Mark Duggan inquest: Family fury at lawful killing decision

Mark Duggan's aunt Carole, speaking outside court: "He was executed"

Mark Duggan's family have said they will fight for justice after an inquest jury concluded by a majority of 8 to 2 that he was lawfully killed by police.

Mr Duggan was shot dead by armed officers in August 2011 in Tottenham, sparking riots across England.

Following the inquest at the Royal Courts of Justice, his aunt Carole Duggan said he had been "executed".

Metropolitan Police Commissioner Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe has asked for a meeting with local community leaders.

There were angry scenes outside the court, with supporters of Mr Duggan's family chanting "murderers" at Assistant Commissioner Mark Rowley as he read a statement.

'Lethal force'

Jurors concluded Mr Duggan did not have a gun when he was shot by officers who surrounded a minicab he was travelling in.

But the jury said it was more likely than not that he had thrown a gun on to some nearby grass just before he was killed. The weapon was found about 20ft (6m) away from the scene.

Assistant Commissioner Mark Rowley was met with a barrage of chants

The panel of seven women and three men was asked to answer five questions:

  • In the period between midday on 3 August 2011 and when state amber was called at 6.00 pm on 4 August 2011, did the Metropolitan Police Service and the Serious Organised Crime Agency do the best they realistically could have done to gather and react to intelligence about the possibility of Mr Duggan collecting a gun from Mr Hutchinson-Foster? The jury said a unanimous no.
  • Was the stop conducted in a location and in a way which minimised, to the greatest extent possible, recourse to lethal force? Unanimous yes.
  • Did Mr Duggan have the gun with him in the taxi immediately before the stop? Unanimous yes
  • How did the gun get to the grass area where it was later found? A majority of 9 to 1 said it was thrown.
  • When Mr Duggan received a fatal shot, did he have the gun in his hand? A majority of 8 to 2 said no, he did not have a gun in his hand.

Following the verdict his mother, Pamela Duggan, was led out of the court in tears, while Mr Duggan's brother was seen screaming and shouting.

Mark Duggan's mother Pamela (left) and aunt Carole outside court Mr Duggan's family said he was "executed"

BBC News home affairs correspondent Dominic Casciani tweeted: "I don't think I have ever heard of a jury, performing their civic duty, being abused in court by members of the public."

Following the conclusion to the inquest, an Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) spokesperson said: "We note the inquest jury's determination and findings and we are considering them as a matter of urgency in relation to our ongoing investigation."

'No justice, no peace'

Outside court, his aunt Carole Duggan said: "The majority of people in this country know that Mark was executed.

"We're going to fight until we have no breath in our body for justice for Mark, for his children, and for all of those (unclear) with deaths in custody that have had nothing.

Sir Bernard Hogan Howe: "We need to do more to build trust"

"We are not giving up. No justice, no peace!"

But Met Police Commissioner Mr Hogan-Howe said: "I welcome the verdict of a jury that our officers acted lawfully when they confronted an armed criminal who they believed posed a threat to them and to the public.

"The death of Mark Duggan in 2011 was a tragedy for his family and led to a significant reduction in trust between London's black communities and the Metropolitan Police.

"I know that we have much work to do with black Londoners to build trust and confidence in the Metropolitan Police.

"I have asked some of the capital's political representatives, and local community leaders from Tottenham, to meet me tomorrow [Thursday] to discuss how the Metropolitan Police can build better relationships for the future."

'Shot on sight'

The Duggan's family lawyer Marcia Willis Stewart said "We can't believe this was the outcome. He had no gun in his hand, yet he was shot, he was murdered.

"To us, that is unlawful killing."

In a statement later, Ms Stewart said: "The jury has found that Mark Duggan was unarmed at the point at which he was shot.

"We cannot countenance a situation in which an unarmed citizen is shot on sight.

"The jury found that there were failings in the way the police conducted the gathering and actioning of evidence. Had they done their job properly, this fatal shooting could have been avoided.

She added the family would seek an urgent meeting with the IPCC, their MP David Lammy, and MP Keith Vaz, in order to ensure the IPCC "carry a vigorous review".

Deborah Coles, from the charity Inquest, said Mr Duggan's family were considering whether to apply for the decision to be judicially reviewed.

Assistant Commissioner Mark Rowley Assistant Commissioner Mark Rowley attempted to read a statement outside court

Outside court, Assistant Commissioner Rowley attempted to read a statement which said the force had sympathy with Mr Duggan's family.

"No officer sets out at the start of the day to run an operation that results in someone dying," he said.

"We send out well-trained, professional armed officers thousands of times a year to combat this threat [of gun violence], only firing shots once or twice. These careful tactics have significantly reduced gun crime."

He added: "We know the trust is not shared by everyone. I will be offering to meet Mark Duggan's family to express our sorrow."

Tottenham MP David Lammy said the IPCC investigation had questions to answer, in particular what happened days before the shooting.

He said: "The Duggan family's sorrow and anger was palpable in court this afternoon and it is a feeling that will inevitably be reflected in the wider community.

"Further clarification on the events surrounding Mark Duggan's shooting is essential to enable the relationship between the community and the police to move forward.

"There are aspects of this verdict that are somewhat perplexing and seemingly contradictory to those of who us who have carefully followed the proceedings over the last few months."

Tottenham 'calm'

A Home Office spokeswoman said it was "inappropriate to comment" while the IPCC was still carrying out its investigation.

BBC News correspondent Tom Symonds, who is in Tottenham, said the area was "very calm but has a high police presence".

The Met said there was an operation in place across London this evening where they have the ability to deploy extra officers if needed.

After Mr Duggan was shot, rioting spread across London and other parts of England in what became some of the worst disturbances in decades.

The inquest began in September. Before the jurors retired for what was seven days of deliberation, Judge Keith Cutler told them to reach their decisions "on the evidence and the evidence alone".

The coroner thanked the jury and told them they will be excused from future jury service for life if they want.

More on This Story

BBC London

Weather

London

Min. Night 13 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    18:00: Beth Rose BBC News Online

    That's all for Local Live today. I'll be back with the latest news, sport, travel and weather for London tomorrow from 08:00. Have a good evening.

     
  2.  
    Travel 17:57:

    The A11 Whitechapel High Street in Whitechapel is closed and there is queuing traffic eastbound at the A13 Commercial Road junction, because of a police incident. Diversions are in place for bus routes 25 67 115 135 205 254.

    And the A5203 Caledonian Road in Kings Cross is closed in both directions between the All Saints Street junction and the Wharfdale Road junction, because of a burst water main.

     
  3.  
    Rugby star sentenced for assault 17:55:

    Welsh international rugby star Ian Gough has been ordered to pay £2,130 in fines and costs for assaulting his beauty queen ex-girlfriend.

    Ian Gough and Sophia Cahill

    Croydon Magistrates' Court heard Gough, 37, grabbed and pushed former the Miss Wales against his van as he dropped their two-year-old son Gabriel home. Miss Cahill said the assault exacerbated injuries she had sustained in an earlier car crash.

     
  4.  
    On air 17:44: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On drive time with Eddie Nestor. Student Mary Brandon who was punched at the Notting Hill Carnival after she told a man to stop groping her speaks about the indent.

    Pictures before and after the attack on Mary Brandon

    You can listen live on BBC London 94.9 and contact the team on 020 7224 2000.

     
  5.  
    BBC London News 17:34: BBC London News TV

    On the programme at 18:30 on BBC One: The mother of a 24-year-old who was stabbed through the heart in a street mugging pays tribute to her son on the day four teenagers are convicted of his killing.

    Dean Mayley Dean Mayley

    And student Mary Brandon tells BBC London about being punched at the Notting Hill Carnival after asking a man to stop groping her.

     
  6.  
    Open House London 17:15:

    London Victoria tweets: We're taking part in this years @openhouselondon & offering free guided tours of our roof! Sign up here #vicopenhouse

     
  7.  
    Seven Seas swimmer en route 17:03:

    Lewis Pugh, the UN Patron of the Oceans is en route to London in the final leg of his Seven Seas Campaign to encourage governments to set aside 10% of the world's oceans for protection.

    Lewis Pugh in Monaco Lewis Pugh in Monaco

    Over the past four weeks he has completed swims in the Mediterranean, Adriatic, Aegean, Black, Red, Arabian and North Sea. Today he has started his final leg from South End to Gravesend, before finishing at the Thames Barrier tomorrow after an overnight stop.

     
  8.  
    News on the hour 16:57: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The top headline in the 17:00 news bulletin: A 17-year-old boy has been found guilty of the murder of a 24-year-old man with the mental age of nine in West London. Three other teenagers were convicted of manslaughter.

     
  9.  
    Closing 'due to too many customers' 16:51:

    A branch of Barclays Bank in Kilburn will close next month because it's too popular and cannot give its customers the desired level of service, the Kilburn Times reports.

     
  10.  
    Above ground Tube map 16:34:

    London Underground has launched an illustrated map of things to see and do above the Victoria line.

    Above ground map

    The illustration forms part of the Without Leaving London campaign to help Londoners and visitors get more out of the capital within easy reach of the transport network.

     
  11.  
    Feedback 16:24:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

     
  12.  
    Fulham sign Munich goalkeeper 16:21:

    Fulham have signed 1860 Munich goalkeeper Gabor Kiraly for an undisclosed fee.

    Gabor Kiraly

    The 38-year-old Hungarian international made 111 appearances for Crystal Palace between 2004 and 2007 and subsequently spent two years at Burnley before joining 1860 Munich in 2009. He has also played for the German Bundesliga 2 side.

     
  13.  
    News on the hour 16:01:

    The top headline at 16:00: A 17-year-old boy has been found guilty of murdering a man during a mugging in west London. Dean Mayley, who was 24 but whose brain disorder meant he had a mental age of nine, was stabbed through the heart when he refused to hand over his mobile phone in Greenford in February.

     
  14.  
    Things to do 15:53:

    The Londonist tweets: Romans Vs Boudicca, and the climax to Festival of Love feature in this weekend's things to do

     
  15.  
    Video: Notting Hill punch woman talks 15:34:

    A student who was punched in the face at the Notting Hill Carnival for telling a man not to grope her says she would do the same again.

    Pictures before and after the attack on Mary Brandon

    Speaking to BBC London, Mary Brandon said although she was having trouble sleeping she refused to let it get the better of her. The Met Police said it was reviewing CCTV footage of the carnival.

     
  16.  
    Right to Buy profit 'not used' 15:22:

    Haringey Council has sold 250 council homes under the Right to Buy scheme, but built no new homes with the money received from the sales, the Haringey Independent reports.

    Across London, 4,912 council homes have been sold under Right to Buy over the last two years, with building work starting on 667 replacement homes in the same period.

     
  17.  
    Spurs' Fredericks loaned to Middlesbrough 15:08:

    Tottenham full-back Ryan Fredericks has joined Championship side Middlesbrough on a season-long loan.

    Ryan Fredericks

    The 21-year-old, who has made four first-team appearances for Spurs, played 14 matches for Millwall on loan in the second tier last season.

     
  18.  
    Have your say 14:46:

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  19.  
    Sherlock's double 14:30:

    Benedict Cumberbatch stands next to his waxwork which is taking shape at Madame Tussauds.

    Benedict Cumberbatch and wax work

    The model, which has so far gone through two sessions of sculpting, will be unveiled at the Baker Street attraction later this year.

     
  20.  
    Private landlords 'to pay for licensing' 14:10:

    Private landlords in Brent will be forced to pay £350 to subscribe to a compulsory five-year licensing scheme after council chiefs gave the go-ahead to the proposals.

    The plans are aimed at clamping down on rogue landlords who allow their tenants to live in insanitary and overcrowded conditions, according to the Brent and Kilburn Times.

     
  21.  
    News on the hour 13:58: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    In the news bulletin at 14:00: The mother of 24-year-old Dean Mayley pays tribute to her son after a 17-year-old boy is convicted of murdering him and three others are found guilty of manslaughter and attempted robbery.

    Clockwise: Jamal Jones, Michael Mensah, Miguel Leiba and Ryan Beresford Clockwise: Jamal Jones, Michael Mensah, Miguel Leiba and Ryan Beresford were all found guilty of their part in Dean Mayley's death
     
  22.  
    Shotgun search 13:39:

    Scotland Yard has carried out a ground and air search around Braybrook Street near Wormwood Scrubs in Hammersmith after reports of someone with a shotgun. MPS helicopters tweeted: 2 persons now stopped by Officers.......We are now leaving.

     
  23.  
    BBC London News 13:14: Katharine Carpenter Reporter and presenter

    Join us at 13:30 on BBC One when we'll be live at the Old Bailey where a 17-year-old has been found guilty of murdering a man with the mental age of nine in West London.

    We'll also have more on BBC London's exclusive report into local councils' anti terrorism funding.

     
  24.  
    News on the hour 13:00: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On the news bulletin at 13:00: A 17-year-old boy has been found guilty of murdering a man during a mugging in west London and three other teenagers are convicted of manslaughter and attempted robbery.

     
  25.  
    Half-baked exit 12:49: Nuala McCann BBC News

    Northern Ireland's man in the Great British Bake Off, Iain Watters, has admitted losing his cool on Wednesday after his ice cream sank into a wet gloop in the heat.

    Iain Watters

    Iain, who lives in London, was knocked out of the baking competition after throwing his attempt at a baked alaska in the bin and storming out the tent.

     
  26.  
    Invictus Games to hold service 12:41:

    A special service will take place at London's inaugural Invictus Games for injured servicemen to remember those who have been killed or injured in conflict.

    Prince Harry playing sitting volleyball Prine Harry at the launch of the Invictus Games

    The multi-faith service will take place on 11 September at London's Lee Valley Athletics Centre, which hosts the track and field events that afternoon.

     
  27.  
    Tube workers 'need to talk' 12:33:

    RMT Union members working on the Tube will no longer work overtime or take part in developments courses in a dispute over plans to close ticket offices at a loss of 960 jobs.

    London Underground said: "We have guaranteed that there will be no compulsory redundancies [but] the only way to resolve the issues raised is to continue talking and not threatening further industrial action."

     
  28.  
    Man jailed for noxious fluid attack 12:22:

    A man has been jailed for two years and four months after admitting splashing a noxious fluid over six strangers in a "vile and violent" attack outside the Lightbox nightclub in Vauxhall on 8 June.

    Jonathan Lynn, 29, pleaded guilty at Inner London Crown Court to causing the three men actual bodily harm and possessing an offensive weapon.

    He also admitted splashing the liquid on a fourth man and a female passer-by before he assaulted a further man.

     
  29.  
    NFL returns to Regent Street 12:14:

    Organisers have confirmed NFL on Regent Street will return to London on 27 September, the day before the Oakland Raiders take on the Miami Dolphins.

    Oakland Raiders quarterback Matt Schaub throws a pass

    The event will include on-stage interviews with the players, the Oakland Raiders cheerleaders - the Raiderettes - will perform and you'll have chance to try out the sport.

     
  30.  
    Dean Mayley killing 12:04: BREAKING NEWS

    Acton 19-year-old Ryan Beresford, Greenford 18-year-old Michael Mensah and a 17-year-old, who cannot be named for legal reasons have been convicted of the manslaughter of Dean Mayley.

    Dean Mayley

    The three denied murder. They were also convicted of the attempted robbery of the 24-year-old, who had a mental age of nine.

     
  31.  
    News on the hour 12:00: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On the radio news bulletin at noon: More on the murder conviction of a 17-year-old boy who stabbed 24-year-old Dean Mayley through the heart. The victim had a mental age of nine.

     
  32.  
    Boy convicted of murder 11:48: BREAKING NEWS

    A 17-year-old boy has been convicted of murdering Dean Mayley, a 24-year-old man with the mental age of nine, in a knifepoint mugging in Greenford. Three others are awaiting their verdicts.

     
  33.  
    Football clash disappointment 11:43:

    BBC London Sport tweets: West Ham manager Sam Allardyce disappointed to have not set up a League Cup clash with Leyton Orient. #WHFC

     
  34.  
    Fire engine 'not returned for year' 11:36:

    A fire engine "temporarily" removed from Romford fire station to provide cover during a strike last August has still not been returned a year on, according to the Romford Reporter.

     
  35.  
    Wembley 'could host' Euro 2028 11:28:

    The Football Association is confident of Wembley's chances to stage the Euro 2020 final and has not ruled out the possibility of hosting Euro 2028.

    Wembley stadium

    FA general secretary Alex Horne said "we're really confident with our bid" and hopes England's national stadium could stage the semi-finals and final in six years.

     
  36.  
    Plane makes emergency landing 11:19:

    An Easyjet plane carrying 157 passengers has made an emergency landing at Gatwick Airport after smoke was detected in the cockpit.

    The Airbus A320 was en route from Liverpool to Naples when it touched down at about 07.20 BST.

    Easyjet said the plane landed safely and the passengers "remained calm".

     
  37.  
    Hello not a Kitty 11:09: Amelia Butterly Newsbeat reporter

    You may be forgiven if you thought the Japanese cartoon character, Hello Kitty, was a cat.

    Hello Kitty

    It turns out, for the uninformed, she's actually a British school kid called Kitty White who lives just outside London, according to her creators.

     
  38.  
    News on the hour 11:00: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    In the news at 11:00: Labour's accused the government of increasing the risk of British people travelling to Syria to fight by cutting the funding it provides to local councils - including 19 in London - to prevent radicalisation.

     
  39.  
    Industrial action for Tube workers 10:51:

    London Underground members of the RMT Union have been instructed not to work any overtime or participate in development courses from next Wednesday, in the latest round of industrial action.

    The dispute is over plans to close all ticket offices and cut 960 jobs.

     
  40.  
    Rugby star assault sentencing due 10:42:

    Welsh international rugby star Ian Gough is due to be sentenced at Croydon Magistrates' Court later for attacking his ex-girlfriend, Sophia Cahill.

    Ian Gough

    Gough was convicted of assaulting the former Miss Wales by pushing her into the passenger door of his campervan outside her home in London, aggravating injuries she had from a car accident.

     
  41.  
    Visiting the Crystal Palace 10:33:

    Dave Walker recounts his visits to the remains of Joseph Paxton's Crystal Palace as a child and its history with some great pictures and paintings as part of Kensington and Chelsea's The Library Time Machine blog.

    Crystal Palace
     
  42.  
    Come friendly blocks 10:25:

    BBC London 94.9 presenter Richard Main tweets: In @StPancrasInt John Betjeman gazes in wonder at the station's new tribute to Tetris

    John Betjeman and tetrs
     
  43.  
    Slow traffic on A13 10:13: Paul Murphy-Kasp Journalist, BBC London

    On the roads, the A13 westbound is slow into town from Rainham to Dagenham after a collision blocked two lanes earlier on.

    Get up to date travel information on BBC London Travel News or on Twitter @BBCTravelAlert.

     
  44.  
    News on the hour 09:58: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Coming up on the news bulletin at 10:00: Labour claims funding for the government's counter-terrorism programme Prevent has been cut from £17m to £1.7m, meaning the 19 local authority areas in London deemed to be high risk receive just £68,000 a year to fight terrorism.

     
  45.  
    RMT action announced 09:48:

    BBC London's transport correspondent Tom Edwards tweets: @RMTunion announce action short of a strike in ongoing dispute over tube ticket office closures. Overtime & development courses ban. 1/2

    And: .@RMTunion: "many locations will be left without sufficient staff to safely and effectively run stations." 2/2

     
  46.  
    The radicalisation of Londoners 09:26: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Penny Smith sits in for Vanessa and asks whether enough is being done to stop young Londoners getting radicalised after the Government has been accused of cutting its counter-terrorism programme by 90%.

    Should we be doing more? You can listen live on BBC London 94.9 and contact the team on 020 7224 2000.

     
  47.  
    Gloomy start to day 09:14:

    BBC London 94.9's Richard Main tweets: August in London

    St Pancras Station
     
  48.  
    Travel 08:52: Paul Murphy-Kasp Journalist, BBC London

    On the trains, London Midland, Virgin Trains & Southern have delays of 15-20 minutes through Watford Junction after a train broke down.

    And on the London Overground there's no service between Surrey Quays and New Cross because of works. London Bridge Station is closed to First Capital Connect and Southern services while works take place. Southeastern are stopping as normal.

     
  49.  
    As it happened
    • News, sport, travel and weather for Thu 28 Aug
    • Updates resume from 08:00 on Friday
    • Listen to BBC London
     
  50.  
    'Bruise' suit 08:37:

    Researchers at Imperial College London have designed a suit which helps identify if Paralympic athletes have been injured.

    Paralympic suit

    The "bruise" suit makes injuries visible so those who have limited sensation in their limbs know if they've been hurt and can get treatment quickly.

     
  51.  
    Counter terrorism funding 08:21: Anjana Gadgil BBC London News

    Government funding for the counter-terrorism programme Prevent is down 90%. Nineteen at-risk boroughs in London now share just £1.7m.

    Hear my full report on BBC London 94.9.

     
  52.  
    Gunners through to Champions League 08:09: Phil McNulty Chief football writer

    Alexis Sanchez's first goal for Arsenal since his £35m move from Barcelona claimed the prize of a place in the Champions League group stage for the 17th successive season on a tense night at Emirates Stadium.

    Alexis Sanchez

    The Chilean struck the goal that edged out Besiktas but Arsenal had to survive nervous moments - including playing the last 14 minutes with 10 men after Mathieu Debuchy was sent off - before winning this qualifier.

     
  53.  
    Weather latest 08:03:

    Patchy rain will clear away to the east by mid-morning, with most parts then dry with some sunny spells. However, there may be the odd shower later in the day.

    Highs of 22C (72F).

     
  54.  
    08:00: Beth Rose BBC News Online

    Good morning, I'll be bringing you all the latest news, sport, travel and weather from London today for BBC Local Live.

    You can also send your news, pictures and comments to london.locallive@bbc.co.uk.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.