Budget paves way for public sector postcode pay freezes

George Osborne MP The chancellor says government departments can move to local pay bargaining for staff

Related Stories

Like much of the Budget, the chancellor's decision to press ahead with local public sector pay bargaining was heavily leaked.

In the end it only merited a few sentences in George Osborne's speech, but they were enough to suggest many public sector workers could face years of wage freezes.

The chancellor has told government departments they can move to local pay bargaining when the overall public sector salary freeze begins to end next year.

Trade unions believe that will lead to growing inequality as salaries in some parts of the country are frozen while others get pay rises.

More jobs

We now know more about the government's case though, as George Osborne has published the evidence he has presented to the public sector pay review bodies.

It claims local pay will increase the quality of public services, help the private sector create more jobs and save the government money.

The Treasury's long-term aim is to tackle what it says is a public sector premium.

According to the Institute for Fiscal Studies, public sector workers nationally earn around 8% more than staff in the private sector.

But there are huge variations, with workers paid on average 18% more in Wales and 13% more in Scotland.

In England, Yorkshire and Humber and the East have the biggest premiums of 13% with the North East not far behind on almost 12%.

Man putting money in his pocket Local bargaining will see public sector workers paid according to where they work in the country

In fact, according to the figures, only male public sector workers in the South East are paid less than their private sector equivalents.

If the government is intent on wiping out that premium, it seems inevitable pay rates in some regions might have to be frozen for years to come.

Stigmatised regions

There are concerns even within government about that. Business Secretary Vince Cable told me at the Lib Dem spring conference he feared regional public sector pay would stigmatise the North East.

But the chancellor insists this will be local and not regional pay bargaining, with pay differentials often emerging within regions.

In its evidence, the Treasury says the local pay system introduced into the Ministry of Justice and Courts Service by Labour could be a model of how it will work in other departments.

That system has pay zones. It has led to higher rates for staff in London and the South East, but it also rewards staff in what it calls "wage hotspots". Most of those are also in the South East but they do include the likes of Bristol, Birmingham and Merseyside.

But in England, no hotspots are found north of Manchester, and so this system could still leave a whole region like the North East out in the cold.

Start Quote

This is the latest attack on the North East from a chancellor who doesn't know or care about our region's economy or public services”

End Quote Kevin Rowan Northern TUC

Unions and Labour MPs have been particularly venomous about that idea, saying it will produce postcode pay freezes.

The TUC estimates just a one-year 1% drop in public sector salaries will take £78m out of the North East's economy.

Kevin Rowan, from the Northern TUC, said: "This is the latest attack on the North East from a chancellor who doesn't know or care about our region's economy or public services.

"This policy would have a devastating impact on the region's households, retailers and set our economy back further. We fear this figure could increase 10-fold in a matter of years if the government gets its way."

Protest letter

The 26 North East Labour MPs have also written an open letter protesting.

In it they say: "The Government's proposals will lead to different wage rates between regions and possibly within the region.

"The North-South divide will grow and the least prosperous areas of the country will be the hardest hit, demand will be sucked out of the local economy as the money will not be there to spend - impacting on jobs in the private sector."

But that's where there is a huge difference of opinion with the chancellor.

Much of the Treasury's case for local pay is based on the money it would save. Some is based on evidence that it could produce better quality public services.

Public sector workers marching Public sector workers in the North East have already protested about pensions change and pay freezes

But the chancellor also believes it could boost private sector growth in places like the North East.

He argues the private sector is "crowded out" because it can't compete with high public sector wages.

Remove the pay differential, and he believes the private sector would be more likely to expand.

It's a theory that is completely rejected by the opponents of local pay bargaining, and the Treasury doesn't quote any detailed evidence in its submission to back it up.

There are though some within business who do say it is a factor.

Nurses and teachers

It will take a long time until we find out who is right.

In reality, the decision to press ahead with local pay bargaining will take a long time to play out, possibly a decade or more.

We also don't know yet whether the pay review bodies for the likes of nurses and teachers will choose to adopt it or stick to national agreements.

But all the current headlines might be causing nervousness in Lib Dem and Conservative MPs in regions like the North East.

Conspicuously, none of them have as yet backed this idea, and they must be worried that they could face the backlash if we begin to see some regions becoming poor relations in terms of public sector pay.

Richard Moss, Political editor, North East & Cumbria Article written by Richard Moss Richard Moss Political editor, North East & Cumbria

Campaign for Miners' Strike inquiry

Pressure is growing for a Hillsborough-style inquiry into the Miners' Strike and an amnesty for those convicted of crimes.

Read full article

More on This Story

Related Stories


Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 1.

    This is a completely flawed idea in every regard without any evidence or even convincing logic to support it. Then we get to points like, what happened to the defence of wage differentials the tories always cite, such as - if you want the best you have to pay a premium etc. I'm a Probation Officer and I don't know if I am affected by this. I get £28000 per year in Bradford. Oooh aren't I greedy.

  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    If this will take 10 years to implement, and let's be honest that is not long enough. Perhaps MP's could lead the way and prove the theory, by taking the pay cuts, as I am sure that they are not paid the average wage of the areas they represent, Or will they use their london addresses that every taxpayer is forced to pay for.

  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    The Unions should refuse to negotiate unless on a national basis. This is classic divide and rule and it should be resisted at all cost. I am in a union but I'm not active I intend to become active. This is the slow burner within the budget over time it will disadvantage whole areas of the country and lower the living standards of millions.

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    So far as I can tell this plan is another way of forcing a wedge to open the country to yet further private sector infiltration. They're doing it with education and now it seems to me, with very little imagination needed, that this will leave private sector finance as the only funding source available. Instead of tinkering why don't we just find a corporation and sell them the country?

  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    23 million private sector workers aided and abetted by the governement continue to feather bed 6 million public sector workers. Why? Teachers etc are incredibly relatively well paid in places like Lincolnshire where you can buy a house for under £100k. This totally distorts the local labour market and then people wonder why these places are overall 'poor' with high unemployment?


Comments 5 of 13


This entry is now closed for comments


  • Spanner CrabEdible images

    Are these the best food photographs of the past year?

  • Beckford's TowerFolly or fact?

    The unlikely debt capital of Britain

  • European starlingBird-brained

    How 60 starlings multiplied into a nightmare flock of 200 million

  • Observatory in Chile with sun in the backgroundStar struck

    Why tourists are flocking to Chile's observatories

  • Two people using sign language Signing out

    The decline of regional dialects for the deaf

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.