Rotherham by-election: Do independents have a prayer?

Denis MacShane The by-election was sparked by the resignation of Labour's Denis MacShane on 2 November

Related Stories

Without a party machine, usually self-funded and probably inexperienced at campaigning, most independents standing in parliamentary by-elections know they haven't got a prayer.

There is no way I could possibly say that about Simon Copley.

That's because he's an ordained clergyman who was so angered at the scandal of his local MP Denis MacShane wrongfully claiming expenses that he's putting himself forward as the "honesty candidate" to replace him.

The likeable clergyman is out to make a point but even he was surprised to find a national bookmakers giving him better odds for the South Yorkshire seat than either of the two candidates standing for the coalition parties.

"I don't usually bet but it might be worth a flutter," he told me.

It's unlikely the bookies are going to lose their shirts. Neither Conservatives nor Liberal Democrats have come anywhere near winning this seat in the eight decades it has returned a Labour MP. They came second and third in the 2010 general election but they were a very long way behind.

Labour inherits a 10,000 majority, but is still taking no chances.

High-profile candidates

The party's national executive engineered what it called a "clean break candidate". It refused to shortlist a local Labour councillor and provoked an unprecedented walkout by supporters of a local Rotherham councillor who had been seen as the favourite to become the candidate.

That embarrassing split lasted just a few hours, with the rebels now saying they've made their point and are out supporting Sarah Champion who has made her name in the town as chief executive of a local children's hospice.

Even so, Labour is pouring in support with no fewer than eight MPs turning up for a single campaigning event - including all three winners from by-elections held just 48 hours earlier in Manchester, Corby and Cardiff.

UKIP and Respect are also fielding high-profile women as their candidates.

But Respect will still be relying heavily on its winner from the Bradford West by-election earlier this year. Former Fleet Street journalist Yvonne Ridley, who has stood for the party in the past, will be described on the ballot paper as the Respect (George Galloway) candidate.

UKIP has chosen its regional organiser Jane Collins as candidate. She hit the headlines in 2011 when she unexpectedly came second in a by-election in the neighbouring Labour stronghold of Barnsley. UKIP's vote across the country has been growing but the anti-EU party has yet to win anything in Yorkshire since its seat in the European Parliament in 2009.

The far-right BNP is fielding the candidate who took 10% of the vote in the 2010 general election against Denis MacShane. But anti-immigration candidate Marlene Guest is struggling under a double handicap.

A large chunk of her party's activists have defected to the English Democrats over the past few months and, of those that remain, not a single one would agree to be filmed pushing pamphlets through letterboxes.

The rest of this long field is made up of the English Democrats, a Trade Union Socialist, another independent and someone calling himself Clint Bristow, who has not described himself as anything on the official nomination papers.

He's Brian Bristow, the South Yorkshire organiser of the far right campaign group the EDL.

Len Tingle Article written by Len Tingle Len Tingle Political editor, Yorkshire

Leon Brittan and the miners who would never forgive him

Three decades on, miners have not forgotten how Leon Brittan used the police to stop the pickets.

Read full article

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 8.

    It is apparent to me that the main reason independents find it difficult to be elected is the mere reason that they are standing on their own, but f you look at what the individual stands for, often the independent is more for the people than any other candidate, And often the area is loyal to a particular party, putting the individual at a landslide of difficulties.

  • rate this

    Comment number 7.

    It's unsurprising the blunder made by Rotherham MBC given the confusion of two far-right active local organisations EDL/BNP. As UKIP and EL only have issues with councils spending hard cash themselves on not teaching English but just promoting other cultures, saying leave that for charities that's fine. It's time for people in Rotherham to call anyone supporting the first TWO racist!

  • rate this

    Comment number 6.

    Let's see how well UKIP does in Rotherham. From the sudden interest, due in no small part to Rotherham MBC's approach to the 'Adoption' row, UKIP's had unparalleled free publicity. Labour is riven by internecine strife, Conservatives are few and far between, LDP has no local presence worthy of the name- so UKIP is in with a reasonable chance. And then up to 8 Conservative MPs might jump over...

  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    The Rotherham voters better make sure they vote for the right political party, the labour / communist / lesbian / loonies or the social workers will take their kids away. Stalin would be proud of theses clowns.

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    Give them a chance, they can not do any worse than the main parties. It might actually be a refreshing change, especially if they turn out honest, trustworthy and actually work for the majority of the people.


Comments 5 of 8



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.