Nick Clegg claims coalition unity on free school meals policy

Nick Clegg in a school dining hall Lib Dem leader Nick Clegg announced the £1bn school meals policy late last year

Related Stories

Nick Clegg has said ministers are at one over plans to give all pupils under seven in England free school meals.

It came after Education Secretary Michael Gove and Lib Dem schools minister David Laws declared they were "not at war", after reports of a rift.

Penning a joint article in the Times newspaper, they said that plans to bring in free school meals from September had "cross-party support".

The deputy PM did not deny reports that he had told them to write it.

Pressed on whether he had ordered the article to be written, Mr Clegg told BBC Radio 4's Today programme: "Of course I want the government in support of a policy that I think is going to make a dramatic difference.

Education Secretary Michael Gove was asked if he "kissed and made up" with Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg

"It's going to save families a lot of money. Every family that has to pay for a school meal for their children is paying about £400 a year."

Recently leaked emails have suggested coalition tensions over funding for school meals, after a former adviser to Mr Gove, Dominic Cummings, criticised the idea as "dumb" and a "bad gimmick".

But the Lib Dem leader said the former adviser had been "wrong" to say the free school meals policy had been put together "on the back of a fag packet".

"We've actually been piloting this for many years," he said.

"The first pilots in Durham and Newham and elsewhere show that not only does it save families money, it has a dramatic educational impact, particularly on children who are poorer and not receiving free school meals at the moment.

"It also has a very significant social impact, because it gets children sharing lunch together during the middle of the school day."

Critics of the policy have questioned whether the cost of providing the food can be met without damaging other core educational aims, like providing school places, and whether enough money has been set aside for upgrading school kitchens to enable them to cope with the increased demand.

In April, a BBC Daily Politics investigation used freedom of information requests to reveal that more than 2,700 schools in England will not be able to start serving the hot school meals on time.

Stephen Watkins, the headteacher of Mill Field Primary School in Leeds, told the Today programme: "We will be providing the free meals in September."

But he said it was "curious" that ministers were claiming the policy was fully funded "when I found out yesterday that... I have to pay 50% of the new extra equipment I'm going to need in my kitchen".

He said: "I don't yet know what that cost is, because they haven't told me."

The sum would "have to come out of the school budget", he said, which he had just spent a fortnight working on, and the unanticipated cost would make it harder to fund some of his other priorities, such as installing wireless internet connections in the school and supplying pupils with tablet computers.

'Last survivors'

In the article, Mr Gove and Mr Laws wrote: "To judge from the latest breathless headlines, you might expect the two of us to be crouched under our desks like the last survivors in a Bruce Willis movie, only popping out occasionally to blast each other with shotguns."

They said the reality of politics was "a lot more prosaic than some like to suggest", adding that, on free school meals, "This is that rarest of political treasures: a policy that has true cross-party support."

David Laws and Michael Gove David Laws and Michael Gove said reporting of their apparent feud had been "breathless"

From September, all Reception, Year 1 and Year 2 children in state-funded schools in England will be entitled to free school meals under the scheme announced by Mr Clegg last autumn.

But leaked emails made public earlier this month revealed that senior officials in the Department for Education had warned that funding the change could mean cutting school places.

In their article, Mr Gove and Mr Laws acknowledged implementing the policy on time would be difficult.

"Some schools will find it easier than others to expand catering services, but at present the overwhelming majority seem to be on track and we are confident the policy will be delivered on time and on budget," they wrote.

Over the weekend senior Conservative and Lib Dem sources strongly criticised each other over education.

Mr Gove was accused of being "ideologically obsessed," while Conservatives said the Liberal Democrats were "pathetic."

But on Wednesday a source close to the Conservative education secretary said "it was time to move on".


More on This Story

Related Stories


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 601.

    The biggest problem facing the future finances of this country is a growing social and welfare bill. Nick Clegg has decided that loading a pointless universal benefit onto the bill is a good idea. He would do better to get irresponsible parents to start looking after the rearing of their kids rather than smoking and gambling away their child benefit. My kids get fed and I look at their homework!

  • rate this

    Comment number 580.

    My children sometimes want a school meal, sometimes a packed lunch, depending on the menu. I am happy to pay for the meal. The hall at school is already full with children eating the school meals, so those bringing sandwiches eat in one of the classrooms. I wonder how they are going to cope with this new policy. They have taken child benefit from the richest, but now bring this in. Bizzarre!

  • rate this

    Comment number 570.

    I can't see what's wrong with free school meals. I don't have children so it will only cost me money.

    Sad truth is parents in any social strata can not all be trusted to always do the right thing, and no child should be at any disadvantage.

    This has nothing to do with political ideology. It's social responsibility.

  • rate this

    Comment number 553.

    I must be missing the point here. Back in the 60s, school dinners cost 1 shilling and everyone sat together and ate a no-choice dinner. It seemed to work. In the 70s we started to get 'choice' and some chose to skive dinners to save money. A French company I deal with still has a sit down, managers and workers, no-choice lunch. It's cohesive. It's not a bad idea just because it's from Clegg.

  • rate this

    Comment number 140.

    My mum worked in a primary school that had a breakfast club, because kids were coming in without being fed. Now there are free lunches. I know there are other factors at play, but what are the parents spending child support on if not to feed their kids? Surely that is the most important issue in raising them, is it not?


Comments 5 of 13


More Politics stories



Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.