Call for coroner to resign over Teesside inquest delays

Margo Wright Margo Wright had to wait 14 months for an inquest into her daughter Mandi's death in 2001

It's been almost 10 years since Margo Wright lost her daughter Mandi.

She collapsed and died at her home in Middlesbrough - aged just 32.

There was no obvious explanation for the death of a young mother in apparently perfect health.

For that reason an inquest had to be held.

But that just added to Margo Wright's agony. It took 14 months for it to take place.

Few answers

She said: "It's month after month after month of not knowing. You start asking yourself were there drugs involved, has someone hurt her?"

Start Quote

It's awful the pain you go through not knowing and wanting answers - and if it was one of his children, would he let it go 14 months? I don't think so”

End Quote Margo Wright Bereaved mother

In the end, there were few solid answers. It was put down to Sudden Adult Death Syndrome - a catch-all description for unexplained deaths.

But Margo was angry that the Teesside coroner Michael Sheffield had taken so long to complete the investigation.

And she was not alone. At the time, bereaved families were waiting up to two years for inquests in Teesside.

MPs called on Michael Sheffield to resign and forced an investigation by the Lord Chancellor's office.

Mr Sheffield kept his job but was severely reprimanded.

But 10 years on, MPs are again concerned about delays to inquests in Teesside.

New investigation

The average waiting time from death to inquest has gone from 33 weeks in 2009, to 43 weeks last year.

That compares to a national average waiting time of 27 weeks in England. And in the neighbouring district of Hartlepool, the coroner takes just 20 weeks.

Stockton North MP Alex Cunningham says the Lord Chancellor should begin a new investigation.

Michael Sheffield MPs say Teesside coroner Michael Sheffield should consider his position if he cannot cut waiting times for inquests

He said: "My concern is for the families of loved ones. They've lost relatives and they're very keen for the inquest to be completed.

"Something has to be done. It's no good Mr Sheffield making excuses. He should really pull his finger out and make something happen or consider his position."

Margo Wright goes even further. She says he should have been sacked 10 years ago, and certainly should be now.

She points to his age. He's now 81.

Wanting answers

She said: "He should have left when he was known as a good person but now he's got all these people waiting again trying to find out why their loved ones died.

"It's awful the pain you go through not knowing and wanting answers. And if it was one of his children, would he let it go 14 months? I don't think so."

Start Quote

It's a postcode lottery at the moment - you can have a waiting time of 10 months in this particular jurisdiction and a similar death could be heard in the area next door much, much earlier”

End Quote Helen Shaw Co-director, Inquest

And what of Mr Sheffield? I encountered him while filming outside his office in Middlesbrough.

He said he didn't have time to do an interview and couldn't because he is an officer of the court.

But when I asked him whether he would resign, he said: "Why should I?", and he urged the MPs to check their facts.

His office has told the local newspaper that a withdrawal of police resources has caused delays - something Cleveland Police has rejected.

But many people will be surprised that he is still allowed to hold the post well after the state pension age.

But there is no mandatory retirement age for coroners, and only the Lord Chancellor's office can dismiss one.

Unacceptable delays

Some campaigners though say it's time to reform the whole system.

The charity Inquest helps families through the process. But it says waiting times are unacceptable in many parts of the country.

Helen Shaw, its co-director, said: "It's a postcode lottery at the moment. You can have a waiting time of 10 months in this particular jurisdiction and a similar death could be heard in the area next door much, much earlier.

"What really needs to happen is an improved service across the board."

The charity and some MPs and peers are also concerned about government plans to abolish the office of chief coroner - a post introduced two years ago to try and reform the system and cut waiting times.

They fear the plight of families will only get worse if the job is scrapped.

And the scars left behind by delays can last a long time too. Margo Wright is still angry at the way her family was treated.

And she believes an inquest process that is supposed to offer explanations and comfort, just added to her grief and pain.

Waiting times for inquests are unacceptable in many parts of the country says the charity, Inquest

Richard Moss Article written by Richard Moss Richard Moss Political editor, North East & Cumbria

Pacer trains may 'still have role' in North of England

The Prime Minister said they were history but 30-year-old Pacer trains may not disappear from the North's railways

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 11.

    Thank you for your comments so far. It's clear there are people who do appreciate Mr Sheffield's work.

    It is important to conduct an inquest correctly and not rush it. The issue about delays is strain on families, but also whether it they can prevent valuable lessons being learned quickly enough.

    Delays to inquests are growing nartinally but as I said they are worse than average in Teesside.

  • rate this

    Comment number 10.

    if the man is capable of doing his job then why should he leave,there has been no incompetence in his work that i know of except people saying he takes to long,well does it really matter if its 6 or 10 family and i were very happy with the way he dealt with my brothers inquest.i trust him 100% over cleveland police because as far as i am concern they didnt do their job correctly.

  • rate this

    Comment number 9.

    I'm afraid we are all going to come across more and more workers over the "pension age" as it would be age discrimination to dismiss someone because of their age. Instead of saying, "Oh well, he's retiring soon", now we are going to have to take "incompetence" action on them, then chuck them on the dole to sign on at 67. (Check your pension age on Directgov State pension age calculator)

  • rate this

    Comment number 8.

    "She points to his age. He's now 81"
    Why does his age matter? It's whether he can do the job that's important. Judging by most of the comments, he can.

  • rate this

    Comment number 7.

    adam does it really matter wether it takes 6 or 11 months for an inquest aslong as it is dealt with correctly.

  • Comment number 6.

    This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    When a friend of mine died in unexplained circumstances last year, it took less than six months for the inquest to take place.

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    i just seen news i think u all wanna get a bigger story line he do's his job and if he rushed it and came out with wron verdict then would u be happy i think you all wana too look at the god this man done

  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    i think they wanna leave him alone i mean do they want a rush job or the truth look at the lies off coppers

  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    i think the police should be looked into aswell because they didnt look into my brothers death very well but Mr Sheffield listened and believed in us and the reports and i would like to thank him for that along with everyone else involved except the police as i dont feel we were treated fair from the day my brother died.

  • rate this

    Comment number 1.

    Mr Sheffield may be old but i thought he done a good job with my brothers inquest,i cant see how there can be a time limit on inquests when they are not all the took 11 mth for my brothers inquest and i was pleased with the verdict as i dont think that was the verdict they wanted but Mr Sheffield i found to be fair and listened to all



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.