Onshore turbines: A new policy wind of change?

Wind turbines Lincolnshire is introducing new planning curbs to block onshore wind turbines

Like the church spire and the electricity pylon, they've fast become a 21st Century landmark of the English countryside.

There are now an estimated 3,200 onshore wind turbines, many of them in so-called wind farms.

But does a decision by Lincolnshire County Council indicate a significant brake on further expansion?

The Conservative-run council has drawn up tough new planning guidelines to curb having any more wind turbines.

Forest of turbines?

Lincolnshire has been a dream location for the turbine operators.

The county is flat, rural and - thanks to its north sea coastline - it's pretty windy.

But Cllr Martin Hill, the county council's leader, has had enough.

Start Quote

Our county is fast becoming a forest of wind turbines”

End Quote Cllr Martin Hill Leader, Lincolnshire County Council

He says there are already 75, and dozens more turbine applications are in the planning pipeline.

"Our county is fast becoming a forest of wind turbines. Our planning guidance is an attempt to put an end to that," he said.

But will other councils follow suit?

The contrast with neighbouring Nottinghamshire couldn't be greater. It's handling just six turbine planning applications, four of those for wind farms.

As a spokesman told me: "We are planning no guidance on wind turbines at the moment and have no plans for the foreseeable future."

Lincolnshire's decision will be controversial.

It's not a planning authority as such. It's the local district councils that handle each planning application.

Refusal on the basis of the county's guidance will spark costly legal appeals.

Turbine tensions

The Green Party is angry.

It cites a recent opinion poll that claims seven in ten people actually want more onshore wind turbines, not less.

Start Quote

Wind turbines

Inefficient and intermittent energy production.... typifies onshore wind turbines”

End Quote Chris Heaton-Harris MP for Daventry

The Lib Dems will also be looking very closely at whether Lincolnshire becomes a standard bearer for other Tory-led shire councils.

The issue increasingly goes to the heart of Conservative opposition to onshore wind turbines.

There's been back bench pressure in the Commons on David Cameron.

Northamptonshire Tory, Chris Heaton-Harris, has led the charge for tougher planning restrictions.

He organised a letter signed by 100 Conservative MPs that urged the Prime Minister to rethink the coalition's whole approach.

"In these financially straightened times, we think it is unwise to make consumers pay, through taxpayer subsidy, for the inefficient and intermittent energy production that typifies onshore wind turbines," said the Daventry MP in his letter.

The Treasury, always on the lookout for new budget savings, may agree.

Renewable targets

But what about the Liberal Democrat who is the coalition's Energy and Climate Change Secretary?

Could Ed Davey have some political wriggle room?

I've seen figures that show Britain may soon exceed its targets for renewable energy from onshore wind turbines.

According to energy lobbyists Renewable UK, a modern turbine can generate enough electricity to power 1,400 homes for a year.

Existing wind turbines and projects already approved will surpass the government's current renewable targets, according to some energy experts.

If the onshore political wind is blowing in a new direction, it could well be coming from Lincolnshire.

John Hess Article written by John Hess John Hess Political editor, East Midlands

Government face legal challenge on rural homes change

Ministers face a legal challenge from rural councils wanting to ensure more affordable homes.

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 6.

    The greens pointed out that 7 in 10 people want more wind turbines, not 1 in 7. We have the best wind resource in Europe: on the days that local turbines aren't generating the wind will be blowing somewhere else and the national grid is designed to move electricity from where it is generated to where it is used. The visual impact of turbines will be nothing compared to the impact of climate change

  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    When will people stop mixing up Wind Turbines and Wind Farms? A Wind Farm needs Wind Turbines but it takes many Wind Turbines to make a Wind Farm. If every farm or school had a small turbine we wouldnt need Wind Farms

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    A basic question no one seems to want to answer, where do we get our electricity from when the wind doesn't blow?

  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    When potential wind farm neighbours research actual impacts rather than claims, the industry rhetoric changes from words like “graceful” and “gentle rustling of trees” to “reaching targets”, “legal process” and “confidentiality clauses” (gagging). It’s amazing these adverse impacts are still not being discussed freely in the media, despite the numbers affected world-wide

  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    We are in danger of creating a countryside full of these ugly things. The whole lot should be scrapped and a ban should be placed on erecting giant wind generators over 30 feet high.

    I think it's rather ironic that the Greens are angry - they are complicit in destroying what countryside we have left by urging the creation of more of these wind farms.


Comments 5 of 6



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.