Viewpoints: Do children need to read more books?

 
A young child reading a book

Related Stories

Fewer children across the UK are reading in their own time and one in five is embarrassed to be caught with a book, a survey suggests.

Just over a quarter of 35,000 children from 188 schools told the National Literacy Trust that they read outside school.

A similar number said they did not think their parents cared if they read.

The trust says a similar survey in 2005 found one in three children read in their own time.

Do children need to read more books, or can they get the same benefits elsewhere?

Start Quote

Christine Blower

It is a sad fact that there are more libraries in prisons than there are in schools”

End Quote
Christine Blower, general secretary of the National Union of Teachers

It is important that children and young people read books, as sustained reading is important. The government should reinstate the free-books-for-children scheme and promote the need for libraries in schools.

It is a sad fact that there are more libraries in prisons than there are in schools. Reading for pleasure should be an integral part of the school curriculum from primary school upwards.

The phonics reading test at the age of five or six years old is also unhelpful when teachers are trying to develop a love of reading not a dread. These measures would ensure that children and young people enjoy reading and will go a long way to getting rid of the idea that it is either an arduous or unnecessary task.

Start Quote

Guy Merchant

It's not just about books; it's about sharing the written form in whatever form it takes”

End Quote
Guy Merchant, professor of literacy in education at Sheffield Hallam University

It's been shown time and time again that sharing books, particularly at bed time, has beneficial effects on children.

But there are numerous other forms in which reading and writing goes on these days, and I'd be keen to advocate their use as well.

It's not just about books; it's about sharing the written form in whatever form it takes.

Interactive storybooks on [tablets], for instance, have huge benefits - they could be equally as important as traditional book stories.

The most important thing is sharing text with a skilled reader, that's the core.

There's often a strain of "golden-age-ism".

"When we were young the television was rationed so we enjoyed good books, and why shouldn't children today?"

It's quite easy to blame new media for making book reading seem old-fashioned or "uncool". [But] we've got more possibilities now, and the more that we can encourage good quality interactive books in different media, the better.

There's more reading and writing going on these days with the advent of things like the internet and mobile technology. Kids are growing up in a much richer literacy world, [but] it's not the world that some of us grew up in.

Start Quote

Aimee

The internet is a way of getting us to read, but the sites are often full of slang”

End Quote

Aimee, BBC News School Reporter at Bullers Wood School in Kent

As a child I liked flicking through the pages of a book and looking at the pictures in detail.

I use a Kindle now because it's easy and I can download a book from anywhere.

I do however miss the fun of picking up a real book. I think we need to be encouraged to read more books because it's important to maintain traditions of language.

Using the internet is a way of getting us to read, but the sites are often full of slang and it's very easy to get distracted from a reading task.

A boy reading an illustrated book

Start Quote

Siobhan Freegard

A book teaches concentration and builds anticipation and a child's imagination like no other format”

End Quote
Siobhan Freegard, founder of UK parenting website Netmums.com

Children are always going to regard computers as "cooler" than books, but it's very worrying that one in five youngsters now regards being seen with a book as "embarrassing".

While children do gain vital literacy skills from reading other material like comics, newspapers, magazines and games, reading a book teaches concentration and builds anticipation and a child's imagination like no other format can.

Books need to be back in fashion for schools, and parents must work together to make books trendy again. Whether it's discovering exciting new authors who fire a child's imagination like JK Rowling and the Harry Potter series, which every kid was clamouring to read, or accepting that children prefer to digest their books on an eReader rather than in paperback, books must be back on every family's reading list to give all kids an equal chance in life.

Start Quote

Don't focus on books. Instead, focus on reading”

End Quote

Jacquie Fisher, in a September article for website Kidsdiscover.com

I often hear this question from parents: "What should my child read?" Sometimes parents are asking for book recommendations, but many times they are expressing some frustration that their kids just don't enjoy sitting down to read a book.

I understand this struggle. I have two very active kids who didn't like to sit still when they were younger. They considered reading to be a full-contact sport on some days. Sometimes kids just aren't in the mood for a book - so what's a parent to do?

My answer: Don't focus on books. Instead, focus on reading! Building literacy skills with children happens in many ways.

Start Quote

Sarah Darwin

Technology is often accused of drawing young people away from books... but it's not all about social updates”

End Quote
Sarah Darwin, community manager at The Student Room

Like most solitary activities, reading might be seen as "uncool" in the playground.

Perhaps now books are regarded as a bit old fashioned next to ebooks on mobiles and Kindles, but young people still love reading, and value reading.

Technology is often accused of drawing young people away from books and shortening attention spans, but it's not all about social updates and video games.

Technology has inspired young people to write blogs, teach themselves to code, to learn together and socialise with people from all over the world. There are a lot of activities competing for the attention of young people, which affects their reading habits, but young people are still passionate about reading.

Skye and Marlies, BBC News School Reporters from Maplesden Noakes School in Kent

Skye

Skye: For me not to be able to read would be like turning the clock back 150 years to a time when women were thought of as servant girls. Not being able to read would mean that young people would not be able to read those fantastic stories that have been written by the great authors. What a waste!

Marlies

Marlies: Reading is even more important today than ever. I am glad that I can read, I think about all the young people around the world who can't, how can their intelligence develop if they have to rely on others for the truth?

Start Quote

Clare Geldard

We should support children to speak about what they read, in whatever form”

End Quote
Clare Geldard, I CAN charity director of operations, and speech and language therapist

Reading is about enjoying language, using your imagination to interpret the written word and having the language skills to talk about the story afterwards.

Before children can read, they need solid foundations in spoken language and understanding - and we know that one in 10 children will struggle with these skills.

Whether children are reading a book, magazine or a Kindle, the fact they are reading and enjoying language is something to be encouraged.

We should support children to speak about what they read, in whatever form, to ensure they develop good verbal language, which in turn improves their literacy and numeracy development.

Start Quote

Teresa Cremin

If our focus is the skill to read only, and not the will, we lose the capacity to extend that attainment”

End Quote
Prof Teresa Cremin, former president of the UK Literary Association

Pleasure reading is important for both educational attainment and, arguably, for social mobility.

Studies highlight that children who read for pleasure are enhancing and extending their own cognitive development, accounting for factors such as socio-economic background and parental education.

All types of reading material are equally valid and important. It is breadth and variety of reading material that is the most significant.

It is clear that reading fiction is positively associated with higher reading scores, so it is an important contribution. But it's the young people who read a variety of materials that perform particularly well.

A huge part of [encouraging] reading is supporting reading in the home. But another significant element is the focus on reading in the curriculum.

My own research has found that whilst primary school teachers do read personally for pleasure, they were insufficiently knowledgeable about children's literature, insofar as being able to recommend books to children.

Our teachers don't know enough children's literature. We need teachers who read, and readers who teach.

If our focus is the skill to read only, and not the will, we lose the capacity to extend that attainment through focusing on the pleasure.

 

More on This Story

Related Stories

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 90.

    Reading is fun, it can broaden the mind (depending on what you read) and it is relatively cheap.

    But, no, reading books is not vital.

    I know plenty of really successful, well rounded people who never got into reading books, hate maths, don't like the news, and can't spill for tiffee.

    Do they miss out?

    Not for a minute.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 89.

    @78. fuzzy

    further vacuous arguments just for the sake of posting comments: Aesop's or Andersen stories don't dwell on wherefore & therefore, just read the edifying Bible stories without belligerence.

    @82. fuzzy

    whimsical tosh.

    "...Kids are not encouraged to think..." (young goats?)

    should children "think" about deeper meanings in Harry Potter, Wimpy kid, or learn from them about Mr Tompkins?

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 88.

    86
    Elaborate. What exactly are you saying? Read.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 87.

    Last time I flew I went for a walk up and down the length of the plane. i did not see one adult//kid reading. They were all,plugged into ear phones or playing mindless video games.A sad indictment.

  • rate this
    -1

    Comment number 86.

    Is it in the interest of them at the top to have the general public & their children able to read?

    I mean legal documents tend to be written in gobbledygook and the small print requires powerful microscopes to read.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 85.

    94 Colinwe
    Go and read a book. Are you well read?

  • rate this
    -1

    Comment number 84.

    Should children read books? So whats next one the list of pointless HYS topics? Should children take vitamins? And please don't take that as a suggestion BBC.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 83.

    Bill And Bob Live Together are not books kids should be reading. Nudge them to the classics and read with them.

  • rate this
    -1

    Comment number 82.

    Aren't the best books those that encourage kids to be curious, to ask questions, to even question the book itself? Kids I've known love to solve problems, to work things out for themselves. If we welcome criticism from our kids, and listen, they may tell us where we've got things wrong, as they see with fresh eyes.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 81.

    How can we expect kids to read when their parents don't. Some years ago my house cleaner was wondering what to buy her husband for Christmas. I suggested a book. Her reply? '' Naw! - ' i bought one of them for him last year''.I'll be dead when they start burning books and libraries.

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 80.

    There is nothing wrong with reading the bible providing it is read in the right context. That is as a work of fiction with a historical background, pretty much the same way as Shakespear's historical plays. There is wisdom and understanding to be gained from both.

    It is when the bible it is passed off as the abolute truth that the problems beging to arise.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 79.

    I don't think the OT has a concept of eternity of the human soul. Isn't that something introduced in the NT or elsewhere?

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 78.

    69.darkeffeteness

    Children can read Bible stories about morality, generosity & kindness, easy to omit old testament stories on incest, rape, decapitations, genocide, use of prostitute spies etc.
    ===
    Are such stories only in the Bible? Besides, it doesn't say *why* you should behave in the ways it advocates, other than a threat of being burned for all eternity. Kids are not encouraged to think.

  • Comment number 77.

    This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

  • rate this
    -1

    Comment number 76.

    25. You
    We should all read lots get really clever and go to Uni.
    Who is going to clean the streets and the drains to stop us from getting life threatening diseases?
    The politicos policy will lead to our downfall, it is the small things that count.
    -
    I know we could use the people who clean up after people who read a lot at Uni, but have to make a large mess to be able to read a lot at Uni

  • rate this
    +3

    Comment number 75.

    Still remember with a shudder the first year A level student who remarked in horror when I gave her a reading list that "she had never read a whole book in her life" and added that her parents did not even have books in the house. She acted as if I were offering her a poison chalice. Good reading habits come from the home, if the parents read and enjoy books, so will the children.

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 74.

    67.tarangoes

    "Well, the OT is rather nasty, advocating stoning to death, human sacrifice (also in NT) ... gang rape etc."
    ---
    Really is that the message of the Bible - that these are the things it asks its readers to do?
    ===
    Stoning, yes. A man was told to sacrifice his son (if we were should we comply?). Lot offered his daughters for rape (what does that teach?) I agree my wording is clumsy.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 73.

    What a stupid question.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 72.

    @62
    Years ago, my brother (who is dyslexic) was given no help to learn to read. I *honestly* thought it would be different now, but my son (who is dyslexic) has had virtually no help. My second son, who was very late learning to speak, has had loads of help to learn the speech sounds, but now I am told that the Speech and Language Therapists don't teach language! The help is just not there!

  • rate this
    -1

    Comment number 71.

    I read a book on a smart phone, it didn't work.

 

Page 1 of 5

 

More UK stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.