Mark Duggan inquest: Q&A

As an inquest into the death of Mark Duggan - which sparked the England riots - ends, what were the issues and background to the case?

Mark Duggan Mark Duggan died after being shot by police in Tottenham, north London

What happened to Mark Duggan?

Mark Duggan was a 29-year-old man from Tottenham in north London. He was shot dead by armed police in Ferry Lane, Tottenham, at 18:15 BST on 4 August 2011.

He had been travelling in a minicab when he was stopped by the armed unit as part an intelligence-led operation against a gang called Tottenham Man Dem.

He got out of the vehicle and one officer shot him twice. Police say Mr Duggan was holding a gun, which they believed he had collected about 15 minutes earlier. But the only civilian witness to the shooting to give evidence at the inquest said it looked like "an execution". Mr Duggan had a phone not a gun in his hand, the witness said, and appeared to be surrendering with his hands in the air when he was shot. The gun was later found some 20ft (6m) away.

When the police are involved in a death, the law says there must be either an inquest or some form of open inquiry to establish what happened and why.

Tottenham on fire during riots The incorrect suggestion Mark Duggan himself had fired at police sparked protests - and then riots - in Tottenham and elsewhere

What happened after Mr Duggan's death?

His family say they were not formally notified of his death, and the Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) later apologised because it initially suggested incorrectly to the media that Mr Duggan had fired at police.

A day-and-a-half after the shooting, protesters marched to Tottenham police station. The protest was followed by violence which turned into rioting.

The rioting spread across London and others parts of England in what became some of the worst disturbances in decades. More than 3,000 people eventually ended up in court across the country.

Photograph of a gun - used as evidence in the Mark Duggan inquest This photograph of a gun was shown to the jury as evidence

How did the inquest work?

A jury of ultimately 10 people heard evidence of what happened during the operation and the circumstances leading up to it.

The question they ultimately had to answer was whether the shooting was absolutely necessary. Did the police officer who fired have an honestly held and reasonable belief that Mr Duggan posed a serious and imminent threat at that moment?

The inquest examined police reports before the shooting which said Mr Duggan was a gangster with a history of violence and guns. The jury had to consider why the gun which was apparently the target of the police operation was not seized by officers sooner.

At the end of the evidence the jury had to answer a series of questions: Did the police do the best they could have done to gather intelligence about Mr Duggan collecting a gun? Was the stop on the minicab done in a way which minimised recourse to lethal force? Did Mr Duggan have the gun with him in the taxi before the stop? Did he have the gun in his hand when he was shot? If so, did the officer who shot him honestly believe that he needed to do so? How did the gun end up where it did?

Unlike a criminal trial, where a jury has to be sure beyond reasonable doubt of the relevant facts to reach a verdict, an inquest jury can base its conclusion on a balance of probabilities. The exception here was a conclusion of unlawful killing - if the jury wanted to reach that conclusion then, the coroner said, it had to be sure.

Replica of scene of Mark Duggan's shooting The inquest jury visit a reconstruction of the shooting

What is the significance of an inquest conclusion?

Inquests are not criminal trials - so juries are never asked whether someone is criminally to blame for a death. Their role is to look at the facts and come to some conclusion about how the individual died.

If an inquest jury decides someone has been unlawfully killed, then it is up to the Crown Prosecution Service to decide whether someone should go on trial.

However, coroners have additional powers to send a report to ministers or other public bodies if an inquest identifies specific issues which must be acted upon to prevent future similar deaths. The body that receives the report must respond to it.

Judge Keith Cutler Judge Keith Cutler was the coroner

Who were the key people in the inquest?

The coroner, Judge Keith Cutler, was assisted by an inquest legal team led by barrister Ashley Underwood QC. The team's role was to take the coroner and the jury through the evidence before counsel for "interested parties" put questions.

The "interested parties" are people who have some connection to the death or specific stake in the outcome of the inquest.

The family of Mr Duggan were represented by Michael Mansfield QC. Hugo Keith QC represented the Metropolitan Police, Samantha Leek QC appeared for the Serious Organised Crime Agency and Ian Stern QC represented the armed police.

Some individual witnesses had legal counsel, as did the IPCC, which has separately investigated what happened but not yet published its report.

Mark Duggan inquest tasks

  • Establish how and why Mark Duggan died
  • Expose any "culpable or discreditable conduct"
  • Examine any suspicions of deliberate wrongdoing
  • Examine any dangerous practices or procedures

Who gave evidence?

There were about 100 witnesses.

Many of them were police officers who gave evidence anonymously, among them V53, the officer who fired the shots. There were also witnesses who were experts in pathology, ballistics and trauma injuries.

There were also civilian witnesses to the aftermath of the shooting, but only one, Witness B, who claimed to have seen the actual killing.

Mark Duggan funeral cortege Friends and family at the funeral in early September 2011

Why did some of them give evidence behind screens?

Courts have the power to grant anonymity to a witness if there is a risk to their personal safety from appearing in public.

Do the police have the power to shoot someone dead?

Article Two of the European Convention on Human Rights says that everyone has a right to life - but that does not mean that police cannot shoot someone dead.

The law states that police can use force, including lethal force, providing it is necessary in the circumstances. In other words, if an officer can show that he was right to believe that the force he used was the only way to protect himself or others, then that can be deemed to be lawful.

The coroner told the jury that it was not necessary for the officer who fired the shots, V53, to prove that the killing was lawful. "Any person is entitled to use reasonable force to defend themselves or others," he said.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London

Weather

London

Min. Night 9 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    18:00: Good evening

    That's all for Local Live today.

    The service will return at 08:00 on Friday with the latest news, sport, travel and weather for London. Have a good evening.

     
  2.  
    17:57: BBC London news BBC London News TV

    On the programme tonight at 18:30 on BBC One: A manhunt is underway after the murder of a married couple at their home in Surrey.

    And claims an independent school ignored warnings about a teacher who abused children before going on to take his own life.

     
  3.  
    17:54: Misty overnight

    This evening and tonight it will stay rather cloudy with only a few clearer interludes in places. It will also turn rather misty overnight.

    Minimum Temperature: 8C (46F).

     
  4.  
    17:50: Artwork treasure hunt

    Artist Dom Pattinson - who has sold pieces of his work to George Clooney - is hiding 10 pieces of his artwork across London for people to find and keep.

    Dom Pattinson artwork

    The treasure hunt will take place between Euston and Hampstead tomorrow ahead of his exhibition at Utopia Studios, Primrose Hill on 11 December.

     
  5.  
    17:44: History of photography exhibition

    Key images from the history of photography are to be displayed at the Science Museum as part of the exhibition Drawn by Light which will showcase the archives of The Royal Photographic Society.

    Leicester Square, 1896, Paul Martin

    Among them are images from the earliest days of the art form and will see pioneers including Alice In Wonderland author Lewis Carroll displayed alongside modern artists including Don McCullin, Terry O'Neill and Martin Parr.

     
  6.  
    17:35: Wasps centre banned

    Wasps centre Elliot Daly has been given a three-week ban for verbally abusing a referee during his side's 31-15 Premiership defeat at Exeter Chiefs.

    Wasps centre Elliot Daly in action against Exeter Chiefs

    The 22-year-old pleaded guilty to "acts contrary to good sportsmanship" at a Rugby Football Union hearing in London.

     
  7.  
    17:33: Accident involving three cars

    There are severe delays with tailbacks of up to nine miles on the A12 eastbound in Wanstead between Green Man Roundabout and Redbridge Roundabout, because of an accident involving around three cars.

    On the A406 North Circular Road there is very slow traffic in both directions in Barking between Beckton Roundabout and Ilford exit.

     
  8.  
    17:29: Courier 'threw Tower of London poppy'

    A courier company has apologised after one of its delivery men was caught throwing a package, containing a ceramic poppy form the Tower of London, over a 25ft fence. You can read more in The Metro.

     
  9.  
    17:23: Observatory lit up with eyes

    Light artist Gerry Hofstetter illuminated the Royal Observatory in Greenwich last night as part of a project by Swiss International Air Lines.

    The Art of Attentiveness

    The installation features the eyes of the cabin crew to symbolise eye contact between people and to encourage everyone to be more attentive to one another.

     
  10.  
    17:09: On air BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On air now with Eddie Nestor, the team talks about the West Hendon estate in Barnet where residents are being moved out to make way for more expensive homes.

    What do you think? You can listen live on BBC London 94.9 and contact the team on 020 7224 2000.

     
  11.  
    17:00: News on the hour

    The lead story at 17:00 on BBC London 94.9: The Conservative MP Andrew Mitchell says he's "bitterly disappointed" after losing the libel action he brought against the Sun newspaper after being accused of referring to police officers at the gates of Downing Street as "plebs".

     
  12.  
    16:44: American ex-wife awarded £337m

    The American wife of a London financier has been awarded £337m by a High Court judge in a divorce case.

    Sir Chris Hohn and Jamie Cooper-Hohn

    Sir Chris Hohn and Jamie Cooper-Hohn, founders of the Children's Investment Fund Foundation, had fought over assets said to be worth more than £700m.

     
  13.  
    16:35: Crowdfund brewery campaign begins

    A brewery that allows members to brew their own craft beer has started a crowd­funding campaign.

    URBREW founders

    UBREW based in Bermondsey hopes to crowdsource £75,000 to buy equipment, rented accommodation and a workforce. It currently has 300 members.

     
  14.  
    @ChrisMasonBBC 16:28: Plebgate ruling

    The BBC's political correspondent Chris Mason tweets: Former Government chief whip Andrew Mitchell has lost his High Court libel action over the "Plebgate" incident.

     
  15.  
    16:23: Watch: Colouring in for grown ups?

    Loved colouring in as a child? Apparently in France colouring books for adults are outselling cookery books.

    Crayons

    London illustrator Richard Merritt talks about the reason behind the craze and the book he has created especially for grown ups.

     
  16.  
    16:12: Have your say Beth Rose BBC News Online

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  17.  
    16:00: News on the hour

    The lead story at 16:00 on BBC London 94.9: The former government chief whip, Andrew Mitchell, has lost his libel action against News Group Newspapers, which publishes The Sun.

     
  18.  
    15:50: Rare Lamborghini goes up in flames via Facebook

    Go to the BBC London Facebook page to watch a rare Lamborghini Miura SV being reduced to a fire blackened wreck.

     Lamborghini goes up in flames

    It's owner, the founder of Foxton's Estate Agents Jon Hunt, is seeking compensation at the High Court after he claims a garage fitted the wrong type of spark plugs to the car.

     
  19.  
    15:40: Teacher denies student affair

    A married religious studies teacher accused of having sex with a teenage pupil at Bexleyheath Academy has told Inner London Crown Court the affair "did not happen".

    Stuart Kerner, 44, from Aylesford, Kent, denies two counts of sexual activity with a child and six counts of sexual activity with a child by a person in a position of trust over an 18 month period.

    It is alleged the pair had sex in empty classrooms and cleaning cupboards at the school.

     
  20.  
    15:27: Mitchell loses 'plebgate' affair

    Former chief whip Andrew Mitchell loses libel action against News Group Newspapers over "plebgate" affair.

     
  21.  
    15:20: Heathrow Airport expansion debate

    A public debate is being held in Wandsworth tonight for residents to have their say on a potential expansion of Heathrow Airport.

    The world's biggest passenger airliner, the giant 555-seater Airbus A380, arrives at London's Heathrow airport

    The debate at St Mary's Church, Putney High Street will involve Wandsworth Council leader Ravi Govindia, MP for Putney Justine Greening and Matt Gorman the sustainability and environment director at Heathrow Airport.

     
  22.  
    15:10: Wilshere out for three months
  23.  
    15:00: News on the Hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The lead story at 15:00 on BBC London 94.9: Police are hunting a 38 year-old man after the bodies of a couple in their 50s were found in a house in Leatherhead.

     
  24.  
    14:54: Drug dealers 'stabbed 24 times in 60 seconds'

    A pair of drug dealers were ambushed and stabbed to death in a "swift, frenzied, utterly brutal attack" in a Leytonstone residential street, the Old Bailey has heard.

    Aaron Carriere (left) and Josiah Manful

    Aaron Carriere, 21, and Josiah Manful, 20, were "lured" to the road on 1 March and stabbed 24 times in under a minute after their vehicle was trapped by four cars. Five men and two youths deny the double murder.

     
  25.  
    @RBKingston 14:43: HIV test week

    Kingston Council tweets: Get a free HIV test aboard the @YoungLivin Bus today outside Accessorize in #Kingston, 10am to 7pm. #HIVTestWeek

     
  26.  
    14:23: EastEnders actress in court

    The actress Linda Henry is to stand trial in February for racially aggravated harassment outside a Jamie Oliver restaurant in Greenwich.

    Linda Henry

    The 51-year-old, who plays barmaid Shirley Carter in EastEnders, was charged following an incident in September. She has denied the charge.

     
  27.  
    @Standsted_Exp 14:10: Standsted Express refund

    The Standsted Express team tweets: Apologies for the disruption caused by a signal fault at #LiverpoolSt this morning. Delay repay here GK

     
  28.  
    14:00: News on the hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The lead story at 14:00 on BBC London 94.9: Police are hunting a 38 year-old man after the bodies of a couple in their 50s were found in a house in Leatherhead.

     
  29.  
    13:53: Author PD James dies

    Crime writer P.D. James has died aged 94.

    PD James

    The novelist, who wrote a string of books about detective Adam Dalgliesh, sat in the House of Lords for many years as Baroness James of Holland Park.

     
  30.  
    13:42: Brentford 'may have to groundshare'

    Brentford have confirmed they may have to move away from Griffin Park and groundshare if they are promoted to the Premier League this season.

    Griffin Park

    The west London club's stadium does not currently satisfy top flight standards. The club's chief executive Mark Devlin said it was "looking at creative and innovative solutions".

     
  31.  
    @LondonFire 13:33: Mayfair leak

    London Fire Brigade tweets: Air conditioning leak on Grafton St #Mayfair: We're working to isolate the burst pipe. Heavy traffic in the area, so avoid if possible.

     
  32.  
    13:16: Afternoon weather

    The rest of today will stay rather cloudy with some patchy rain at times, although some bright spells may develop by mid afternoon, particularly towards Watford.

    Maximum Temperature: 10C (50F).

     
  33.  
    13:06: BBC London news Katharine Carpenter Reporter and presenter

    Join me for our lunchtime news at 13:30 on BBC One when we'll reveal the findings of a report into the paedophile teacher who abused more than 60 boys at a top private school.

    Mikhail Baryshnikov

    Plus we'll be hearing from one of the world's greatest male ballet dancers and star of Sex in the City. Mikhail Baryshnikov is in London to open his first UK exhibition of photography.

     
  34.  
    12:56: News on the hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The lead story at 13:00 on BBC London 94.9: A couple found murdered in their home in Leatherhead last night have been named locally as Patrick and Gill Kettyle.

     
  35.  
    12:45: Stagecoach shares

    Shares in Stagecoach are up more than 8% following the announcement that it won the East Coast rail franchise.

    Meanwhile, rivals FirstGroup are down 5.6%.

     
  36.  
    12:34: The Giving Tree

    Shoppers in Bexleyheath have started buying presents for children and women using Bexley Women's Aid, a refuge from domestic violence.

    The Giving Tree tags

    The Giving Tree at Broadway Shopping Centre is covered in tags detailing the age and gender of a child. Shoppers are able to choose a tag before buying a present for that child which they can then drop off at the tree.

     
  37.  
    12:22: Flats 'to be build in library car park'

    Housing provider East Thames has submitted plans to build 21 flats and four houses in the car park of Wood Street Library according to the Walthamstow Guardian.

     
  38.  
    12:11: MCC to lower flag for Hughes

    The MCC has said the flag at Lord's will be lowered in Phil Hughes' memory, following his death two days after being struck by a ball.

    Australian cricketer Phillip Hughes (file pic Aug 2010)

    The ground is home to one of the 25-year-old's former clubs Middlesex.

     
  39.  
    11:58: News on the hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The lead story at noon on BBC London 94.9: A couple found murdered in their home in Leatherhead last night have been named locally as Patrick and Gill Kettyle.

     
  40.  
    11:45: Man sought after Tube assault

    British Transport Police are trying to identify a man from CCTV footage after a teenager was punched in the face at Canons Park London Underground station.

    CCTV

    The 16-year-old was assaulted on 23 October at about 18:00 when he was making his way to football practice. As well as suffering a black eye and bloody nose the incident is said to have had a "lasting emotional impact" on him.

     
  41.  
    11:35: Crossrail 2 'to cost £27.2bn'

    Building Crossrail 2 - a rail network linking south west and north east London - would cost £27.2bn, a report has revealed.

    PricewaterhouseCoopers also set out funding options for the project which could include using the revenue generated by fares, a Business Rate Supplement or council tax.

    Any decision on funding would require a formal process before being implemented.

     
  42.  
    11:25: London has lowest drink-drive rate The Daily Telegraph

    Londoners are least likely to have drink or drug-driving convictions while a town in Wales has the worst record, according to a survey reported in The Daily Telegraph.

    Llandridod Wells was revealed to have recorded 1.98 offences per 1,000 drivers over the past 12 months, compared to East London, which had just 0.76 per 1,000 drivers.

     
  43.  
    11:14: Boris in the Far East

    Boris Johnson will take part in a trade mission at the Singapore High Commissioner's residence on the first day of his business tour of the Far East.

    Boris in the Far East

    The London Mayor is leading a trade visit to Singapore, Jakarta, and Kuala Lumpur and will meet Malaysian prime minister Najib Razak and Singapore prime minister Lee Hsien Loong.

     
  44.  
    11:00: News on the hour

    The lead story at 11:00 on BBC London 94.9: A manhunt's underway across two counties after a man and a woman were stabbed to death near Leatherhead.

     
  45.  
    @MPSHackney 10:47: Police seize £2.5m

    Met Police officers in Hackney tweet: In the last 18 months police in #London have seized £2.5m destined for terrorist & criminal groups. Average seizures are £30-£50k #CTAW2014

     
  46.  
    10:34: Arteta may be 'out for while'

    Arsenal captain Mikel Arteta could be "out for a while" as Arsene Wenger's injury concerns deepened following the 2-0 win over Borussia Dortmund.

    Mikel Arteta

    The 32-year-old Spanish midfielder suffered a calf problem in the second half of the win which clinched their place in the knockout stages.

     
  47.  
    10:16: London trio on Brit shortlist

    London trio Years and Years are one of three acts which have been tipped for success in 2015 after being shortlisted for the Brits Critics' Choice Award.

    Years and Years

    George The Poet and James Bay will also battle for the honour which will be announced on 4 December. Previous winners include Emeli Sande, Jessie J and Adele.

     
  48.  
    10:00: News on the hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The lead story at 10:00 on BBC London 94.9: Police are warning the public not to approach a man from Walton-on-Thames they're urgently trying to find in connection with a double murder in Leatherhead.

     
  49.  
    09:55: History of photography goes on display

    Key images from the history of photography are to be displayed at the Science Museum, where one of the UK's first photography exhibitions was held.

    Lieutenant Colonel Mervyn O'Gorman

    Drawn by Light will showcase the archives of The Royal Photographic Society, which holds one of the world's most important photography collections.

     
  50.  
    09:45: What do you think? PM Beth Rose BBC News Online
  51.  
    09:30: Tube strike talks to begin

    Talks will take place later in an attempt to avoid a 24 hour strike on the the Northern Line scheduled for next Monday in a row over a driver being sacked.

    The talks at the conciliation service ACAS will involve both Transport for London and the Rail, Maritime and Transport Union.

     
  52.  
    09:21: Rail contact awarded

    A consortium made up of Stagecoach and Virgin has won the franchise to run the East Coast mainline rail route between London and Edinburgh.

    East Coast train

    The firms have promised to invest £140m in the route over eight years, and will pay the government £3.3bn for the contract.

     
  53.  
    09:12: Attempted murder charge

    A man has been charged with the attempted murder of a woman in a street in Ilford.

    The Met said the 43-year-old will appear at North East Barkinside Magistrates Court later charged with threatening a person with a bladed article and possession of a bladed article after an attack on Ilford Lane.

     
  54.  
    09:01: News on the hour

    The lead story at 09:00 on BBC London 94.9: Surrey Police have begun a huge manhunt for a man from Walton-on-Thames following a double murder overnight in Leatherhead.

     
  55.  
    08:56: On air Vanessa Feltz Presenter, BBC London 94.9

    On with Vanessa Feltz this morning, Steve Pound, Labour MP for Ealing North, will be in the hot seat and taking your questions.

    You can listen live on BBC London 94.9 and call in with your questions on 020 7224 2000.

     
  56.  
    08:47: Manhunt for double murder suspect

    A manhunt is under way after a man and woman in their 50s were found stabbed to death in a house in Fetcham, near Leatherhead.

    Viktoras Bruzas

    Surrey Police are trying to trace Viktoras Bruzas who they said was now likely to be in Sussex although he also had links to south-east London. Another man in his 30s has been arrested in Walton-on-Thames on suspicion of conspiracy to commit murder.

     
  57.  
    08:38: Student loans 'bankroll terrorism' The Daily Telegraph

    One of London's top anti-terror officers is warning that some extremists are using welfare payments and student loans to bankroll terrorism in Syria and across the world.

    The Telegraph reports that the Met's Assistant Commander Terri Nicholson believes women who are not known to the police are also being used to smuggle money out of the country.

     
  58.  
    08:27: Road delays Paul Murphy-Kasp Journalist, BBC London

    On the roads the M25 is queuing anticlockwise from Junction 2 to the Dartford Tunnel following a collision after the tunnel exit earlier on.

    There are still some periodic closures of the tunnel.

     
  59.  
    08:22: Police shooting protest 'peaceful'

    Scotland Yard has said a demonstration at the US Embassy in Grosvenor Square, which turned into an impromptu march to Westminster, passed off peacefully last night.

    Michael Brown

    About 1,000 people gathered to condemn the decision not to prosecute the police officer who shot dead the unarmed teenager Michael Brown in Ferguson, Missouri earlier this year.

     
  60.  
    08:15: Railway delays Paul Murphy-Kasp Journalist, BBC London

    A fire on an engineering train at Epsom has closed all lines affecting South West Trains and Southern services which are diverting.

    First Great Western are delayed in and out of Paddington following a signal failure at Reading and Southeastern Services between London Bridge and Charlton via Greenwich are not running following a signal failure.

     
  61.  
    08:05: Cloudy and misty start

    It will be a cloudy and misty start to Thursday with occasional rain or drizzle and hill fog, but becoming mainly dry later.

    BBC weather

    Some bright spells may develop and south easterly breezes will persist.

     
  62.  
    08:00: Good morning Beth Rose BBC News

    I'll be bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather from across the capital today for BBC Local Live.

    You can also send your news, pictures and comments to london.locallive@bbc.co.uk or Tweet @BBCLondonNews.

     

Features

  • How ebola spread graphicPatient zero

    How one boy’s death triggered Ebola outbreak


  • Passport control at airportNews quiz

    How much do you know about migration?


  • Phillip Hughes playing cricket for Australia in September 2014Brain trauma

    How is the brain injured and protected from injury?


  • Passengers pushing planeHeave!

    How many people does it take to push a plane?


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.