Horsemeat scandal: Don't dump meat, says food minister


Owen Paterson says he would eat withdrawn meat products because "they pose no threat to human health"

Related Stories

People should not throw away frozen meat products in the wake of further revelations in the horsemeat scandal, the food minister has said.

David Heath advised consumers to carry on eating meat unless told otherwise.

The Food Standards Agency has asked UK firms to test all processed beef foods, but said it did not "suspect there is any health issue with frozen food".

Environment Secretary Owen Paterson is to hold a summit with heads of meat retailers and suppliers on Saturday.

Food Minister Mr Heath said the government's advice was "exactly that" of the FSA's.

"The FSA says there is no reason to suppose there is a health risk and therefore the advice is to carry on with normal shopping habits until you are told otherwise," he told the BBC.

But shadow environment secretary Mary Creagh has expressed fears that other contaminated foods may be found.

'Criminal activity'

Supermarket chain Aldi said tests on its Today's Special Frozen Beef Lasagne and Today's Special Frozen Spaghetti Bolognese showed they contained between 30% and 100% horsemeat. These products had already been withdrawn after a warning from French supplier Comigel.

Is it a health risk?

Horsemeat itself should be no more dangerous than beef and is eaten in many countries around the world.

However, there is concern around a drug given to horses - known as bute (phenylbutazone) - which is dangerous if taken by humans.

Decades ago it was used as a treatment for gout and arthritis, but it caused a serious blood disorder, aplastic anaemia, in rare cases.

While it was banned for human use, it is still used for animals. However, it is not allowed to enter the human food chain.

Findus has been asked to test for bute in its products.

If people have any of the affected meals lurking in their freezer, they are advised to return them to the store they were purchased from.

An Aldi spokesman said: "This is completely unacceptable and like other affected companies, we feel angry and let down.... If the label says beef, our customers expect it to be beef."

Findus UK became caught up in the row this week after horsemeat was found in its lasagne.

A third-party French supplier alerted Findus on Monday to concerns the beef lasagne product did not "conform to specification".

The FSA said Findus had tested the meat in 18 of its beef lasagne products and found 11 meals in which it contained between 60% and 100% horsemeat. Findus has withdrawn the meals. Comigel said it had withdrawn all products related to its own supplier.

The FSA said it was "highly likely" criminal activity was to blame for the contamination.

Mr Paterson said: "Clearly there are some people who believe they can get away with selling cheap meat and passing it off as something else. Our investigations will find them and they will feel the full force of the law."

In other related developments:

  • The body representing school caterers in the UK says it is "as certain as anyone could be" that that horsemeat products have not been used in schools
  • Prime Minister David Cameron describes the latest revelations as "very shocking" and "completely unacceptable"
  • Ms Creagh says she has contacted police to pass on information concerning UK companies who are potentially involved in the illegal horsemeat trade
  • The GMB union says all hospitals, schools and meals-on-wheels services should verify that horsemeat has not been served to vulnerable people
  • The Ministry of Agriculture in France says it is investigating the possibility of criminal fraud in relation to horsemeat found in ready meals
  • Trading standards and environmental health bodies say their officers across the UK are on "high alert"
  • Findus says it is "sorry that we have let people down", in a fresh statement. It has also withdrawn several ready-meals from supermarkets in France and Sweden.
  • Retail analysts warn the latest disclosures could be "disastrous" for the meat processing industry

FSA chief executive Catherine Brown told the BBC: "We are demanding that food businesses conduct authenticity tests on all beef products, such as beefburgers, meatballs and lasagne, and provide the results to the FSA."

The FSA's website advises consumers: "There is no reason to suspect that there's any health issue with frozen food in general, and we wouldn't advise people to stop eating it."

UK  beef consumption Between fresh and processed, the UK consumes more fresh or frozen beef.
Imports and exports The UK still produces and consumes more of its own beef than it imports
Imports of processed beef Ireland and Brazil are major suppliers of the UK's imported processed beef

Peter Kendall, president of the National Farmers' Union, said farmers who had suffered from food scares in the past were "furious" over the horsemeat revelations because they had already "raised their game".

He urged consumers to buy British meat to be sure of what they are eating.


The French authorities have been slow to react. But today the French Ministry of Agriculture did finally issue a statement. It considers the issue "a matter of criminal fraud" and the authorities will be investigating.

The question - as yet unanswered - is how horsemeat ended up in the beef chain. Was there confusion between the two meats - beef and horse - that were processed in the same plant? Or, as is more likely, was Comigel duped by a third party supplier?

There is also a wider issue for the European authorities. The rules on labelling for meat products are fairly straightforward. But the rules are less clear on the provenance of meat when it comes to the ingredients of processed products. And food analysts are now calling for a review.

Since Comigel also supplies the Benelux, Scandinavian and Eastern Bloc supermarket chains, this is fast becoming a European problem.

Horsemeat may not pose a significant risk to humans but the health of European food processing is very much open to question.

Findus is the latest company to be caught up in the controversy surrounding contamination of meat products, which has affected firms in the UK, Irish Republic, Poland and France.

Last month, Irish food inspectors announced they had found horsemeat in some burgers stocked by a number of UK supermarket chains, including Tesco, Iceland and Lidl.

Ms Creagh expressed fears there were further revelations to come from the food industry.

"What we have had over the last four weeks is a constant drip, drip, drip of revelations from the food industry, from the Food Standards Agency, and what I am worried about is that the more they are testing for horse, the more they are finding," Ms Creagh said.

She suggested further guidance was needed on whether people should eat other processed foods labelled as containing beef.

Mr Heath said the FSA was undertaking the "biggest testing of beef products that has ever taken place" in order to offer reassurance.

A statement from the British Meat Processors Association (BMPA) said it "deplores the latest reported incidents of gross contamination of some processed meat products".

It urged members to review their raw material and ingredients-sourcing procedures.


More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 107.

    May 1990 - Agriculture Minister John Gummer and his daughter eat beef burgers in front of British press.

    nothing to see, move along.. yeh right!

    The problem is not horse meat, the problem is we don't know what's in our food.. we should know.

    The ENTIRE food chain for ALL meat should now be scrutinised, not every piece, but random samples from all sources.

  • rate this

    Comment number 106.

    22. Paul
    The worse thing about all this is the smugness emanating from those who (have the time to) prepare and cook their own food...
    Ignoring the fact you can make pasta sauce faster than it takes to cook a ready lasagne in the oven there's not much smugness here. I'm really having to trust the butcher that the fresh beef mince really is A) beef & B) fresh.

  • rate this

    Comment number 105.

    Why is the FSA ordering the Producers "to test their own evidence" (food products) ?

    Surely this is the same as asking the criminal to test and decide upon the evidence against him? would get the truth?

    Isn't this why things have got so bad?

    Horse and Contaminants have apparently been in food for years

    There's no safe limit for "phenylbutazone" in humans

  • rate this

    Comment number 104.

    This is fraud, simple and clear cut. By all means eat the meat, whatever it is. Before you do consider the dreadful conditions that these horses suffer. Wild horses and unwanted pets are shipped over to the continent to be slaughtered in unacceptable conditions. The carcass is butchered, the good meat to the tables of the host country; the bits blasted off the bone and returned to us as beef.

  • rate this

    Comment number 103.

    This will no doubt be blamed on people wanting cheaper food, in reality meat is not cheap & the quality of supermarket meat even when sold as what it is (eg chicken injected with water to increase volume) is questionable.

    The root cause of this is large supermarkets & their supply chains wanting to squeeze more & more profit by reducing quality, while consumers lose trust, greed rules again!

  • rate this

    Comment number 102.

    For those who have serious concerns surrounding how our food is checked and regulated for safety and content the following article says more than I ever could:

    Gamekeeper turned poacher? . . .

  • rate this

    Comment number 101.

    Horses can be a veritable cocktail of pharmaceuticals together with the laughable horse passporting system should ensure the withdrawal of ALL processed meat NOW.. BSE and Salmonella in eggs sound familiar????

    Never mind the welfare aspects of "illegal meat" slaughter in Mexico and Poland would make consumers blood run cold

  • rate this

    Comment number 100.

    If I'd known that horse meat was in Findus Lasagna, I would have bought hundreds of packets. I love horse meat. It makes me feel great.

  • rate this

    Comment number 99.

    "Don't dump meat, says food minister"

    WHAT!? We do not know for sure what any of our manufactured food products contain!!

    Why is the Food Standards Authority leaving the food manufacturers to test their own products??? What the hell is the point of the Food Standards AUTHORITY!!!!!????

  • rate this

    Comment number 98.

    Throw frozen Findus foods away? Ney, lad, ney!

    You wouldn't catch me hoofing it from the freezer to the bin. Horse meat has never done me any harm, I've always had a long face.

  • rate this

    Comment number 97.

    100% horse meat in Findus Lasagne! Heavens only knows what goes into their Crispy Pancakes, horse shoes perhaps?

    Certainly tastes like it...

  • rate this

    Comment number 96.

    I have no problem with eating horse.
    The only issue are:-
    1. Where did the meat come from?
    2. Was it probably screened for harmful drugs/diseases?
    3. The packaging did not say what is in it.

    Apart from that, a redrum burger does not obviously taste a lot different to beef, after all, no-one actually noticed when eating them.

  • rate this

    Comment number 95.

    Aside from the fact that selling horse in place of beef is fraud, I am shocked at how these companies claim there is no health risk. They do not know the wrong species of animal is coming into the food chain, how do we know none of these horses are not diseased or been given drugs / anitbiotics that are banned from human consumption?

  • rate this

    Comment number 94.

    If the supermarkets etc would care to reduce the equine meat products to
    10p a pack to get rid of them then I'd love to fill my freezer up! Can't say I ever noticed anything wrong with these products which we are now informed are less than a racing favourite!

  • rate this

    Comment number 93.

    I wouldn't trust any processed meat product until the industry is cleaned up.
    We farmers have to spend considerable time and money ensuring our produce is traceable (risking prosecution, fines and not being able to sell our animals if we don't comply) and have to declare animals are fit to eat when we sell them.
    They can't know that contaminated products are safe. Reassure first, questions later

  • rate this

    Comment number 92.

    @blackie1947- "Meat is meat and as long as it comes from didease free animals basically who cares"
    You are totally missing the point. Of course there is nothing wrong with eating horse if you want to. But if something is labelled beef it should be beef!

  • rate this

    Comment number 91.


    'When I make a chili con carne'

    Unless you're grinding your own 'carne' that you shot yourself then you have no clue what's in there. Regardless if your supplier is a ruddy faced local butcher with stripy apron or a pimply kid at Tesco's checkout.

  • rate this

    Comment number 90.

    Got nothing against horse meat but when I buy something, I expect it to contain what it says on the label.

    I'll be buying all my meat from the local butcher now.

  • rate this

    Comment number 89.

    As long as the horse meat is safe, I'm not sure why there's a panic.

    Horse meat tastes nice, and there's nothing intrinsically wrong with it. This is just a food labelling issue, not a safety one.

    PS - all the people saying 'make your own food' - that works OK if you breed your own cows. Otherwise, do you KNOW where that steak came from?

  • rate this

    Comment number 88.

    I wonder how many of you have been to France and other foreign countries that eat horse meat and other meat that we don't eat here and eaten it without being told what it was?

    I have been on 2 school exchanges to France and stayed with families and ate was given to me out of politeness.


Page 49 of 54


More UK stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.