Leveson inquiry: Hacking 'link to other papers'

Robert Jay QC outlined the details found in the private investigator Glenn Mulcaire's notebooks

An inquiry launched in the wake of the phone-hacking scandal has heard details suggesting that the illegal practice was widespread.

Notebooks belonging to private detective Glenn Mulcaire suggest he hacked phones for the Sun, the Daily Mirror and the News of the World.

Some 28 NoW employees were named in the notebooks, the inquiry heard.

Earlier, Lord Leveson warned newspapers not to victimise inquiry witnesses who speak out against press intrusion.

But he added he had "absolutely no wish to stifle freedom of speech and expression".

Counsel to the inquiry, Robert Jay QC, gave details of notebooks belonging to Mulcaire, who was jailed with the News of the World's former royal editor Clive Goodman in 2007 after admitting intercepting messages on royal phones.

Mulcaire wrote first names in the top left-hand corner of his notes recording voicemails he illegally intercepted, the hearing learned.

Some of these corresponded to NoW employees, one of whom - referred to only as "A" - apparently made 1,453 separate requests for information.

But he also wrote "The Sun" and a name relating to the Daily Mirror in his notebooks, the inquiry was told.

At the scene

"Who guards the guardians" was the pithy way Lord Justice Leveson summed up the far from pithy task facing this inquiry - which was described at one point as "a root and branch investigation of the press".

The senior judge stressed the importance of newspapers to democracy. He also issued a blunt warning - he'll be watching to see if any of the "victims" who give evidence have a rough time in the papers afterwards.

Two competing versions of British newspapers were presented. In one, they are a force for great public good and hold the powerful to account. In the other, they (particularly the tabloids) use unscrupulous methods and believe themselves to be almost above the law.

It will be Lord Justice Leveson's not inconsiderable challenge to decide where the truth lies.

About 28 corner names are legible in the 11,000 pages of notes seized by police from Mulcaire, which relate to a total of 2,266 instructions and the names of 5,795 potential victims, the inquiry heard.

Mr Jay said it was clear that hacking was not limited to a single "rogue reporter," the defence previously mounted by News International, publishers of the now closed NoW.

He said: "I suggest that it would not be unfair to comment that it was at the very least a thriving cottage industry."

The inquiry heard that actor Jude Law has brought a claim against the Sun for allegedly hacking his phone.

"Part of the evidential matrix in support of his case is a corner name in the Mulcaire notebook which simply states 'the Sun' without specifying the individual working there," Mr Jay said.

The barrister added: "There is also documentary evidence which we have seen of another corner name relating to the Mirror."

BBC political correspondent Ross Hawkins, who is reporting on the inquiry via twitter, says that Mr Jay has stated that "questions must be asked as to how high up in News International the metaphorical buck stops".

Responding to the suggestion that Mulcaire may have hacked phones for the Mirror, a Trinity Mirror spokesman said: "The company has no knowledge of ever using Glenn Mulcaire."

'More convincing teeth'

Mr Jay also questioned whether the public and politicians had lost faith in the Press Complaints Commission, saying it mainly operated by seeking to find middle ground because it needed to retain the support of the press for what it does.

He said: "The PCC cannot require a newspaper to print a correction or apology on the same page as the original offending article. It can advise and recommend but there is no sanction for disobeying its rulings. Nor has the PCC power to fine newspapers or order them to pay compensation.

"All of this gives the impression that the PCC is operating largely without teeth, and that in the occasionally ruthless world in which it is forced to operate, something altogether sharper is required."

News International lawyer Rhodri Davies: "That phone hacking was wrong, it was shameful"

Meanwhile, Justice Secretary Kenneth Clarke has told the Society of Editors' annual conference the press watchdog must cover the entire industry if it is to restore confidence following the phone-hacking scandal.

He said he backed self-regulation of the press, adding that newspapers must be allowed "to carry on enraging some politicians, getting under the skin of governments, and deeply embarrassing public figures" where there was a public interest.

Neil Garnham QC, the barrister for the Metropolitan Police and the Crown Prosecution Service, said the criminal investigation into phone hacking was unlikely to be completed before the inquiry publishes its report in September, because of the scale of the evidence involved.

He also spoke of the balance that needed to be struck between the press and the police.

"A healthy relationships between press and police can be mutually beneficial, but too close a relationship can, I would suggest, distort proper judgement by both parties. And there are competing considerations which do not always militate towards a common outlook."

Hearings will later examine the extent of unlawful conduct by the press, and the police's initial hacking investigation.

This second phase will wait until after the current police investigation into NoW phone hacking, and any resultant prosecutions.

More on This Story

The Leveson report

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More UK stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.