Mark Duggan inquest: Q&A

As an inquest into the death of Mark Duggan - which sparked the England riots - ends, what were the issues and background to the case?

Mark Duggan Mark Duggan died after being shot by police in Tottenham, north London

What happened to Mark Duggan?

Mark Duggan was a 29-year-old man from Tottenham in north London. He was shot dead by armed police in Ferry Lane, Tottenham, at 18:15 BST on 4 August 2011.

He had been travelling in a minicab when he was stopped by the armed unit as part an intelligence-led operation against a gang called Tottenham Man Dem.

He got out of the vehicle and one officer shot him twice. Police say Mr Duggan was holding a gun, which they believed he had collected about 15 minutes earlier. But the only civilian witness to the shooting to give evidence at the inquest said it looked like "an execution". Mr Duggan had a phone not a gun in his hand, the witness said, and appeared to be surrendering with his hands in the air when he was shot. The gun was later found some 20ft (6m) away.

When the police are involved in a death, the law says there must be either an inquest or some form of open inquiry to establish what happened and why.

Tottenham on fire during riots The incorrect suggestion Mark Duggan himself had fired at police sparked protests - and then riots - in Tottenham and elsewhere

What happened after Mr Duggan's death?

His family say they were not formally notified of his death, and the Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) later apologised because it initially suggested incorrectly to the media that Mr Duggan had fired at police.

A day-and-a-half after the shooting, protesters marched to Tottenham police station. The protest was followed by violence which turned into rioting.

The rioting spread across London and others parts of England in what became some of the worst disturbances in decades. More than 3,000 people eventually ended up in court across the country.

Photograph of a gun - used as evidence in the Mark Duggan inquest This photograph of a gun was shown to the jury as evidence

How did the inquest work?

A jury of ultimately 10 people heard evidence of what happened during the operation and the circumstances leading up to it.

The question they ultimately had to answer was whether the shooting was absolutely necessary. Did the police officer who fired have an honestly held and reasonable belief that Mr Duggan posed a serious and imminent threat at that moment?

The inquest examined police reports before the shooting which said Mr Duggan was a gangster with a history of violence and guns. The jury had to consider why the gun which was apparently the target of the police operation was not seized by officers sooner.

At the end of the evidence the jury had to answer a series of questions: Did the police do the best they could have done to gather intelligence about Mr Duggan collecting a gun? Was the stop on the minicab done in a way which minimised recourse to lethal force? Did Mr Duggan have the gun with him in the taxi before the stop? Did he have the gun in his hand when he was shot? If so, did the officer who shot him honestly believe that he needed to do so? How did the gun end up where it did?

Unlike a criminal trial, where a jury has to be sure beyond reasonable doubt of the relevant facts to reach a verdict, an inquest jury can base its conclusion on a balance of probabilities. The exception here was a conclusion of unlawful killing - if the jury wanted to reach that conclusion then, the coroner said, it had to be sure.

Replica of scene of Mark Duggan's shooting The inquest jury visit a reconstruction of the shooting

What is the significance of an inquest conclusion?

Inquests are not criminal trials - so juries are never asked whether someone is criminally to blame for a death. Their role is to look at the facts and come to some conclusion about how the individual died.

If an inquest jury decides someone has been unlawfully killed, then it is up to the Crown Prosecution Service to decide whether someone should go on trial.

However, coroners have additional powers to send a report to ministers or other public bodies if an inquest identifies specific issues which must be acted upon to prevent future similar deaths. The body that receives the report must respond to it.

Judge Keith Cutler Judge Keith Cutler was the coroner

Who were the key people in the inquest?

The coroner, Judge Keith Cutler, was assisted by an inquest legal team led by barrister Ashley Underwood QC. The team's role was to take the coroner and the jury through the evidence before counsel for "interested parties" put questions.

The "interested parties" are people who have some connection to the death or specific stake in the outcome of the inquest.

The family of Mr Duggan were represented by Michael Mansfield QC. Hugo Keith QC represented the Metropolitan Police, Samantha Leek QC appeared for the Serious Organised Crime Agency and Ian Stern QC represented the armed police.

Some individual witnesses had legal counsel, as did the IPCC, which has separately investigated what happened but not yet published its report.

Mark Duggan inquest tasks

  • Establish how and why Mark Duggan died
  • Expose any "culpable or discreditable conduct"
  • Examine any suspicions of deliberate wrongdoing
  • Examine any dangerous practices or procedures

Who gave evidence?

There were about 100 witnesses.

Many of them were police officers who gave evidence anonymously, among them V53, the officer who fired the shots. There were also witnesses who were experts in pathology, ballistics and trauma injuries.

There were also civilian witnesses to the aftermath of the shooting, but only one, Witness B, who claimed to have seen the actual killing.

Mark Duggan funeral cortege Friends and family at the funeral in early September 2011

Why did some of them give evidence behind screens?

Courts have the power to grant anonymity to a witness if there is a risk to their personal safety from appearing in public.

Do the police have the power to shoot someone dead?

Article Two of the European Convention on Human Rights says that everyone has a right to life - but that does not mean that police cannot shoot someone dead.

The law states that police can use force, including lethal force, providing it is necessary in the circumstances. In other words, if an officer can show that he was right to believe that the force he used was the only way to protect himself or others, then that can be deemed to be lawful.

The coroner told the jury that it was not necessary for the officer who fired the shots, V53, to prove that the killing was lawful. "Any person is entitled to use reasonable force to defend themselves or others," he said.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London



Min. Night 8 °C

BBC Local Live

    Brentford promotion 16:45:

    Watch this great fan's-eye view of yesterday's historic Brentford match by the BBC's Rory Cellan-Jones. Look out for the fan kneeling on the pitch.

    Brentford celebrate
    Tottenham beat Fulham 16:28: Emma Jones BBC London

    reports: Fulham FC manager Felix Magath did not speak to radio broadcasters after the club's loss against Tottenham. But I understand he remains positive about survival.

    Live football coverage 16:27:

    You can follow live text and radio football commentary here. After a win for Spurs, Chelsea host Sunderland later.

    John Lewis memories 16:07: via Facebook

    Jen Malyon writes: "My first job was there - started on YTS scheme 1985 and they took me on, had a great time."

    Quins 'belter' 15:48:

    Harlequins kept their Premiership play-off hopes alive with a narrow win over Leicester yesterday.

    Harlequins players

    The two sides were level at 13-13 at half-time after Vereniki Goneva's opening score for Tigers was cancelled out by a penalty try. Quins' Conor O'Shea called it a "belter of a game".

    Bounds Green crash 15:32:

    TfL Traffic News tweets: A109 Bounds Green Road near Tube station - collision affecting both directions. Police directing traffic each way past the scene. Delays.

    West Ham player remembered 15:09:

    Russell Hargreaves tweets: An emotional minute's applause for the late Dylan Tombides at Upton Park. Hammers retiring his 38 shirt. Class touch.

    West Ham
    Feedback 15:04:

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

    Easter music 14:49:

    Canticum Chamber Choir in Pimlico tweets: Happy Easter, everyone! Here's some wonderful choral music from us to get you in the mood

    West Ham v Crystal Palace 14:39: Pete Stevens Sport editor, BBC London

    From 15:00 we have West Ham taking on Crystal Palace at Upton Park. You can hear that game on BBC London 94.9, BBC London digital radio, Satellite TV and BBC London online.

    West Ham player remembered 14:23:

    There will be a minute's applause ahead of West Ham's Premier League fixture with Crystal Palace at 15:00 to mark the death of 20-year-old player Dylan Tombides.

    Dylan Tombides

    Hammers players will also wear black armbands, the club has said. Dylan died after a three-year battle with testicular cancer.

    Man dies after house fire 13:57:

    An elderly man has died in hospital after being pulled from a burning house.

    London Fire Brigade said firefighters in breathing gear had rescued the man from a first-floor bedroom at the semi-detached house in Norbury Crescent, Norbury, early this morning.

    Firearms charge court appearance 13:47:

    A gardener has been remanded in custody in connection with firearms offences, after Scotland Yard claimed to have seized one of its biggest gun hauls.

    Dean Stokes, 50, of Balmoral Road, Leyton, appeared at Thames Magistrates' Court charged with one count of possession of a pump action rifle and one count of possession of ammunition without a certificate, contrary to the Firearms Act 1968.

    Twickenham action 13:27:

    There's rugby in Twickenham from 15:15 - the mid-table clash between Wasps and Gloucester. Listen here.

    South West Trains warns a queuing system will operate after the match.

    John Lewis memories 13:09: via Facebook

    Alison Fareham writes: "I remember when for years it was only one floor & a metal framework, after it was bombed in the war!!"

    Record Store Day 12:49:

    It's Record Store Day and BBC Magazine has met the eight tribes of vinyl collector including the new buyer, represented by Tom Kangro, an architect from east London.

    Tom Kangro
    Holy Saturday vigils 12:30:

    Today is Holy Saturday for Christians when the Paschal Candle is lit. There is a vigil at Westminster Abbey at 20:00 and at Westminster Cathedral at 20:30, among many others.

    Tottenham v Fulham 12:11: Pete Stevens Sport editor, BBC London

    On BBC London 94.9, BBC London digital radio, satellite TV and BBC London online, you can listen to the London derby between Tottenham and Fulham. That game kicks off at 12:45.

    'Not affecting household supplies' 11:52:

    Thames Water says the burst main in The Grange, Wimbledon, will be fixed this afternoon and is not affecting household water supplies.

    Woman hit by bus 11:33:

    A 34-year-old woman has been left with serious head and foot injuries after she was hit by a 156 bus in Battersea Park Road, Battersea, police say.

    Officers were called shortly after 22:50 yesterday. The woman is in a critical condition.

    John Lewis anniversary 11:14:

    On Facebook we're asking if you've ever worked for John Lewis and what you think of the partnership. On Twitter people have been saying why they think it's a success.

    Seechucks tweets: @BBCLondonNews@andydangerfield fantastic people! Wonderful

    Watch: Wiltshire to Westminster 10:55:

    A canoe marathon billed as the world's toughest has begun in Wiltshire.

    Canoe race

    The 125-mile route ends in Westminster tomorrow.

    Have your say 10:37:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you news, sport, travel and weather updates in one place. We'd like to know what you think.

    John Lewis history 10:17:

    John Lewis became a drapers apprentice in London, aged 14, in 1856.

    He worked his way through the ranks to become the youngest silk buyer in the city and in 1864 he turned down an offer to become Robinson's partner and instead opened his own shop.

    Newspaper review 09:58:

    A number of London stories are in the national newspapers, including the claim on The Sun's front page that a London Marathon runner is accused of cheating. Here's a round up.

    Composite image of Express and Independent front pages
    Robert Elms 09:40: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Coming up on the show from 10:00, Robert is asking how you got on with securing a place for your child at your favourite school.

    There'll be gardening tips with St John Stephens and news on today's Record Store Day.

    Today's football 09:19:

    Championship London matches today include Leicester v QPR at 12:15 and Middlesbrough v Millwall and Watford v Ipswich kicking off at 15:00.

    Burst water main 09:00:

    Merton Police tweets: There is a burst water main in The Grange SW19, avoid it if you can for the time being until Thames Water can deal @thameswater GJ

    John Lewis anniversary 08:48:

    John Lewis celebrates 150 years. What's the story of its success? Andy Dangerfield finds out.

    John Lewis, 132 Oxford Street, 1884
    Easter travel 08:27:

    Disruption over the Easter period for improvement works:

    • District Line: No trains between Ealing Broadway and Turnham Green until Tuesday
    • Jubilee Line: No trains between Waterloo and Finchley Road until Tuesday
    • Piccadilly Line: No trains between Acton Town and Uxbridge until Tuesday
    • Bakerloo Line: No trains between Harrow & Wealdstone and Willesden Junction on Easter Sunday
    • London Overground: No trains between Surrey Quays and Clapham Junction all weekend, and no trains between Watford Junction and Queens Park on Sunday.
    • DLR: No service between Stratford and Bow Church until 2200 on Friday 25 April.
    Weather 08:11:

    There will be bright and sunny intervals today, but with cloud thick enough at times to give some showers, especially this morning. Highs of 14C (57F).

    08:00: Josephine McDermott BBC News Online

    Hello. It's a beautiful morning. I'll be with you until 18:00 with the latest news, sport, travel and weather for London.

    You can tell me your news by emailing or tweeting @BBCLondonNews.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.