Murder 'must not besmirch Royal Marines', Cameron says


David Cameron spoke to marines ahead of Remembrance Sunday

Related Stories

The conviction of a Royal Marine for murdering an injured Afghan insurgent should not "besmirch" the organisation, Prime Minister David Cameron has said.

Speaking to marines at Downing Street, Mr Cameron said the "appalling" case in no way represented the spirit and proud history of the Royal Marines.

The sergeant, identified only as Marine A, was convicted over the shooting of the unknown man in 2011 on Friday.

A retired commander has said he should be shown leniency when he is sentenced.

Addressing a group of serving and former Royal Marines raising funds for the Commando 999 charity, Mr Cameron said the Royal Marines had "one of the proudest histories of any in the world".

"We should not let that single incident besmirch the incredible work the Royal Marines have done, not only over decades but over centuries," he said.

The prime minister also thanked the marines for the "incredible work" they had done in Afghanistan, saying he believed "we will be able to leave that country with our heads held high".

Labour leader Ed Miliband said it was a "tragic" incident and must be dealt with, but the case did not change the "esteem in which our armed forces are held".

'Friends brutalised'

Marine A faces a mandatory life sentence but a minimum term will be set on 6 December.

Maj Gen Julian Thompson, who led 3 Commando Brigade during the Falklands War, said a five-year or 10-year term would be more appropriate than life.

Marines footage The judge released stills from the footage but not the footage itself

He told BBC Radio 4's Today programme the shooting of the Afghan insurgent in Helmand Province was "totally wrong, totally unforgiveable" and it was "quite right" that Marine A would be sentenced.

But he said we did not know what pressure the sergeant might have been under in the past.

The Geneva Convention

This international agreement concerning the treatment of captured and wounded prisoners of war was first signed in Geneva in 1864. It was later revised in 1949 and consists of four treaties.

Article three of the third convention rules that members of the armed forces who have laid down their arms or who cannot fight due to sickness, wounds or detention should be "treated humanely, without any adverse distinction founded on race, colour, religion or faith, sex, birth or wealth, or any other similar criteria".

To this end, it is prohibited to pass sentences on prisoners or carry out executions without a constituted court judgement. Prisoners may not be harmed, degraded, humiliated or taken hostage.

Under the convention, the wounded and sick should be collected and cared for by an impartial humanitarian body, such as the Red Cross.

"I understand that he's quite an experienced guy. People are talking about him being battle hardened and therefore there is no excuse.

"Well actually it's the other way round, the more times you do tours in that filthy war, the more pressure there is on you," he said.

He said some sort of clemency should be exercised.

"He certainly shouldn't serve any less than five years, maybe 10. I hope that his behaviour and the fact he truly regrets what he did would be taken into account when the time comes," he said.

Military commentator Colonel Mike Dewar said he was "horrified" by Marine A's actions but echoed calls for clemency, saying society had to make "exceptions for soldiers in extraordinary circumstances".

"These soldiers have had their officer killed - their platoon commander, a very fine young man - they had seen their friends brutalised, lost legs, they had been under the pressures of battle for weeks and months," he said.

But former Army Major Richard Streatfeild told the BBC it was too soon to tell what kind of sentence would be appropriate.

"We don't know enough about his personal situation in terms of a plea of mitigation yet," he said.

However, he said he agreed with Maj Gen Thompson about the "cumulative effect" war could have on members of the armed forces.

'Amounted to execution'

It is the first time a member of the British forces has faced a murder charge in relation to the conflict in Afghanistan, which began in 2001.

Two other marines were cleared after the trial at the Military Court Centre in Bulford, Wiltshire. An anonymity order was granted last year to protect the three men from possible reprisals.

The murder took place after a patrol base in Helmand Province came under attack from small arms fire from two insurgents.

The Afghan prisoner had been seriously injured by gunfire from an Apache helicopter sent to provide air support, and the marines found him in a field.

One of the cleared marines - known as Marine B - inadvertently filmed the murder on his helmet-mounted camera and that footage, taken on 15 September 2011, was shown to the court during the two-week trial.

It showed Marine A shooting the Afghan prisoner with a 9mm pistol, and saying: "There, shuffle off this mortal coil... It's nothing you wouldn't do to us."

He adds: "Obviously this doesn't go anywhere fellas. I just broke the Geneva Convention," to which Marine B replies: "Yeah, roger mate."

During the court martial, prosecutor David Perry told the court the murder was "not a killing in the heat and exercise of any armed conflict. It amounted to an execution".

Extract from helmet camera recording of incident in Helmand, Afghanistan

Marine A told the court martial he had fired because of "poor judgement and lack of self-control", but said he had thought the insurgent was already dead.

Marines B and C were accused by the prosecution of being "party to the killing" and of having "encouraged and assisted" Marine A to commit the murder.

At the time of the killing, Marine A was an experienced sergeant, Marine B was new to the Helmand base, while Marine C was the most junior of the three.


More on This Story

Related Stories


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 500.

    What bothers me most is the casual way in which this marine executed an injured insurgent. The camera footage was only discovered accidentally by civilian police investigating another matter, so we have no idea how many other executions may have taken place at the hands of UK forces personnel. It reminds me of how Waffen SS executed people. We must not stoop to the level of the enemy; the Taliban

  • rate this

    Comment number 499.

    To those knocking Bomber Harris, the bomb sights of the time were such that you had to have at least 200 bombers over the target, like the ball bearing factory at Schweinfurt, to try to get a couple to actually hit the factory.
    On ground combat my mantra has always been "Blessed is he whose heart is truly just, but twice blessed he who gets the boot in first.

  • rate this

    Comment number 498.

    Of course war is hell, and mistakes can be made, but if an Afghani fighter were to shoot an injured, unarmed British soldier, we would call him a vicious monster,deserving of the death penalty. That is why this soldier deserves a harsh sentence for his action. It was not a heat of the moment decision, the murder was discussed in advance.

    Having said that, Blair deserves his share of the blame.

  • rate this

    Comment number 497.

    Remind me again, what is war?

  • rate this

    Comment number 496.

    Geneva convention, that's what all we people safe & protected think about. These people are on the front line. The person killed was a terrorist who would have shot, maimed, blown up - probably even you!! Get a grip you arts luvvies. Get up to speed with the real world.


Comments 5 of 500


More UK stories



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.