EDL protest policing 'the price of democracy'

Police in a line in front of protestors Police said members of both the EDL and opposing groups had to be "contained" at one point

In my job it's fairly common to be asked to move on by the police when I turn up with a camera crew to cover an event.

Receiving that familiar request from officers of South Yorkshire, Northumbria, Lancashire, Merseyside and North Wales constabularies all in the space of one afternoon is not so common.

That was a measure of the huge police operation on the streets of Sheffield when the far-right street protest movement English Defence League swaggered into the city led by its national leader Tommy Robinson.

Reinforcements had been drafted in from far afield and the local South Yorkshire force cancelled all leave.

'We will return'

Robinson had complained that the previous week anti-racist groups in Sheffield had prevented 80 of his supporters from laying a wreath to commemorate the tragic death of Fusilier Lee Rigby.

He immediately vowed the EDL would return to the city in far greater numbers to ensure that they could carry out what he called their "patriotic duty".

I counted about 400 EDL supporters who actually turned up for the return visit. That was about half the number many far-right social media contributors had predicted.

Even so, it was a substantial number for a relatively tiny organisation like the EDL, but it was not the reason why the wreath-laying finally went ahead.

That was down to the 1,000 police officers on duty who cleared a path to the war memorial and created an "isolation zone" separating the EDL from at least three times as many chanting anti-racist supporters.

Price of democracy

I caught up with Tommy Robinson as the EDL marched away from the brief ceremony and recorded an interview for that evening's Look North TV news bulletins for Yorkshire.

The Luton-based leader of the movement claimed his supporters had proved they had an unfair reputation for violence by successfully holding what had turned out to be a peaceful and dignified ceremony.

He shrugged off what will certainly be a bill running into hundreds of thousands of pounds for policing the event. That, he said, is "the price of democracy".

Within minutes of that interview police were drawing batons and calling up mounted colleagues as around 200 EDL supporters broke away from the main group being escorted towards the station.

It took another three hours of disciplined containment, at one stage involving police in riot gear, before the EDL finally dispersed. Police later confirmed that there had been five arrests.

As the police operation was in full swing, a totally different protest against the presence of the EDL was taking in the city's sun-drenched Peace Gardens.

A specially organised multi-cultural music festival was being enjoyed by local families. It was hard to believe that this was just a few streets away.

Len Tingle Article written by Len Tingle Len Tingle Political editor, Yorkshire

Will Yorkshire enter the open door?

The chancellor remains at loggerheads over directly-elected mayors for South and West Yorkshire.

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    This is a very good report. Both sides were gearing themselves up for a fight and i thought the police did a very good job of keeping the sides fairly well apart. Most of the comments that you will see on here will be against the UaF, but most of the chanting from West Street was coming from the EDL supporters which weren't the nicest chants I have ever heard.

  • rate this

    Comment number 1.

    No mention of Unite Against Fascism’s pro Hezbollah chanting and waving Palestinian and Jihad flags. No mention of Unite Against Fascism trampling all over the War memorial after the EDL had left. No mention of the Unite Against Fascism rioting and attacking the police in and around West Street, trying to get to the EDL.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.