Afghan blast: Soldiers 'unlawfully killed'

Clockwise from top left: Pte Wade, Pte Wilford, Pte Frampton, Pte Kershaw, Cpl Hartley and Sgt Coupe Clockwise from top left: Pte Wade, Pte Wilford, Pte Frampton, Pte Kershaw, Cpl Hartley and Sgt Coupe

Related Stories

Six British soldiers who died in an Afghan bomb blast claimed by the Taliban were "unlawfully killed on active service", a coroner has ruled.

The six men were on patrol in a Warrior armoured vehicle when it triggered a device on 6 March last year.

Recording a narrative verdict, Oxfordshire coroner Darren Salter said there was "nothing their comrades could have done to rescue or save them".

A series of improvements have been made to Warriors since the incident.

Sgt Nigel Coupe, 33, of 1st Battalion The Duke of Lancaster's Regiment, was killed alongside Cpl Jake Hartley, 20, Pte Anthony Frampton, 20, Pte Christopher Kershaw, 19, Pte Daniel Wade, 20, and Pte Daniel Wilford, 21, all of 3rd Battalion the Yorkshire Regiment.

Analysis

After soldiers using them were killed by improvised explosive devices in Iraq, the government upgraded all Warrior vehicles used on operations.

Those used in Afghanistan were upgraded in June 2011 as part of a £40m urgent operational requirement that included more than 30 enhancements to tackle the specific threat of mines or IEDs.

These included a flexible modular armour system, enhanced seating design and cushioning to improve protection and comfort, and an improved driver vision system with an increase from one to three periscopes, providing a wider field of vision and night-vision capability.

A further £1bn upgrade was announced in October 2011, to try to ensure the vehicles' suitability for future operations to beyond 2040 by improving their firepower and manoeuvrability.

The MoD says the "Warrior provides some of the highest levels of protection available, but sadly no armoured vehicle can provide absolute protection from the very largest explosions".

All those deploying with the vehicle will be very familiar with it, and for troops arriving in Helmand, there is mandatory refresher training on how to exit an overturned armoured vehicle in the dark.

The attack, which was so powerful it turned their vehicle upside down and blew off its gun turret, was the biggest single loss of life in an enemy attack for UK Afghanistan forces since 2001.

Two Warriors left on a patrol from a base at Lashkar Gah, southern Afghanistan, just after 18:30 local time.

Soon after, the Warrior travelling in front triggered a pressure plate which detonated an improvised explosive device (IEDs).

A fire broke out almost instantly, setting off ammunition inside the vehicle, the inquest heard.

Fellow soldiers tried, in vain, to put out the fire and get into the bombed vehicle.

The inquest heard evidence from pathologists who said the men were likely to have been killed or rendered unconscious immediately by the blast.

"This, of course, is a tragic loss of these six soldiers and these young lives," Mr Salter said.

"At least it is very clear from the evidence of the two pathologists and the evidence of those who witnessed the strike that they did not suffer."

He said he was "not going to second-guess decisions of commanders in a courtroom today; that is not the purpose of an inquest".

"These are experienced commanders who took decisions on the ground, balancing the risks and exercising judgements," he added.

He said it was clear "significant steps" had been taken to improve the vehicles.

'Good' vehicle

Start Quote

Of any vehicle, I would travel in Warrior”

End Quote Maj Douglas Nelson

Oxford Coroner's Court heard on Thursday from Warrior expert Maj Douglas Nelson who said it had been "a very large device - and what I would say is, no vehicle that we had was designed to take that".

He said that, while the Mastiff armoured vehicle was specifically designed with improvised IEDs in mind, the Warrior was "infinitely more capable" of fighting at night, when the attack took place.

Maj Nelson was among a number of soldiers who told the inquest they felt safest, when on patrol, in a warrior.

"Of any vehicle, I would travel in Warrior," he said.

"It's as good as we can make it."

Start Quote

I am still struggling with this but how like him to be ready to do his duty for his fellow soldiers”

End Quote Monica Kershaw on her son, Pte Christopher Kershaw

He said improvements made to the vehicles since the attack included thicker armour, better fire-fighting and detection systems and improvements to ways of getting out in an emergency.

Improved fuel tanks were also being fitted to the vehicles, he added.

The inquest heard that, when the order was given to leave at 18:00, Pte Kershaw had volunteered to take the place of another soldier, who was just returning from a shower.

Speaking after the verdict, his mother, Monica, said it was "a pure quirk of fate that Chris should have been kitted up and got into a patrol for which he was not intended".

"I am still struggling with this but how like him to be ready to do his duty for his fellow soldiers," she said.

And Emma Hickman, who has battled to prove her fiance, Pte Wade, fathered her daughter before he was killed in the incident, said: "From the struggle to establish Lexie's identity and hearing all the evidence it has been an exhausting ordeal and still we have not come to terms with our loss."

The Ministry of Defence released Pte Wade's DNA last year so Ms Hickman could prove paternity and put his name on the birth certificate of their daughter, Lexie-Mai.

Warrior armoured vehicle

Source: British Army

Warrior armoured vehicle

Crew:

Three, plus seven fully equipped soldiers

Speed:

Max speed of 75km/h, average speed 40km/h

Weaponry:

Turret-mounted cannon, anti-helicopter chain gun and eight portable Light Anti-Armour (LAW) or anti-tank weapons

Armour:

Shielding on front, sides and underneath gives extra protection

More on This Story

Related Stories

More UK stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.