkshire seats at the General Election if the electorate vote in the same pattern again.

Each of those constituencies - Rother Valley; Rotherham itself and just up the road the Penistone and Stockbridge - is held by Labour and also has a solid core of white working class adults.

There is, of course, a major factor which these latest polls do not take into account.

Two out of every three voters across Yorkshire and the Humber did not bother to turn out for either the European or local elections.

At next year's General Election at least double that number are expected to vote.

As a consequence UKIP needs to at least double its statistical success if it really is to send a single South Yorkshire MP to Westminster.

Bloom's bloomers

There is another factor that UKIP will have to overcome if it is in with a chance.

In Yorkshire it had to "part company" with its previous sole MEP Godfrey Bloom in the run-up to these latest elections. The high-profile scourge of political correctness had simply become too much of a loose cannon.

In fact Mr Bloom was far from the only casualty of self-inflicted damage by the crop of 13 UKIP MEPs who won their seats in 2009.

Conservative campaigners in particular used to quote with glee that by the end of their term of office a majority of them had either jumped ship or been sacked by the party for varying levels of misdemeanour.

In the months before the 2015 General Election the new generation of UKIP political winners now have to prove that they can effectively represent the electorate better than the mainstream parties.

The clock is ticking.

Len Tingle Article written by Len Tingle Len Tingle Political editor, Yorkshire

Leon Brittan and the miners who would never forgive him

Three decades on, miners have not forgotten how Leon Brittan used the police to stop the pickets.

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 38.

    33. vin
    "Labour no longer represents the working man"


    Labour never has represented people who do not share its values, nor should it.

    If working class people become racist or otherwise inegalitarian, self-centred rather than international, then they've abandoned core values of the labour movement so can't really expect any more.

  • rate this

    Comment number 37.

    Well done to the people of Dinnington for voting UKIP. In nearby Woodsetts and Anston parish the Labour incumbant scraped through with a majority of only 31. Similarly in the other Rotherham wards. Labour could well have had a wipe out. Labour do not seem to represent working people any more - but they don't mind taking the yearly £13.5k allowance (not expenses - it's paid to them no questions).

  • rate this

    Comment number 36.

    Could we have a realistic piece of journalism on the mechanism and steps involved in leaving the EU?
    Of the news media the BBC does give us a fact finding insight to the EU. Unlike the newspapers (which have always been anti Europe) give a very narrow view.

  • rate this

    Comment number 35.

    My contacts are scientific and industrial customers in Tsukuba and Tokyo mostly. The key may be your phrase "*historically* leading the world". If you put before them a machine with great specs, its tough to even get a hearing. I suspect both our experiences are true - if perceived as in decline they perceive also that we need a "prop" and can't understand why we would leave.

  • rate this

    Comment number 34.

    23. Peter
    "When I go to Japan...assume the UK couldn't possibly have the best technology..."
    I live in Japan and everybody I've talked to about the EU has the completely opposite view. They see Britain not only in it's historical `leading the world` position but as a leader in Europe. They can't understand why we'd want to leave as our influence through the EU is global in politics and trade.

  • rate this

    Comment number 33.

    Labour no longer represents the working man.
    It now represents immigrients and asyslum seekers.

  • rate this

    Comment number 32.

    30. KardiffKid
    "Nigel Farage answers yes/no questions. How refreshing!"

    He's free to say whatever he likes, because he knows he will NEVER be burdened with the reality of having to try and deliver whatever he proposes. So "yes" or "no" are literally no problem for him. He doesn't even have to explain himself in the EU parliament, nor present a cogent argument for anything, more's the pity.

  • rate this

    Comment number 31.

    My impression is that other countries with a similar outlook (e.g. Canada, Australia, New Zealand etc) have ended up with environmental regulations mostly equivalent to ours. Cleaning up the Tyne (marvellous though this has been) can hardly then be uniquely thanks to the EU (or common market as they sold it to us).

    I'm sure you've researched UKIP/asbestos (though it sounds apocryphal).

  • rate this

    Comment number 30.

    1997 - I voted Bliar - shame on me. That worm spoke on Iraq today - if I were him I'd shut my mouth and keep taking the pension.
    Labour will never again represent the worker, since all nationalised industries have been privatised. Time the "Always vote Labour" woke up.

    Nigel Farage answers yes/no questions. How refreshing! He sure has made the FibfLabCon sit up.
    UKIP time is coming

  • rate this

    Comment number 29.

    28: why are they the very regulations from which Cameron seeks to negotiate a release then?

    I remember the Tyne, Thames and Trent in the 1960s, and our coastal waters too. Disgusting. Not to mention the appalling carnage in our industries along with disease.

    Ukip, incidentally, would have asbestos classed as non-hazardous.

  • rate this

    Comment number 28.

    27. "But the disastrous state of our environment, health and safety at work, and much else pre-EU .."

    Hmmm.. for the time Britain - and come to think of it Germany - led the world in H&S legislation way before the EU existed. Clean air acts set us well on the way to environmental legislation in the 1950s, and its very doubtful indeed that things would have been much different now without the EU.

  • rate this

    Comment number 27.

    24. DevilsAdvocate
    " if we get out of the EU we can start to Govern ourselves"


    But the disastrous state of our environment, health and safety at work, and much else pre-EU shows what happens when we do that, in a race to the bottom against the rest of the world.

    Only the EU can do these things, that national parties' vested interest donors and backers otherwise prevent.

  • rate this

    Comment number 26.

    Could we have a realistic piece of journalism on the mechanism and steps involved in leaving the EU? I feel it is the BBC's role - in part - to help prepare the UK for this. You can help us BBC - look to the future.

  • rate this

    Comment number 25.

    23. Peter

    well said, and just as I was saying it too! The history of Europe is one of domination, ONLY the English have never desired European hegemony, (except when ruled by French (Norman) kings) the European wars we fought in were ALL to keep one or other of Germany, France, Low Countries, Portugal, Spain, Belgium, Poland & US! from being conquered by Spain, France, Germany etc.

  • rate this

    Comment number 24.

    . This is a colleague announcement

    Has any Ukip voter got any GOOD news for anyone?
    Yes, if we get out of the EU we can start to Govern ourselves, and get over this attitude that the UK is so puerile it is incapable of surviving without the EU. It will also mean we can control our own fishing grounds, Agriculture, Laws and a myriad of other things that any Mature Democracy should control.

  • rate this

    Comment number 23.

    I've worked in tech exports for 17 years. When I go to Japan or China, folk assume the UK couldn't possibly have the best technology in any field. We don't govern ourselves, have given up sovereignty, which (for Chinese or Japanese that would NEVER do so) must indicate some weakness or lack of capability. They see an ex-country. The elimination of this alone,I feel, would be worth billions to us.

  • rate this

    Comment number 22.

    Has any Ukip voter got any GOOD news for anyone? You know, if we come out of the EU we'll never get another cloudy vinegary pint, that sort of thing? Or is it all about how awful it will be for people they hate, such as teachers, public health inspectors, pollution monitors, and other public sector workers?

  • rate this

    Comment number 21.

    Every so often some wiseacre spots that there's a crowd of discontented, gullible people, and starts a new religion for them, promising to make them happy. We've had the Moonies, Scientologists, etc. Now we have Ukip. They all have their mumbo-jumbo, the credulous Faithful swallow everything the Great One says, and they have their mantras that they repeat like Hail Marys "Still voting Ukip" etc.

  • rate this

    Comment number 20.

    UKIP certainly have made an impact, the poo pooing of their success by the BBC and some of their political journalists is a clear indication that their paymasters are running scared.

    Well done UKIP count me in I am a convert.

  • rate this

    Comment number 19.

    " In the months before the 2015 General Election the new generation of UKIP political winners now have to prove that they can effectively represent the electorate better than the mainstream parties. " - Not much of a challenge there, then!


Page 1 of 2



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.