Jeff Astle: Head injury footballer's case tip of the iceberg?

Ally MacLeod Ally MacLeod died, aged 72, in 2004 after suffering with Alzheimer's disease for 10 years

Related Stories

It is 12 years since an inquest into the death of England and West Bromwich Albion footballer Jeff Astle ruled he died from brain trauma caused by heading heavy leather footballs.

After the FA failed to publish promised research into the condition, the Astle family renewed calls for a study to be done via its Justice for Jeff campaign.

The campaign has prompted other families of ex-players to come forward, claiming Astle's case could be the "tip of the iceberg".

Among them is physiotherapist, Andrew MacLeod, whose father Ally managed Scotland at the 1978 World Cup in Argentina.

He believes his dad developed Alzheimer's after repeatedly heading a ball during a 16-year playing career with teams including Hibernian and Blackburn Rovers.

He died in 2004, aged 72, after suffering with the disease for almost 10 years.

"It started as memory loss and forgetfulness," Mr Macleod said. "He would forget where my house was or he would ask to go and visit his mother in Glasgow who had died 23 years before.

"I was keen to see the research by the FA published because if there is evidence that repetitive heading causes brain injuries then it does have consequences even for the modern day player."

Justice for Jeff Astle campaign West Bromwich Albion fans held protests at the teams games against Cardiff City and Hull City

Richard Wickson, the chairman of Reading Football Club's former players' association, believes the Astle case is "the tip of the iceberg".

"We're hearing a lot of disturbing stories from organisations like ours around the country and it seems that these illnesses are affecting players from a certain era, the 50s and 60s," he said.

"Head a medicine ball"

Duncan Forbes

Duncan Forbes, 72, played more than 500 games for Norwich City and Colchester in a 16-year career starting in 1961.

He was admitted to a dementia care home in October.

His wife, Janette, believes his condition, which started when he was 64, was caused by heading footballs.

She said: "Duncan played the game since he was a little boy and with being centre back he was always heading balls out, which were a lot heavier than nowadays.

"He once told me as part of his training he used to head a medicine ball, with the idea that he could then head a normal football much further.

"I know of several players that haven't come out to say they've got dementia because there's a stigma attached to it but I think if clubs investigated it and looked at ex-players, we would find a lot more."

"I think the fear of having to pay out compensation is the only thing holding back the authorities from fully researching it.

"But the families I have spoken to are not interested in money they just want to make sure young players don't suffer."

In a letter to Astle's widow, Laraine, the chairman of the FA, Greg Dyke, said a commission had been set up to investigate head injuries, which includes representatives from the FA, the Professional Footballers' Association (PFA) and the Premier League.

A spokesman for the FA said "The football commission on head injury... are working towards increasing awareness at all levels of the game of football."

Dr Michael Lipton is currently carrying out a study with adult amateur footballers in the US investigating how heading impacts on the brain.

His initial findings suggested heading a ball more than a 1,000 times a year could cause traumatic brain injury.

"Those people were also more likely to perform worse in cognitive tests especially memory and, less so, processing speed and attention," he said.

"There is clear data that traumatic brain injury increases the risk of Alzheimer's and dementia maybe as much as three fold."

Jeff Astle celebrating a goal Jeff Astle scored the winning goal in West Brom's 1-0 victory over Everton in the 1968 FA Cup final

However, scientific opinion on the issue is divided.

Dr Andrew Rutherford, of Keele University, has been researching possible brain damage caused by heading for more than 10 years. He said there was no definite evidence to link it to dementia.

"There is a danger that when somebody who happens to have been a footballer suffers from dementia, it becomes highlighted as a problem with football when it could be any number of causes just as it is in a person who never played the game," he said.

"With these individual cases it can appear that a large number of ex-players are suffering from dementia.

"That may be the case, but it could also just be five or six footballers in the whole of the country that suffer from that particular problem."

More on This Story

Related Stories

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More England stories



Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.