Analysis: Where now for Lawrence investigation?

 
Doreen Lawrence speaking outside the Old Bailey Doreen Lawrence has been through a very public ordeal in her search for justice

Wednesday's sentencing of Gary Dobson and David Norris was momentous for the history of modern British justice. It was a moment that Stephen Lawrence's parents in their darkest hours feared they would never see.

It was also a moment of huge importance for British society and the public were queuing out of the doors to get in.

Barristers sacrificed a little of their wigged dignity and squashed up bottom-to-bottom to make room for the Lawrence family and the legions of reporters.

One of Stephen Lawrence's relatives had her eyes closed and mouthed a prayer as Mr Justice Treacy read out the sentences.

The defendants stood, said and did nothing, and were taken down. There was applause - something I have never seen in court - and a shout of "Shame on all of you" from Gary Dobson's father.

What now?

So what happens now? Let's start by looking at where this incredible trial has left us.

Metropolitan Police chiefs have been extremely careful to avoid describing this as "justice" for Stephen Lawrence's family. They know it isn't when the other prime suspects are at large.

It is, as succinctly put in a tweet by Mr Lawrence's friend Duwayne Brooks, "some justice at last".

The convictions were a critical moment because the jury's verdict reflected where society now stands on overt blatant racism.

And the national sympathy for the Lawrence family has helped remind us all about the complex business of institutional racism - the subtler form of unspoken prejudice that allowed the death of a black man to go uninvestigated.

Doreen and Neville Lawrence's long and often bitter battle for justice has had a massive effect on British society. Their denial of justice led to two significant reforms of justice in its broadest possible sense.

Firstly, Parliament reformed race-relations law to place a duty on every public body to promote equality.

Secondly, it allowed somebody to be tried twice for the same serious crime. Today's jailings owe a great deal to those reforms.

The scene in court There was unprecedented applause following the sentencing of the pair

The first, along with the damning findings of the 1999 public inquiry, changed the way the police worked. The second landed Dobson back in the dock.

So a corner was turned with the trial of Dobson and Norris - and what a corner it was. But the practical question is whether the investigation can continue - or will it only hit a dead end?

Mr Justice Treacy urged the police not to "close the file" on catching the remaining killers. Judges rarely intervene in this way - and he was giving voice to the public anger that men still remain at large.

We know that when the police re-opened the Lawrence files and started afresh in 2006, there were almost 200 potential suspects on the database.

Today, with Dobson and Norris convicted, there are nine suspects who have not been eliminated from inquiries. Police have always believed either five or six carried out the attack.

'Prime suspects'

The Macpherson report in 1999 said the "prime suspects" were Dobson, Norris, brothers Jamie and Neil Acourt and Luke Knight - all of whom have denied the allegation.

Metropolitan Police Commissioner Bernard Hogan-Howe said that the unidentified remaining remembers of the gang that killed Stephen "should not rest easily in their beds".

"We are actively reviewing the consequences of what opportunities might be presented," he said. And, appealing directly to witnesses, he added: "Anything you know, please tell us... We can make a difference in this case still."

The BBC understands that the Lawrence team are meeting next week to assess where the case now stands - and what the Yard as a whole can learn from this remarkable cold case turnaround.

But it will not be an easy road ahead. The original investigation was so utterly botched it is remarkable that there was any evidence to convict Dobson and Norris.

And so in the absence of forensic evidence against other suspects, police will hope that one of two things will happen.

Firstly, Dobson or Norris could turn on the other gang members. The long wasted years of prison life have a sobering effect on former criminal allegiances.

The pair are facing a likely move away from London because their presence in HMP Belmarsh, not far from their homes, may threaten security and order. Norris has already suffered from a serious beating while on remand.

The pair had an opportunity between conviction and sentence to speak to the police. They didn't take it.

The Stephen Lawrence Memorial in Eltham The conviction of Dobson and Norris is seen as a historic moment in British policing

The second possibility is that someone out there who knows something - perhaps a former partner or gang member - may find the courage to come forward.

There is one more outstanding legal issue: Will the men appeal? At present it appears extremely unlikely. The Court of Appeal's decision to sanction the retrial of Dobson emphasised the quality of the evidence. An appeal would probably have to be based on adverse publicity.

As for the sentences themselves - it is hard to see how they can be challenged. Mr Justice Treacy sits on the Sentencing Council that advises his colleagues - they follow his lead.

About 10 years ago, the then Lord Chief Justice reviewed life sentences given to some 40 juvenile offenders.

The most common minimum term before possible parole was 10 years. The highest was 20 years. Dobson and Norris have been convicted of the most notorious racist murder of 20th Century Britain - and their sentences are right in the middle of that range.

 
Dominic Casciani Article written by Dominic Casciani Dominic Casciani Home affairs correspondent

How the battle against IS is being fought online

The battle against Islamic State (IS) militants is being fought online as well as on the ground - but how should the jihadist message be countered?

Read full article

More on This Story

Lawrence Verdict

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 98.

    It seems at last some kind of justice has been achieved for Stephen Lawrence and his family. I hope the remaing guilty men are brought before the courts as soon as possible. It seems almost unbelievable in the twenty first century that the police and CPS are still unable to pursue the others involved. Here's hoping they are preparing a case against the guilty parties based on sound evidence.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 97.

    Looks like correspondent has put every effort to dwarf the gravity of injustice by narrating the nabbing of culprits; credit to the System, however. Good effort has been made to downplay the delay of generation long; after all BBC has to keep it's colour intact. Thank you BBC, so much to make name out of institutional failure, as usual to camouflage the ongoing disorder in most civilised society.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 96.

    Diane Abbott hope you are proud of yourself, you've managed to divert attention from the inspiring story of dogged determination of two parents allowing all these racists to crawl out of their closets, yes it may seem tacky to profit from their son's death, am sure the campaign over the last 18 years hasn't been cheap, they wouldn't have had to if the police had done their job in the first place

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 95.

    The conviction of these morons is a good day for Britain and am proud to be British..though the tenacity and unrelenting Neville and Doreen Lawrence should get all the credits, the 18 year strain had taken its toll on the two, if Labour hadn't won in 1997 I don't think we would have had the Macpherson Inquiry, the Tories would never have sanctioned it...hopeful the A/G would increase the sentences

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 94.

    There are some truly shocking, proper racists commenting on this story (of all the stories to show your true colors in!) Do you all really want to be associated with the likes of Norris & Dobson?! And as with all anonymous web-racists, they just can't resist adding their bigoted tuppence worth. If comments were only published with photos & street names it'd cut out 50% of the drivel instantly.

 

Comments 5 of 98

 

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.