Mark Duggan inquest: Tottenham's police relations 'worse' since riot

Mark Duggan and riot scenes

The inquest into Mark Duggan's death - which has concluded he was lawfully killed when he was shot by a police marksman - has placed the relationship between Tottenham's black community and the police under scrutiny. Have relationships got better or worse since his death?

On a warm August evening in 2011, Mark Duggan was shot twice by a police marksman.

Two days later, parts of the capital were ablaze and towns and cities across England were suffering their worst rioting since the 1990s.

The riots grew out of a demonstration organised outside Tottenham Police Station following Mr Duggan's shooting.

Koos Couvée, a reporter for North London and Herts Newspapers, said he was on the scene of the shooting 30 minutes after it happened.

"It was a very hot day and you felt something was brewing - that atmosphere continued all the way through to the riots," he said.

"When the riots started it was almost like a carnival atmosphere, and people have described it to me as a sense of release.

Ken Hinds Ken Hinds said stop and search was the reason why relations were bad between young people and police

"But then obviously a lot of people lost their homes and businesses, which was the very dark side of it."

Promises of regeneration were made after the disorder but, for many people in Tottenham, nothing has changed.

Broadwater Farm riots

Broadwater Farm riots
  • Riots on the Broadwater Farm estate in Tottenham took place on 6 October 1985. It was in response to the death of Cynthia Jarrett who suffered heart failure after police officers broke into her house
  • Police were pelted with bottles and petrol bombs and cars were overturned and set alight
  • PC Keith Blakelock died after he was stabbed multiple times while trying to protect firefighters tackling a blaze
  • Three men - Winston Silcott, Engin Raghip and Mark Braithwaite - were convicted of his murder, but cleared on appeal amid claims the evidence in the case may have been fabricated
  • Following a fresh appeal for information, Nicholas Jacobs, 45, of Hackney, was charged with murder in July
  • He pleaded not guilty and will face a trial in March

Studies suggest a significant cause of the riots was "widespread anger and frustration" at the way police engaged with communities.

In particular, they highlighted the policy of stop and search, where officers are allowed to temporarily detain someone and search them if violence or weapons are suspected.

Worryingly, some fear relations between young people in the area and the police may have deteriorated further. Indeed, some fear the riots could happen again.

Ken Hinds, who has worked as a mediator between warring gangs in north London, said he thought relationships with the police had "got worse" since Mr Duggan's death.

Mr Hinds, who was at the Broadwater Farm riot in Tottenham in 1985, said he believed more riots were possible because of the way "the youth are treated by police".

In 2009 he was awarded £22,000 after being wrongfully arrested by British Transport Police. He said the "key to the problem" was stop and search, which he said was "simply racial profiling of black men aged between 15 and 40".

"I've been stopped more than 100 times in my life and it damages you," he said.

"You feel like you've been picked on and violated. You feel sometimes like you've been sexually exploited, because they are feeling you up.

"I believe things have got worse since the riots. The police and courts threw everything at convicted people and giving them massive sentences, even if they took a bottle of water, but we still haven't found out who killed Mark.

"The stuff that has come out of this inquest has been fascinating and damning against the police. Mark Duggan was no angel, but it looked like they made an example of him.

"It's still us versus them and it's not going to change until stop and search is abolished. It's not fit for purpose."

Nynver Miller and Wasim Glowacki Nynver Miller and Wasim Glowacki said relations between young people and police had got "worse"

Figures from the Met regarding Haringey, the London borough which includes Tottenham, show that between November 2011 and October 2012, black people were nearly two-and-a-half times more likely to be stopped and searched than white people. And of those people stopped, 10.8% were arrested.

The following year, black people were just under two times more likely to be stopped and searched, with an arrest rate of 16.4%.

Similar views to Mr Hinds' on stop and search are heard when speaking to young men in Tottenham.

Nynver Miller, a student, said: "At first you feel, 'why are they stopping me?' But you get used to it.

"When you get those police officers who have a bad attitude... you know they are wasting their time, so sometimes it's just funny."

According to a recent Met report, 61% of people stopped and searched between October 2012 and October 2013 were aged between 10 and 24.

Mr Miller said trust between young people in Tottenham and police had always been low.

"That vibe had been there long before what happened to Mark Duggan - it's been like this since day one," he said.

His views were echoed by Wasim Glowacki, also a student, who said that trust had deteriorated.

"Things have got worse, not better, since the riots," he said.

Carpetright building, Tottenham High Road The landmark Carpetright building in Tottenham High Road was set ablaze during the riots
Carpetright building, Tottenham High Road It is now being rebuilt as part of regeneration efforts in Tottenham

"It feels like no-one really knows what happened with Mark Duggan. There are all sorts of stories with people saying one thing and police saying another - it's a mess."

Mr Hinds said in the days after the killing he was contacted by Mr Duggan's father, Bruno. In the Met's report into the riots - Four Days in August - he is referred to as "Mr D".

"Bruno asked me to talk to police and act as a mediator," he said.

"The police hadn't told the family that Mark had been killed and there was a lot of anger. The whole thing could've been averted by going to the family."

Mr Couvée said nothing seemed to have fundamentally changed since the riots.

"It is the perceived lack of access to justice and equal rights from generation to generation," he said.

"And there's a feeling of absolutely no hope for a lot of young people - and that's quite a toxic combination.

"The riots could happen again if the right circumstances conspire. I don't think the conditions for it to happen have been removed."

Alan Stanton, a ward councillor for Tottenham Hale, where Mr Duggan was shot, said time had been "wasted" since the riots.

Kous Couvée Journalist Koos Couvée said there is a perceived lack of access to justice for people in Tottenham

"We haven't moved on at all," he said

"I don't know whether people will riot again, because the response was so heavy. But I don't think we've advanced at all and I don't think we've got a plan to move things."

In 2012 the Met Commissioner Bernard Hogan-Howe ordered an overhaul of stop and search policing in London.

He admitted the tactic had not always been used professionally, but was important to tackle crime.

Assistant Commissioner Mark Rowley said: "The Met is trying to make stop and search more effective, more targeted and less frequent.

"S60 stops - where anyone can be stopped in one area for a limited period of time if violence or weapons are suspected - has been cut back and is down by one fifth.

"And complaints about the use of stop and search is down by almost a half. Disproportionately it is down very significantly and the arrest-to-stop ratio is up."

More on This Story

Related Stories

BBC London

Weather

London

18 °C 9 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    What do you think? 14:07:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

     
  2.  
    Slipstream unveiled 13:57:

    Heathrow Airport tweets: Today we unveiled #Slipstream in T2 created by artist Richard Wilson, which will be seen by 20m passengers a year!

    Slipstream at T2
     
  3.  
    On air 13:46: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On the Robert Elms show: Marlena Lukasiak, the Artistic Director of Kinoteka, the Polish Film Festival, talks about the event which opens tomorrow at Riverside Studios. And Americana folk musician Malcolm Holcombe plays live.

    You can listen live on BBC London 94.9 and contact the team on 020 7224 2000.

     
  4.  
    Hidden homes 13:32: BBC Radio 4

    Thousands of people in London are living in hidden homes because they cannot afford to live elsewhere.

    Inside a warehouse which has been converted into living accommodation

    The BBC has found people paying to live in shop storerooms, above car repair garages, on industrial estates and in former warehouses.

    London Fire Brigade said it had "grave concerns" about the situation.

     
  5.  
    Terry and Cech injured 13:23:

    Captain John Terry (pictured) and goalkeeper Petr Cech will miss the rest of the Premier League season after suffering injuries in Chelsea's Champions League semi-final first leg in Madrid.

    John Terry

    Terry went off with a foot problem while Cech injured his shoulder in the 0-0 draw with Atletico Madrid last night.

     
  6.  
    Dolls' house triumph 13:12:

    A dedicated father from Hornchurch has completed his daughter's Christmas Eve wish for a dolls' house, 35 years after she made it.

    The Romford Record reports that Geoffrey Walkley, 69, finished the replica of the 18th Century National Trust building Rainham Hall last year.

     
  7.  
    BBC London News 13:01: Alex Bushill Presenter

    On the lunchtime news at 13:30 on BBC One: The Londoner originally from Staines who's been murdered in the Philippines. Tony Gilchrist ran a scuba diving business and was apparently shot dead by a security guard who had turned up drunk and was late for work.

    And the largest video portrait of a city ever - the 1,000 Londoners and their stories of life in the big city.

     
  8.  
    Father is bank director 12:50:

    The parents of the two boys and a girl found dead at a property in New Malden have been named locally as Tania and Gary Clarence.

    Gary Clarence and his two sons

    Mr Clarence is said work for Investec Bank as the director of investment banking for healthcare. A 43-year-old woman has been arrested on suspicion of murdering the four and three-year-olds.

     
  9.  
    'Super tutor' truth 12:40: Sean Coughlan BBC News education correspondent

    As exam pressure mounts, some families will be turning to the help of a tutor to help their children.

    It might not be fair, but tutoring is an inescapable feature of competitive education systems across the world.

    Murray Morrison, who has been tutoring in London for 15 years, said "everyone wants the best for their child. But helicoptering in an expensive tutor to do hours of extra work can make the kid miserable, it can put undue pressure on them".

     
  10.  
    'Brought some roses' 12:28:

    A woman has been arrested on suspicion of murder after three children were found dead at an address in south-west London.

    New Malden property

    Local resident Emma Pinn said: "We're devastated as a local area to have heard the story of these three lovely children.

    "There's all kinds of multicultural people [here] and not much crime, so to have this happen here is madness. All my thoughts and prayers are with the family, that's why I came and brought some roses straight away and brought them here."

     
  11.  
    'Can't put a price on life' 12:21: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Kim Mawby, who has been taking Kadcyla for two-and-a-half years for breast cancer after being given a life expectancy of six months, told Vanessa: "It's a lot of money but it gives you back your life and you can't put a price on life.

    "It means I can take the boys out [her teenage sons], watch them do their sport. I went to Thailand for a wedding which I wouldn't have been able to go to if I hadn't been taking the drug. I just want them [NICE] to come and see what the drug's done for us as a family."

    The medicines watchdog, NICE, says the new drug is "unaffordable for the NHS", at £90,000 per patient.

     
  12.  
    London City Airport Flybe deal 12:08:

    Flybe is to offer flights from London after signing a five-year deal with London City Airport.

    Flybe plane

    The airline will offer services to and from Edinburgh, Belfast, Dublin, Inverness and Exeter from 27 October.

     
  13.  
    Video: 'Shock and sadness' 11:58:

    Local residents have spoken of their shock and sadness after three children were found dead at a house in New Malden.

    Local resident in New Malden

    Officers were called to a property in Thetford Road at about 21:30 last night where the bodies of a four-year-old girl and two three-year-old boys were found.

     
  14.  
    City Fathers 11:41:

    A networking group to help fathers who work in the City balance their office and family life is being launched today.

    City Fathers follows the success of City Mothers, which has 3,000 members from a variety of sectors including law, banking and human resources and helps members manage their parental duties while maintaining their career.

     
  15.  
    Where did the theatres go? 11:31: Vincent Dowd BBC World Service

    It is 450 years since William Shakespeare was born and there are events planned around the world to mark the anniversary.

    Shakespeare's Globe theatre

    But in London, no purpose-built theatres survive from his day. Where did they all go?

     
  16.  
    EDF workers to strike 11:20:

    Hundreds of workers at energy firm EDF are to go on strike in a dispute over pay, warning the action will lead to delays in fixing and installing meters.

    The Unite union said almost 500 of its members in London, the South East, South West and Eastern regions would walk out on 6 and 8 May.

     
  17.  
    Travel 11:09:

    TfL Traffic News tweets: WOOLWICH FERRY: Service is currently closed to road vehicles northbound (carrying foot passengers only) due to a collision on A117 Pier Road

     
  18.  
    Family identified locally 10:59:

    The parents of three children found dead at a property in New Malden last night have been named locally as Tania and Gary Clarence.

     
  19.  
    Missing prisoner arrested 10:43:

    A convicted robber who went missing from an open prison in Suffolk has been arrested in London.

    Jerry Monerville

    Jerry Monerville, 49, failed to return to HMP Hollesley Bay last week after being granted leave. He was found at a property in Tower Hamlets.

     
  20.  
    Tributes for children 10:31:

    BBC London 94.9 reporter Jason Rosam tweets: Local people in New Malden leave flowers & messages for the 3 murdered children. More on @BBCLondon949

    New Malden tributes
     
  21.  
    'Way too much' 10:20: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Vanessa Feltz is talking about the medicines watchdog NICE saying that a new drug to treat breast cancer is too much, at £90,000 a patient.

    Kim in Croydon said: "Life is the most precious thing. If they were in their 30s and they were going to live up to their 90s I would support that, but for six months at a price of £90,000 it's just way, way too much."

     
  22.  
    Video: Children found dead 10:06:

    The BBC's Chris King reports on the murder arrest of a woman after a girl, four, and two three-year-old boys were found dead at a property in New Malden last night.

    Aerial view of house

    The 43-year-old remains in custody and officers are not looking for anyone else in connection with the deaths.

     
  23.  
    Children's ages confirmed 09:56:

    Scotland Yard has confirmed the three children found dead at a property in New Malden were a girl aged four and two boys aged three.

    A woman, aged 43, was taken to hospital for treatment to minor injuries and later discharged. She has been arrested on suspicion of murder.

     
  24.  
    Video: Election countdown 09:50:

    Londoners go to the polling stations next month to vote in local elections which see seats in all 32 boroughs up for grabs.

    London elections 2010

    BBC London's Political Editor Tim Donovan looks at the key issues.

     
  25.  
    Kew Garden cuts 09:39:

    Axing up to 125 jobs from the Royal Botanical Gardens in Kew would break the law, a union claims.

    Kew Gardens

    GMB, which represents horticultural workers, said the cuts would prevent Kew from fulfilling its legal obligation as an educational and scientific resource.

     
  26.  
    On air with Vanessa Feltz 09:28:

    The medicines watchdog for England and Wales NICE says a new drug to treat breast cancer is too expensive for the NHS, at £90,000 per patient, and it is unlikely to recommend the use of Kadcyla.

    Breast cancer cell

    Vanessa speaks to a lady who says she took the drug as part of a trial and it changed her life. You can listen live on BBC London 94.9 and contact the team on 020 7224 2000.

     
  27.  
    Yours views 09:18:

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  28.  
    'Children had genetic disorders' 09:07:

    A neighbour, who did not wish to be identified, said the family with four children were originally from South Africa and were "really, really lovely people".

    New Malden property

    She said the three younger children, four-year-old twin boys and an older girl, were suffering from genetic disorders - believed to be life-limiting - but the eldest child, thought to be about seven or eight years old, was in good health.

     
  29.  
    LATEST UPDATES
     
  30.  
    Tube strike talks 08:53:

    The first day of talks to try to avert two planned Tube strikes by London Underground workers over job cuts has ended without agreement.

    Further talks are due to take place later today.

     
  31.  
    Man stabbed near pub 08:43:

    A man has been stabbed near the Tapestry Pub in Mortlake, Lower Richmond Road.

    The man, thought to be in his 40s or 50s, was attacked at about 22:00 yesterday, police said. He is said to be critically ill.

     
  32.  
    'Shocked and confused' 08:30:

    BBC London 94.9 tweets: Our reporter @JasonRosam says people on the New Malden street where the 3 children were found dead are 'shocked and confused' by the news.

     
  33.  
    A warm day 08:17:

    Today will be brighter and warmer than yesterday, with early mist patches soon clearing to allow sunny spells.

    There is a chance of an isolated shower this afternoon. It will feel pleasantly warm, with highs of 17C (63F).

     
  34.  
    M25 problems 08:08: Louise Pepper Journalist, BBC London

    There are two lanes blocked on the M25 anti-clockwise at J8 for Reigate due to a collision.

    And J6 for Godstone to J9 for Leatherhead is very slow due to an earlier accident.

    For the latest go to our travel page or follow us on Twitter @BBCTravelAlert.

     
  35.  
    'Not looking for anyone else' 08:04:

    A 43-year-old remains in custody and officers say they are not looking for anyone else in connection with the investigation.

    Police are currently not giving any details on the cause of the deaths.

    BBC London 94.9's Jason Rosam said several evidence bags had been removed from the property by officers.

     
  36.  
    Children found dead 08:01:

    A woman has been arrested on suspicion of murder after three children were found dead at an address in south-west London.

    House where the bodies were found

    A police spokesman said officers had been called to an address in New Malden on Tuesday night where the bodies of the youngsters were found.

     
  37.  
    08:00: Beth Rose BBC News Online

    I'll be bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather for London throughout the day.

    You can tell me your news by emailing london.locallive@bbc.co.uk or tweeting @BBCLondonNews.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.