Met Police has 'culture of fear', officers say

A police officer walking The report includes criticism that officers are regularly "named and shamed with a league table"

Related Stories

There is a "culture of fear" in the Metropolitan Police because of the "draconian" use of performance targets, a report into the force has said.

It calls some targets "meaningless" and "unrealistic" - and says others are "disguised" by senior officers.

The report was compiled by the Met Police Federation from interviews and surveys with 250 officers.

Scotland Yard denied claims of a "bullying culture" and said it made "no excuses" for valuing performance.

John Tulley, Met Police Federation and Simon Byrne, Met Assistant Commissioner discuss the issue

John Tully, chairman of the Metropolitan Police Federation, said the report painted a "devastating" picture.

'Rock bottom'

He told the BBC's Today programme that officers who missed targets were put on a "hit list", with some facing potential misconduct action.

"It's correct that we are measured on what we do. Whether or not it's an absolute must that there are performance-driven targets I think is questionable," Mr Tully said.

Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe The report has been submitted to Met Commissioner Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe

One officer, he said, told the federation that he had to arrest at least four people a month and that he had to do 10 stop-and-searches, one of which had to have a positive outcome.

The federation chairman said some officers were "at rock bottom" and that they wanted to see some sort of change in management style.

"I think there is need for some change. We need to look at that," Mr Tully added.

"Whether or not it's a full root-and-branch change, I'm not sure. The Met has a long and bright history around serving the people of London and I hope that continues."

The report, submitted to Met Commissioner Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe and other senior officers, follows a warning from Home Secretary Theresa May that police performance targets are making a "comeback".

Mrs May - who has scrapped most centrally-imposed police targets - told a conference in September that performance measures were being reintroduced by some forces as a "security blanket".

As soon as the first bulletin about the federation report had been broadcast I was contacted by a former Met officer.

He'd not been an active federation member - but had risen through the ranks to a senior position in the force. He told me the main reason he'd left was because of a "pervasive" culture of bullying, with too great an emphasis on arrest and stop-and-search targets, to the detriment of neighbourhood policing.

In fact, the report shines a light on practices that I'd heard about anecdotally for several years.

Even taking into account the federation's role, to represent its members and highlight issues of concern, the findings make uncomfortable reading for an organisation already under the spotlight because of the Lawrence case, corruption allegations and claims that crime figures were manipulated.

The report highlighted a number of stop-and-search targets:

  • A 20% arrest rate for stop-and-searches
  • 20% of stop-and-searches should be for weapons
  • 40% for neighbourhood (property) crime
  • 40% for drugs

It also identified targets set for one policing team in 2011:

  • PCs to make one arrest and five stop-and-searches per shift
  • Metropolitan Special Constabulary officers to make one arrest per month and five stop-and-searches per shift
  • Police community support officers (PCSOs) to make five stop-and-accounts per shift and two criminal reports per shift

BBC home affairs correspondent Danny Shaw said the report's findings made "uncomfortable reading" given the Met was already under the spotlight following allegations of corruption and cover-up in the Stephen Lawrence case, and given claims that crime figures had been manipulated.

But Metropolitan Police Assistant Commissioner Simon Byrne accused the federation of "sensationalising" the issue.

Start Quote

Officers believe target-setting is sometimes camouflaged and occasionally its existence is even denied”

End Quote Met Police Federation

He told the Today programme that it was the Met's job to bring down crime and since it had a "more accountable way of doing things", rates were down by nearly 10%.

Mr Byrne said targets were often set at team level, in which supervisors set work rate targets, which he said he approved of.

"The public expects that we are out there to police the streets and keep them safe," he said.

Mr Byrne added that the report missed the bigger point, saying there were no targets for bravery that was seen every day on the force, in which people "put themselves sin the face of danger".

'Constant threat'

He added that there was a small minority that do not like to be held to account because the Met was changing. "People push back a bit when we take that no-nonsense approach," he said.

Start Quote

The Met has a long and bright history around serving the people of London and I hope that continues”

End Quote John Tully Metropolitan Police Federation chairman

The Met Police Federation, which represents about 30,000 officers at the rank chief inspector and below, said "never before" have targets been applied with "such determination" as they currently are in the Met - the UK's biggest force.

One officer told the report: "Every month we are named and shamed with a league table by our supervisors, which does seem very bullying/overbearing."

Another officer refers to a "bullying-type culture".

The report says: "There is evidence of a persistent and growing culture of fear spawned by the vigorous and often draconian application of performance targets, with many officers reporting that they feel almost constantly under threat of being blamed and subsequently punished for failing to hit targets."

But Scotland Yard denied officers were being unfairly pressurised.

In a statement, the force said it was faced with many challenges, but insisted it did not have a bullying culture.

"We make no excuses for having a culture that values performance," it said.

"We have pledged to reduce crime, increase confidence and cut costs. It's a big task and we have a robust framework in place to ensure we achieve this. The public expects no less."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More UK stories

RSS

Features

  • Man with typewriterLove to Patrick

    The official whose over-familiar letters infuriated his boss


  • Man's hands putting ring on woman's fingerName changer

    Why do wives take a man's name after marriage?


  • Person scratching their arm10 things

    Scratching really does make things itch, and other nuggets


  • Corsican flagCorsican mafia

    Are Corsica's days of mafia and militants over?


  • Mobil canopies on the A6 at Red Hill, LeicestershireEnglish heritage

    Zebra crossings to bus stations: unusual listed buildings


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.