What are the police for?

Home secretary with police officers Theresa May hopes to save £150m a year with the new police pay deal

The Home Secretary's speech on the police on Monday was billed as a coherent ideological vision for the service in England and Wales.

As she rubber-stamped proposed changes which will take tens of millions out of officers' pay packets, Theresa May emphasised that, while "some police officers will be disappointed by this outcome", she was not forcing through reform just to save money.

She explained how changes to officers' pay and conditions, cuts to police budgets and the introduction of elected police commissioners all form part of a plan to make the force more responsive to the demands of the citizens they serve.

The reforms, she said, "will leave us with a police force that is answerable to the public and transformed in its ability to fight crime".

In effect, the Home Secretary was offering her answer to a question upon which I have been pondering for the past couple of months: what are the police for?

My new BBC Radio 4 series, for which that question acts as the title, begins on Monday. At first glance, we think we know the answer: it is about fighting crime and keeping people safe. But a cocktail of major reform and budget cuts obliges politicians and police chiefs to be a bit more precise than that.

Some chief constables are warning that neighbourhood policing may have to be cut. Others say they need to look at the amount of time spent on partnership working and the meetings with other agencies.

Start Quote

What really bothers people is anti-social behaviour, minor damage, noisiness, people parking inconsiderately”

End Quote Sara Thornton Thames Valley Police

I have met police advisors who think officers should do less investigating crime and more preventing crime. Ministers insist there is a lot of bureaucracy and duplication which can be reduced.

On becoming Home Secretary, Theresa May told senior officers she wanted to be crystal clear that the mission of the service was "to cut crime, no more and no less". While the first part of that statement is unarguable, the second would seem to relegate great chunks of what the police currently do into "extras".

The lost child, the confused old gentleman who has forgotten how to get home, the burst water main that has flooded the High Street, the death notice to be delivered to relatives of a teenager killed in a road accident, the road safety advice for primary school children, the neighbours who need to be told to turn the music down: are we really saying that the police should stop doing these duties unless they are demonstrated to "cut crime"?

In episode one, the policing minister Nick Herbert accepts that there is rather more to the job than cutting crime, but insists the home secretary was right to emphasise that that is the core of their mission.

Police on horses outside the stadium before the FA Cup Fourth Round match between Millwall and Southampton Police duties are many and varied

The past decade has seen a shift in police priorities from an enforcement approach which targets those who break the law to a consensual style which encourages people to obey the law. The service has become a bit more Dixon of Dock Green and a bit less The Sweeney.

For some, this is a worrying trend. As one delegate at the Tory conference last year put it, there should be more emphasis put on "rat catchers" rather than "social workers".

However, having spent a week with police officers of all kinds in Thames Valley, it seems to me that there is a paradox in terms of what the public want the service to do.

On a general level, people will often say they want police to catch villains and lock them up. But when you ask what they want the police to do locally, it tends to be more mundane tasks.

As the Chief Constable of Thames Valley, Sara Thornton, told me: "When we do our surveys very, very rarely do people say what's bothering us around here is burglary or robbery or car crime. What's really bothering them is anti-social behaviour, minor damage, noisiness, rowdiness, people parking inconsiderately."

In the old coaching town of Stony Stratford near Milton Keynes, for example, I met the chair of the local neighbourhood action group, Denise Branning. Top of local people's concerns were litter and thoughtless parking, she said.

Officer talking to members of the public Community engagement is a watchword

Another common grievance was dog poo. Just around the corner I met a police community support officer whose duties included patrolling parks and footpaths to ensure owners picked up and disposed of the offending items.

Is this what police budgets should be spent on? In Monday's speech, the home secretary put it like this: "From the graffiti and litter that blights a local area, to the binge drinking and drug dealing that makes people frightened to step outside, right up to the criminal gangs who flaunt their illegal wealth and cheat the exchequer out of millions - our police reforms will help fight them all."

That is a much broader description of the police's role than cutting crime "no more and no less". Indeed, it might be argued, Theresa May wants them to do it all - from kids tagging a lamp-post to organised criminal gangs.

So what do you think the role of the police should be? Take part in the debate on Twitter, using the hashtag #whatarepolicefor.

Mark's series What Are The Police For starts on BBC Radio 4 on Monday 30 January at 20:00 GMT, or catch up with iPlayer

Mark Easton Article written by Mark Easton Mark Easton Home editor

Savile: 'How could this be allowed to happen?'

Today's investigation into Jimmy Savile reveals how his criminal behaviour "was facilitated by ministers or civil servants".

Read full article

More on This Story


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 138.

    We need tough action on nuisance neighbours as it can affect people's health and wellbeing. The police often don;t treat calls reporting bad benhaviour seriously eg elderly lady reporting children throwing and kicking footballs at her window deliberately trying to intimdate her - reply from police 'are they enjoying themselves'.

  • rate this

    Comment number 137.

    So, WHERE are these "police" people you speak of?

  • rate this

    Comment number 136.

    They want the Police to risk their lives, work unsociable hours, never strike whatever the reason, put up the stress of horrific crime and accident scenes, public abuse, lack of support from the Courts and their higherachy, and the Government, forgo annual leave. and so on - What is their reward: Have their pay reduced by up to £4.000 p.a. add red to that Do you want a Police Service?

  • rate this

    Comment number 135.

    Try calling the council in relation to a loose,roaming dog after 4pm any day...Despite councils having the responsibility to deal with such things, often the public have no one else to turn too but to call the police to deal with these matters out of hours.

  • rate this

    Comment number 134.

    Good first episode Mark.I take 999 calls for the police. Over time Ive noticed the police are more social services than crime fighters. You can set your watch to 4pm every day and especially Fridays when social services and mental health professionals go home and clearing their desks by calling the police to say "we visited Mr/Mrs X and we are concerned they "may" be suicidal. Were going home".


Comments 5 of 138



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.