Jeremy Hunt's Lewisham hospital cuts plan quashed at High Court

Campaigners celebrated at the Royal Courts of Justice following the ruling, but will the jubilation last? Jane Dreaper reports

Related Stories

Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt has had his decision to reduce services at a major hospital declared unlawful and quashed by the High Court.

Mr Justice Silber ruled Mr Hunt acted outside his powers when he announced casualty and maternity units at Lewisham Hospital would be downgraded.

He said the Secretary of State had breached provisions of the National Health Services Act 2006.

The judge gave him permission to appeal against the decision.

Mr Justice Silber said recommendations of the Secretary of State had to have regard to, or be supported by, GP commissioners.

It was quite clear that the Lewisham GP commissioners did not give support to the proposals, said the judge.

'Incredible day'

He went on: "On the contrary, they strongly opposed them although those GP commissioners in a number of surrounding but different areas were happy with them.

Analysis

There were cheers and tears in Court 76 as Mr Justice Silber gave hospital campaigners the news they had hoped for.

He ruled that Jeremy Hunt and the administrator he appointed to South London Healthcare had acted outside their powers when they decided to reduce services at Lewisham hospital.

He ruled that local GPs had not supported the plans and therefore they should not be allowed to go ahead.

Today's ruling comes six months to the day since Jeremy Hunt announced the downgrading of services like the A&E and maternity units at Lewisham.

Campaigners had argued it was being made to suffer because of the failings of the neighbouring South London Healthcare Trust which is £65m in deficit.

This was the first time the Trust Special Administrator regime had ever been used.

The government has been given permission to appeal.

"I considered that it was the absence of support from the local GP commissioners which constituted an additional reason why the decision of the Secretary of State cannot stand."

The challenge was brought by Save Lewisham Hospital and the London Borough of Lewisham.

Dr Louise Irvine, a local GP who chairs the Save Lewisham Hospital campaign, said: "This is an incredible day.

"We are delighted for every single person who has supported the campaign and those who will now continue to benefit from this extraordinary hospital."

Rosa Curling, a lawyer with solicitors' firm Leigh Day acting for the campaigners, described it as a "tremendous victory".

She said: "This judgment should serve as a warning to the government that, if they try to do this, local communities will fight back to ensure their healthcare services remain in place."

Mayor of Labour-run Lewisham Council, Sir Steve Bullock, said justice had been delivered to a hospital "well-managed, highly-respected and financially solvent".

In January Mr Hunt told MPs that the cuts were necessary because neighbouring South London Healthcare NHS Trust has been losing more than £1m every week.

A spokesman said Mr Hunt's department was "disappointed by the decision" and would consider the judgment carefully.

He said: "This judgment applies to one aspect of a package of changes which we believe are in the best long-term interests of patients and the public across south-east London.

"We expect to continue other elements of that package of changes, including the dissolution of the South London Healthcare NHS Trust, planned for October 1 - although there are a number of steps to go before that can take place."

The other changes expected to go ahead are King's Health Partners taking over Princess Royal Hospital and the merger of Queen Elizabeth Hospital and Lewisham Hospital trusts.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London

Weather

London

Min. Night 15 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Fulham young side boost 16:20: BBC Sport

    Fulham striker Ross McCormack hopes the League Cup win over Brentford will kick-start their season after four consecutive Championship defeats.

    Ross McCormack

    McCormack, an £11m summer arrival from Leeds, scored his first goal for the club at Griffin Park.

     
  2.  
    Court date over lecturer attack 16:10:

    A preliminary hearing date has been set for two Polish nationals accused of beating a university lecturer during a burglary.

    Paul Kohler, 55, was left with serious facial injuries after four men burst into his home in Wimbledon on 11 August, and beat him, demanding money. The preliminary hearing will take place on 26 November at Kingston Crown Court.

     
  3.  
    News on the hour 16:00:

    Coming up on BBC London 94.9: the jury has retired to consider its verdict in the trial of four teenagers accused of murdering a man whose brain disorder meant he had a mental age of nine.

    Dean Mayley, who was 24, was stabbed in the heart as he walked home in Greenford in February. Listen live to find out more.

     
  4.  
    Arrest over politician murder 15:52:

    A second man has been arrested in connection with the murder of an exiled Pakistani politician who was attacked on his way home from work in London.

    Dr Imran Farooq Dr Imran Farooq had been living in exile in the UK

    Dr Imran Farooq was stabbed several times and bludgeoned with a brick after he was ambushed by two men outside his Edgware home, four years ago.

     
  5.  
    Man witnesses Croydon stabbing 15:43:

    The Croydon Guardian has interviewed Kaz Ali, 24, , who witnessed the attempts of emergency services to save the life of a man who was stabbed to death in Croydon yesterday.

    He told the paper: "The man was saying 'I cannot see, I'm going blind'. He was shouting 'I cannot see anything'."

     
  6.  
    Have your say 15:33:

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  7.  
    Change of plan over 'glass box' 15:22:

    Architects have been forced to change designs for a glass box on the roof of a luxurious penthouse-style flat after opponents warned it would shine "like a beacon" over Highgate, reports the Ham & High.

     
  8.  
    London Broncos signing 15:09:

    London Broncos have agreed a deal to sign Fiji international centre Wes Naiqama from Penrith Panthers on a two-year deal from the 2015 season.

    Wes Naiqama

    The 31-year-old has played over 120 games in the NRL, enjoying spells with St George Illawarra Dragons, Newcastle Knights and Penrith.

     
  9.  
    News on the hour 14:57:

    BBC London 94.9's top local story this hour:

    Police have today arrested a 30-year-old man at an address in Waltham Forest in connection with the murder of the Pakistani politician Dr Imran Farooq in September 2010.

    The 50-year-old was attacked outside his home in Green Lane, Edgware.

     
  10.  
    Cycling scheme 14:46:

    Enfield Council and the London Cycling Campaign's are launching a scheme to try to get more people to experience the benefits of cycling.

    If you live, work or study in Enfield, you can loan a bike for four weeks for £10.

     
  11.  
    Warmer weather 14:37:

    This afternoon will be more cloudy than this morning, with a little less in the way of sunshine, but will still feel slightly warmer than of late. Maximum temperature: 22C (72F).

     
  12.  
    Fines issued 'to litterbugs' 14:26:

    Nearly 200 fines have now been handed to fly-tippers and people dropping litter in Hounslow this year, Get West London reports.

    Deputy council leader Amrit Mann said: "Our clampdown on litter louts, fly-tippers and those selfish few who spoil our streets will be relentless."

     
  13.  
    Olivier Giroud injury 14:14: BBC Sport

    Arsenal are not planning to sign another striker to replace Olivier Giroud - even if scans on his ankle confirm a serious injury.

    Giroud will remain Arsenal's number one striker - even if he is ruled out for three months Olivier Giroud signed for Arsenal from Montpellier in 2012 for just under £10m

    The club has said it has no intention of recruiting any forwards on a permanent deal in this summer's transfer window.

     
  14.  
    News on the hour 14:00: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On BBC London 94.9: police have today arrested a 30-year-old man at an address in Waltham Forest in connection with the murder of the Pakistani politician Dr Imran Farooq in September 2010. Listen live to find out more.

     
  15.  
    Primary school budget squeeze 13:44:

    There are warnings the rising primary school population is putting pressure on budgets, with councils across England having to spend £1bn on providing extra places.

    Ealing Council has had to top up government funding with £129m, while Hillingdon has added £114m, says the Local Government Association.

     
  16.  
    Exploitation of boys 'overlooked' 13:29:

    The stereotypical belief boys are less vulnerable to child sexual exploitation means they are receiving insufficient protection from frontline services, charity Barnardo's has claimed.

    By analysing the records of 9,042 victims of child sexual exploitation (CSE) since 2008, University College London found almost one in three (2,986) was male.

     
  17.  
    Crystal Palace manager named 13:19: BBC Sport

    Crystal Palace have appointed Neil Warnock as their new manager.

    Neil Warnock

    The 65-year-old, who was in charge of Palace between 2007 and 2010, has been chosen over former West Brom boss Steve Clarke.

     
  18.  
    Kate Bush comeback 13:15:

    Kate Bush's first concert since 1979 has been greeted with overwhelmingly positive reviews by newspaper critics. She performed at the Hammersmith Apollo last night.

    Kate Bush
     
  19.  
    Lunchtime bulletin 13:04: Katharine Carpenter Reporter and presenter

    Coming up in our lunchtime news, we'll have the latest on the Metropolitan Police commissioner's comments on terror suspects. He wants stricter controls over their movement.

    And we'll be discussing the new figures which suggest guide dogs and their owners are often hit by bikes on our roads. Join me at 13:30 on BBC One.

     
  20.  
    News on the hour 12:53: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Coming up on BBC London 94.9: the Met Police commissioner says he is "concerned" by the number of stabbings at the Notting Hill Carnival.

    Tune in to find out more.

     
  21.  
    Crystal Palace boss contenders 12:42:

    Crystal Palace are to make a decision on who will be their next manager later, with Steve Clarke and Neil Warnock the only contenders.

    Steve Clarke and Neil Warnock

    Both men were interviewed this week after Palace turned their back on Malky Mackay, and Tim Sherwood pulled out of the race to succeed Tony Pulis.

     
  22.  
    Listen: Gig 'like no other' 12:32: BBC Radio 4

    Kate Bush's London's Hammersmith Apollo gig last night was "like no other comeback gig" according to The Telegraph's music editor.

    Bernadette McNulty, who attended the gig said there were wooden puppets and helicopters" and no backing dancers like you would see in a Lady Gaga gig.

     
  23.  
    Tube challenge 12:20:

    Brothers Richard and Michael Brownnutt are attempting to visit 270 Tube stations in 24 hours to raise money for the Batten Disease Family Association.

     Richard and Michael Brownnutt

    Both their cousin's children, Ellie Mae & Caleb, have recently been diagnosed with Late Infantile Batten Disease.

     
  24.  
    Robert Elms show 12:09:

    Tim Arthur, who is sitting in for Robert Elms, welcomes Irish band Hudson Taylor who are about to begin a tour with Jake Bugg. The tour will culminate with a show at Alexandra Palace on the 21 October.

    They will be playing live in the studio.

     
  25.  
    News on the hour 11:55: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Coming up on BBC London 94.9: two Polish men accused of beating up a university lecturer during an alleged burglary have been ordered to stand trial in the new year. Listen live to find out more.

     
  26.  
    Met chief backs passport plan 11:49:

    The UK's most senior police officer has said he backs a call to seize passports from Britons who go abroad to fight with militants in Syria and Iraq.

    Met Police chief Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe also said "something like" control orders to restrict the movement of terror suspects should be brought back.

     
  27.  
    Dagenham school stalwart dies 11:39:

    A former policeman who organised the annual reunion for a Dagenham school has died aged 65, according to the Barking and Dagenham Post.

    Bob Miller attended Alibon Primary before progressing, along with his entire class, to Dagenham County High, now Sydney Russell School.

     
  28.  
    Foxtons jump in profits 11:24:

    London-based estate agent Foxtons has reported a big rise in half-year profits, but warned it expects business to slow down in the second half of the year.

     
  29.  
    Stop and search rules 11:14:

    We reported yesterday police forces in England and Wales have signed up to a new code of conduct for how they use their controversial stop and search powers.

    Derek and Fab speak to Chief Superintendent Victor Olisa

    Radio 1 Newsbeat met 26-year-old Derek and his friend 23-year-old Fab in Tottenham. Between them they say they've been stopped and searched more than 50 times.

     
  30.  
    Croydon stabbing 11:05:

    A 24-year-old man has died after he was stabbed during a fight amongst a group of males in Croydon.

    Police said Adrian Young died two hours after the attack yesterday afternoon.

     
  31.  
    News on the hour 10:56: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On BBC London 94.9: The leader of Barnet Council tells other boroughs to plan ahead better after it emerged many are borrowing money or diverting cash away from repairs to meet the demand for primary school places. Listen live to find out more.

     
  32.  
    Cyclist 'threat' 10:44: Facebook

    About 25% of guide dogs working in London have been hit by a bike, according to the organisation Guide Dogs.

    Louise Amy Ellis commented on Facebook: "Ok a dog really isn't that hard to see if your on a bike and they are wearing their harness! Come on take more care!"

    Do you agree?

     
  33.  
    Guide dog awareness 10:34:

    BBC London 94.9 reporter Jason Rosam tweets: 1 in 4 guide dogs in London have been hit by a cyclist. @GuidedogsLondon are raising awareness today in Lambeth. pic.twitter.com/RvCx68ylEj

    Guide dogs
     
  34.  
    Guide dogs 'threatened' 10:25: Facebook

    A quarter of blind and partially sighted people and their guide dogs have been hit by bikes in the capital.

    On Facebook, Glen Freeman said: "This is shocking, but I am not surprised. Over the last few years cyclists have become a menace on our roads."

    Do you agree? Comment on Facebook.

     
  35.  
    Kate Bush's glowing return 10:09:

    The long-awaited return of Kate Bush has been greeted with glowing reviews from both fans and newspapers.

    Kate Bush on stage

    Last night the songstress took to the stage at Hammersmith Apollo - her first concert for 35 years. Did you go? Let us know what you thought of the show?

     
  36.  
    News on the hour 09:55:

    On BBC London 94.9: a study by University College London suggests boys and young men are more likely to be victims of sexual abuse than previously thought. Listen live to find out more.

     
  37.  
    Feedback 09:44:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

     
  38.  
    Jimmy Mizen cafe 09:28:

    The Jimmy Mizen Foundation is opening it's third café run by young people to help them play a positive role in the community.

    Jimmy was attacked a day after his 16th birthday in Lee, south-east London, in 2008.

     
  39.  
    Fulham win 09:18:

    Fulham's £11m striker Ross McCormack eased the pressure on manager Felix Magath with his first goal for the club in a Capital One Cup win at Brentford.

    Magath spoke to BBC London 94.9 after his club's win.

     
  40.  
    Guide dog walking dangers 09:07:

    A quarter of guide dogs working in London have been hit by a bike, according to the organisation Guide Dogs.

    Man walking with a guide dog

    A survey involving a fifth of guide dog owners in the city also found 70% had experienced a near miss with cyclists on pavements or jumping red lights.

     
  41.  
    News on the hour 08:58: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On BBC London 94.9: a 23-year-old man's being treated in hospital after he was shot in the leg and stabbed in Pimlico. To find out more, listen live.

     
  42.  
    League Cup 08:47: BBC Sport

    Crystal Palace and Fulham got their first wins of the season last night, as they qualified for the third round of the League Cup.

    Palace beat Walsall 0-3 while Fulham scored a 0-1 win at Brentford.

    Elsewhere, Millwall and Charlton both lost, while West Ham leave the competition after they lost a penalty shoot-out against Sheffield United.

     
  43.  
    On air 08:38: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Penny Smith is standing in for Vanessa Feltz this morning.

    She'll be asking should E-cigarettes be banned indoors? It comes as the World Health Organisation has raised questions about how safe they are.

    E-cigarette

    Get in touch with your views: call the studio on 020 7224 2000.

     
  44.  
    Travel 08:27: Paul Murphy-Kasp Journalist, BBC London

    South West Trains has delays and cancellations on trains through Wimbledon while emergency works take place and Greater Anglia is experiencing delays of 15 mins in and out of Liverpool Street because of a late running freight train.

    Get up to date travel information on BBC London Travel News or on Twitter @BBCTravelAlert.

     
  45.  
    Fuel spill 08:17:

    The A406 North Circular is partially blocked eastbound between Finchley High Road and Colney Hatch Lane after a fuel spill. Queues on the approach. BBC Travel has the latest.

     
  46.  
    Top headlines
     
  47.  
    Cloudy with sunny spells 08:09:

    A fine and dry day with sunny spells and occasional cloud in the east.

    Cloud is likely to be more abundant in the west with patchy rain possible later in the day. Highs of 22C (72F).

     
  48.  
    08:00: Andy Dangerfield BBC News Online

    Good morning, I'll be bringing you all the latest news, sport, travel and weather from London today for BBC Local Live.

    You can also send your news, pictures and comments to locallive@bbc.co.uk.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.