War on illegal drugs failing, medical researchers warn

 
A syringe and heroin on a spoon The report said drug prices had fallen in real terms over 20 years, while purity had increased

Related Stories

Illegal drugs are now cheaper and purer globally than at any time over the last 20 years, a report has warned.

The International Centre for Science in Drug Policy said its report suggested the war on drugs had failed.

The report, published in the British Medical Journal Open, looked at data from seven international government-funded drug surveillance systems.

Its researchers said it was time to consider drug use a public health issue rather than a criminal justice issue.

The seven drug surveillance systems the study looked at had at least 10 years of information on the price and purity of cannabis, cocaine and opiates, including heroin.

The report said street prices of drugs had fallen in real terms between 1990 and 2010, while their purity and potency had increased.

In Europe, for example, the average price of opiates and cocaine, adjusted for inflation and purity, decreased by 74% and 51% respectively between 1990 and 2010, the Vancouver-based centre said.

The report also found there had been a substantial increase in most parts of the world in the amount of cocaine, heroin and cannabis seized by law enforcement agencies since 1990.

Most national drug control strategies have focused on law enforcement to curb supply despite calls to explore other approaches, such as decriminalisation and strict legal regulation, it said.

It concluded: "These findings suggest that expanding efforts at controlling the global illegal drug market through law enforcement are failing."

Start Quote

We desperately need to shift the regime from a prohibitionist one to one of legal regulation”

End Quote Transform Drug Policy Foundation

Co-author Dr Evan Wood, scientific chairman of the centre, said: "We should look to implement policies that place community health and safety at the forefront of our efforts, and consider drug use a public health issue rather than a criminal justice issue.

"With the recognition that efforts to reduce drug supply are unlikely to be successful, there is a clear need to scale up addiction treatment and other strategies that can effectively reduce drug-related harm."

The study comes two days after a senior UK police officer said class A drugs should be decriminalised.

On Sunday, Chief Constable Mike Barton, of Durham Police, said drug addicts should be "treated and cared for, not criminalised".

The chief constable, who is the intelligence lead for the Association of Chief Police Officers, told the Observer he believed decriminalisation would take away the income of dealers, destroy their power, and that a "controlled environment" would be a more successful way of tackling the issue.

He said prohibition had put billions of pounds into the hands of criminals and called for an open debate on the problems caused by drugs.

Mr Barton is among a small number of top police officers in the UK who have called for a major review of drugs policy.

'Tackle organised crime'

Danny Kushlick, of the Transform Drug Policy Foundation, welcomed Mr Barton's comments and said prohibition of drugs had been a "miserable failure".

Overseas drug laws

  • Uruguay's House of Representatives has passed a bill legalising cannabis. Under the proposed law, which still needs to be approved by the Senate, only the government could sell the drug
  • In Portugal, people caught with drugs can avoid punishment if they agree to treatment
  • Cannabis is illegal in the Netherlands but sale and use are tolerated in about 700 coffee shops

"We desperately need to shift the regime from a prohibitionist one to one of legal regulation," he said.

He said criminalising drugs had "gifted one of the largest commodity trades on earth to organised crime".

"It's an absolute no brainer for any government that is thinking responsibly about how best to regulate these things that they look after them and don't leave it in the hands of criminals," Mr Kushlick added.

The Home Office said drugs were illegal because they were dangerous.

It said the UK's approach on drugs was clear: "We must help individuals who are dependent by treatment, while ensuring law enforcement protects society by stopping the supply and tackling the organised crime that is associated with the drugs trade."

No major UK political party supports decriminalisation of class A drugs, though the Liberal Democrats said Britain's current approach was "costly and ineffective".

A Lib Dem spokeswoman said the government should consider other approaches used overseas and should "always base drugs policy on independent scientific advice", but did not say the party would decriminalise any currently banned drugs.

Labour said it would not decriminalise any banned recreational drugs, while the Green Party wants to make cannabis legal.

 

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +64

    Comment number 488.

    The only thing that annoys me about this issue is the politicians not listening to the scientists. I find it very frustrating with any issue where expert scientists inform politicians, the politicians don't agree with them, and ignore the advice when forming policy. Drugs policy (including alcohol and cigarettes) should be informed by medical science. Smoking is usually fatal. Why is that legal?

  • rate this
    -76

    Comment number 223.

    So lets give in then !! Fools are calling for legalisation of of drugs. Lets look at the two legalised drugs in the UK & witness the havoc wreaked by alcohol and tobacco. Yea great idea lets add to the mayhem !!!!!!!!!!

  • rate this
    -133

    Comment number 110.

    We should have more stringent laws on drugs, anyone found in posession or whos is caught using illegal drugs should be jailed for a minimum of 5 years, 93% of people who use cannabis, cocaine and heroine go on to commit serious crimes.
    Britain should never legalise these drugs, tougher laws is the answer.

  • rate this
    -74

    Comment number 13.

    If drug abuse becomes legal, how do employers meet their obligation to have a safe workplace when their staff believe they have a "right" to use drugs? How do we police drugs driving (which in USA is now a bigger problem than drink driving, but for which we have no meaningful statistics)? Beware the law of unintended consequences.

  • rate this
    +159

    Comment number 9.

    The only thing being achieved by the current legal system is to enrich the criminals and those in their pockets. Anyone who wants to take drugs can get them, and I don't believe many (if any) people are dissuaded from drug use by illegality. Plus the cost of the habit creates a huge wave of petty acquisitive crime. Learn the lessons of Prohibition.

 

Comments 5 of 6

 

More UK stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.