Cold War ends except in North Yorkshire

'Guided walk' around Menwith Hill electronic defence base CND chair Dave Webb leads a 'guided walk' around Menwith Hill electronic defence base

Peace groups thought the end of the Cold War and the election of Barack Obama would see American military bases in the UK pack up and head for home.

In North Yorkshire exactly the opposite has happened.

This week two new giant 'golf balls' at Europe's biggest electronic defence base at RAF Menwith Hill near Harrogate are thought to be within weeks of becoming fully operational.

It marks a major expansion of the role of the base which has been seen as the electronic 'eyes and ears' of NATO since the early 1960s.

A spectacular array of infra-red, radar and digital monitoring systems has gradually been developed to do everything from tracking hostile missile launches to checking mobile telephone calls for the communications of potential terrorist groups.

Command and control

Each of the 'golf balls' is really a shell which houses revolving dishes able to intercept transmissions or detect hostile military activities.

It is thought around 2,200 Americans operate the equipment and analyse the data it collects.

They are either US military personnel or experts from the National Security Agency.

Golf balls number 31 and 32 are different.

They are the "command and control" systems for a new defensive screen of US missiles installed hundreds of miles away in former Eastern bloc countries.

As the threat of the former Soviet Union has evaporated the missiles are thought to be a deterrent against "rogue" regimes such as North Korea and Syria.

Economic espionage

There are those who believe the activities in the base are far wider than mere military defence.

Lindis Percy is one of them.

In her yellow high visibility jacket emblazoned with the words CAAB - Coalition for the Accountability of American Bases, the veteran peace campaigner stages a protest meeting at the base gates every Tuesday evening.

Lindis Percy of CAAB Lindis Percy of CAAB-Coalition for the Accountability of American Bases

It is hard to believe that the polite, late middle-aged, former NHS midwife from Harrogate has been jailed in the past for scaling the wire fences in attempts to unlock Menwith Hill's secrets.

"It is an American base serving American interests," she told me in an interview for the Politics Show for Yorkshire and Lincolnshire.

"It used to be focussed on the detection of missiles launches and terrorism but now there is a great deal of attention on the economic threat from countries like China.

"The Americans monitor every conceivable communications system across the world and share the odd morsel with our government but this is all about American commercial interests."

'Guided walk'

The Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament is also so concerned about the base that it held part of this year's annual conference by the main gate and then went on what must be the most unusual "guided walk".

CND's national chairman, Dave Webb, megaphone in hand, pointed out the "sights" as the 100-strong crocodile of walkers strolled around the perimeter of the base on a network of ancient rights of way.

"It just should not be here in this glorious English countryside," he told me.

"We are told it is for defence but it is just another form of increasing the arms race.

"We have published our own printed guide to Menwith Hill because we feel people need to know what is happening here."

The RAF now publishes a limited amount of information about it on its own website.

It says: "RAF Menwith Hill is an integral part of the US DoD world-wide defence communications network. Its primary mission is to provide intelligence support for UK, US and allied interests."

Political division

The base has plenty of political support from all sides of the house.

Successive governments have made brief statements in reply to parliamentary questions stressing its importance.

Test launch of new US defence missile located in Eastern Europe but controlled from Yorkshire New US defensive missile screen in Eastern Europe with "command and control" centre in Yorkshire

Labour MP for York Central, Hugh Bayley, a member of the parliamentary NATO liaison committee, agrees it is an important factor in the defence of the UK and that it is a logical place to locate the "command and control" centre for the new missile screen.

However, other Yorkshire Labour MPs are far from satisfied.

"Just image if the tables were reversed," says Leeds North East MP, Fabian Hamilton.

"Would the Americans allow the UK to build a base on their soil without Congress and senators being told exactly what is going on there?

"I have asked numerous questions about Menwith Hill and information is rarely forthcoming."

Outside the gates the local community says it has no problem with its American neighbours.

One local farmer told me that they have even been invited to Thanksgiving dinner on the base.

"You are OK as long as you don't ask them what they actually do," he told me.

Len Tingle, Political editor, Yorkshire Article written by Len Tingle Len Tingle Political editor, Yorkshire

Ballot boxes for national parks?

The Queen's Speech contained a brief reference to government plans that could see the biggest change to how the national parks are run in the six decades since they were set up.

Read full article


Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 1.

    Given that CND would have left the country defenceless against Soviet aggression during the Cold War, their unsurprising opposition to Menwith Hill reinforces my view that its presence is both necessary and beneficial. What particular quirk of psychology makes these people want to side with our enemies rather than our allies?

  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    I've lived in the shadow of this base all my life. What happens in there is a far cry from life in Nidderdale and the surrounding area. Should it close, there would be dire results for the local economy etc.
    This base is unlikely to be a prime target due to its advance warning defence systems. Since when have we seen a major attack on a large military base in the UK, even through the Cold War?

  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    Given the dangerous nature of the world at the moment, I would have thought that the more information we can get, the better. The attitude of these pointless groups just shows how out of touch they are with the current world.

    CND has not achieved anything in its history, and most people think they ceased to exist years ago - perhaps they ought to have done!

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    American Bases in the UK serve only american interest not think America would let Britain build bases in Alaska ? or give Britain some sort of Tariff preferences in exchange for the bases ? NO CHANCE

    Syria ? North Korea ? dont make me laugh,they have nothing against the UK. the us has plenty of bases in south korea

    the world is a very safe group, small local terror conflicts only

  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    Well it's not exactly doing any harm being there if anything it's beneficial to the local economy. It's a capability that if the Americans didn't put it here we'd build it. So I don't see the problem as long as they don't make a habit of it of course.


Comments 5 of 24


This entry is now closed for comments


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.