Do you live above the bread, butter and jam line?


Discussion about poverty in Britain quickly gets snagged on the question of whether you can be poor if you have a plasma TV.

But if, instead of thinking about the breadline, we consider what level of income is needed for an acceptable standard of living, the debate changes.

It gives us a sense of what is decent in a rich country like ours, what we regard as a socially acceptable minimum.

It is not just about having bread - it's about having butter and, occasionally, a dollop of jam too.

The concept of a minimum income standard (MIS) was introduced by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation (JRF) four years ago - I wrote about it here.

Since then, of course, austerity has barged its way into our lives. So JRF decided to repeat the exercise of 2008 and see what's changed.

And the surprise is that so little has.

More than 20 panels of ordinary citizens were asked to put together a list of items they considered essential for an acceptable standard of living and the choices were very close to what their predecessors had selected four years earlier.

Family car

There were a few nods to belt-tightening: the budget for eating out and takeaways has been cut to £90 a year for a family of four; the current amount set aside for Christmas and birthday presents has been reduced; instead of swimming with a toddler once a week the panels made it once a month.

Back in 2008, the view was that people living in towns and cities could get by with public transport.

The JRF's Donald Hirsch and the ASI's Dr Eamonn Butler debate living standards

Now, though, the public panels have concluded that it makes more financial sense to use a second-hand hatch-back (1.6l petrol Ford Focus to be precise) - buying one that's five years old and selling at 10.

Rising public transport fares, cuts to bus services and the access to out-of-town discount stores a car allows, now make your own four wheels a necessity in all places except London.

On the roof of your Ford Focus, incidentally, you are expected to fit a storage box to accommodate supplies for a week's self-catering holiday in the UK.

No cigarettes or tobacco are on the list of needs, but a couple are permitted to buy four cans of lager and a bottle of red (keeps better than white) wine each week.

A TV is allowed - only Freeview, no cable or satellite contracts.

Watch Mark's report friom the BBC Ten O'Clock News

Mobile phones are now deemed a necessity, with the panels calculating it's cheaper to get one with an alarm clock and digital camera so you don't need to buy those items separately.

All families with children should have a computer with internet access.

When all the needs identified were added up, the minimum earnings for a family of four with both parents working worked out at just under £37,000 a year.

For a single working-age adult, minimum earnings would need to be £16,400.

That means more than a quarter of the population in Britain - 17 million people - don't have enough income to reach the level the public think is required for an acceptable living standard.

Those on benefits don't come close.

The minimum acceptable income calculated by the public panels is, in real terms, almost exactly the same as four years ago.

What has changed is that three million more people in Britain now don't have the money to meet it.

April 2012 minimum income standard

Family type Single working age person Pensioner couple Couple + 2 children Lone parent +1 child

* Excluding council tax ** If both members of couple work full time

Weekly budget excl rent & childcare





% increase since 2008 (cf CPI rose 14%)





% of median income, after housing costs





% of budget* provided by Income Support / Pension Credit





Earnings calculation:

Weekly budget incl rent & childcare





Annual earnings required





Hourly wage required





Mark Easton Article written by Mark Easton Mark Easton Home editor

Savile: 'How could this be allowed to happen?'

Today's investigation into Jimmy Savile reveals how his criminal behaviour "was facilitated by ministers or civil servants".

Read full article

More on This Story


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 274.

    What a silly question, no I am a retired automotive/aerospace design engineer, nobody who does anything useful gets decent pay or pension.

  • rate this

    Comment number 273.

    One man's necessity is another man's luxury. Ask me what I think is a necessity & I will reply an Aston Martin DB9. Do I have one - no, will the govt increase the minimum wage so I can afford one - no. Should I moan about it & complain I'm hard done by? What do you think?

    Deciding what is a "necessity" is hard but a pre-requisite for any sort of meaningful debate. Shouldn't we start there?

  • rate this

    Comment number 272.

    Is this before or after tax?

  • rate this

    Comment number 271.

    WRONG, 37k is not the socially acceptable minimum, how do I know? Millions of people are currently living below this standard, and society does nothing about it. That makes it socially acceptable by definition. Smart left wing annalists telling people what they DO find acceptable, not should. Basic minimum wage £11K a year is the real figure. Whether it should be or not is another argument!!

  • rate this

    Comment number 270.

    Stop unemployment benefit after 4 weeks.... people would find a way to work, the family unit would have meaning again and people would have self respect. In China there is no unemployment benefit, and families look after their own, and everyone has a sense of duty to pull their own weight.

    Would do the UK some good !


Comments 5 of 274



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.