'Community resolutions' used in 10,000 serious violence cases

A man being arrested Unlike a caution, a community resolution does not lead to a criminal record

Related Stories

More than 10,000 serious violent crimes were dealt with informally last year, despite guidelines to the contrary.

Police used "community resolutions", which can include an apology or compensation to the victim, instead of prosecutions and cautions.

The Association of Chief Police Officers says resolutions should only be used for low-level crime.

The data came from 33 police forces in England and Wales which responded to a Freedom of Information request.

It was analysed by the House of Commons library after being obtained by the Labour Party.

BBC home affairs correspondent Danny Shaw said police were increasingly being encouraged to deal with minor incidents informally to reduce the burden on the criminal justice system.

Analysis

Police used to complain (and some still do) that they were burdened by red tape: arresting someone for spraying graffiti or stealing sweets was a waste of time - hours would be spent at the station filling in forms.

So Labour expanded the use of fixed-penalty fines; more cautions were issued.

But amid further concerns about paperwork, the criminalisation of young people for minor crimes and the lack of discretion for officers, the "community resolution" was born.

The figures clearly show it's being used for serious offences it wasn't designed for - against Acpo guidelines.

Is this due to police budget cuts or because it's proving to be effective?

Opinion appears to be divided.

But if it turns out that repeat offenders are being dealt with informally or that someone let off without even a caution went on to commit a really serious attack, expect to see the numbers plummet.

This approach is known as a community resolution and it can involve restorative justice techniques, such as the offender apologising to the victim, paying compensation or repairing any damage caused.

Unlike a caution, a community resolution does not lead to a criminal record.

The Association of Chief Police Officers (Acpo) advises in guidelines that community resolutions should be used for "less serious" offences which may include "minor assaults without injury".

But last year a community resolution was applied in 10,160 incidents of "serious violence" - about 12 times the figure for five years ago, the figures obtained by Labour show. They were also used in 2,488 domestic violence cases in 2012.

In total, community resolutions were used 33,673 times for violence against the person offences last year.

The figures do not include cases where restorative justice is used after an offender has been cautioned or convicted.

The number of community resolutions being issued in cases of violent crime has risen from 7,621 in 2010 to 8,523 in 2011. However, the figures show the largest increase was from 792 in 2008 to 5,173 in 2009.

Incidents classed as serious violence by the House of Commons library in its analysis include:

  • Grievous bodily harm (GBH) with intent
  • GBH without intent
  • Assault occasioning actual bodily harm
  • Malicious wounding
  • Wounding with intent to do grievous bodily harm
  • Use of substance or object to endanger life

Shadow home secretary Yvette Cooper said the figures were "extremely serious".

Start Quote

At times it may be necessary, and appropriate, to use such informal resolutions to deal with more serious cases”

End Quote Assistant Chief Constable Garry Shewan

There had been "a massive increase in the number of serious and violent crimes dealt with just by community resolution ever since the police cuts started - breaking all the expert guidance and promises from ministers", she said.

"Offenders who admit to serious and violent crimes - including knife crime, domestic violence and serious assault - are increasingly being let off with no criminal record, no justice and not even a caution.

"That's bad for justice, bad for victims and goes against all the evidence."

Peter Neyroud, former chief constable of Thames Valley Police, told the BBC that three conditions had to be met for restorative justice to be an option - low-harm offence, the offender had to accept his or her guilt and the victim had to consent.

He said some cases which used restorative justice "didn't look right" and he expressed particular concern about domestic abuse incidents, saying there was an issue with the "genuineness of consent".

Mr Neyroud said there was concern the resolutions were being used as a quick way of clearing up a case.

"That concern has to be increased when you have falling numbers of police officers on the street who are feeling under pressure," he added.

"That was one of the reasons why Yvette Cooper asked the question - she had heard an incidence of a police officer doing a community resolution because it was a convenient way of closing off the job and moving on."

'Victim-led'

A Home Office spokesman said it was the responsibility of chief constables to ensure community resolutions were used appropriately.

"Through crime maps and police and crime commissioners, the public now have the means to hold them to account," he added.

Graphs showing number of violent crimes against the person and number of crimes dealt with by community resolution

Acpo's Assistant Chief Constable Garry Shewan said guidelines were in place to help forces decide where the use of community resolutions might be appropriate.

"But in every case, this decision will be victim-led and above all reflect their views and wishes," he said.

"At times it may be necessary, and appropriate, to use such informal resolutions to deal with more serious cases.

"Going through a restorative justice meeting has also been proven to have more impact on an offender than a prison sentence or a court punishment alone, as they see the consequences of their actions and so want to make changes in their future behaviour."

The Restorative Justice Council - "the national voice for restorative practice" - said it should be "available for all victims of crime who want it, subject to a risk assessment by a trained restorative justice professional".

Incidents which are dealt with by community resolution are still recorded as crimes, so there is no impact on the crime figures.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More UK stories

RSS

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.