Archbishop of Canterbury backs new finance tax

Dr Rowan Williams has made his first substantial response to the protest at St Paul's Cathedral

Related Stories

The Archbishop of Canterbury has backed calls for a new tax on financial trading - dubbed a "Robin Hood" tax.

Dr Williams told the BBC the St Paul's protests had raised awareness of the "unfinished business" of financial sector reform.

He said the public had the feeling that changes to financial institutions were not coming fast enough.

David Cameron says there is widespread support for the principles of such a tax but it had to be adopted globally.

In an interview with BBC religious affairs correspondent Robert Pigott, Dr Williams said the protests outside St Paul's Cathedral by groups opposed to corporate excess had "triggered awareness" of the unfinished business between government and banks and the need to deliver a more just and rational system.

He said: "An occasion like the protests outside St Paul's has been a real focus for people's feelings and their imagination - even if they haven't known exactly what [the protesters] are after, they've felt [the protest] is saying something that needs to be said."

Dr Williams' remarks suggest he has some degree of sympathy with what he described as the widespread and deep exasperation with the financial establishment articulated by the protesters, our correspondent said.

'Powerful sense'

Writing in the Financial Times, Dr Rowan Williams said the levy would be one way of advancing the "moral agenda" of the protesters outside St Paul's.

In his first substantial response to the protest, Dr Williams cited ideas put forward by the Vatican for creating ethical regulation of financial markets.


As St Paul's - and the wider Church - has appeared like a rudderless ship battered by storms beyond its control - there has been silence from Lambeth Palace.

For two weeks Anglicans have watched a debate that should have been about banks and traders, focussing on whether their own church is standing up for Christian values.

Now the Church's leader has acknowledged that the protest camp which has so embarrassed St Paul's has served a useful purpose.

But Archbishop Rowan Williams is putting his own interpretation on the concerns it needs to raise.

It's an attempt by Dr Williams to wrest back the initiative, and stamp the protest with his own proposals for change.

That way the Church might regain its identity as movement of people committed to the poor, as well as a body of majestic stone temples.

He supported controversial proposals for the so-called Tobin tax - dubbed a "Robin Hood tax" by the FT - which would levy a small tax on share, bond and currency transactions with the proceeds reinvested in the "real economy".

Dr Williams said the best outcome from the unhappy controversies at St Paul's would be if such ideas could form the basis for "credible change in the financial world".

The archbishop wrote: "There is still a powerful sense around - fair or not - of a whole society paying for the errors and irresponsibility of bankers; of messages not getting through; of impatience with a return to 'business as usual' - represented by still soaring bonuses and little visible change in banking practices."

Dr Williams referred to a document produced by the Vatican's Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace last week.

The article also suggested separating the retail and trading arms of banks and placing more obligations on banks that were bailed out with public money.

"These ideas - ideas that have been advanced from other quarters, religious and secular, in recent years - do not amount to a simplistic call for the end of capitalism, but they are far more than a general expression of discontent", he said.

Aerial photo of protest camp at St Paul's

"If we want to take seriously the moral agenda of the protesters at St Paul's, these are some of the ways in which we should be taking it forward."

Dr Williams said the protesters' demands needed to be "a bit more specific", and said the Vatican's proposals should be a starting point for debate.

Speaking at Prime Minister's questions, Mr Cameron backed Dr Williams the Archbishop of Canterbury's call for greater responsibility by "people at the top of our society" but played down the idea of the UK introducing a Tobin tax on its own.

Legal action

Later, the former head of Microsoft, Bill Gates, said applying a tax on financial transactions to world development aid would have a "fantastic effect".

He told the BBC he would like to see the tax raise funds for countries that had fallen short of their aid commitments to help reach their targets.

What is the Tobin tax?

  • Tax on global financial transactions
  • Named after Nobel Prize-winning economist James Tobin, who proposed the idea
  • Intended to discourage destabilising market speculation while raising large revenues
  • Pushed by former prime minister Gordon Brown in response to the financial crisis but currently opposed by the coalition government
  • Recently proposed by the European Commission, with the suggestion revenue could be used to tackle the financial crisis

The City of London Corporation has "paused" its legal action against the camp outside St Paul's, set up by protesters on 15 October.

Stuart Fraser, the corporation's policy chairman, said the decision followed the cathedral's move to suspend its own legal action against the camp.

When asked on BBC Radio 4's Today programme if the corporation had paused its legal action because "you don't want to look like the vicious ones who got the police in", Mr Fraser responded: "It's probably stupid to deny that that's not in our thoughts."

He went on: "What we want to do is to have a discussion with the protesters - can they accommodate our desire to clear the public highway? That's all we're asking."

The church said it had wanted to "engage directly" with the protesters.

The Bishop of London, Dr Richard Chartres, said the situation was now in a "much better place" following "open and frank" conversations on Tuesday morning.

Bill Gates on the different "flavours" of financial transaction taxes

Asked how damaging the episode had been for the Church, he told the Today programme: "Christians are very used to near-death experiences [and] they're also used to resurrections.

"The cathedral has burned down [but] its symbol is the phoenix and I have absolutely no doubt that that will be the story this time as well."

When asked if the protesters could camp as long as they liked, he said the cathedral would look at the situation day by day.

Occupy London Stock Exchange said it was "delighted" the two potential legal cases had been suspended.

Protester Naomi Colvin told the Today programme the demonstrators wanted any decision to leave to be theirs, and it would come only when they had achieved their objectives in the current location.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More UK stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.