Eric Pickles: I protected North East from bigger cuts


Eric Pickles insists he has 'gone out of his way' to give extra help to Tyneside.

To many council leaders in the North East he's the axeman, the devil incarnate, the man responsible for the cuts which have caused such pain.

But on his visit to Tyneside, Eric Pickles insisted he had gone out of his way to give extra help to the region.

The Communities Secretary even told me he'd taken money away from wealthier areas in the south to help out poorer councils in the north.

He said: "I made the system more progressive by adjusting the formula for need rather than just per head of population.

"And I introduced some transitional relief for areas like the North East which they wouldn't have got under the cuts Labour planned to certain grants.

Start Quote

I am in a hurry, I'll confess that, but maybe I should be giving out a bit more love in the future”

End Quote Eric Pickles MP Communities Secretary

"So I have gone out of my way to help an area like this."

Disgruntled politicians

That's not the perception of many council leaders though.

Eric Pickles met with South Tyneside Council leader Iain Malcolm during his visit.

And Iain Malcolm said he was going to tell the Secretary of State exactly how disgruntled the North East's politicians are with him.

He said: "When Eric Pickles leaves South Tyneside and the North East, he will be under no illusion about the depth of feeling in the area about the local government settlement he negotiated with the Treasury.

"When South Tyneside residents lose £250 per head in government grant, and yet rich and prosperous areas like Maidenhead, Windsor, and Kensington and Chelsea lose less than £5 per head, it is unfair and unjust."

Eric Pickles Eric Pickles at British Telecom office under construction in South Shields .

So who's right?

Well, both are in a way.

Government grant

Councils in the North East are more dependent on government grants, so a 20% cut in the grant will certainly take more money out of South Tyneside than Maidenhead.

But Eric Pickles argues that the larger government grant is already there to compensate poorer areas.

He is also right to point out that he did cushion the blow for some councils by capping the amount they could lose.

Start Quote

When Eric Pickles leaves South Tyneside, he will be under no illusion about the depth of local feeling on the settlement ”

End Quote Cllr Iain Malcolm Leader, South Tyneside Council

Without that intervention, councils like South Tyneside and Middlesbrough would have lost even more money - but as they still lost more than any other councils in the country, it was of little comfort.

Mind you, it's not just Labour councillors in the North East who are upset with Mr Pickles.

The Politics Show has been speaking to Cumbria County Council leader Eddie Martin.

He's a Conservative but is still exasperated with the Communities Secretary. Cllr Martin compares Mr Pickles to a steamroller, with no empathy for the pain the cuts have caused.

More money

That was something I put to Mr Pickles. He promised rather ominously to give Mr Martin a call soon. But he did try and be conciliatory.

He said: "I am in a hurry, I'll confess that, but maybe I should be giving out a bit more love in the future."

I'm guessing the councils might prefer more money!

And there may be more battles ahead.

At a dinner at the end of his visit, Mr Pickles confirmed his enthusiasm for the localisation of business rates.

Eric Pickles and reporters Eric Pickles faces up to the media during his visit to South Shields.

Rates are currently collected locally but go straight to the Treasury's coffers. Localisation would see councils keep some or all of their locally-raised rates.

Eric Pickles believes that will give councils more independence and extra incentives to attract employers in.

But it's an idea which frightens many northern councils, who fear their lack of a business base could see a massive redistribution of money from the north to the more prosperous south.

Places like Northumberland and Durham could really suffer under full localisation.

Mr Pickles insists there will be a method of helping councils in that position, and they won't suffer.

But for now it does look likely to provoke yet another clash between the Secretary of State and the region.

Richard Moss Article written by Richard Moss Richard Moss Political editor, North East & Cumbria

North East poll backs move of powers to local areas

A new BBC poll suggests people in the North East are the strongest supporters of more powers for local areas.

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    Yes of course Jonathan, it was to redress the previous cuts which resulted in people being unable to correctly spell (e.g. 'waist' instead of waste, incorrect spelling of inefficiency) Babel - 'works sets you free' or 'arbeit macht frei' which I seem to recall was the slogan greeting those who entered Auswhwitz.....

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    People will vote for the party that brings employment to a region!

    If you have a strong region, you need to decide whether you support that region further (becoming excessive support) or assist with growth elsewhere. I don't understand why, when we don't need to dig material out of the ground to make an economy, we cannot have growth in many other regions.

    Surely win/win for govt and people?

  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    @2 Nice to see someone who encourages full unemployment. Labour did it to reduce the figures while abandoning the rest of the unemployed. It was pretty contemptible, but can there be any integrity in politics.
    Now the unemployed are going to get the punishment for the widespread resentment felt against the false council jobs/waste. Work sets you free.

  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    Erik, I support you 100%, Public spending under Labour went through the roof creating a culture of waist and ineficiency. CUT, CUT, AND CUT some more, sharpen that axe CHOP, CHOP, AND CHOP some more. Then we may get back to some sensible councils who spend and think wisely.

  • rate this

    Comment number 1.

    Mr Pickles supports electors in the North East and Cumbria having less power in their vote than electors in devolved parts of the UK. This is not equitable. The new independent website campaigns for a common vote in all UK constituencies.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.