Muslim woman must remove veil to give trial evidence

Woman arrives at Blackfriars Crown Court The defendant, who cannot be identified, was present for the hearing

Related Stories

A Muslim woman can stand trial wearing a full-face veil but must remove it to give evidence, a judge has ruled.

Judge Peter Murphy made the ruling at Blackfriars Crown Court in London where the woman is due to stand trial accused of intimidating a witness.

The 22-year-old woman, from Hackney, has refused to remove her niqab and reveal her face in front of any man.

The woman, who cannot be named for legal reasons, pleaded not guilty at an earlier hearing.

The judge's ruling means that if the woman, who started wearing a veil in May 2012, refuses to comply during her trial she could be jailed for contempt of court.

The only part of a niqab-wearer's face that is visible is a narrow section across the eyes.

The judge said he would offer the woman a screen to shield her from public view while giving evidence but that she had to be seen by him, the jury and lawyers.

At other times during the trial the woman will be allowed to keep her face covered while sitting in the dock.

'Elephant in courtroom'

In the ruling Judge Murphy said: "The ability of the jury to see the defendant for the purposes of evaluating her evidence is crucial."

Referring to the woman as "D", he said he had "no reason to doubt the sincerity of her belief" and his decision would have been the same if she had worn the niqab for years.

Analysis

It is an important element of adversarial trial by jury in England and Wales that the facial expressions of a witness or defendant are part of the evidence in the case.

The jury is entitled to rely on their observations of the defendant both when he or she gives evidence, and also throughout the trial, as they see how the defendant reacts when evidence is given by others.

None of that is possible if the accused's face is covered.

That is why, in Judge Murphy's words, the niqab has become the 'elephant in the courtroom'.

It is in order to try and deal with that 'elephant' that he has tried to give guidance which respects the defendant's right to manifest her religious beliefs, whilst also allowing a centuries-old way of conducting trial by jury to continue.

It is a not an easy balance to strike.

He said that "the niqab has become the elephant in the courtroom" and there was widespread anxiety among judges over how to tackle the issue.

He added he hoped "Parliament or a higher court will provide a definite answer to the issue soon".

Judge Murphy said: "If judges in different cases in different places took differing approaches [to the niqab] the result would be judicial anarchy."

The woman's defence barrister Susan Meek had argued the woman's human right to express her faith through her attire would be breached if she was ordered to remove her veil.

When asked if there would be an appeal against the decision, the woman's lawyer said she and her client would "consider our options".

At a previous hearing, the issue of her identity was resolved when the woman removed her veil in private for a female police officer.

Judge Murphy's ruling comes as Liberal Democrat Home Office minister Jeremy Browne said he was "uneasy" about restricting freedoms and called for a national debate on the state's role in stopping veils being imposed on girls.

Keith Porteous Wood, executive director of the National Secular Society, said he believed it was "vital" defendants' faces were visible at "all times" and said he "regretted" the judge's decision.

He added: "We will be complaining to the Office of Judicial Complaints and also be asking senior legal officers to make visibility throughout court hearings mandatory, and not subject to judges' discretion."

The woman's trial over alleged witness intimidation is due to begin at Blackfriars Crown Court on 4 November.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London

Weather

London

25 °C 16 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Brazilian football festival 15:20:

    Football fans are invited to enter a free tournament as part of a festival celebrating Brazilian culture in London.

    The Brazilian Sevens event in Camden will offer residents the chance to take part in one of the capital's fastest growing sports, and get a free health check on Sunday.

     
  2.  
    Missing Alice: Suspect's bike found 15:07:

    The mountain bike ridden by a convicted murderer who is wanted in connection with the disappearance of 14-year-old Alice Gross has been found.

    Alice Gross

    Scotland Yard said the bike had been recovered on Friday but it was not prepared to say where it was found.

    The schoolgirl was last seen on 28 August when she was spotted on CCTV by the Grand Union Canal in west London.

     
  3.  
    News on the hour 14:57:

    Our top local story on BBC London 94.9 this hour:

    UEFA has announced that Wembley will host the semi-finals and final of the European Championships in 2020.

    For the first time, matches in the tournament are being staged in several countries across the continent.

     
  4.  
    Alice Gross disappearance 14:49:

    Police investigating the disappearance of teenager Alice Gross in west London have discovered Arnis Zalkaln's mountain bike, says Scotland Yard.

    Latvian Zalkalns was seen on CCTV at Brentford lock around same time as Alice on 28 August - the day she went missing.

     
  5.  
    West Ham v Liverpool 14:34: Pete Stevens Sport editor, BBC London

    Finally, tomorrow sees West Ham against Liverpool at Upton Park.

    That game kicks off at 17:30 and you can hear full commentary on BBC London digital radio through you TV and online.

     
  6.  
    New cinema 14:23:

    Picturehouse Cinemas has unveiled it will open Picturehouse Central, a 1,000-seat, seven-screen cinema on Shaftesbury Avenue, near Piccadilly Circus, in spring 2015, Screen Daily reports.

     
  7.  
    Murder appeal 20 years on 14:08:

    Atek Hussain was stabbed outside his home in Burnels Avenue, East Ham in the early hours of 18 September 1994. The 32-year-old restaurant owner died in hospital a short time later.

    Atek Hussain with family

    Police have launched a fresh appeal 20 years on from the murder.

     
  8.  
    News on the hour 13:57:

    On BBC London 94.9: UEFA has announced that Wembley will host the semi-finals and final of the European Championships in 2020.

    For the first time, matches in the tournament are being staged in several countries across the continent. Listen live to find out more.

     
  9.  
    Live Championship games 13:50: Pete Stevens Sport editor, BBC London

    Tomorrow, at 15:00, BBC London 94.9 will offer a choice of two games from the Championship.

    On BBC London 94.9 FM you can hear the game between Middlesbrough and Brentford plus over on BBC London digital radio and through your TV you can listen to Rotherham versus Charlton Athletic.

     
  10.  
    Risk of thunder 13:39:

    There will be some warm sunny spells this afternoon. It will be dry for most but there is a chance of a heavy shower or thunderstorm. Maximum temperature: 23C (73F).

     
  11.  
    BBC London TV News 13:25: Sonja Jessup Presenter, BBC London News

    I'll have BBC London's lunchtime news for you. Despite Scotland's "No" vote, is it now inevitable that London will be granted more powers of its own? We'll have reaction from London MPs and Scots living here in the capital.

    And it's been announced that Wembley Stadium will host the semis and final of Euro 2020. That's all coming up at 13:30 on BBC One.

     
  12.  
    Man 'tarred and feathered' 13:19:

    A 58-year-old man was found drunk on a bench in east London covered in black paint and feathers.

    Passers by discovered him at Roneo Corner in Romford on the afternoon of Sunday 14 September.

     
  13.  
    Brothers jailed for manslaughter 13:08:

    Three brothers have been jailed for manslaughter after a man they attacked jumped from a window to escape them.

    Brothers Viktoras Tarasov, Valodia Tarasov and Jurius Tarasov

    The Tarasov brothers denied killing 37-year-old Pawel Pacholak, who broke his neck in the incident in Streatham. They were each jailed for seven months.

     
  14.  
    News on the hour 12:56: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On BBC London 94.9: Tottenham have reported an anti-Semitic banner displayed by Partizan Belgrade fans during last night's Europa League game to European football's governing body UEFA.

    Listen live to find out more.

     
  15.  
    BBC London Sport Show 12:48: Pete Stevens Sport editor, BBC London

    There is plenty of live action this weekend on the BBC London 94.9 Sports Show. First up tomorrow we'll have full coverage of the lunchtime kick-off between QPR and Stoke City.

    That match gets underway at 12:45. You can listen to the first-half on BBC London digital radio through your TV and online plus the second half is on BBC London 94.9 as well.

     
  16.  
    Man City v Chelsea 12:38:

    Chelsea striker Didier Drogba says he is eager to be reunited with his former "partner-in-crime" Frank Lampard when the Blues take on Manchester City on Sunday.

     
  17.  
    Wembley to host Euro final 12:28: BBC Sport

    Wembley Stadium will host the final and semi-finals of Euro 2020, Uefa has confirmed.

     
  18.  
    Spacey stalker sentenced 12:18:

    A woman who engaged in a "persistent and malevolent" cyberstalking campaign against actor Kevin Spacey has been sentenced to four years in prison.

    Kevin Spacey Spacey has won two Oscars, for roles in The Usual Suspects (1995) and American Beauty (1999)

    Linda Louise Culkin, 55, threatened to cause physical harm to the actor, who has been artistic director of London's Old Vic Theatre since 2004.

     
  19.  
    Robert Elms show 12:07: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On Robert Elms' show, Lizzie Treip is talking about this weekend's Open House London event.

    As part of the event, she will be allowing people to visit part of her home called The Tree House, which was her solution to making her two terraced cottages work as a living space for her as a wheelchair user. Tune in now.

     
  20.  
    News on the hour 11:57:

    On BBC London 94.9: Detectives investigating a suspected murder in Uxbridge have made a second arrest.

    Police were called to reports of an assault at an address in Ryefield Avenue yesterday lunchtime and found a 42-year-old man unconscious. He was pronounced dead about an hour later. Listen live to find out more.

     
  21.  
    Wembley to discover Euro 2020 fate 11:49:
  22.  
    Racist flag 'unacceptable' 11:39:

    Tottenham manager Mauricio Pochettino said the anti-Semitic banner displayed by Partizan Belgrade fans during their Europa League tie was unacceptable.

     
  23.  
    Rugby World Cup 11:31:

    Rugby World Cup 2003 winner and England 2015 ambassador Lawrence Dallaglio teamed up with Hounslow Council yesterday as part of a "long pass" event marking the one year countdown to the start of Rugby World Cup.

    Hounslow school children

    Lawrence received the final pass from a Hounslow student to complete the event which saw around 100 Hounslow school children pass a Rugby ball from Redlees Park in Isleworth to Twickenham Stadium.

     
  24.  
    Putney Bridge reopens 11:12:

    The countdown is on to the reopening of Putney Bridge, with just a week to go before pedestrians, drivers and cyclists can start using the bridge again, Wandsworth Guardian reports.

    The bridge is scheduled to reopen to all traffic next Friday, when the £1.5m repair project is expected to finish.

     
  25.  
    News on the hour 11:00:

    On BBC London 94.9, the top headline is: Tottenham have reported an anti-Semitic banner displayed by Partizan Belgrade fans during last night's Europa League game to European football's governing body UEFA.

    Listen online to find out more.

     
  26.  
    Man's face slashed 10:50:

    Four weeks after a man was slashed across the face in a pub in Green Lanes, north London, Scotland Yard is renewing appeals for information to trace a man they wish to speak to in connection with the assault in the early hours of Saturday 23 August.

    Mr Kenny is described as missing his left ear Mr Kenny is described as missing his left ear

    Officers would like to speak with Anthony John Kenny, 25. Mr Kenny is described as missing his left ear and having two tattoos: "Stand alone" on his neck and "North London" on his left hand.

     
  27.  
    Norovirus case 10:40:

    The first signs of winter vomiting bug norovirus have been recorded in Redbridge, the Ilford Recorder reports.

    Barking, Havering and Redbridge University Hospitals NHS Trust said it had recorded a case of norovirus, the most common stomach virus in the UK, on a ward at its Romford hospital.

     
  28.  
    Murder appeal anniversary 10:25:

    Detectives investigating the unsolved murder of a father-of-three in East Ham have joined his family in launching a fresh appeal for help and information on the 20th anniversary of his death.

    Atek Hussain, who was also known as Shelim, was stabbed to death outside his home in Burnels Avenue in the early hours of Sunday, 18 September 1994, Scotland Yard said.

     
  29.  
    Charge over woman's murder 10:13:

    A man has been charged with the murder of a woman who was stabbed to death at a house in Walthamstow.

    Leighann Duffy

    Leighann Duffy, 26, was found at the property in Hatherley Road on 1 September with stab wounds to her arm and neck.

     
  30.  
    News on the hour 09:57:

    London Mayor Boris Johnson tells BBC London 94.9 the Scottish referendum result is a great day for Britain and he's unbelievably relieved the country he loves is basically going to stay together.

    Listen to BBC London 94.9 to find out more.

     
  31.  
    'Great day for Britain' 09:49:

    London mayor Boris Johnson told BBC London 94.9: "This is I think a great day for Britain, a great day for the union.

    "I'm unbelievably relieved that the country I love and grew up in is basically going to stay together."

     
  32.  
    'More power to cities' 09:45: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Reacting to the referendum "No" vote, London mayor Boris Johnson told BBC London 94.9: "One of the best answers to the problem of devolution for England is to do what some of us have been suggesting for some time, which is to give more powers to the great cities."

     
  33.  
    Contactless payments 09:37:

    More than 128,000 contactless payments have been made on London's rail transport network since the new system was introduced on Tuesday.

    Man tabs in to Tube using mobile phone

    People can now use their bank cards and smartphones with special apps installed instead of having to top up their Oyster Cards, although these will still be accepted.

     
  34.  
    Power to London? 09:27:

    Following the Scottish referendum result, a London Councils spokesman said: "The future for London and England's other great cities looks very different today than it did before the referendum.

    "The work that will now begin to deliver a 'devo max' settlement to Scotland following the referendum result needs to be coupled with an urgent focus on devolving power to English cities and localities."

     
  35.  
    Tell us what you think 09:16:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

     
  36.  
    PCSO sold paper Campbell story 09:06:

    A former Met Police community support officer has been given a suspended jail sentence for selling a story to the Sun about supermodel Naomi Campbell.

    Naomi Campbell Stories were published about Naomi Campbell as a result of Randall's phone call

    Paul Randall, was paid £150 by the tabloid after he told them the model attended the police station in Westminster where he worked.

     
  37.  
    Top headline 08:59: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The latest headline on BBC London 94.9: Scotland Yard has paid £45,000 in damages in an out-of-court settlement to a black motorist who claimed he was struck with batons and sprayed with CS gas during an unlawful arrest.

    Listen to BBC London 94.9 to find out more.

     
  38.  
    Vanessa Feltz show 08:50: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Vanessa Feltz will be discussing the implications of the referendum result on BBC London 94.9just after 09:00.

     
  39.  
    #indyref 0840:

    London MP Diane Abbott tweets: The 6 million strong city of London (& other cities) must get powers to parallel those being devolved to Scotland #indyref

     
  40.  
    Heroin worth £37m found in Jag 08:36:

    Heroin with a street value of more than £37m was "rammed" into a battered X-type Jaguar and smuggled into the UK from Pakistan, a jury has heard. Luton Crown Court was told 316 packets of the drug were found in the car when police examined it.

    Jaguar with drugs Luton Crown Court was told the car could not have been driven and drugs were hidden throughout, including in its bumpers, engine and dashboard

    Israr Khan, 35, of St Ethelbert Avenue, Luton and Noman Qureshi, 32, of Bracken Hill Mews, Bradford, deny conspiracy to supply Class A drugs. Mohammed Safder, 43, of Sidney Elson Way, East Ham, denies the same charge.

     
  41.  
    Lightning hits rail services 08:29:

    Southeastern Trains are disrupted between Ashford International and Victoria via Maidstone East due to a lightning strike.

    The strike has also resulted in delays for Thameslink services between Sevenoaks and Blackfriars.

    For the latest travel news follow us on Twitter @BBCLondonTravel

     
  42.  
    Latest updates
     
  43.  
    Metropolitan Line delays 08:12:

    There are minor delays on the Metropolitan Line between Wembley Park and Amersham, Chesham, Watford and Uxbridge.

    For more travel news, visit BBC London's travel website.

     
  44.  
    Foggy start, bright later 08:05:

    Low cloud and fog will gradually lift by the afternoon to leave some warm bright or sunny spells. It will be dry for most but, throughout today, there is a chance of a heavy shower or thunderstorm. Maximum Temperature: 23C (73F)

     
  45.  
    08:00: Andy Dangerfield BBC News Online

    Good morning. I'll be bringing you all the latest news, sport, travel and weather from London today for BBC Local Live.

    You can send your news, pictures and comments to london.locallive@bbc.co.uk.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.