UK needs northern prosperity to boost growth - report

Tyneside The report says growth is needed in northern cities like Newcastle

Related Stories

Those of us who live and work up north know that it's far from grim.

Apart from having some vibrant cities and amazing countryside, it also has economic success stories.

But a new report suggests more needs to be done to unlock its potential - not just for the benefit of people who live there but also for the good of the UK as a whole.

Return to growth

The Northern Economic Futures Commission has spent 18 months gathering evidence and considering what's going right and wrong.

But above all it was concerned with how the north could help the British economy return to significant levels of growth.

Over the last decade the three northern regions - the North West, Yorkshire and Humber and the North East - have been responsible for a fifth of the UK's prosperity, but London alone contributed more than a quarter.

And while countries like Germany, Holland and Spain have several economically-powerful cities, the UK just has London.

Why, the report asks, can't the likes of Newcastle, Leeds or Manchester be as economically significant as Stuttgart, Rotterdam or Barcelona?

Barcelona skyline The commission says it wants northern cities to be as economically significant as Barcelona

The commission's solution is to move power and funding north.

It has come up with an action plan to increase the northern contribution to UK plc.

Direct flights

The commission wants air passenger duty cut significantly for northern airports for a three-year period.

It believes that could be vital in ensuring there are direct flights from Manchester, Leeds and Newcastle to the new international economic powerhouses of Beijing, Shanghai, Sao Paulo, Delhi and Mumbai.

The report also says a new body - Transport for the North - should be formed to oversee the northern rail network.

But the power and money grab wouldn't stop there.

The commission also says huge pots of government money should also be handed directly to the north.

It says a single fighting fund for economic growth should be created by handing local transport, housing, skills, regeneration and development funding directly to the north's Local Enterprise Partnerships (LEPs).

Under the recommendations £13bn of housing benefit and funding for house-building would also be transferred out of Whitehall and into the north.

Start Quote

Ed Cox, director IPPR North

If the north of England was to emulate its northern European neighbours then it might just lead the UK economy out of its present lopsided doldrums”

End Quote Ed Cox Director, IPPR North

Local employers would get a greater say over skills policy and the number of apprenticeships would double to 60,000 by 2015.

A Northern Innovation Council could get £1bn from the proceeds of sale of 4G mobile licences, and there would be a special northern section of a UK investment bank.

Elected mayors

The commission also wants to see powerful northern leaders emerge. It says the 11 LEPs should hold an annual summit and elect a chair.

In addition, directly elected metro mayors would take charge of urban areas such as Tyneside, Merseyside and Greater Manchester. The north, it believes, needs its own Boris Johnson.

The commissioners believe that could create 500,000 extra jobs in the north, close the economic divide with the south and boost the British economy by £41bn.

The commission was brought together by Newcastle-based think tank IPPR North.

Its director Ed Cox said: "The 'north south divide' is a stock-in-trade and 'it's grim up north' is a familiar refrain.

"Like all clichés, there is more than an element of truth in this characterisation.

"But the north is capable of taking its place in the ranks of successful northern European economies, with competitive companies trading in global markets, a fully employed and well-skilled workforce, and strong civic leadership that supports growth and shared prosperity.

"Far from lagging behind the rest of the country, if the north of England was to emulate its northern European neighbours then it might just lead the UK economy out of its present lopsided doldrums and towards a more progressive and sustainable economic future."

Rebalancing the UK

Some of the report does echo some of what Lord Heseltine recently recommended in his report, and harks back to a Victorian age when northern cities played a huge part in the UK and global economy.

Boris Johnson The report suggests the north needs its own version of London mayor Boris Johnson

The government has also repeatedly talked about rebalancing the UK and stimulating private sector growth across the north.

So some of these ideas may be welcomed.

But they also require the sacrifice of control by Whitehall - something successive governments have been reluctant to do.

So is a change of culture possible?

And does the government really want a northern Boris Johnson knocking on the door of Downing Street?

I can also imagine politicians and businesses in the West Midlands being taken aback by the idea that northern flights could be taxed at a lower rate than those leaving Birmingham.

Campaigners in the south west might also question why the north qualifies for special treatment.

But the commission is clear, the north as a whole has a population of 14.5 million people and a large chunk of its manufacturing base.

And it believes that without a focus on northern prosperity, there's less chance of the UK as a whole emerging from its current economic difficulties.

Richard Moss Article written by Richard Moss Richard Moss Political editor, North East & Cumbria

Pacer trains may 'still have role' in North of England

The Prime Minister said they were history but 30-year-old Pacer trains may not disappear from the North's railways

Read full article

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 70.

    Seems to me a one way street; with all the support going north - hence lower cost of living and better facilities in 'the north' .
    I travel England a lot and am amazed at the number of people employed by Councils in places such as Leeds, Liverpool, Newcastle etc. How I wish we had street cleaners and park maintenance staff!

  • rate this

    Comment number 69.

    Maybe it is time for the North to request that the Scottish border is moved quite a way south in time for the Scots referendum! Then the self righteous South can keep their disastrous banking system while the North can get back to the real world of manufacturing.

  • rate this

    Comment number 68.

    The reason for the prosperity and success of the great Northern and Midlands cities in the past was that they were self-confident and politicians, who understood industry and enterprise, listened to them. The politicians became careerist party drones,stopped listening,confidence was lost and so was our prosperity.

  • rate this

    Comment number 67.

    The north has been fundamental to Britain's industrial past. Rather than Cameron thinking only about infrastructure projects (HS2, planning) - what about waking up to the north. It's time we focussed on a massive jobs programme up there to compete with Germany in manufacturing again. If Cameron doesn't wake up then only Boris Johnson will have the 'olympic spirit' to master such a scheme.

  • rate this

    Comment number 66.

    Let's start by moving parliament from London to Manchester and abandoning the multi billion pound refit that the politicians are about to vote for in relation to the houses of parliament. Spend this on getting people back to work! Having MP's away from London will reduce costs and give them a more UK perspective - more of the UK's people live outside of London than live within.

  • rate this

    Comment number 65.

    The only bad thing about the North is the constant mentality to vote for Labour even though the Labour party has done nothing for the North ever in history except make in worse. There are so many Labour councils that are consistently bottom of any quality tables, yet people never learn and keep voting for these odious fools. A time has to come when we stop banging on about Tories closing t'pits!

  • rate this

    Comment number 64.

    World Innovation Foundation
    Huddersfield, United Kingdom – Bern, Switzerland – Arlington, United States of

  • rate this

    Comment number 63.

    This government has already ruled out growth as a strategy
    so any words written on the subject are a waste of effort.

  • rate this

    Comment number 62.

    Some facts to inform the debate;
    NW. England; pop. 6.7m
    NE.England; pop. 2.5m
    Yorks-Humber; pop. 5.0m
    None of the above English "Regions" boasts their own "accountable" and therefore legitimate tier of governance - in stark contrast
    Greater London; pop. 7.2m
    Scotland; pop 5.2m
    N.Ireland; pop. 1.8m
    Wales; pop. 3.1m
    All possess some form of legitimitsed tier of self-governance

  • rate this

    Comment number 61.

    How can we have global economy when we can't even see the UK as one?
    Those of us who live in the North East don't want the south coming and spoiling it. We have quality of life, affordable housing, reducing population, excellent road, rail & air links, three Universities, stunning accessible landscapes, arts & culture architecture. There is more to life than money and we have it in abundance.

  • rate this

    Comment number 60.

    If you think of UK plc as the human body, then all of the body parts have to be strong and healthy for it to work properly. If just one part of your body isn't healthy (eg a broken arm-or the North-east), then that means the rest of your body doesn't work properly. Heaven only knows what would happen if we got man-flu.

  • rate this

    Comment number 59.

    "The 'North South divide" is a stock in trade.
    How very true,if you want to see,an example of this,just watch the weather report after the 6 o'clock news on the BBC.The weather map,stops at Birmingham and Norwich,and starts again at Newcastle.There seems to be,no civilisation whatsoever after Birmingham.It's like some barren,post apocalyptic wasteland.Leeds,Liverpool,York,Manchester,all gone.

  • rate this

    Comment number 58.

    57.Bluesland - "Don't worry, you smug southerners, Georgie Boy's economic policies mean that the food banks are coming your way soon!......"

    Or in the case of this corner of rural Devon they already have arrived....

    ...since the boy Gideon took the reins we've lost three local factories & have needed the food bank to keep families fed what with there being no new jobs round here.....

  • rate this

    Comment number 57.

    Don't worry, you smug southerners, Georgie Boy's economic policies mean that the food banks are coming your way soon!

    And what is so bad about the north? I love it - and would rather eat my own testicles than live in the south east.

    And we have already said said that we do not want "a Boris" in our towns and cities - especially after his anti-northern comments!

  • rate this

    Comment number 56.

    Why Manchester? Bradford has already a 95% link to both Delhi and Mumbai. Just build a brand new airport there and that will help ease the air traffic from the London airports by about 60%.
    Newcastle? WAY I MAN! Hmm? OK! Moving on...

  • rate this

    Comment number 55.

    54 Paul - we may not have much talent, but at least we can spell it

  • rate this

    Comment number 54.

    I am fed up with hearing how hard done by the North is. They have had lots of industries moved there from the south.They have had massive investment by the labour party when in power to the detriment of the south. It is expensive to live in the south and we have major work problems here too. if it is thought so good down here why arnt you moving here ? Some of my family have moved north for jobs !

  • rate this

    Comment number 53.

    I would like to see prosperity in the North, or anywhere in the UK for that matter. Manufacturing has disappeared in the South, replaced by "service" industries. gamblers on money markets, or importers of China tat. The North should be encouraged to expand its manufacturing and innovative skills base.

  • rate this

    Comment number 52.

    If there is so much tallent and dormant prosperity in the north, i hardly see why the north can't unlock it itself. Braying about things that happened 30 years ago is hardly reason enough to not do something about it now. You want to mine coal? That carbon polutant based industry is going the way of the Loom and the Knitting factory. Public service payroll isn't the answer either.

  • rate this

    Comment number 51.

    @48 Ex Tory Voter

    'Quite. If that was their attitude who would want to work for them!'

    There's always some excuse for doing nothing.


Page 1 of 4



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.