Why have the white British left London?

 
Commuters on the Tube

Something quite remarkable happened in London in the first decade of the new millennium. The number of white British people in the capital fell by 620,000 - equivalent to the entire population of Glasgow moving out.

The consequence, as revealed by the latest census, is that white Brits are now in a minority in London, making up just 45% of its residents.

So where have they gone to - and why did they leave?

I've been analysing and mapping the census data, and what emerges is a much more positive story than some headlines would make you think.

The movement of the white British is often characterised as white flight - the indigenous population forced out of their neighbourhoods by foreign migrants. That may be part of the story, but I think the evidence suggests it is also about working class aspiration and economic success.

BBC's Mark Easton: It's a story of success

Trying to track internal migrants is never easy. Just because the population of one place has fallen and another has risen does not mean residents moved between them. But there are some clues as to where London's white British migrated to between the censuses of 2001 and 2011.

While the capital's white British population fell by 620,000, the white British population in the rest of England and Wales increased by 220,000. (The overall fall of 400,000 is explained by a low birth rate and emigration.)

These maps show the change to the white British population in local authorities in England and Wales between 2001 and 2011. (Click between the three headings to see how the white British population is seemingly shifting around the country.)

Ten largest decreases in white British population. Newham 37.5%,Ealing 23.8%, Waltham Forest 23.6%, Barking and Dagenham 30.6%, Slough 30.3%, Redbridge 29.8%, Harrow 28.5%, Brent 27.3%, Enfield 24.5%, Luton 24.4%
Ten largest decreases in white British population outside London. Wolverhampton 9.7%, Coventry -10.4%, Rushmoor -10.5%, Birmingham -11.1%, Watford -11.4%, Reading -11.8%, Leicester -12.3%, Oadby and Wigston -13.1%, Luton -24.4%, Slough -30.3%
Ten largest increases in white British population. South Derbyshire 13.7%, North Kesteven 13.0%, Uttlesford 11.8%, East Northamptonshire 10.9%, West Lindsey 10.7%, East Cambridgeshire 9.7%, Mid Suffolk 9.7%, South Norfolk 9.7%, Mid Devon 9.5%, Forest Heath 8.8%

London's dramatic loss of white British residents is represented by a splash of yellow and orange. Outside the capital, the dominant blues tell a story of an increasing white British population. In some places the rise is quite marked.

Areas with biggest increase

South Derbyshire

13.7%

North Kesteven, Lincolnshire

13%

Uttlesford, Essex

11.8%

East Northamptonshire

10.9%

West Lindsey, Lincolnshire

10.7%

East Cambridgeshire

9.7%

Mid Suffolk

9.7%

South Norfolk

9.7%

Mid Devon

9.5%

Forest Heath, Suffolk

8.8%

St Edmundsbury, Suffolk

8.7%

Kettering, Northamptonshire

8.7%

The dozen authorities with the highest percentage increase in the white British population are almost all found in eastern England. Only mid-Devon falls outside a horseshoe of largely rural authorities extending south and east from the Fens.

It would appear that, in the first decade of the 21st Century, the dream of escaping to the country became a reality for tens of thousands of urban white Britons. But did they leave willingly or were they forced to move?

To find out, I have been to Barking and Dagenham, a London borough which has seen a phenomenal change in its cultural make-up over the past decade or so. In 2001, the census records that more than 80% of residents were white British. By 2011, it was statistically in the minority - just 49% of people in the area described themselves as white and British.

The story of Barking and Dagenham is the story of the white working class EastEnders. In the 1920s and 30s, tens of thousands of families were moved out of the inner city slums and into the huge council estates which had been built in the borough.

The 27,000 houses on the Becontree estate were described as homes for heroes, often allocated to the families of World War I servicemen. Another wave of Cockney sparrows built their nests in the area, having been bombed out of the East End during the Blitz in WWII.

Becontree estate The Becontree estate in 1950

This was a real step up for many families. Their new homes had indoor toilets and often a small garden. When Ford opened its giant plant at Dagenham in 1931, tens of thousands of jobs provided income security in the midst of profound economic depression.

Although Barking and Dagenham's population declined slightly in the 1960s and 70s, the last years of the 20th Century saw it rise again. Many families took advantage of the right to buy their council house at 30% of its market value - at least two-thirds of the Becontree estate was sold to the private sector.

In 2000, the borough was among the very few places in Greater London where you could still buy a three-bedroom house for under £100,000. The capital's buoyant property market meant that anyone who got on the housing ladder would see their home become a valuable investment during the first 10 years of the new millennium.

The decade also saw the Ford plant contract and ultimately the company announced it was closing down. The economic engine of the borough was being switched off, leading many of the local people to think about their future. In the first 10 years of the new century, the number of full-time jobs in Barking and Dagenham fell by a quarter.

Water towers near Ford plant in Dagenham Ford is cutting jobs at its Dagenham factory

For many white British households, the 2000s had left them without a job but with a sizeable chunk of capital in their home. Some had also benefited from redundancy pay-outs and pension deals offered by Ford. It was a cue for the families who had left London's East End in the middle of the 20th Century to move on again at the start of the 21st.

A closer look at London reveals how many neighbourhoods in the outer boroughs have seen significant falls in the white British population - Newham, Brent, Haringey, Enfield, Ealing, Hounslow, Merton and Lewisham almost form a ring around the capital. Only the affluent boroughs of Richmond and Kingston along the river to the west prevent the completion of the orange doughnut.

Change in white British population in London between 2001 and 2011

Ten largest decreases in white British population. Newham 37.5%,Ealing 23.8%, Waltham Forest 23.6%, Barking and Dagenham 30.6%, Slough 30.3%, Redbridge 29.8%, Harrow 28.5%, Brent 27.3%, Enfield 24.5%, Luton 24.4%
Ten largest decreases in white British population outside London. Wolverhampton 9.7%, Coventry -10.4%, Rushmoor -10.5%, Birmingham -11.1%, Watford -11.4%, Reading -11.8%, Leicester -12.3%, Oadby and Wigston -13.1%, Luton -24.4%, Slough -30.3%

Inner London saw some places losing the white British population, but quite a number - coloured blue - bucked the trend and recorded an increase.

Even central boroughs that experienced a decline in white British may have seen an increase in the number of white residents. Kensington and Chelsea recorded 17,300 fewer white British residents but the category "white other" now makes up 28% of the local population. The immigrants here are rich white Europeans and Russians.

Start Quote

Tea rooms and restaurants have been replaced by takeaway chicken shops and halal supermarkets serving the new arrivals”

End Quote

It is a different story in Barking and Dagenham.

The people moving into the borough tend to be of black African heritage. I was introduced to Victor and Victoria, whose parents came to Britain from Ghana in the 50s. He works for London Transport and she is a nurse in the NHS - typical of the professional black families who've arrived from inner London to take advantage of available housing as the borough's white residents leave.

With a time-lapse camera, it would appear that London is pulsing as generations and ethnic groups move up and move out.

On Dagenham's main shopping street, I met a number of white locals who were planning to leave the borough. One male pensioner was hoping to relocate to Clacton - a seaside town on the Essex coast now nicknamed Little Dagenham. A local councillor told me how his parents had sold up and bought a large cottage with a quarter-acre of garden in Lincolnshire. Another woman says she had her eyes set on a little cottage in Leigh-on-Sea near Southend.

Leigh is a particular favourite. Many residents from Barking and Dagenham will have taken the train along the Thames Estuary towards Southend on a work excursion - the old beano to the seaside. Some still do, looking out of the window as the industrial landscape gives way to green fields and open wetlands teeming with birds.

Over the past decade or so, towns along the railway line between Fenchurch St and Shoeburyness have seen significant increases to the white British population. In Westcliff, part of Southend, I met a family who recently cashed in their three-bedroom house in Barking for a six-bedroom home by the sea. They keep bumping into old school friends, realising that they were joining a sizeable population of migrants from the borough.

Pub in Crewe with Polish sign Polish is the second most common language spoken in England

The years between the last two censuses have witnessed significant cultural change in London, particularly in the outer boroughs. Some white British may have moved because their neighbourhood has been culturally transformed, the tea rooms and restaurants replaced by takeaway chicken shops and halal supermarkets serving the new arrivals.

But there is also a story here of white working class families that escaped from the slums and bombed-out East End in the middle of the last century, found new opportunities in London's outer boroughs and then, in the past decade - often having prospered from the housing boom and the capital's economic growth - cashed in their assets and bought themselves that little cottage in the countryside or by the sea.

It is a story of aspiration. It is a story of success.

Update 16:05 GMT

Fords Dagenham inform me that a recent reorganisation means 3,500 people remain employed at the plant.

 
Mark Easton Article written by Mark Easton Mark Easton Home editor

Don't have nightmares - crime is down

Recorded crime is an unsatisfactory measure of crime trends - and improving recording practices will not change this.

Read full article

More on This Story

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +3

    Comment number 1005.

    I'm sure there's much truth in this narrative. A look at the chart makes one wonder, though - the areas of increase (blue) have a maximum scale of 15%, while zones of decreased white population (orange) are scaled at up to 50%...

    This may be due to population density - we wouldn't expect a 50% increase rural villages, but one wonders how much the statistics are shaped to fit this 'success' story.

  • rate this
    +12

    Comment number 1004.

    what a complete and utter joke of an article this is by Easton

    typical PC BBC garbage - we aint happy with mass uncontrolled immigration - we aint happy that we will soon be outnumbered - we aint happy that we will then be at the mercy of this unknown quantity

  • rate this
    +12

    Comment number 1003.

    Mark, your analysis is wrong. White flight by the older generation because their local shopping centres and amenities have been changed by all the immigrants. The younger generations so that their children can get an education not tainted by foreign ideologies.

  • rate this
    +6

    Comment number 1002.

    What Mark conveniently ignores is the massive immigration and "assimilation" imposed on ALL white countries and ONLY white countries.

    Eliminating any group by any means is genocide under international law, but if we call it "Diversity" or "economic success" that makes it all right?

  • rate this
    +22

    Comment number 1001.

    The BBC's job for the past few decades has been to socially engineer the public. To make us believe that "diversity" & "multiculturalism" aren't a choice, but a necessity.

    The BBC subtly drills this into us.

    Example:

    http://tinypic.com/r/15ei9vp/6
    http://tinypic.com/r/30m1l4w/6

    Two stories to do with education, and the BBC uses pictures of minorities to represent 'British students'.

  • rate this
    +13

    Comment number 1000.

    I came to London with 2K in my pocket, paid international student rates to do degree, paid to do my accountancy qualifications, own my flat, own my car and have 2 young kids. I am also paid far less than my less educated/experienced colleagues in all the companies I've worked at. As an economic migrant, I was never entitled to ANY benefits, not even JSA. Not all of us foreigners are scroungers.

  • rate this
    -8

    Comment number 999.

    It really is just an excuse isnt it. Facts are the UK became great through Empire, not because of your average hard working joe. The high currency rate and economic and political power of the past have been eroded and the UK is in the tank with all the other fish. The Empire has come and gone and apparently it is the fault of the immigrants - whatever.

  • rate this
    -38

    Comment number 998.

    Why is this even a news story.......Who actually cares?!?!?!

    I certainly don't - I like the fact we live in a multicultural society

  • rate this
    +5

    Comment number 997.

    Oh Dear Mark,not playing as well in the comments section as it would in,say for instance the Groucho Club,your opinion piece is it ? You are afforded a pleasant lifestyle by the license payer (we have no choice in the matter) to inform us,instead you patronise and take us for half-wits.You are a disgrace to your profession,you really are.

  • Comment number 996.

    This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

  • rate this
    +6

    Comment number 995.

    Left in 1999 as either you live in a middle class area that costs a bomb or a low class area where you are in the minority. Add to that the costs of transport - public and fuel and it's no wonder I moved to the US of A. London is just TOO EXPENSIVE

  • rate this
    +7

    Comment number 994.

    How long before there's war on the streets of London I wonder.....

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 993.

    There are a few startling ironies exposed by this HYS.

    One is that "white" immigrants (Polish) are favoured over non white, but everyone declares the topic is not subject to racism.

    Another is that London and NY are generally considered the places to go to by every young person on earth who grows up in an ethnically pure area. Such as the congo. Saudi arabia. Mongolia. North Korea. Iran.

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 992.

    If we had proportional representation BNP and UKIP would get about 20% of the vote each. If you want something done about immigration, vote Lib Dem. A Lib Dem gov, would introduce proportional representation. Unfortunately, you would have to put up with the Lib Dems for 5 years.

  • rate this
    +11

    Comment number 991.

    Where are the editors selection. THE BBC Is scared to really tell the truth.
    Most comments reflect peoples fear that whole areas are being taken over by an alien culture. THE BBC is patronising Mark Easton is not telling the truth. There is racism and bigotry but its not from the original inhabitants. On a BBC presenters salary you can avoid areas
    where misogony and homophobia are rife

  • Comment number 990.

    This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

  • rate this
    +3

    Comment number 989.

    London is no longer a British city. The sooner Scotland is independent and we no longer have to send our taxes down there the better I like it. Roll on the 2014 independence referendum!

  • rate this
    +6

    Comment number 988.

    @961. Dagobert Rumdoch - "Life in London is hard and you need to be tough, hard-working, resilient an resourceful to survive."

    Pffft. The main skill you need is to be able to put up with cramped living conditions and the terrible smell. It's not worth it.

  • rate this
    +13

    Comment number 987.

    I have lived in my present former village, now London suburb, since 1943. The change is so great the place is un-recognisable. We are now very much in the minority and in old age I wish we had moved years ago. Now sadly it is too late and we are strangers in our own home town. As someone said earlier, it is only natural to want to be among your own kind, not a sin.

  • rate this
    +3

    Comment number 986.

    Nonsense. It's not 'aspirational' that whites leave London. London is the most concentrated business centre in Britain so if anyone wants to aspire, they go TO London, not away from it.
    The examples quoted are people moving to the seaside. That's retirement. Selling up and moving out. The immigrants moving in are the aspirational ones. London is a factory, not a home town.

 

Page 54 of 104

 

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.