Mark Duggan inquest: Q&A

As an inquest into the death of Mark Duggan - which sparked the England riots - ends, what were the issues and background to the case?

Mark Duggan Mark Duggan died after being shot by police in Tottenham, north London

What happened to Mark Duggan?

Mark Duggan was a 29-year-old man from Tottenham in north London. He was shot dead by armed police in Ferry Lane, Tottenham, at 18:15 BST on 4 August 2011.

He had been travelling in a minicab when he was stopped by the armed unit as part an intelligence-led operation against a gang called Tottenham Man Dem.

He got out of the vehicle and one officer shot him twice. Police say Mr Duggan was holding a gun, which they believed he had collected about 15 minutes earlier. But the only civilian witness to the shooting to give evidence at the inquest said it looked like "an execution". Mr Duggan had a phone not a gun in his hand, the witness said, and appeared to be surrendering with his hands in the air when he was shot. The gun was later found some 20ft (6m) away.

When the police are involved in a death, the law says there must be either an inquest or some form of open inquiry to establish what happened and why.

Tottenham on fire during riots The incorrect suggestion Mark Duggan himself had fired at police sparked protests - and then riots - in Tottenham and elsewhere

What happened after Mr Duggan's death?

His family say they were not formally notified of his death, and the Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) later apologised because it initially suggested incorrectly to the media that Mr Duggan had fired at police.

A day-and-a-half after the shooting, protesters marched to Tottenham police station. The protest was followed by violence which turned into rioting.

The rioting spread across London and others parts of England in what became some of the worst disturbances in decades. More than 3,000 people eventually ended up in court across the country.

Photograph of a gun - used as evidence in the Mark Duggan inquest This photograph of a gun was shown to the jury as evidence

How did the inquest work?

A jury of ultimately 10 people heard evidence of what happened during the operation and the circumstances leading up to it.

The question they ultimately had to answer was whether the shooting was absolutely necessary. Did the police officer who fired have an honestly held and reasonable belief that Mr Duggan posed a serious and imminent threat at that moment?

The inquest examined police reports before the shooting which said Mr Duggan was a gangster with a history of violence and guns. The jury had to consider why the gun which was apparently the target of the police operation was not seized by officers sooner.

At the end of the evidence the jury had to answer a series of questions: Did the police do the best they could have done to gather intelligence about Mr Duggan collecting a gun? Was the stop on the minicab done in a way which minimised recourse to lethal force? Did Mr Duggan have the gun with him in the taxi before the stop? Did he have the gun in his hand when he was shot? If so, did the officer who shot him honestly believe that he needed to do so? How did the gun end up where it did?

Unlike a criminal trial, where a jury has to be sure beyond reasonable doubt of the relevant facts to reach a verdict, an inquest jury can base its conclusion on a balance of probabilities. The exception here was a conclusion of unlawful killing - if the jury wanted to reach that conclusion then, the coroner said, it had to be sure.

Replica of scene of Mark Duggan's shooting The inquest jury visit a reconstruction of the shooting

What is the significance of an inquest conclusion?

Inquests are not criminal trials - so juries are never asked whether someone is criminally to blame for a death. Their role is to look at the facts and come to some conclusion about how the individual died.

If an inquest jury decides someone has been unlawfully killed, then it is up to the Crown Prosecution Service to decide whether someone should go on trial.

However, coroners have additional powers to send a report to ministers or other public bodies if an inquest identifies specific issues which must be acted upon to prevent future similar deaths. The body that receives the report must respond to it.

Judge Keith Cutler Judge Keith Cutler was the coroner

Who were the key people in the inquest?

The coroner, Judge Keith Cutler, was assisted by an inquest legal team led by barrister Ashley Underwood QC. The team's role was to take the coroner and the jury through the evidence before counsel for "interested parties" put questions.

The "interested parties" are people who have some connection to the death or specific stake in the outcome of the inquest.

The family of Mr Duggan were represented by Michael Mansfield QC. Hugo Keith QC represented the Metropolitan Police, Samantha Leek QC appeared for the Serious Organised Crime Agency and Ian Stern QC represented the armed police.

Some individual witnesses had legal counsel, as did the IPCC, which has separately investigated what happened but not yet published its report.

Mark Duggan inquest tasks

  • Establish how and why Mark Duggan died
  • Expose any "culpable or discreditable conduct"
  • Examine any suspicions of deliberate wrongdoing
  • Examine any dangerous practices or procedures

Who gave evidence?

There were about 100 witnesses.

Many of them were police officers who gave evidence anonymously, among them V53, the officer who fired the shots. There were also witnesses who were experts in pathology, ballistics and trauma injuries.

There were also civilian witnesses to the aftermath of the shooting, but only one, Witness B, who claimed to have seen the actual killing.

Mark Duggan funeral cortege Friends and family at the funeral in early September 2011

Why did some of them give evidence behind screens?

Courts have the power to grant anonymity to a witness if there is a risk to their personal safety from appearing in public.

Do the police have the power to shoot someone dead?

Article Two of the European Convention on Human Rights says that everyone has a right to life - but that does not mean that police cannot shoot someone dead.

The law states that police can use force, including lethal force, providing it is necessary in the circumstances. In other words, if an officer can show that he was right to believe that the force he used was the only way to protect himself or others, then that can be deemed to be lawful.

The coroner told the jury that it was not necessary for the officer who fired the shots, V53, to prove that the killing was lawful. "Any person is entitled to use reasonable force to defend themselves or others," he said.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London

Weather

London

Min. Night 13 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    18:00:

    That's all for today's BBC Local Live. We'll be back from 0800 tomorrow with the latest news, sport, travel and weather updates for London.

     
  2.  
    Tube strike 17:58:

    Don't forget if you use the Central or Waterloo & City lines, then your journey tomorrow may be heavily affected by a planned Tube strike.

    Passengers on a Tube train

    Parts of the service will be severely reduced, and there will be no early morning or evening trains.

     
  3.  
    Weather 17:56:

    Cloud will build up ahead of showery outbreaks of rain, some of which may be heavy especially in places such as Shooters Hill. These will linger overnight but become more fragmented towards dawn.

    Lows of 9C (48F)

     
  4.  
    On air 17:54: BBC London News TV

    On tonight's programme with Asad Ahmad, our home affairs correspondent Guy Smith looks at how big the threat is to Londoners from fighters returning from Syria.

    It comes as the Met Commissioner said there were between 400 and 500 British citizens fighting in Syria - half of them from London.

    And Fiyaz Mughal, the director of Faith Matters, an organisation which works at reducing and tackling extremism, will be in the studio giving his views.

     
  5.  
    Ride London 2015 17:51:

    More than 50,000 cyclists have registered to take part in the 2015 RideLondon event in the 72 hours since the ballot opened, despite "biblical" rain during this year's event.

    RideLondon

    The ride, part of the Mayor of London's festival of cycling, takes place on 2 August 2015 in London and Surrey.

     
  6.  
    Roundabout gets go ahead 17:47:

    Elephant and Castle's northern roundabout is set to be transformed after a public consultation was backed by 80% of more than 2,000 people.

    The roundabout will be redesigned as part of TfL's £4bn investment in improving roads across London.

     
  7.  
    Charity Tube challenge 17:44:

    A man is aiming to break a world record by travelling through every London Underground station in one day.

    Ben Holt, who has cerebral palsy, will need to complete the challenge in under 16 hours and 20 minutes to break the current record. He hopes to raise £500 for respite care charity Vitalise.

     
  8.  
    Cash fraudsters jailed 17:41:

    Florin Silaghi, Vasile Pop, Ovidiu Metac and Adriana Turc compromised 953 bank accounts and took some £160,000, although they stole details from more than 60,000 accounts.

    Clockwise: Florin Silaghi, Vasile Pop, Ovidiu Metac and Adriana Turc

    The Romanian nationals, who operated from Harrow, were jailed for between 21 and 64 months.

     
  9.  
    Slow broadband 17:35:

    Businesses in central London are losing more than 50,000 working days and £37m a year because of broadband issues, according to a new report on internet speeds in the capital.

    The Centre for Economics and Business Research (CEBR) analysed more than 400,000 small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) and their broadband capabilities, finding that many were being hindered by issues with their internet connection.

     
  10.  
    Fulham 'will go up' 17:24:

    Manager Felix Magath is adamant Fulham can make an immediate Premier League return despite their early struggles.

    However, the 60-year-old German admits the task of winning promotion from the Championship is bigger than he and club owner Shahid Khan had anticipated.

     
  11.  
    What's Mourinho doing? 17:16:

    Wondering what Chelsea boss Jose Mourinho is bracing himself for?

    Jose Mourinho

    Find out with this mini video.

     
  12.  
    Drivetime with Eddie Nestor 17:07: Eddie Nestor Presenter, BBC London 94.9

    As the number of sexual crimes committed on trains in England and Wales has gone up, a chartered psychologist will talk to me about why some people may commit the assault in full view of other people.

    And just before 1900, I'll be chatting to Lewis Been, the trustee of Notting Hill Carnival, ahead of this weekend's event.

     
  13.  
    News on the hour 16:55: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    In the 1700 bulletin:

    • Undercover Met officers who allegedly had sexual relationships with women without revealing their true identities will not face charges
    • Details of how hundreds of thousands of commuters could be affected by a Tube strike tomorrow
    • Crystal Palace caretaker manager Keith Millen says Iain Moody's resignation is a blow for the club
     
  14.  
    Zoo weigh-in 16:43:

    Animals at London Zoo are striking a pose and holding steady for the annual weigh-in.

    Llama is measured

    Every animal is weighed and measured and their vital statistics are then recorded and shared with zoos across the world.

     
  15.  
    How happy are you? 16:33: via Facebook

    On BBC London's Facebook page, people have been commenting on whether Londoners really are the unhappiest in the country after a report suggested they were.

    Oscar Mangas wrote that it depends on what you are looking for or want to experience while Lorraine De'a wrote that London was far too expensive.

     
  16.  
    Allardyce takes ice challenge 16:25:

    BBC London Sport tweets: West Ham manager Sam Allardyce took the #IceBucketChallenge after being nominated by Ravel Morrison

    Sam Allardyce takes the ice bucket challenge

    Watch the full video, which also features Carlton Cole and Cheikhou Kouyate.

     
  17.  
    Officers not charged 16:14:

    Four police officers who worked undercover will not face any charges in connection with alleged sexual relationships, the CPS has said.

    The decision is part of Operation Herne, an ongoing investigation examining both potential criminality and misconduct by officers who were part of the Special Demonstration Squad.

     
  18.  
    News on the hour 15:57:

    BBC London 94.9's top local story this hour:

    Undercover Met police officers who allegedly had sexual relationships with women, without revealing their true identities, will not face criminal charges.

     
  19.  
    Hackney stab victim named 15:48:

    A 19-year-old man stabbed to death in Hackney, east London, has been named by the police as Charlie Burns.

    Charlie Burns

    Police found Mr Burns, of Sharon Gardens in Hackney, with multiple stab wounds in Frampton Park Road on 18 August. Two teenagers, aged 16 and 19, arrested on suspicion of murder, remain in police custody.

     
  20.  
    Hajj fraud arrests 15:37:

    Two men have been arrested and an estimated £400,000 seized at travel agencies in east London as part of an ongoing investigation into Hajj fraud.

    The tour operators are suspected of selling package holidays, including Hajj pilgrimages, by either falsely claiming to have protection or selling unlicensed packages with no protection, leaving customers exposed if something went wrong.

     
  21.  
    Have your say 15:25:

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  22.  
    Tube strike 15:08:

    Tomorrow, Central and Waterloo & City line users may have their journeys severely affected as Aslef members are set to take strike action over safety training.

    Underground sign

    TfL said no trains will run early in the morning or at night, and trains will not run into central London.

    Extra busses will be put on.

     
  23.  
    News on the hour 14:56:

    BBC London 94.9's top local story this hour:

    A Romanian gang who operated a "large-scale and highly sophisticated" bank card fraud out of their Harrow base have been jailed at the Old Bailey.

     
  24.  
    DLR and Tube crime 14:45:

    Wharf.co.uk is covering British Transport Police (BTP) figures which show reports of sexual violence on the DLR and London Underground have risen by 31% within the last financial year.

     
  25.  
    Notting Hill Carnival 14:33:

    If you're planning to head to the Notting Hill Carnival this weekend, check out Transport for London's website which has all the details on how the Tube is running and road closures.

    For instance, on the Tube Ladbroke Grove and Latimer Road will be closed while other stations will be exit only.

     
  26.  
    London Bridge works 14:21:

    Major works are planned for London Bridge station from Saturday.

    Southern and First Capital Connect services will be affected, as services will be diverted away from London Bridge (pdf download) to East Croydon and Blackfriars.

     
  27.  
    New York, New York 14:11:

    Just outside London, a sand sculpture has been unveiled at Gatwick Airport.

    Sculpture at Gatwick Airport

    The statue, of New York's Chrysler Building, is in celebration of more airlines now flying to the state.

     
  28.  
    News on the hour 13:58: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    West Ham manager Sam Allardyce has said the way that clubs work so closely together, allegations of this nature would not have stayed secret for long.

    He was reacting to news that Iain Moody has left Crystal Palace following allegations of racist, sexist and homophobic texts being shared with his former colleague Malky Mackay.

    Find out what he's talking about by listening to the 1400 bulletin.

     
  29.  
    Weather 13:43:

    Cloud will push in from the north-west during this afternoon and evening with the odd shower possible towards dusk.

    Highs of 19C (66F).

     
  30.  
    Feedback 13:30:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

     
  31.  
    On air 13:20: BBC London News TV

    Coming up on the lunchtime news, the BBC's Home Affairs correspondent Matt Prodger will explain why the CPS has decided to not press charges against undercover police officers.

    Land where solar farm could be built Could a solar farm be built here?

    And plans to build a solar farm the size of 34 football pitches on green belt land in Surrey has angered residents.

     
  32.  
    GCSE results 13:10:

    Local newspapers have been reporting on pupils getting their GSCE results today, such as these two from Stoke Newington school.

    Pupils getting GCSE results

    Find out how pupils in your area did with the Croydon Guardian, Ealing Times,Wandsworth Guardian,Hackney Gazette,Islington Gazette,Wimbledon Guardian and Romford Recorder.

     
  33.  
    News on the hour 12:56: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    In the 1300 bulletin:

    • Met Police officers will not be charged over claims they fooled political activists into having sexual relationships with them
    • Crime on London's transport network has fallen by more than 10% in the last year
    • Iain Moody has resigned as sporting director of Crystal Palace
     
  34.  
    Terrorism accused in court 12:48:

    A 19-year-old has appeared in court charged with preparing to commit acts of terrorism.

    Dressed in a Call of Duty T-shirt, unemployed Brustchom Ziamani, of Warner Road, Camberwell, spoke only to confirm his name at Westminster magistrates.

    He was remanded in custody until 12 September.

     
  35.  
    Moody resigns 12:37:

    Iain Moody has resigned as Crystal Palace sporting director in the wake of allegations about racist, sexist and homophobic texts shared with his former colleague Malky Mackay, reports BBC Sport.

     
  36.  
    On air 12:27: Robert Elms Presenter, BBC London 94.9

    On today's show, the band behind Otis Redding, Booker T & the MGs, Muddy Waters, and Sam & Dave will perform live.

    Muddy Waters The band behind Muddy Waters will be performing live

    And Tony Fletcher, the author of music biographies including Keith Moon and REM talks about his new book, which documents his own love affair with music.

     
  37.  
    'London' jihadist hunted for 12:15:

    Police and security sources are hunting for a jihadist - believed to be from London or the South East - who appeared in footage of the killing of US journalist James Foley.

    The Guardian reports the man was thought to be the leader of a group of British fighters based in Syria, and that he called himself "John".

     
  38.  
    Ward progresses in US Open 12:05:

    Britain's number two tennis player, Londoner James Ward, has made it through to the second round of qualifying for the US Open.

    James Ward

    BBC Sport says the 27-year-old is at a career-high 131 ranking and will be looking to make his first US Open main draw.

     
  39.  
    News on the hour 11:55: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The United Arab Emirates' foreign ministry has released a map advising its citizens to avoid areas of London it claims are too dangerous because of fraud, theft and pickpocketing.

    Find out what areas have been highlighted in the 1200 bulletin.

     
  40.  
    Vandals fell trees 11:44:

    Police patrols have been stepped up in a park after vandals cut down 13 trees, reports the Evening Standard.

    The 15ft conifers were all felled during a single night in Enfield Town Park in north London. Eleven of them had been planted in a circle around a memorial bench.

     
  41.  
    Card fraudsters jailed 11:29:

    A gang of Romanian fraudsters have been jailed for stealing an estimated £16m-worth of bank card details from more than 60,000 people in the UK and abroad.

    The gang, three men and a woman, were involved in three stages of fraud - scamming bank card data from ATMs, downloading it on to a computer and then copying the details on to counterfeit plastic cards.

    They were jailed for between 21 and 64 months.

     
  42.  
    Winehouse statue 11:17:

    A life-sized statue of Amy Winehouse is to be unveiled on her birthday.

    Maquette of Amy Winehouse statue

    The bronze figure will be placed in the Stables Market.

     
  43.  
    Travel 11:03:

    There are severe delays on the Jubilee Line following an earlier signal failure at Swiss Cottage.

    Keep an eye on @jubileeline for updates.

     
  44.  
    News on the hour 10:55: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Londoners are being described as the least happy people in the UK - despite us having the strongest economy and the best wages.

    Edward Lister, deputy mayor for planning and policy, gives his views in the 11:00 bulletin.

     
  45.  
    Road deaths 10:43:

    Road safety in London is an important issue, particularly as the mayor's office is currently looking at improving the roads to make it safer for cyclists.

    But how many people have died on the capital's roads?

    Road death map

    Search your area and find out with this interactive map by BBC News.

     
  46.  
    London happiness 10:26:

    Although London has the strongest economy in the UK and pays the best wages, people are still not happy.

    A report for the London Assembly shows the unhappiest in the capital are those earning less than a £100 per week. But those paid over £4,000 a month had anxiety scores higher than people living elsewhere in the country

     
  47.  
    Violent offences on trains 10:12:

    There has been a big rise in violent offences on the London Underground and the Docklands Light Railway, figures from British Transport Police show.

    Cases of violence against the person rose 9.5%, from 1,897 in 2012-13 to 2,077.

     
  48.  
    News on the hour 09:57: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Our top story this hour: Police and the intelligence services are trying to identify the suspected British Islamic fighter who murdered an American journalist.

    Hear the views of former Secretary-General of the Muslim Council of Britain, Sir Iqbal Sacranie, on the current approach to preventing extremism, in the 1000 bulletin.

     
  49.  
    Couple rescued 09:50:

    A couple from London have been rescued after they were stranded on a north Wales island.

    Couple being rescued

    The pair became marooned on Ballast Island, Gwynedd, yesterday at about 17:00.

     
  50.  
    Third defeat for Fulham 09:41:

    Fulham suffered a third straight defeat since being relegated from the Premier League after Bakary Sako's goal earned Wolves victory at Craven Cottage.

    Sako struck after the Cottagers failed to deal with a first-half corner - the former France Under-21 international firing into the bottom corner.

     
  51.  
    Fly-tipping in Croydon 09:31:

    Travellers have left a "colossal" amount of fly-tipping on a third Croydon playing field in less than a fortnight, claims the Croydon Advertiser.

     
  52.  
    Olympics' architect to get honorary degree 09:20:

    Award-winning architect Dame Zaha Hadid is to receive an Honorary Degree from Goldsmiths, University of London in September.

    Dame Zaha designed the Aquatics Centre at the London 2012 Olympics site.

     
  53.  
    Hospital 'must improve' 09:09:

    Emergency and end-of-life care need to be improved at the North Middlesex University Hospital, the Care Quality Commission has said.

    North Middlesex University Hospital North Middlesex University Hospital will be unable to get foundation status until its grade improves

    It rated the hospital as "requires improvement" but praised its surgery, children's and maternity care. The hospital's trust welcomed the report, saying it had just been through a period of "massive change".

     
  54.  
    News on the hour 08:58: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Figures released today show violent offences committed on the London Tube and the DLR has gone up almost 10% compared to a year ago.

    British Transport Police Chief Constable Paul Crowther gives his verdict in the 0900 bulletin.

     
  55.  
    On air 08:49: Vanessa Feltz Presenter, BBC London 94.9

    The United States says it tried and failed to rescue the murdered American journalist James Foley. British intelligence services are working to identify his killer, who spoke with an English accent.

    I'll have more from 09:00.

     
  56.  
    Crystal Palace successor 08:40:

    Malky Mackay is no longer in contention to succeed Tony Pulis as Crystal Palace boss after misconduct allegations were made by his former club, Cardiff City.

    Malky Mackay Malky Mackay is out of contention after misconduct allegations

    The Welsh club have sent a dossier to the Football Association outlining their claims against the Scot.

     
  57.  
    Signal failures 08:32:

    There are severe delays on London Overground on routes to Stratford, Richmond and Clapham Junction because of an earlier signal failure at Gunnersbury.

    There are problems on the Tube too following a signal failure at Rayners Lane. Piccadilly Line has minor delays between Acton Town and Uxbridge while the Metropolitan Line also has minor delays between Harrow on the Hill and Uxbridge.

     
  58.  
    Roads closed 08:23:

    In Southall, the A4020 Uxbridge Road remains closed between Woodlands Road and Townsend Road while police investigate a fatal stabbing.

    In the A503 Seven Sisters Road remains closed southbound from St Ann's Road to Amhurst Park for ongoing repairs to a water main. Get the latest travel information on BBC London Travel News or on Twitter @BBCTravelAlert.

     
  59.  
    as it happened
    • News, sport, travel, weather for Thurs 21 August
    • More updates from 08:00 on Friday
    • Listen to BBC London 94.9
     
  60.  
    Dry and cool day 08:09:

    A fine, dry and cool start to the day, with plenty of sunshine.

    But cloud will push in from the north-west during the afternoon and evening with the possibility of the odd shower tonight. Highs of 19C (66F).

    BBC London weather
     
  61.  
    08:00: Rebecca Cafe BBC News

    Good morning, I'll be bringing you all the latest news, sport, travel and weather from London today for BBC Local Live.

    You can also send your news, pictures and comments to locallive@bbc.co.uk.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.