Horden shootings family campaigns for gun law changes

Susan McGoldrick, Alison Turnbull and Tanya Turnbull Left-to-right, Susan McGoldrick, Alison Turnbull and Tanya Turnbull were shot by Michael Atherton

Related Stories

On New Year's Day 2012 David Rowe confronted a scene of unimaginable horror.

He found his partner, her daughter and his partner's sister dead or dying from gunshot wounds at a house in Horden in County Durham.

Next to them was their killer - taxi driver Michael Atherton - who had also turned the shotgun on himself.

Devastating impact

Atherton's murder of his partner Susan McGoldrick, as well as David's partner Alison Turnbull and her 24-year-old daughter Tanya caused shock not just in the community but nationally.

Although the killings may no longer be front page news, David and the rest of the family are still living with their devastating impact.

But there is one thing they are now focused on; they want changes to the firearms regulations and laws to prevent further needless deaths.

They have been collecting signatures for a petition both locally and on the UK Parliament site.

David Rowe is concerned that changes first proposed in 2011 after the Derrick Bird shootings in Cumbria still have not been implemented.

He believes if they had been, Michael Atherton's three victims could still be alive.

Start Quote

David Rowe

The longer this is dragged out the more likely it is that another family could suffer as we did”

End Quote David Rowe Partner of Alison Turnbull

He said: "The longer this is dragged out the more likely it is that another family could suffer as we did. They need to hurry up.

"I'd hate for anyone to go through what we went through because it is the worst feeling ever.

"When you find out it could have been prevented it is a terrible blow because you know the people you love the most in the world could still be here if mistakes hadn't been made.

"That's why we want those mistakes correcting."

Case for change

The inquests into the Horden shootings have yet to take place and until they do a report into the gun licensing issues will not be published.

But the family does not want to wait for change, and nor does their MP Grahame Morris.

He has taken up the case for change in the Commons.

In a debate this week the Labour MP for Easington questioned why anyone should be allowed to have a shotgun.

He said: "It is difficult for many, including me, to comprehend why someone would need access to firearms in a domestic setting when there is little need for immediate access to a weapon.

"I am not opposed to shooting per se. I am saying that people should be able to demonstrate a clear legitimate need before a firearms certificate or shotgun licence is issued."

Grahame Morris Easington MP Grahame Morris calls for tighter gun laws during a Commons debate

He also outlined the changes he and the family would like to see:

1) Anyone applying for a shotgun should have to demonstrate they have a good reason to own one;

2) The authorities should automatically check with GPs on the medical fitness of applicants;

3) Partners and ex-partners of applicants over the previous two years should have to sign the application form - if not a further investigation will be triggered;

4) A new single licensing authority should take over firearms applications from police forces to ensure consistent rules are applied.

Bureaucratic hurdles

That last recommendation does have the support of people who represent firearm licence holders but they are nervous about some of the other proposals.

Alasdair Mitchell, from the British Association for Shooting and Conservancy, said: "We do have concerns about a couple of the ideas. You can imagine what problems could be caused by consulting spouses and ex-partners of applicants.

"The problem of unnecessary bureaucratic hurdles is they soak up precious resources and divert police attention from the real issue of assessing the suitability of people into chasing red herrings."

The government also appears to be cautious.

Start Quote

Damian Green

The UK has comparatively low levels of gun crime, and some of the strictest gun laws in the world”

End Quote Damian Green MP Policing Minister

Policing Minister Damian Green told the Commons that if the rules were tightened too much it could prevent legitimate gun users getting a licence.

He said: "It is generally recognised that the UK has comparatively low levels of gun crime, and some of the strictest gun laws in the world.

"Applying a good reason test... could be problematic. Unlike target shooters, shotgun owners do not always belong to clubs that could vouch that they had shot regularly."

He also rejected plans for a single licensing authority, although he said measures were being put in place to ensure consistent standards were applied by different forces.

The minister also said the laws would be looked at again once the report on the Horden shootings was published.

Measured and sensible

The Horden victims' family and Grahame Morris insist they are not looking for hasty or ill thought-out measures, but they do think action is needed soon.

They say they have spent months considering what measures could prevent other families suffering the same horror, and believe their suggestions are measured and sensible.

David Rowe says Christmas and new year will always now be tainted by the shootings, the trauma he experienced, and the loss he suffered.

But as the anniversary of the shootings draws closer, it seems he and the rest of the family will have to redouble their efforts to achieve the changes they want.

Richard Moss Article written by Richard Moss Richard Moss Political editor, North East & Cumbria

Push on for city powers - but what about the voters?

England's big cities look likely to get more powers - but how much influence will their voters get?

Read full article

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 7.

    Blanket ban's have never worked in the past, and despite the lies and smears from political opportunists and autocratic Senior Police Officers will not change anything now. Simply decreeing that it is illegal to own a gun will not stop a nutter from buying a .44 Magnum in a back street pub. People’s safety should not be prioritised by opportunists IMHO - it is too important.

  • rate this

    Comment number 6.

    A shotgun is a tool just like any other used in the country. Using the logic of the 'Ban Everything Brigade' we will have to ban private ownership of cars and vans as they are used as a weapon much more often than legally held guns. Have a look at the recent case in Cardiff of a van driver who used his vehicle as a weapon.

  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    A study of most of the tragic high profile shootings with authorised firearms over the past decades will most likely reveal police failings in not heeding warnings or as in this case returning guns to someone who had made threats in the past - as pointed out by Captain Fantastic. It is police procedures that need tightening and this I believe was addressed by the recent Select Committee.

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    I have every sympathy for the family of the deceased. However, the MP is clearly unware of the hoops that gun owners have to jump through to justify posession. The laws are already very tight. Better to ask why Atherton, a man with anger issues, who had already had his guns taken off him because of threats to kill and then returned, was granted possesion in the first place.

  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    Another MP's gut reaction, perhaps he should take the time to understand the current law, before making ill conceived statements. How can you enforce an Ex partner signing an application, how would they know you had an ex? A single licensing authority would be a disaster, no local knowledge, no continuity with the officers and operated from a call centre, that would work wouldn't it?

  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    Not mentioned is that Atherton held a firearm certificate for his rifles, which require a "good reason". The idea of having former partners countersigning the form comes from Canada, but can be evaded by lying on the form. Having a national agency is a good idea but the police always oppose it. But can you imagine going to the local police for a driving licence or pilots licence, very outdated.

  • rate this

    Comment number 1.

    G Morris's comments on gun control show how stupid people can be, most of what he suggests already happens. UK gun controls are already some of the tightest in Europe. People who want to kill others will do so with whatever they have available, would he have all kitchen implements banned or controlled or have people justify their right to have them? I am not trying to be little this tragic event.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.