RBS boss Stephen Hester rejects £1m bonus


Ed Miliband: "The government has got a completely tin ear when it comes to understanding what people are feeling"

Related Stories

Royal Bank of Scotland chief executive Stephen Hester has turned down his controversial bonus, worth nearly £1m.

BBC business editor Robert Peston said Mr Hester would renounce the £963,000 shares-only payment after succumbing to "enormous political pressure".

Chancellor George Osborne said it was a "sensible and welcome" decision that now let Mr Hester focus on getting back billions of pounds for the taxpayer.

Labour leader Ed Miliband said the RBS boss had "done the right thing".

Earlier, Labour said it would force a vote on the issue after Prime Minister David Cameron refused to block the bonus from the mostly publicly-owned bank.

'Out of touch'

Robert Peston said the board felt Mr Hester had earned the bonus for the way he had made RBS a less risky organisation.


It was Labour's decision to put Stephen Hester's bonus to a Commons vote that gave the RBS chief executive no option but to say he would not be taking £963,000 in shares.

As an RBS director put it to me, it would have been a great mistake for the semi-nationalised bank to fight Parliament to preserve rewards for its chief executive seen by many as excessive.

MPs were expected to vote against the bonus payment, and in those circumstances, it was untenable for him to pocket it. Or at least that was the conclusion that Mr Hester reached in conversation with the bank's chairman, Sir Philip Hampton.

That said, RBS's non-executive directors stand by their decision to award Mr Hester 60% of the maximum bonus he could have earned - because they feel he has strengthened the bank, and they argue that Mr Hester is paid less than his peers.

But when it looked as though MPs were going to vote against it, the general consensus amongst the directors was that the "game was up", he added.

Earlier this month, RBS announced it would cut 3,500 jobs from its global banking division.

The cuts will mean RBS has removed 11,000 employees from its staff, almost halving its 2007, pre-credit crunch headcount of 24,000.

Shares in the bank have fallen 36% in the last year, falling 2% on Monday's open.

Shadow business secretary Chuka Umunna said Mr Hester was already being adequately rewarded for his performance.

"He received £1.2m a year - that's 46 times the average salary of an average employee in this country - to do that job," he said.

"Usually you receive a bonus when you've done something above and beyond - exceptional, extraordinary."

"But many of the things that have been cited in terms of things that he's done for the bank are things that you would expect him to do."

Mr Hester was awarded only 60% of his bonus, which is judged on five categories. These are: strategic direction;

business delivery and financial performance; stakeholders; risk and control; and capability and development.

But William Wright, investment bank analyst for Financial News told the BBC: "It sets a very dangerous precedent for RBS.

"It raises the level of political risk and political interference in the day-to-day running of RBS to what some people many consider to be intolerable levels.

"It raises very serious questions about who actually is running RBS day to day.

"Shareholders, in this case the UK government, appoint a board, which in turn appoints an executive team to run the bank, and here we have a situation where the board agrees something, which has been signed off by shareholders and then they have been forced into a U-turn by political opinion."

Former Liberal Democrat Treasury spokesman Lord Oakeshott said Mr Hester's decision was "better late than never".

"I'm glad that eventually Stephen Hester has seen sense and seen the outrage of most people in this country, and Lib Dems who have been complaining bitterly about this for weeks," he said.

Bob Diamond Mr Hester's bonus would not look big compared with that of Barclays boss Bob Diamond, Mr Peston says

"I'm very sorry that David Cameron and George Osborne didn't see that, and have been defending the indefensible right up to today."

Mr Hester was appointed chief executive at the end of 2008 to replace Sir Fred Goodwin, after the bank had to be bailed out by the government, which now owns 82% of it.

RBS chairman Sir Philip Hampton had already announced that he would waive his payout.

He had been on course to claim 5.17 million RBS shares in February, but it is thought he told the bank's remuneration committee it would "not be appropriate" to take a £1.4m payout.

Robert Peston said RBS's directors now recognise it would have been better to delay Mr Hester's bonus decision until after it was revealed how much Barclays chief executive Bob Diamond received.

"Mr Hester's bonus would not look big in comparison," he explained.


More on This Story

Related Stories


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 1136.

    There is a systemic issue with bankers' pay and it should be tackled at a systemic level. Bullying particular individuals 'because we can' is not the right way to go about it. As a taxpayer, I need Mr Hester to do a great job to protect the multi-billion investment that the UK has made in this organisation and prevent it ever again threatening our country's stability.

  • rate this

    Comment number 1134.

    One man doing A job is never worth a salary AND a bonus of millions.

    As a civil servant I'm constantly being told I must get into the "real world", well I'd invite all of the banking sector to do the same. I'm sure he's very good but he won't be the only one and maybe his job is more stressful and difficult than most but nowhere near that much more.

  • rate this

    Comment number 1101.

    Mr Hester is paid very well to do a very demanding job. Whether he should be paid as much as he is is open to debate and it's clear from all the comments below that there are a variety of opinions. One things for sure and that is the "non-payment" of £1m in Shares is hardly likely to sort the economy out - which is of course the significantly bigger picture.

  • rate this

    Comment number 949.

    I am all for salary reform, but I do not think that it is fair to do this retrospectively and to decide it starts here. Hester agreed to do a job for a particular remuneration package, why should he be the target for personal outrage when he is doing what he was brought in to do: turn the bank around. Pay reform should be within a fair well-thought out process, not by personal attack.

  • rate this

    Comment number 892.

    Only real decision Hester could take. The 'bankers' club will now say that RBS will not be able to attract the 'best' people. But who are the 'best' people?. Many 'best' people appointed don't perform, leave to take up and perform badly in another senior job. . Maybe it's time for banks to give competent managers outside the 'club' an opportunity who maybe expect less?


Comments 5 of 22


More Business stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.