Paying tradesmen cash in hand morally wrong, says minister


Mr Gauke said cash payments were "facilitating" the hidden economy

Related Stories

Treasury minister David Gauke has said it is "morally wrong" to pay tradesmen such as plumbers, builders and cleaners in cash in the hope of avoiding tax.

He argued the practice came at "a big cost" to the Treasury and meant other people had to pay more.

But Treasury sources stressed Mr Gauke was answering a specific question rather than proposing a policy change.

Labour said the government should be focusing on "clamping down" on "large-scale tax avoidance".

Asked if he ever had paid cash to tradesmen to reduce his costs, London Mayor Boris Johnson said: "I've certainly paid a lot of cash in hand."

In response to the same question, Local Government secretary Eric Pickles said: "Certainly not."

And Culture Secretary Jeremy Hunt said: "David Gauke was saying that tax-dodging is wrong and personally I haven't dodged tax."

The government is estimated to lose about £2bn each year to the black economy as tradesmen fail to pay VAT or income tax by not declaring payments and keeping them "off the books".

Mr Gauke told BBC Two's Newsnight there was nothing wrong with paying in cash, but doing so actively to avoid tax was wrong.

'No alternative'

Mr Gauke said: "When a tradesman says, 'Here's a 10%, a 20% discount on your bill if you pay me cash in hand' that is facilitating the hidden economy. That's as big a problem in terms of loss to the Exchequer as tax avoidance. Revenue is not being paid as it should be paid."


I pay a builder for a new patio. Crazy paving and all. Knowing he has to pay VAT on my bill I make a suggestion: How about I pay him in £20 notes?

That would enable him to slip the cash into his pocket and out of sight of the tax man. It would also make my bill smaller.

It's illegal for my builder not to declare all his earnings. But what's my responsibility for his action?

According to Treasury minister David Gauke it's "morally wrong" to want to offer cash for that purpose.

Hear that? The sound of cabinet ministers shuffling uncomfortably as they remember years of paying cash to their builders, plumbers, gardeners, nannies and cleaners.

In its assault on the tax-avoidance practices of the rich, the government has been ready to use the rhetoric of morality. It's about fairness.

But at a time when people feel stretched, telling people they have a moral responsibility to pay top whack is a slightly sticky place for a minister to be.

He added that he had "never said to a tradesman, 'If I pay you cash, can I get a discount?'"

But asked if he thought any ministerial colleagues had done so, Mr Gauke replied: "I don't know, but if people do do that they have to do so with the recognition that means taxes will be higher for the rest."

The Daily Telegraph quotes Mr Gauke as saying: "Getting a discount with your plumber by paying cash in hand is something that is a big cost to the Revenue and means others have to pay more in tax.

"I think it is morally wrong. It is illegal for the plumber but it is pretty implicit in those circumstances that there is a reason why there is a discount for cash."

But Tariq Dag Khan, of the tradesman recommendation website Rated People, said: "David Gauke's comments that it is morally wrong to pay tradesmen in cash do little to help tradesmen who are struggling in a difficult economic climate.

"For the reality is that there is little or no alternative to cash payments for many tradesmen, and criticising the whole industry belies a misunderstanding of the situation many customers and tradesmen are in.

"There is a great deal of trust involved when hiring a tradesman for both the tradesman and the customer and therefore cheque payments do not provide a viable alternative especially when, if the cheque bounces, the tradesmen could be dangerously out of pocket and in some circumstances forced out of business as a result."

Boris Johnson among politicians asked if they ever paid cash in hand

Labour leader Ed Miliband, on a visit to Paris to meet French president Francois Hollande, said: "What I say is that the job of government is to pass the right laws to clamp down on tax avoidance - that's the most important thing of all.

"What I will be saying to the government is that they should be clamping down on the large-scale tax avoidance which has been revealed in the past few days and I think that's what people want to see from the government."

Last month Prime Minister David Cameron condemned the use in the past by comedian Jimmy Carr of a Jersey-based scheme as "morally wrong" and in his Budget speech Chancellor George Osborne described tax avoidance as "morally repugnant".

Mr Gauke was interviewed after he outlined proposals to tackle "aggressive" tax avoidance schemes, promising the government would force "cowboy" financial firms to disclose the names of people using them.


More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 2282.

    Is it just me or have the government only just woken up to the issue of cash paid tradesmen/women not declaring their cash income?

    This has been going on for a great many years and I am sure it is nowhere near the scale of the measures taken by the super rich to avoid paying tax.

    People in glass houses shouldn't throw stones

  • rate this

    Comment number 2234.

    This works on the assumption that if you pay a trader in cash then he won't declare it to the tax man. However, many people are honest. Much of our trade is in cash - it's recorded in the books, paid into a bank account and the tax man takes his share. We like cash because we are not waiting 4 to 8 weeks for a payment or risk no payment at all.

  • rate this

    Comment number 1839.

    So you're on a minimum wage, the tradesman does a small job... you pay him/her cash and suddenly you're a tax evader. It's the poorest people who have no choice but to pay tax while the rich hide theirs away and the bankers use your money to make more for themselves or lose it and then get you to bail them out. I know what I'd rather be... I will and do use cash whenever I can.

  • rate this

    Comment number 1030.

    I don't have a cheque book. Most tradesmen don't carry EPOS terminals around. The result is, I pay cash for most small jobs. If a tradesman wants to offer a discount for cash that's fine by me. It's his responsibility to pay his taxes, not mine to police him. I'm reasonably sure most tradesmen spend most of their cash earnings in this country whereas most of the elite don't.

  • rate this

    Comment number 796.

    Sigh, out crawl all the hypocrites, again.

    Tax evasion is tax evasion. Just because its you that does that rather than some "greedy banker" doesn't make it right.

    All of you disagreeing with the comment that it is immoral are acting like spoilt kids. Come on people, grow up a little.


Comments 5 of 17


More Politics stories



Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.