Abbas Khan: Doctor's death in Syria 'in effect murder'

Hugh Robertson MP: "Syrian authorities have in effect murdered a British national who was in their country to help people"

Related Stories

British doctor Abbas Khan has been "in effect murdered" by the Syrian authorities just days before his expected release from jail, Foreign Office Minister Hugh Robertson said.

He said the death of the 32-year-old orthopaedic surgeon from south London was "at best extremely suspicious".

Mr Khan was arrested last year in Aleppo where he was helping civilians.

Syria's Deputy Foreign Minister Faisal Mekdad said Mr Khan committed suicide using his pyjamas to hang himself.

He said the results of an autopsy proved this, and Mr Khan's body would be released to his family so they could conduct their own inquiry.

One of Mr Khan's brothers, Shahnawaz Khan, said it was "a lie" and "pure fiction" that his brother committed suicide as he had written to his family saying he was looking forward to coming home and spending Christmas with them.

'No excuse'

The doctor's relatives had been told he would be freed on Friday following an order from Syrian President Bashar al-Assad.

Mr Robertson said the government was seeking "urgent clarification" about what had happened to Mr Khan, originally from Streatham.

Mr Abbas Khan travelled to the city of Aleppo last year to help civilians

He said: "We can't at the moment be absolutely certain about the circumstances in which Dr Khan met his death, but what is clear is that he went to Syria on a humanitarian mission, was imprisoned by the Syrian authorities and met his death while he was in prison in circumstances that are at best extremely suspicious.

"There is no excuse whatsoever for the treatment that he has suffered by the Syrian authorities who have in effect murdered a British national who was in their country to help people who were injured during their civil war."

'Summarily executed'

Respect MP George Galloway, who has liaised with the Syrian authorities and was due to collect Mr Khan on Friday, said the death was "murder most foul" and it was "inconceivable that he committed suicide".

The MP for Bradford West said he believed somebody within the regime had killed Mr Khan to defy President Assad's decision to release him.

Three days ago a Syrian government official told us Mr Khan would be released within days.

Today Deputy Foreign Minister Faisal Mekdad showed me some of his exchanges with British politician George Galloway who was expected in Damascus on Friday to take Mr Khan home.

Dr Mekdad emphatically denied reports Mr Khan was killed by Syria's intelligence services.

President Assad, he said, had ordered his release as a present to the British people before Christmas.

This was a suicide, he said - an explanation Mr Khan's family dismisses as "absurd.

"Why would he take his own life when he was so excited to be coming home?", his sister Sara asked.

She told me his children were joyously decorating the house for their father's return.

Just when they thought his pain, and theirs, was ending, his own life has come to a terrible end.

But the argument over how he died won't go away, and there is certain to be political fallout at a time when Damascus was hoping to improve relations with the West.

The former British Foreign Office minister, Alistair Burt, who handled Mr Khan's case up until two months ago, said he does not believe the Syrian government's version.

He said: "The chances of this poor man killing himself when there was a possibility of release seems very remote.

"Had he thought there was a chance of release and return to the United Kingdom, he would most certainly have wanted to do so. In some way he has been killed by the Syrian authorities and they bear the entire responsibility for his death."

BBC correspondent Paul Wood, reporting from Beirut, said Mr Khan could have been a casualty of a power struggle between the Syrian president and his own security services.

He said: "Only President Assad could have ordered the doctor's release. If he did so it may well have been a goodwill gesture in the run up to peace talks that Britain is helping to organise.

"Some in the regime perhaps do not want those talks to succeed."

Shahnawaz Khan said his mother was in a "state of shock and disbelief".

"She was readying herself to bring her son home in four days time after 13 months of a rollercoaster of emotions," he said.

"To be so close and then to be robbed of it is almost the cruellest way it could possibly happen."

Shahnawaz Khan Shahnawaz Khan said his brother was summarily executed

He rejected the Syrian government's claim of suicide, saying it was a "complete fiction" and "utter nonsense and I would ardently deny anything of that scenario".

"We have letters from [my brother] from last week, looking forward to coming home for Christmas, spending Christmas together and starting the new year fresh, he's been in the best spirits he's been in in the last 13 months and he is not a man to give in like that."

Extracts of a letter dated 4 December, shown to the BBC, which appear to be from Mr Khan to his six year old daughter Ruqquaya, reads: "To Ruqqa, thank you for your lovely drawing of everyone.

"Inshallah I will soon come home and give you a big hug and kiss."

He also wrote: "I think the decision to release me has been taken - just some formalities... Inshallah."

On claims that the doctor might have links to jihadi groups, Shahnawaz Khan said: "Again, this is pure fiction and it is an easy excuse to make about an individual who they have summarily executed in effect without due process".

Mr Khan accused the UK government of treating his brother's case "like he's been some wayward traveller in Dubai being caught drunk and contravened some sort of trivial law in Syria".

The family had received "very little assistance", he added.

Mr Khan with his son Abdullah Mr Khan was looking forward to spending Christmas with his family

Mr Khan, who worked at the Royal National Orthopaedic Hospital in Stanmore, north-west London, was detained 48 hours after entering Syria last November.

He had been moved by the plight of refugees and worked in refugee camps in Turkey, his family said. He had not planned to go to Syria but travelled there to treat badly injured civilians.

Earlier this year, his mother - who has spent the last four months in Damascus - found him in a prison in the city weighing just five stone (32kg) and barely able to walk.

He claimed he had been tortured while being detained without charge, and had been held for much of the time on his own.

Mr Khan was one of seven brothers and sisters and is survived by his wife Hanna, his seven-year-old son Abdullah and daughter Ruqquaya, aged six.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London

Weather

London

Min. Night 9 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    German painters' exhibition 16:22:

    A new exhibition will celebrate two German painters, Gerhard Richter and Sigmar Polke, by bringing together 65 of their works in a two-man exhibition.

    A Christie's employee poses with a painting by Gerhard Richter

    The display at Christie's, in London, takes place 50 years after the artists' joint exhibition in 1966 at Galerie h in Hanover, Germany. The exhibition runs from tomorrow.

     
  2.  
    FBI probe teacher abused boys in UK 16:12:

    A convicted paedophile abused children at a private school in London where he taught, its chair of governors says.

    William Vahey, 64, taught students at Southbank International School from 2009 to last year. He was found dead last month.

     
  3.  
    Have your say 16:00:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

     
  4.  
    Cyber gang leader jailed 15:50:

    Tony Colston-Hayter, 48, led a cyber gang which used a "Trojan horse" device to hijack computers at branches of Barclays and Santander. They also stole credit and bank card details from about one million intercepted letters and used the money to buy Rolex watches and jewellery.

    Tony Colston-Hayter

    At Southwark Crown Court, Judge Juliet May QC said: "There is no doubt in my mind that you played a key operational role in taking forward and implementing these plans."

     
  5.  
    Free school not ready until 2015 15:40:

    A free school set to open in five months time has found a site in Merton Park, but it will not be ready before September 2015, reports the Wimbledon Guardian.

     
  6.  
    Chelsea clear to name weakened team 15:31:

    Chelsea are not expected to face punishment from the Premier League if manager Jose Mourinho decides to field a weakened team at Liverpool on Sunday. League regulations have been relaxed since Blackpool were fined in 2011.

    Chelsea players celebrate a goal against Arsenal

    Mourinho has hinted he will prioritise Wednesday's Champions League semi-final second leg with Atletico Madrid, which is goalless after Tuesday's away leg.

     
  7.  
    Coming up 15:21: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Coming up on BBC London 94.9, as part of her feature The Barking Hour, Jo Good will be speaking to Rebecca Smith whose dog Winnie has been cloned to create Minnie Winnie.

    Also on the programme, Jo will be asking what makes you happy? She will be joined by former MP, actor and writer Gyles Brandreth who will discuss his one-man show Looking for Happiness.

     
  8.  
    Mother charged over daughter's death 15:10:

    A mother has been charged with perverting the course of justice after the death of her six-year-old daughter Ellie Butler, who collapsed at home in Sutton on 28 October.

    Jennie Gray, 34, is due to appear on bail before Croydon Magistrates' Court on 6 May. Ellie's father, Ben Butler, has been charged with murdering his daughter and is due at the Old Bailey on 29 May.

     
  9.  
    Audio: The life-threatening effects of SMA 15:00:

    A woman believed to be the mother of three children found dead at a south-west London home has been arrested on suspicion of murder.

    The children are believed to have had a serious genetic condition, thought to be Spinal Muscular Atrophy (SMA). Kelly Fletcher's daughter Lily Mae was diagnosed with SMA, she explained the condition to the BBC Radio 4's Today programme.

     
  10.  
    New Malden deaths 14:52:

    BBC Political Correspondent Ben Geoghegan said that a close friend of the Clarence family has said that Gary Clarence had arrived in the UK from South Africa this morning.

    Gary Clarence and one of his two sons

    The friend said Mr Clarence was in a "complete state of shock". Police are continuing to question Tania Clarence, 42, who is suspected of murdering three of her children in south-west London.

     
  11.  
    Squatters take over police station 14:40:

    Squatters have moved into a police station in north London which closed last year.

    The Met Police said it was notified on Monday that squatters had moved in to the former Hampstead Police Station in Rosslyn Hill.

     
  12.  
    Pet Shop Boys premiere at BBC Proms 14:25:

    An orchestral work by the Pet Shop Boys about the life of wartime codebreaker Alan Turing is to have its world premiere at this year's BBC Proms.

    Pet Shop Boys duo Neil Tennant (l)  and Chris Lowe

    The two-month music festival, which begins on 18 July, will also feature appearances by Paloma Faith and Rufus Wainwright. There will be 92 concerts in total, most of which take place at London's Royal Albert Hall.

     
  13.  
    BTP targeting crime 14:17:

    BTP Northern Line tweets: Today we are working with @CityWestminster and @MPSWestminster targeting crime in the area of #Westminster and tube network #OpBigWing

     
  14.  
    Cyber gang leader jailed 14:09:

    The leader of a cyber gang which stole £1.25 million from British banks has been jailed for five and a half years at Southwark Crown Court.

    Tony Colston-Hayter, 48, led the gang which used a "Trojan horse" device to hijack computers at branches of Barclays and Santander and siphon off cash.

     
  15.  
    Video: Team GB set for Aquatics Centre return 13:55:

    Seven British divers from the 2012 Olympics, including bronze medallist Tom Daley, will compete in London's Aquatics Centre for the first time since the Games when the World Diving Series event gets under way on Friday.

    Tom Daley and Olympic team-mates
     
  16.  
    Travel 13:45:

    On the roads, the M25 is closed clockwise between junction 21a, A405 and junction 22, A1081 at St Albans, because of smoke blowing across the road.

    There is also disruption to Greater Anglia train services between Liverpool Street and Braintree, Clacton-on-Sea, Ipswich and Colchester due to person hit by a train at Witham. For more travel news visit BBC Travel website or follow BBC London Travel on Twitter.

     
  17.  
    HGV blind spot testing 13:35:

    A new project is to test blind spot safety technology in an effort to reduce the risk of collisions between High Goods Vehicles (HGVs), pedestrians and cyclists.

    The scheme, which will be funded by Transport for London, will evaluate the effectiveness of the full range of blind spot safety technology which can be fitted to HGVs.

     
  18.  
    Tottenham 'needs to show more character' 13:25:

    Tottenham Hotspur have lacked character in important matches this season, says goalkeeper Hugo Lloris. "We had a lot of bad defeats. We have to show more character," he said.

    Tottenham suffered a heavy defeat at Liverpool in March

    Spurs are sixth in the Premier League but took only one point from 24 against the top four.

     
  19.  
    Weather 13:15:

    There will be sunny spells and one or two showers this afternoon. The winds will remain light and it should feel warm with highs of maximum Temperature: 17C (63F).

     
  20.  
    Coming up 13:03: Katharine Carpenter Reporter and presenter

    Coming up on BBC London News at 13:30, we will have the latest on the FBI's attempts to trace victims of a paedophile who taught at a London school. William Vahey took his own life but police in the USA say he admitted abusing boys at international schools around the world.

    Also on the programme, a sneak preview of the mini prima ballerinas from London Children's Ballet during their final rehearsals for tonight's premiere performance.

     
  21.  
    Coming up 12:50: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On BBC London 94.9, Dotun Adebayo will be joined by historian and author Chris Laoutaris to discuss his new book Shakespeare and the Countess, which is the first ever biography of Lady Elizabeth Russell, the woman who waged battle against Shakespeare.

     
  22.  
    Rugby Union salary cap 'warning' 12:41:

    The chairman of Saracens rugby club, Nigel Wray, has told BBC Extra Time that the £5m salary cap in the English Premiership Rugby Union is helpful at keeping down costs, but could cause talented players to go elsewhere.

    Chairman of Saracens rugby club in London, Nigel Wray

    "It is a short-lived profession and actually it is quite wrong that you stop people getting what they are worth," he said.

     
  23.  
    Ilford murder trial 12:29:

    The jury in the trial of two men accused of murdering a businessman is due to start considering verdicts later.

    Harjinder Singh Bhurji, 32, was stabbed in Ilford, east London, for allegedly refusing to hand over his car keys.

    Rory Gordon, 22, of Bow, and Jae-don Fearon, 20 of Manor Park Drive, Harlesden, deny murder. Andre Campbell, 22 of Aldriche Way, Waltham Forest, denies handling stolen goods.

     
  24.  
    Man rescued from water 12:21:

    Tower RNLI tweets: Last night the crew had a call at 20:48 and rescued a man from the water with @MPSonthewater #teamwork .

    RNLI board
     
  25.  
    PuppetSoup event 12:10:

    Imperial NHS tweets: Mums & dads in #NWLondon come to special @puppetsoup theatre events for advice on #childhealth tinyurl.com/mnh6qfl

     
  26.  
    Ivor Novello awards 12:00:

    Group London Grammar are up for the best song musically and lyrically award at this year's Ivor Novello awards, for their track Strong.

    London Grammar

    The annual ceremony will take place at London's Grosvenor House Hotel, in Park Lane, on 22 May.

     
  27.  
    Contactless payment pilot 11:50:

    The first customer volunteers have begun Transport for London's pilot of contactless payment on the Tube and rail network.

    Around 5,000 customers are trialling the new way of touching in and out on the network ahead of the launch of the scheme later in the year. Contactless payment is already used on London's buses.

     
  28.  
    Severed finger found in Sutton park 11:40:

    The grim discovery of a severed finger led to a North Cheam park being sealed off by police, reports the Wandsworth Guardian.

     
  29.  
    Have your say 11:30:

    Tell us what you think of BBC Local Live. We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  30.  
    Waterloo delays 11:16:

    South West Trains ‏tweets: #Waterloo. Delays to and from London Waterloo expected until 12:30.

     
  31.  
    Russell Square collision 11:08:

    Simon Lamrock sent us this photo of a car in collision with a van at the junction of of Woburn Place and Bernard Street, near Russell Square.

    Vehicles at Woburn Place and Bernard Street

    The Met Police said there were no serious injuries following the incident which happened at 05:20. TfL tweeted that the road has now reopened.

     
  32.  
    New Malden Deaths 10:58:

    Post mortems are due to take place later on three children who were found dead in New Malden on Tuesday, the Met Police has said.

    The examinations will take place at Great Ormond Street Hospital this afternoon. A 42-year-old woman is being questioned by officers on suspicion of murdering her children.

     
  33.  
    Central Line suspension 10:45:

    Service has been suspended on the Central Line Westbound between North Acton and West Ruislip. There are also minor delays on the rest of the line due to a signal failure at North Acton.

    For more travel news visit the BBC Travel website.

     
  34.  
    Thames Tunnel tours tickets 10:36:

    The public are being given the opportunity to take a public tour of the historic Thames Tunnel, which runs under the Thames between Rotherhithe and Wapping Stations.

    The tours will run from 24-26 May and tickets go on sale on from 10:00 on the London Transport Museum website and will cost £18 per person.

     
  35.  
    Banksy art to be auctioned 10:25:

    A collection of street art works by Banksy, removed from walls, is to go on display at a London hotel before being sold at auction.

    Banksy's 2 Rats mural

    Banksy has not commented, however auction house Bonhams said buyers should be wary of buying artwork which had not been authenticated.

     
  36.  
    Waterloo delays 10:14:

    South West Trains tweets: #Waterloo #ClaphamJunction NEW - power supply issues between Waterloo & Clapham Junction, trains subject to delay, cancellation & alteration

     
  37.  
    Police make Syria plea 10:03:

    British counter-terrorism police chiefs are making an appeal to Muslim women to urge their relatives not to travel to Syria to fight. Shiraz Maher, from Kings College London, said the strategy was ill conceived.

    "The inference that the average parent, in particular, will draw and this is who the campaign is directed at, is that if they take any information about their child to the police they will risk having their child locked up or imprisoned under very draconian legislation," he said.

     
  38.  
    London private schools 'boom' 09:52:

    Pupil numbers at private schools in London have soared since the start of the recession, while institutions in the North have been left struggling, the TES reports.

     
  39.  
    Green park access 09:40:

    TfL Travel Alerts ‏tweets: Step free access has been restored at Green Park to the @piccadillyline platform @TfLAccess

     
  40.  
    Dounreay to be put on display 09:31:

    Parts of a fast reactor control room at Dounreay in Caithness, in the Scottish Highlands, look set to be dismantled and rebuilt at the Science Museum in London.

    Control panels at DFR control room

    The panels and the control desk from the former experimental nuclear power plant near Thurso would be displayed temporarily at the museum.

     
  41.  
    Tower Bridge opening times 09:22:

    Tower Bridge will open at the following times:

    • 11:30
    • 12:!5
    • 14:45
    • 15:30
    • 18:30
    • 19:30
    • 22:30
    • 23:30

    Traffic will be halted while the bridge is open.

     
  42.  
    Mortlake murder charge 09:07:

    A man has been charged with murder following the death of a 49-year-old man in Mortlake, the Met Police have said.

    The victim was found at the Tapestry public house, on Lower Richmond Road on 22 April and died in hospital on 23 April. Nicholas Hunter, 36, from Clapham, is due to appear at Wimbledon Magistrates' Court later.

     
  43.  
    Vanessa Feltz 08:56: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    As counter-terrorism police urge Muslim women to step in if they think their male relatives are planning to join the civil war in Syria, Vanessa Feltz will be asking what do you think of the appeal?

    The call from Scotland Yard comes after the deaths of at least 10 men from Britain in the conflict. Join Vanessa on BBC London 94.9 from 09:00.

     
  44.  
    New Malden deaths 08:47:

    Police are continuing to question a 42-year-old woman suspected of murdering three of her children in south-west London.

    House where the children were found

    Tania Clarence was arrested after the bodies of a girl, aged four, and twin boys, aged three, were found at home in Thetford Road, New Malden, on Tuesday.

     
  45.  
    Central Line 08:37:

    Trains are not stopping on the Central Line at Bond Street because of station improvement works.

     
  46.  
    Latest updates
     
  47.  
    Video: Police quiz mother 'murders' 08:27:

    Flowers and toys have been left outside a home in Thetford Road, New Malden, after three children were found dead at the property on Tuesday.

    Police are continuing to question a 42-year-old woman on suspicion of murder following the deaths of a girl, aged four, and twin boys, aged three.

     
  48.  
    Travel 08:17:

    On the roads, the M1 is blocked northbound from junction 10 at the Luton Airport Spur towards junction 11 at Dunstable following an accident.

    There is queuing traffic on the M25 clockwise between junction 25 A10 at Enfield and junction 26 A121 at Waltham Abbey due to an earlier breakdown in the Holmesdale Tunnel.

    For the latest travel updates follow BBC London Travel on Twitter pr go to our travel page.

     
  49.  
    Police make Syria plea 08:08:

    Events in London will see police reach out to Muslim women to urge men against travelling to possibly fight in Syria in an unprecedented appeal.

    Abdul Waheed Majeed
     
  50.  
    Weather 08:03:

    It will be mainly dry through this morning with any mist quickly clearing. This afternoon will bring sunny spells and scattered, slow moving showers, with the odd heavy one possible. Winds will remain light and it will feel warm. Highs of 18C (64F).

     
  51.  
    08:00: Elaine Okyere BBC London News

    Good morning. I'll be bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather for London today.

    You can tell me your news by emailing london.locallive@bbc.co.uk or tweeting @BBCLondonNews.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.